An educational historical critique hosted by Dr. David Miano examining alternative history arguments surrounding the ancient ruins of Baalbek in Lebanon. The analysis focuses specifically on the monolithic pink granite columns sourced from the Aswan quarry in Egypt, systematically debunking claims by fringe advocate Brien Foerster regarding lost high technology, advanced stone age lathes, and diamond tools. The presentation details genuine Roman quarrying methods, transport logistics using specialized cargo ships and pack animals, and material engineering realities to demonstrate how mainstream archaeological evidence and Roman iron-steel tool capabilities perfectly account for these architectural marvels. #worldofantiquity#baalbek#lebanon#brienfoerster#ancienthistory#romanarchitecture#debunked#aswan#archaeology#engineering
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video refutes alternative historian Brian Forster's claims that the massive granite columns of Baalbek evidence a lost, high-tech prehistoric civilization. By analyzing archaeological data, material science, and historical records, the narrator demonstrates that these structures are the result of sophisticated Roman engineering, logistics, and craftsmanship.
For regular videos on ancient cultures and forgotten civilizations, please subscribe.
If you would like to support the channel and become part of our ancient history fan community,
visit patreon.com slash world of antiquity.
The ancient city of Heliopolis in Lebanon, better known as Baalbek,
sports some of the most impressive architecture of the ancient world.
The sheer size of some of the building stones found here
have spawned alternative history theories about their origins.
If you're interested in the site of Baalbek and whether present-day historians and archaeologists
have their stories straight about who built these magnificent structures,
stick around because we're going to get into the details.
Brian Forster is a big name in the alternative history business.
He has written numerous books on lost ancient high technology
and has been featured several times on ancient aliens.
He claims to be an expert on the megalithic works of South America
and his website, HiddenIncaTours.com,
arranges tours there and to various other parts of the world,
during which he offers his personal views on the sites.
Views that are frequently at odds with mainstream scholarship.
The ruins of Baalbek have piqued Mr. Forster's interest and he has taken tours there as well.
Although all the archaeologists who have worked at the site
have concluded that the temples and other large structures at Baalbek
are of Greco-Roman origin,
Mr. Forster is of the opinion that there are remains there
of a lost advanced civilization from the Stone Age.
On his YouTube channel, he has posted a lecture that he gave,
I'm not sure where, titled,
Baalbek in Lebanon, Megaliths of the Gods.
It has over 300,000 views.
In some of this lecture, he deals with the topic of the Trilithon Stones
and the unfinished stones in the quarry near the site.
Since I've already discussed that at length in a previous video,
I'm going to focus here on claims he makes about
the large granite columns found at Baalbek.
If you're interested in the Trilithon and the quarry,
please check out my other video,
which is called Baalbek Mystery of the Trilithon Stones.
I also have an interview posted of one of the archaeologists who worked at the site,
which you may find of interest.
But now, let's see what he says about the granite columns
and see if there is substance to his conclusions.
The pillar in the foreground is made of granite,
whereas most of the construction of Baalbek is limestone from the quarry.
We see that granite is also located here.
So the question is, where did the granite come from?
And luckily, we brought a geologist with us from Canada,
and she had just been with us in Egypt.
So she was able to figure out that the granite of Baalbek
was probably from the Aswan quarry located in southern Egypt.
The geologist is probably correct that the stone came from Aswan in Egypt.
But Aswan wasn't the only active quarry in the area where you could get granite.
The Greeks weren't comfortable using granite,
but the Romans used it quite a bit.
They not only reopened the Egyptian granite quarries that had fallen out of use,
but also opened up some of their own new ones,
such as Mons Claudianus and Wadi Fawakir in Egypt,
as well as several in Asia Minor, Italy, and Germany.
A scientific study done recently analyzed 1,176 granite columns from the Roman era
in seven regions around the Mediterranean
and traced them to their original quarries.
Yeah, 1,176 of them, and that's just a sample.
They were taken from 126 different sites.
Unfortunately for us, Lebanon was not one of them.
Most of the granite production occurred between the 1st century BCE and the 4th century CE,
with the peak during the 2nd century CE.
Anyway, these granite columns were traced by geochemical analysis to 16 different quarries,
but that list is incomplete.
There's a handy website, the Oxford Roman Economy Project,
and one of their databases is of stone quarries.
You can filter by the type of stone, and there are 46 granite quarries that come up.
46, which were used in Roman times.
Check it out if you get a chance.
But the type of granite obtained from Aswan, with its bright pink feldspar crystals,
is fairly easy to identify,
and I have no reason to doubt that the granite at Baalbek came from Aswan.
And the Aswan quarry is 1,000 miles away.
So that's curious, and that's also something that we see in other ancient locations.
The stone isn't necessarily from the present locality,
but can have been brought from hundreds of miles away.
I don't know why Mr. Forster, whom I assume knows something about Roman granite,
finds this curious.
The overseas stone trade was a big and bustling industry.
After marble, granite was the next most widely used stone
for structural or decorative purposes in Roman times.
It was worked in enormous quantities for the manufacture of columns,
flooring and facing slabs, and large tubs.
To show off their supremacy,
the emperors made major spectacles of Roman engineering and organization
by erecting magnificent structures.
Even the convoy of stones and other building material commanded significant attention
and was a source of pride to the emperors.
As Roman elites moved into new territories acquired from the expansion of the Roman Empire,
stone for building came in high demand
and even the local elites wanted to copy the Roman building style,
which was very much in fashion.
The Roman style was of course itself a copy of the Greek style.
So yeah, granite was transported over long distances in the Roman period quite commonly.
So questions automatically arise,
how was the stone moved from that exotic location
and why was it important to bring the granite all the way from Aswan?
This stone was not brought in from an outside territory,
which wouldn't have been unusual either,
but it merely was transported within the empire's own borders.
Egypt was part of the Roman Empire and Baalbek was part of the Roman Empire.
And Aswan granite was brought much further than Baalbek.
There is Aswan granite in the city of Rome itself.
Aswan granite is found all over the empire.
So as we explore the complex at Baalbek,
again we see very massive stonework.
This again is likely from the megalithic period, which is pre-Roman.
And then here, again the foundation appears to be megalithic with smaller stones on top.
And then on the upper right hand side,
you see granite columns that have been reconstructed.
The term that he used, megalithic period, is not a real archaeological period.
It's made up.
I don't know who coined it.
I think the term is a holdover from literature of the 1800s.
But just so you know, various academic disciplines
have divided the history of the world into time periods.
So there are geological time periods, archaeological time periods,
historical time periods, art history time periods, etc.
And in none of them will you find something called the megalithic period.
The idea of a megalithic period that Mr. Forster appears to be proposing
is that there was a time during which large stones were used in construction.
At least that's what the name suggests.
The thing is, large stones were used in construction
in many time periods in many parts of the world.
They aren't restricted to one time.
Being in the presence of something of this complexity and antiquity
raises lots of questions, both in terms of ancient engineering
and very much makes us ask whether academics have the full story.
And from what you'll see, they have not fully described
the antiquity and complexity at Baalbek.
So here, for example, as you saw in previous photographs,
you saw sections of granite columns.
But what this shows us is the bottom part, which is still intact.
And the surfaces here are perfectly smooth, perfectly polished,
and this column is perfectly round.
So that tells us originally it was between 15 and 20 feet tall
and was made of one piece of stone.
The only way that could have been achieved would be on a giant lathe.
I was hoping he might have provided the scientific evidence
that these columns were made on giant lathes,
but he never really gets into it.
Fortunately, the Romans left us with information how columns were made,
both in their writings and from what we see in the material evidence,
like partially completed objects.
First, quarrymen with iron picks outlined the general shape
of the object they wanted to excavate.
Then they drove in wooden wedges with mallets to force the stone loose.
Alternately, they used the pointier method,
making a straight line of small pits in the stone
and then hammering back and forth between them using iron chisels.
After getting the stone loose,
stonemasons would roughly shape it with iron chisels.
By the way, the iron the Romans used was basically a low grade steel.
It was important that enough stone was taken off the column
so that it could be transported more easily,
but not so much that it could be damaged when moving.
Once the object got to the site,
smoothing was done using flat chisels or rasps,
and then polishing would be done by abrasive stones or powders.
There were different gradations of polish.
The finer the abrasive, the finer the polish.
Only certain stones were able to be polished, but granite is one of them.
And the technology to be able to shape granite to this fineness and high polish
was only developed once we had diamond tool technology,
and that didn't occur until the late 19th century AD.
So not only was it impossible for the Romans to have constructed this,
but literally, these 300 ancient columns
had to have been found by the Romans and then reused.
So here he states his main thesis,
that the Romans could not have made these columns,
or more specifically, that these columns could not have been made by anyone in Roman times,
and therefore the columns must come from a different time period.
The strange thing is, although he says that the technology to make such columns
was not developed until the 19th century,
his conclusion is not that the columns come from the 19th century or later,
but from a time earlier than the Romans,
a time for which there is no evidence of the technology he assumes.
Except for the columns themselves.
If the Romans discovered hundreds of granite columns somewhere in mint condition,
surely someone would have mentioned it.
That would be an amazing find, right?
The Romans were known for taking spoils in every region they conquered
and bragging about the acquisition.
Why not say that here?
And there are more than 300 granite columns that were used by the Romans.
There were thousands.
Why did no writer from any of the centuries of the Roman period
mention all the ready-made columns that supposedly were already there?
And perhaps more importantly,
why were the granite columns made according to the same construction model
as Greek and Roman marble columns?
The only explanation that makes sense
is that the marble and granite columns were made by the same people.
So this again shows you quite clear evidence
that the columns themselves,
all 300 of them in granite,
were turned on ancient lathes.
We don't actually have this technology today,
or if we do, it's very recent.
But if you go back 200 years,
these could not have been made.
And you go back 2,000 years,
and there is no way they could have been made by the Romans.
And once again, the detail.
You see the smooth surfaces,
and this indicates lost ancient high technology at Baalbek in Lebanon.
Note how he just says it as a matter of fact.
Doesn't he know that beautiful large-scale granite work
has been created from ancient times to the present?
The existence of such work demonstrates
that we don't have to make up a new civilization to account for it.
And once again, all of this granite,
300 columns being at least 15 feet,
if not 20 feet tall,
each was originally one piece of stone.
All of them came from Aswan, which is 1,000 miles away.
So how many ships would that have taken?
And how would they have been transported
from the quarry in southern Egypt
all the way up the Nile to the Mediterranean,
and then to the site of Baalbek?
Okay, so he keeps bringing this up,
so it looks like we'll need to take a closer look.
Would it have been impossible,
or at least financially impractical,
for the Romans to have moved the materials from Aswan to Baalbek?
Marble, actually, is heavier than granite,
and therefore would have been more challenging to move.
In other words, if they could transport marble,
they could transport granite.
And they transported marble galore,
and I don't hear Mr. Forster arguing otherwise.
Several emperors, including Augustus and Caligula,
had giant granite obelisks
transported from Egypt all the way to Rome.
A notable event in those days.
But as time passed,
more and more obelisks from Egypt were brought to Rome.
First century historian Pliny the Elder
describes the transport this way.
But the most difficult enterprise of all
was the carriage of these obelisks by sea to Rome,
in vessels that excited the greatest admiration.
Indeed, the late emperor Augustus
consecrated the one that brought over the first obelisk
as a lasting memorial of this marvelous undertaking
in the docks of Putioli.
But it was destroyed by fire.
As to the one in which, by order of the emperor Caligula,
the other obelisk had been transported to Rome,
after having been preserved for some years
and looked upon as the most wonderful construction
ever beheld upon the seas,
it was brought to Ostia
by order of the late emperor Claudius.
And towers of Putioli and earth
being first erected upon it.
It was sunk for the construction of the harbor
he was making there.
The Pantheon in Rome,
built during the reign of the emperor Hadrian,
sports these magnificent granite columns,
40 Roman feet high,
5 Roman feet in diameter.
They came all the way from Egypt.
The eight light gray ones in the front,
from Mons Claudianus,
and the pink ones in the middle and back rows,
from Aswan.
One of these columns is estimated to weigh
about 50 to 55 metric tons.
A granite column such as found at Baalbek,
being shorter and less wide
than one from the Pantheon,
would have weighed less.
The emperor Maxentius had marble columns
weighing more than 100 tons each,
along with thousands of tons of additional marble
transported from the island of Proconusis,
1,500 miles to the Roman Forum.
Water transport, by the way,
is much easier than land transport,
so the bulk of the journey
would have been a relative cinch.
The largest cargo ships in Roman times
could carry loads up to 250 tons,
but sometimes special ships were constructed.
A granite obelisk weighing 510 tons
was transported from Thebes in Egypt,
down the Nile,
to the Mediterranean by Constantine the Great.
A gigantic ship had to be built to carry it.
Ancient Roman historian Ammianus Marcellinus
recounts what happened with this massive monolith.
Whereas Octavianus Augustus
had brought over two obelisks
from the city of Heliopolis in Egypt,
one of which was set up in the Circus Maximus,
the other in the Campus Martius,
as for this one recently brought in,
he neither ventured to meddle with it nor move it,
overawed by the difficulties caused by its size.
Let me inform those who do not know it
that that early emperor,
after bringing over several obelisks,
passed by this one and left it untouched
because it was consecrated
as a special gift to the sun god,
and because being placed in the sacred part
of his sumptuous temple,
which might not be profaned,
there it towered aloft like the peak of the world.
But Constantine, that is Constantine the Great,
making little account of that,
tore the huge mass from its foundations.
And since he rightly thought
that he was committing no sacrilege
if he took this marvel from one temple
and consecrated it at Rome,
that is to say in the temple of the whole world,
he let it lie for a long time,
while the things necessary for its transfer
were being provided.
And when it had been conveyed
down the channel of the Nile
and landed at Alexandria,
a ship of a size hitherto unknown
was constructed to be rowed by 300 oarsmen.
Constantine died before he got it to Rome,
and his son Constantius II completed the task.
We have written documentation from Egypt
that animals, camels usually,
were used in the transportation of stone
from the quarries to the Nile River.
One papyrus speaking of a 50-foot column
being transported in this way.
A 50-foot column would have weighed about 150 tons.
It's been calculated that a column weighing 207 tons
would have exerted a pressure
of 6.9 kilograms per square centimeter
on the wheels of a 12-wheeled wagon.
That's not an excessive load.
One camel is capable of hauling one ton,
so a 150-ton column would need 150 camels to move it.
Is that unrealistic?
Well, we have a record that speaks of
64 mules being used to haul a sarcophagus.
The Roman poet Tibullus,
musing about the life of a merchant, wrote,
His fancy turns to foreign marbles,
and through the trembling city
his column is carried by 1,000 sturdy pairs of oxen.
This may be hyperbole,
but clearly large teams of animals
were used to move heavy items.
There's no doubt that moving columns
would have been expensive.
Still, it would have been more expensive
to move a bunch of column sections
than one whole column
because of the extra time involved
or extra wagons and extra drivers needed.
The raising of columns
employed a variety of equipment,
including cranes and lift towers.
Vitruvius, a Roman engineer and architect,
in the 10th book of his work
On Architecture,
describes how Greeks invented machines
that could move and lift heavy blocks and columns
in the construction of temples.
If you want to read it,
I'll leave a link below the video.
Ammianus Marcellinus describes the erection
of the 510-ton granite obelisk
in the middle of the city of Rome
during the reign of Constantius II.
Now, there remained only the raising,
which it was thought could be accomplished
only with great difficulty,
perhaps not at all.
But it was done in the following manner.
To tall beams,
which were brought and raised on end
like a grove of derricks,
were fastened long and heavy ropes
in the likeness of a manifold web
to hide the sky with their excessive numbers.
To these were attached that veritable mountain,
and it was gradually drawn upon high
through the empty air.
And after hanging for a long time,
while many thousand men turned wheels
resembling millstones,
it was finally placed
in the middle of the circus.
Today, it stands before the Basilica
of St. John Lateran.
And again, with a sense of scale,
you have a number of people
in the upper left-hand area,
and they are walking across stones in a row,
each of which weighs 800 tons.
And then you see the smaller work above that.
The smaller work above
is the work by the Romans.
The foundational stones
of 800 ton blocks each
is the work of the earlier
and more mysterious megalithic builders.
He uses instances where he finds
larger stones below smaller stones
to make a case that the larger stones
are from an earlier time period.
The problem is that
this is not always the case.
There are clear instances
where smaller stones
are below larger stones.
If you watched my earlier video on Baalbek,
and if you haven't,
please go check it out
after watching this one,
you will know that there are
many remains below the 800 ton stones
beneath the surface,
including a Neolithic village.
And this just shows you,
once again, the sense of scale.
How would 800 ton blocks have been moved
from the quarry at Baalbek,
even just one mile to this location?
The idea that tree trunks were used
is highly unlikely
because these blocks would have crushed
any wooden roller
that was put underneath them.
Also, the terrain is not flat,
so they would have had to have been
pushed up and down hills.
This was brought up in the comments section
of my previous Baalbek video
a couple of times.
I'm sorry to say that
what he's claiming here is untrue.
A tree trunk can indeed bear
that amount of weight,
or I should say many tree trunks.
Different types of wood are different,
but wood generally can bear
about 625 pounds per square inch.
If you have trees underneath
the entire bottom of the stone,
with an area that large,
it would handle the weight no problem.
Wooden rollers would not be crushed
because the weight is spread out
over a bunch of them.
This can be calculated mathematically.
And it was all downhill to the temple,
not up and down hills.
That was discussed in my earlier video,
and in the interview I did
with one of the archaeologists
who worked on the site.
And this is Roman.
This is classic Roman work in limestone.
You see the fine detail.
And the intriguing thing
is that in the megalithic work,
we find no art whatsoever.
It's all simply shape and form.
This is also what we find
at other locations,
which are megalithic,
such as in Egypt.
The interior and exterior
of the Great Pyramid,
we do not see any artwork whatsoever.
And so this indicates
that the megalithic builders
were simply pragmatic.
Art meant nothing to them.
All they were interested in
is scale, form, and function.
Forster is using the presence
or absence of detail work and art
as an indicator of whether stonework
comes from his presumed
megalithic period or not.
This is convenient
because art styles
help us to date artifacts.
But if you remove all the art,
it's easier for you to date
the artifact to whatever
time period you like.
And even if a structure
has art on it,
you can do what he does
and say the art is from
a different time period
from the plain parts.
But for this assumption to work,
it needs to be consistent.
And it isn't.
There are clear instances
in Roman times
where simple shape and form
stonework was employed.
That means the lack of detail work
cannot be used
as a reliable indicator
of what isn't Roman.
And this gives you
another sense of scale.
You see the block
on the left hand side
next to the staircase.
That block weighs
at least 800 tons.
The staircase is made
of much smaller stones
and the stones above
the giant megalithic block
are from the Roman period
roughly put into place.
And this just emphasizes that
the difference between
this 800 ton block
and here the smaller Roman work.
See those holes
in the side of the 800 ton block?
Guess what those were for?
Yes, good guess.
They were used to move the block.
You ever hear of a holy vella?
It's a device invented by the Greeks
and used by the Romans
to move stones.
A stone cutter would carve
small rectangular holes
in the stone.
A holy vella would be
placed in each one.
Then the pin would be removed
and iron slices placed between
until the fit was tight.
The pin would be replaced.
Ropes tied to the holy vella
and they'd be good to go.
What this tells us
is that those 800 ton blocks
were not only moved
without advanced tech
but they were moved by the Romans.
You can see holes
of the same type on stones
that Mr. Forster says are Roman.
And here we have column sections
weighing in at at least
50 tons apiece.
And there Stephen, excuse me,
Stephen Mailer is pointing
to a drill hole.
That's a perfectly round drill hole.
Could that have been done
by the Romans?
In order to connect
the different sections
of the columns together?
Possibly.
But what we see are
the surfaces are completely
and perfectly flat.
Almost laser flat.
Almost laser flat?
How does he know that?
He'd have to use a tool
that could take a measurement
where he could justify
making such a statement, right?
You can't figure that out
with the naked eye
or with an everyday straight edge.
But my bet is
they used no precision
measuring tool to find out.
The fact is the Romans
were perfectly capable
of making a flat surface.
So flat that it looked perfect
to the naked eye.
So of course that's me
standing next to a section
of a giant column.
And this is where it gets fuzzy
because in a lot of cases
we'll see profound difference
between the megalithic work
and the later,
in this case, Roman work.
But in this case,
are the giant sections megalithic?
Or are they amazing works
by the Romans?
That I still can't figure out.
I am glad to see
that he can hold back
from making definitive statements.
But he's kind of stuck here.
Remember, his evidence
for attributing the columns
to mysterious megalithic builders
is showing whole granite columns,
which he thinks could only
have been made on a lathe.
If he says these column sections
are from megalithic times,
he cannot say
they were made on a lathe.
On the other hand,
if he says these column sections
are Roman,
he has to admit
that the Romans got large
and finely worked granite objects
from Aswan.
So not wanting to be pinned down
on either,
he says he can't figure it out.
But this shows you,
again, incredibly flat surfaces.
We see no errors in the work.
Normally, the work of human sculptors
or stonemasons,
you will see errors.
You'll see slight indentations
or slight protrusions
based on the fact
that the tool technology
they had,
which was likely iron
or possibly steel,
once in a while,
they would make an error
of some kind.
In the case of where
I'm looking right now,
that surface is as close
to perfection as is possible.
But he is just eyeballing it.
The Romans had craftsmen
that could very easily
make sculptures
that looked perfect
to the naked eye.
Yeah, there were artisans
with greater and lesser skills
in Roman times,
as in all times.
The presence of unskilled work
in a certain period
does not show
that all work
from that time period
was unskilled
because there were people
with a variety of skills.
And then we get
to another fuzzy area.
There you see me
next to a series
of giant columns.
The columns are made
in sections,
approximately six
to seven feet tall.
So it is possible
that the Romans
were able to construct this.
Again, the important point
to emphasize
is that the earlier
megalithic columns
made of granite
were one single piece of stone
and the later work
of the Romans
was multi-sectional.
Okay, so then he is acknowledging
that there was a granite industry
in Aswan
in Roman times
and that the Romans
brought heavy granite objects
from Egypt
here to Baalbek.
So the only reason
I can think of
that Romans couldn't
have put these columns here
are that the Romans
never quarried whole columns
and that whole columns
were too heavy
for them to transport.
And yet,
we also have already seen
with our own eyes
whole granite columns
that were quarried
by the Romans
such as at Mons Claudianus,
a quarry that was used
only during Roman times.
And we know
not only from documents
but also by the presence
of Egyptian granite
in various parts of the empire
that granite obelisks
and whole columns
well in excess of 100 tons
were transported
by the Romans.
And we know
from mathematical calculation
that Roman technology
could move these objects
over long distances.
So I have to wonder
whether Mr. Forster
has additional evidence
that the Romans
could not have made
the whole columns
that he hasn't revealed
in this talk.
Or is that it?
Another question arises
and that's that
the work in Rome itself
was never of this scale.
So why is it
that the Romans
were working
in such a huge scale
far, far away
in the hinterlands
of their empire?
That again
has not been
satisfactorily answered.
This is not in the hinterlands.
Baalbek was in a Roman province.
In fact, this area
the eastern side of the empire
was the most urban,
the most prosperous,
the most inhabited
part of the empire.
Roman emperors
frequently came to this area.
And here
it's kind of hard to see
but in the next photograph
you'll see the megalithic work
on the left hand side
at the bottom
and then the arch work
on top
is of a smaller scale.
So it's quite likely
in this photograph
that the rougher,
larger work
on the bottom
was the megalithic work
and then the Romans
added the arch work
on top.
Why is it not possible
that the people
who made this tunnel
decided to use
heavier stones
on the bottom
and smaller stones
on top?
Doesn't that make sense?
I'm curious.
Why is Mr. Forster
not commenting
on the smooth,
polished,
almost laser flat,
perfect surface
of the megalithic work here?
Well, obviously he can't.
It's rough as you can see.
So my question for him is
what tools
did the megalithic builders use
to cut these stones?
Were they machines
with laser-like precision
or something else?
Also the amount of erosion
on the surfaces
of the lower stones
indicates
a greater antiquity
than those above.
You see the discoloration.
You see the weathering.
And so this photo
possibly by itself
shows you
that two different civilizations
were involved.
So apparently we have
stones from the megalithic period
that are perfect
and we have stones
from the same time period
that are rough.
If they are the same age
why are some rough
and some not?
Why is this block
right in the same area
not eroded at all?
According to his logic
wouldn't the erosion
of these stones
which are under a roof
and the lack of erosion
on this one
indicate that they're from
two different civilizations?
What scientific method
is he using
to determine
how much time
it would have taken
to erode those stones?
What caused the erosion?
Is this wind erosion?
Rain erosion?
What?
He said he had a geologist with him.
What did the geologist
say about this?
Even if we assumed
the rough appearance
on these stones
is from erosion
does it look to you
imagining what these stones
look like
when they were not eroded
like they were precisely cut?
Not to me.
Now I can't get a full look
at them from the photo
but I would be willing to bet
that those marks
you see on the stones
are quarrying marks
not features of erosion.
If you would like
to research it yourself
there's a great website
called Quarryscapes
which includes
all kinds of information
on ancient quarries
including a guide
to identifying the quarry tool
by the marks seen on the stone.
See if you can figure out
what tool made these marks.
And once again
there are many
many of these stones
in the foundation
at the Baalbek
religious area.
I would say
there are at least 20
to 30
to possibly even 40
stones
locked in place
at 800
to possibly a thousand tons.
And those stones
are placed in front of
and they block
a once exterior wall
that was built
in the Roman period.
How is that possible
under Mr. Forster's assumptions?
If we were to believe him
the Romans would have had
to have constructed
an exterior wall
on the inside
of these large blocks.
Not very likely.
More likely
is that the larger stones
were placed here
after not before.
More on this
in my earlier Baalbek video.
And then contrast that
with the work of the Romans
in the background.
A very great architectural
and engineering achievement.
But this work
is humanly possible
and the other work
is possibly
not the work of humanity.
We don't know
who the ancient
megalithic builders were.
Were they so-called Atlanteans?
Were they aliens?
Were they an unknown culture
that simply disappeared?
That is something
that we are presently working on.
Okay, this is where
he jumps the shark.
He argued that the columns
were made on a lathe
and that they were precisely made.
And now asserts that
none of that was humanly possible.
What's not human about a lathe
or moving heavy objects?
That's a technological issue,
not a species issue.
Mr. Forster deliberately
is not taking a position
on the question of
whether he thinks it's aliens
or Atlanteans
or an unknown culture.
His fan base consists of people
from all three camps
and he risks alienating some
if he comes down on one side.
So it's better for him to say
that is something
we're presently working on.
I encourage you to ask him
what scientific work
he and his team specifically are doing
in order to determine the answer.
This is Roman work.
Again, you see smaller stones,
you see artwork,
you see arches,
you see surface decoration.
But what's intriguing
are the two columns
because those two columns
are the granite.
The one on the left hand side
was broken into sections
and then rebuilt
during the Roman time period.
And then the one on the right
is still a single piece of stone.
So that is one of the only
pre-Roman works in granite
that is still in place.
And again,
at least 15 to 20 feet tall
and had to have been turned
on a massive lathe.
If Mr. Forster would have asked someone,
he would have found out
that the column on the left
was reconstructed in modern times
because it fell and broke.
Notice the base under the right one.
That's clearly Roman.
So his assertion
that it remained in place must be wrong.
Unless he thinks the Romans
moved the column,
put the base there,
and lifted the column
back onto the base.
If that were the case,
then the Romans clearly
had the technology
to put the granite column
there in the first place.
And again,
just to emphasize
the fine work of the Romans
in limestone,
which is relatively soft.
And in contrast,
the ancient cutting marks
in granite.
To emphasize hardness,
limestone is about 3 to 3.5
in hardness out of 10,
with 10 being diamond.
And granite is 7 out of 10.
So the only technology
we know of
that can cut granite efficiently
is diamond technology.
Is that true?
That the only technology
that can cut granite is diamond?
No, it's not.
Mr. Forster is using
the Mohs scale,
which jewelers use,
and it's based on
what stones are able to scratch
what other stones.
It's a relative scale
in which stones are ranked.
But the rankings
are not equally spaced.
There are five other
hardness scales,
and if you look at those
that measure hardness
absolutely instead of relatively,
you will see that
using diamond on granite
would be overkill.
Roman iron,
steel,
was perfectly capable
of cutting granite efficiently.
Mr. Forster is the first person
I've ever heard say otherwise.
He is simply wrong.
The Romans themselves
measured the material strength
of stone used for building,
dividing it into six categories.
Very soft,
soft,
semi-firm,
firm,
hard,
and cold.
Marble and granite
were considered cold,
and the Romans regularly cut both.
They were used by the elite class
because they were more expensive.
The harder the stone,
the more fine detail it could hold.
So that's why the hardest stones
were preferred by the rich.
So basically,
the hardness indicated
what the stone could be used for.
Categorizing the stones by strength,
therefore,
was equivalent to
categorizing them by purpose.
And again,
what these ancient cut marks were from,
are they modern?
Were they done prior to this
being made a world heritage site?
We do see some rust marks,
so that indicates possible
steel technology.
Yep,
technology that the Romans possessed.
But they do look at it.
I don't know if he's purposely lying,
or just doesn't know.
Anyway,
he goes on to talk about another site,
Byblos,
which I don't have time to address right now.
This video has gotten long enough.
But if you're worried that I took
anything he said out of context,
I will leave a link to his video below,
so that you can check to make sure.
I want to be as fair as possible.
If you like ancient history,
and haven't subscribed to the channel yet,
please do,
and feel free to check out more of my videos.
You might like my little e-booklet,
Why Ancient History Matters.
It's designed to persuade people
that the subject is important,
even in the modern world.
You might also wish to use it
to help spread the word.
So feel free to share it with someone you know.
It's free for anyone who wants it.
I've left a link in the description box below the video
for you to grab a copy.
Catch you later.