A major sports news report covering Manchester City being found guilty of the vast majority of its 115 alleged financial rule breaches. The breakdown outlines potential upcoming sanctions—ranging from massive fines and heavy points deductions to potential expulsion from the top football league—alongside the likelihood of a club appeal and future compensation lawsuits from rival teams.
Manchester City has been found guilty of the majority of over 100 financial rule breaches following a years-long investigation. The club faces severe potential sanctions, including heavy fines, points deductions, or expulsion from the Premier League, threatening to taint a decade of unprecedented sporting success.
They've been the dominant force in English football for more than a decade, with millions
of fans around the world.
But now Manchester City's status as one of global football's top clubs is under threat,
after having been found guilty of a majority of over 100 financial rule breaches.
It follows an unprecedented investigation that's lasted several years.
What punishment could follow is still to be decided, and the club is likely to appeal,
but one sanction could see them kicked out of the Premier League.
In a moment, we'll take a look at how the scandal came to light, the result of a hack
of City's emails, but first, Dan Rowan has our top story tonight from the Etihad Stadium
in Manchester.
Dan.
Clive, this is a ruling that will reverberate around the sporting world, and if it is confirmed
and upheld after any appeal by City, it will surely confirm one of English football's greatest
scandals.
The scale of this case is staggering, spanning 14 seasons, a period in which City won the
Premier League seven times.
The Premier League had come under mounting pressure over the amount of time this case
had been taking, but finally today, as first reported by The Athletic, came news, and it
was news that City had been dreading.
Over the past decade, Manchester City have enjoyed an era of unprecedented success, the
only English club in history to have won the top division title four times in a row.
But for years now, a cloud has hung above the Etihad, City accused of a catalogue of
financial rule violations by the very competition they dominated for so long.
And today, finally, came seismic news, City found guilty of the majority of 115 charges.
In a statement, the club said, the Premier League process remains ongoing, with significant
elements to be completed.
The club has diligently respected due process for eight years, on the basis that the Premier
League board and executive would behave as an independent, impartial and fair-minded
regulator, free from partisan influence.
And tonight, reaction from a former chairman and star player.
Well, I feel almost in a state of shock at this news, and I have to say I feel incredibly
sorry for our wonderful fans, great supporters who support the club through thick and thin,
and now find themselves with this problem that's a huge issue the club is facing.
What we did, they cannot take out of us.
I mean, it's something that is not paid off by money, you know, it's paid with effort,
with partnership, with, you know, being shoulder to shoulder every day.
This the reaction of fans outside the Etihad.
Regardless of what happens, we're certifying first and foremost, do I agree with the rules?
No, but if they broke the rules, then they broke the rules.
I don't want to say something's been tainted when we're not at the bottom of this, there's
still, you know, things to go on in the background.
It's a big club, they've got the infrastructure to fight it, they've got the money, I think
it'll be all right.
So how did we get here?
In February 2023, City faced a catalogue of alleged breaches of the Premier League rulebook.
54 charges over a failure to provide accurate financial information across nine seasons
and 14 more over a failure to provide accurate details for player and manager payments over
the same period.
They were also accused of 12 counts of failing to comply with both UEFA and Premier League
financial rules and 35 charges of failing to cooperate with the Premier League's investigation.
Manchester City have been accused of misrepresentation, effectively financial fraud, in the shape
of, first of all, artificially inflating the money coming into the club.
According to the Premier League, at the time, Manchester City were taking money from the
owner and pretending it was money from sponsors, and that went into their money-in column.
Denying all the allegations, City said they were surprised by the charges and supported
by what they called a body of irrefutable evidence.
How confident are you that you have been told everything?
My first thought is that we have already been condemned.
The saga began back in 2008, when City's fortunes were transformed after it was bought by Sheikh
Mansour, a billionaire member of Abu Dhabi's ruling family.
His wealth secured some of the world's best players and a first Premier League title in
2012.
But two years later, the club was sanctioned by UEFA for breaching financial fair play
rules that limited clubs' losses to deter overspending.
And then in 2016, German publication Der Spiegel published details from leaked emails.
The magazine claimed the documents showed that City had effectively deceived UEFA by
artificially inflating sponsorship revenue from state-owned companies.
City and the companies involved denied wrongdoing, the club saying the leaked emails were obtained
illegally and an attempt to damage its reputation, its chief executive declining to comment when
I asked at the time.
Mr Soriano, can we just ask you about Der Spiegel and the Football League story?
Thank you.
What do you have to say about that?
Thank you.
I have no comment.
In 2020, City were found to have broken UEFA's rules, but they appealed and had a two-year
ban from European competition overturned.
On the field, more and more titles were being won, but in February 2023 came the Premier
League's charges.
Are you confident?
A hearing took place more than two years ago, and on the eve of the new season, with a decision
still not revealed, I asked the Premier League's chief executive what was going on.
Are you surprised by the length of time it's taken, or do you think it's not a surprise
given the scope, given the scale of it?
It's hugely complex, the hearing took 12 weeks, and so it has taken longer than expected.
Finally, football appears to have one of its biggest ever results, but with no news of
a sanction and City set to appeal, the saga is far from over.
Well, you saw then how this story first emerged a full decade ago.
Laura Scott now takes a closer look at the role played by a computer hacker and his revelations.
He's the cherubic-looking, convicted computer hacker who for a decade has brought chaos
to the world of football, including Manchester City.
And yet even the most avid fans don't know the name Rui Pinto.
We travelled around Europe to find out more about this mysterious figure, long before
he made powerful enemies through his hacking.
Pinto was described as a normal, sociable schoolboy who had a humble upbringing in Portugal.
He was very good in computers, or the work that he did for various courses were very
good, when he put his mind to it.
Pinto moved to Budapest and in 2015 set up Football Leaks, which sought to show the hidden
side of football.
Having initially published everything on his Football Leaks website, Rui Pinto agreed
to meet a journalist, Raphael Buschmann, from the German magazine Der Spiegel.
Once he knew he could trust him, he shared tens of millions of documents with him.
It was then up to a team of journalists in this building in Hamburg to meticulously go
through it all, producing some of the most explosive articles the football world has ever seen.
It just painted a picture of the football world that we weren't able to paint before.
Rui Pinto absolutely is a whistleblower. He's one of the most important whistleblowers that
we have in Europe, or maybe the world.
Pinto has threatened to release more information in recent years, but his actions have brought
serious consequences for him personally, facing several court cases, including one brought
by sports bodies such as Benfica, which was dismissed on the basis he'd already been
convicted over similar charges in 2023.
He's a knacker, period. Just like that. What he did is not allowed. It's a crime and there
are no excuses.
He should be made an ally of our judicial and criminal investigative authorities.
What would you say then to Manchester City, who have had their email hacked by Rui Pinto?
Couldn't care less. Their problem? If they have nothing to hide, what's their problem?
For some, he's a criminal hacker who stole information with sinister intentions. To others,
he's a heroic whistleblower who shone a light on the darker side of the beautiful game.
Laura Scott, BBC News.
Well, this current season was meant to be a new era for City with a new manager and
a new squad. Instead, the club faces the prospect of their many titles and achievements being
tainted over recent years by a cheating scandal. And now there may well be, indeed there will
be, a sanctions ruling when they may face punishments ranging from very heavy fines
to points deductions, perhaps even expulsion from the league. And beyond that, the threat
of legal chaos as well with a number of rival clubs weighing up the possibility of seeking
compensation and damages from them if they feel that they've lost out on titles as a
result of City's rule-breaking. And so a long way to go still in this saga. And depending
on the outcome of any appeal, they must now hope that almost two decades of Premier League
history don't have to be rewritten.