Sky Sports News correspondent Kaveh Solhekol analyzes the severe fallout after Manchester City was found guilty of extensive breaches regarding Premier League financial rules. The independent commission revealed the systematic use of over eight hundred and thirty million pounds in disguised funding and sham contracts spanning from the 2009-10 to the 2017-18 seasons. The discussion details the impending sanctions hearing, the strict limitations of a new three-person appeal panel, potential unprecedented punishments like total expulsion, and massive upcoming legal compensation claims from rival clubs.
Manchester City has been found guilty of serious breaches of Premier League financial rules, involving over £830m in disguised funding and sham contracts between 2009 and 2018. The club faces a damning judgment and potential severe sanctions, while the Premier League seeks a resolution before the end of the current season.
Manchester City have been found guilty of all charges by an independent commission regarding
serious breaches of the Premier League's financial rules.
City used over £830m in disguised funding and sham contracts between the 2009-10 and
2017-18 seasons as they cemented their place as one of the biggest and most successful
clubs in the world.
So the big question now is what happens next.
Our Chief Correspondent Carvey Solicole joins me on set to discuss this.
Chief Correspondent Carvey, you've had nearly 24 hours now to digest this news since it
came out yesterday evening.
Have City appealed yet?
We know the deadline is Friday for that appeal to be lodged.
And how long could an appeal take and what is their mitigation, because they need grounds
for an appeal, don't they?
Definitely.
Look, they can't just appeal because they don't like the judgement that was released
yesterday.
They have to have grounds for an appeal.
For instance, they can't re-litigate the whole case.
They can't recall witnesses.
I think this appeal will happen this season.
I sense from the Premier League that they want this issue sorted out before the end
of the season.
The appeal will be a new three-person panel.
I suppose City could argue, for instance, that there were problems with the original
commission.
They could find fault with some of their findings.
The new panel would look and see whether the commission had made any serious mistakes.
But it is not going to be something that is going to take years and years.
I think it will be pretty quick.
And I think the Premier League want to make sure that we have the judgement from that
appeal well before the end of the season.
Looking at the judgement, the 40 pages that we've had, my personal opinion is that City
have a mountain to climb.
I don't see how they can possibly win an appeal because the judgement we had is so damning.
This is the biggest scandal I've ever seen in the history of sport.
This is not a one-off.
This is not doping to win one race.
This is cheating over nine seasons in the biggest sport in the world and in the biggest
and most watched league in the world as well.
In terms of what their mitigation might be and what their reasons for the appeal might
be, have we had any hints?
We've had a very bizarre video from the chief executive of Manchester City, somebody who
has been at City since 2012.
Now of course it's come to light now that if City's owners weren't artificially inflating
City's revenues, they would not have been in a position to be able to lure somebody
from Barcelona to come and be their chief executive.
So Mr Soriano has been at City for 14 years.
He was there for the vast majority of the time when this was happening.
Now he released the video yesterday which was initially for the 1,000 or so people who
work at City and you have to say it was bordering on the delusional what he was saying.
He wasn't even calling this judgement a judgement.
He was saying it was an opinion and he was suggesting that there's been this vast conspiracy
and that Manchester City in the end will come out victorious and he was sending out the
message to everyone who works for City, just trust us.
You do your jobs, we'll take care of everything else.
The sense I got from this video is that he's got his back to the wall and he wants to come
out fighting but when he looks around him, who is going to be fighting on his side?
Who still believes what he's saying and does he himself actually believe what he's saying?
The whole Premier League case against us is based on a single false accusation that
the owner's personal money was somehow and secretly put into the club via some sponsors
from Abu Dhabi.
This is just not true.
Irrefutable evidence has been provided to the Premier League Commission that shows that
it could not happen and that it did not happen.
This includes bank statements, money transfers, witnesses and everything necessary to categorically
demonstrate the money did not come from the owner.
In terms of potential punishments for Manchester City then, what powers did the Premier League
have?
Well, the Commission has almost unlimited powers.
There are no set punishments for breaking the Premier League's financial rules.
So it's basically at the discretion of the Commission but they have to be guided by what
is in the Premier League's rule book.
And I'm sure they will go back and look at other similar cases, well not similar but
other instances when clubs have broken the financial rules.
But in those cases, for instance, Everton, Nottingham Forest, those have been for one
breach of the rules.
This is for well over 100 breaches of the rules.
A lot of people think that they will get a points deduction.
You are talking a points deduction which could be 100 points but a lot of people say that
is not enough because if they got a 100 point deduction this season, what would happen?
They would finish bottom of the table, they would be relegated to the Championship and
with the money they have, they would be straight back.
Is that enough of a punishment?
And that is why I think a lot of football fans you speak to will say the appropriate
punishment is to expel them from the Premier League because this happened over at least
nine seasons and it completely distorted the competition, it robbed a lot of teams of titles
and trophies and a lot of players of winners medals as well.
I think we will find out pretty quickly what the punishment is going to be.
I think it could be a matter of weeks or maybe a couple of months before we get the judgement
because what we need to happen is for there to be a sanctions hearing and at that hearing
the Premier League will put forward their case of what they believe the punishment should
be and Manchester City will argue and try and make sure that the punishment they get
is not severe but what can they argue?
The judgement is so damning that I don't see where they can go apart from saying we are
totally innocent and we have irrefutable evidence.
Well you must have produced the irrefutable evidence at the hearing and these very, very
senior legal individuals, we don't know who they are yet, probably a former judge, KC's
have looked at it and said you are guilty as charged.
There is big potential isn't there for litigation from other Premier League clubs, what can
you tell us about that, what could that look like and where could that end up?
Well look this is an absolutely great time to be a sports lawyer in England, if I wasn't
a journalist I wish I was a sports lawyer because they will be calling up all the other
Premier League clubs and all the other clubs who have been affected by Manchester City's
cheating and saying we believe that we can represent you in bringing action against Manchester
City for compensation because of money that you may have missed out on, on not winning
the title, on failing to finish in Champions League places, so this is another serious
problem for Manchester City going forward and we know already that four Premier League
clubs reserved the right a couple of years ago to sue Manchester City for compensation,
those four clubs were Manchester United, Liverpool, Arsenal and Spurs.