Burnham’s First Budget (It’s Not Looking Good…)

Workplace Wavelengths
31 followers
Run a small business and worried about what Andy Burnham's first Budget could mean for your tax bill?
0:00 - Intro
0:30 - The Budget Has a Maths Problem
1:35 - What Happens to the Personal Allowance?
3:18 - Employer National Insurance
5:18 - The New 10% Income Tax Rate
7:02 - What Has Burnham Actually Changed?
8:18 - Where Could Burnham Find the Money?
9:08 - Dividend Tax
10:04 - Capital Gains Tax
11:10 - Corporation Tax
12:08 - Property & Wealth
13:25 - Final Thoughts
#investing
#business
⚠️ Disclaimer: All opinions are my own. Information is correct at time of filming. This video does not constitute personalised financial advice.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Andy Burnham's first budget is coming on the 28th of October and it's looking like your tax bill
will increase. Since Mr Burnham came in I've been paying close attention to what he's been saying
about the budget and here's what I think you need to be ready for. Freezing tax thresholds,
employers' national insurance, personal allowance and more. So in this video we're going to break
down the promised changes, the speculation and the wider story of what's happening with UK tax
Before we start looking at individual taxes there's one thing we need to understand about
Andy Burnham's first budget. The numbers have to add up because Burnham's already announced tax
cuts, he's talked about others and at the same time the government has acknowledged that the
financial position is challenging and crucially tax rises have not been ruled out by him. Now
governments really only have three ways of finding more money. They can raise taxes, they can cut
spending or they can borrow more. So if Burnham wants to cut taxes in one place but doesn't have
the money to pay for it, something somewhere has to give and this is where I think this budget gets
interesting because the biggest tax rise on the 28th of October might not necessarily be the one
that gets splashed across the front pages the following morning. It could be something he simply
chooses not to change and we're already starting to see an example of that. So as we go through this
budget keep one question in the back of your mind, not just what is Burnham giving us but how is
Burnham paying for it. One of the things I'll be watching on budget day is what Burnham does with
the personal allowance because this is potentially one of the easiest ways for the government to
collect more tax without actually increasing income tax rates at all. The personal allowance
is currently £12,570, the amount most people can earn before they start paying income tax
and the higher rate threshold is £50,270. Those thresholds have been frozen for years
so as wages, pensions and the minimum wage go up but the thresholds don't, more and more of your
income gradually becomes taxable and more people are getting dragged into higher rates. That's
fiscal drag or as it's sometimes known a stealth tax and this is where things get interesting with
Burnham because when he was campaigning in the Makefield by-election Burnham said the freezing
of the personal allowance was one of the things he'd heard most about on the doorstep and when
he became Prime Minister there was a lot of talk about him potentially unfreezing that £12,570
threshold but then just days after entering number 10 the language started to change. Burnham started
playing down the suggestions that the personal allowance would actually be increased in this
first budget pointing to how expensive it would be given the state of the public finances and he
does have a point. The IFS estimates that simply returning the personal allowance to inflation
linked increases from April 2027 could eventually cost the Treasury around £8.4 billion a year and
that's something that Burnham and Healey just don't want. So this is our first real example of
the problem I mentioned earlier. It's very easy to talk about giving people a tax cut, it becomes
considerably harder when somebody shows you the bill and if Burnham leaves the personal allowance
at £12,570 it might not look like a tax rise on budget day, there's no big announcement, there's
no increase from 20% to 21% but effectively as your income rises and the threshold doesn't your
tax bill can still keep going up. So one of the first things I'll be looking for isn't just has
Healey cut income tax, it's has he actually moved the threshold because if he hasn't one of the tax
rises we were looking for might already be staring us in the face. But this is where it gets slightly
strange because at the same time Andy Burnham appears to be backing away from unfreezing the
personal allowance, he's also been talking about introducing an entirely new 10% starting rate of
and when you put those two things together there's an obvious question, why introduce a new tax cut
while keeping the stealth tax? For business owners there's another potential U-turn I'll be watching
very closely, employer national insurance because this has become a significant additional cost of
employing people. Employers are now paying national insurance at 15% and the point at which they start
paying it was reduced to just 5,000 of an employee's salary and the problem isn't necessarily
that businesses immediately start making people redundant. From what I see it's often much more
subtle than that, a business that was thinking about taking on another member of staff decides
to wait, someone who might have taken on an apprentice decides they can't quite justify the
cost or when somebody leaves perhaps they don't replace them and that potentially creates another
problem, we've already got a serious number of young people who are not in education, employment
or training, often referred to as NEETs. Now I'm not suggesting employer NI totally caused that,
there are obviously much bigger and more complicated reasons around it as well but when you increase
the cost of employing somebody, businesses potentially become more cautious about taking
on the next person and the people who might find that hardest are often those trying to get the
foot on the first rung of the ladder, younger workers with less experience. So if Burnham wants
to improve job prospects and opportunities for younger people, keeping a tax increase that
potentially makes businesses think twice about hiring them does seem slightly contradictory,
particularly because Burnham himself previously criticised the employer NI increase calling it
the wrong decision. So naturally business owners might be thinking brilliant, does that mean he's
going to reverse it? Well this is where we run straight back into our maths problem because
reversing employer NI might be very popular with businesses but it would also mean giving up
billions of pounds of tax revenue and suddenly criticising a tax rise from outside number 10
is rather easier than reversing it when you're responsible for balancing the books. So I think
there are actually three things to watch on budget day. Does he reverse the increase completely?
Does he reduce the 15% rate? Or, and I think this could be interesting for smaller businesses,
does he leave the rate alone but change the threshold or introduce more targeted relief?
Because if he does none of those things that's another important part of this budget story.
Burnham might announce new measures designed to help businesses whilst leaving one of the biggest
recent tax increases completely untouched. That brings us to something even stranger because
while Burnham appears to be cooling expectations around some tax cuts, he's still been talking
about creating this entirely new 10% starting rate of income tax which sounds great until you
ask who's paying for it. And this is where things get slightly confusing because whilst Burnham
appears to be cooling expectations about unfreezing personal allowance, he's also talked a lot about
this new 10% starting rate of income tax which on the face of it sounds great. Instead of somebody
going straight from paying no income tax all the way up to 20%, the idea would be to introduce a
lower 10% band for some of that income. For lower earners that could mean a genuine reduction in the
tax bill. But there are two fairly big questions. Firstly, how big would that 10% band actually be?
Because a 10% rate sounds fantastic in a headline but if it only applies to a relatively small amount
of income, the actual saving might be considerably less exciting. Secondly, and I think this is much
more interesting, how do you pay for it? We've just seen Burnham playing down expectations of
increasing the personal allowance, partly because of how much money that could cost the Treasury.
If there isn't enough money to unfreeze the £12,570 personal allowance, where does the money come from
for a brand new 10% income tax rate? Remember, if the personal allowance stays frozen, fiscal
drag doesn't suddenly disappear. Wages and pensions can continue rising but more income
gets dragged into tax and the government continues collecting that extra revenue. So
potentially you could have a very attractive new 10% tax rate appearing in the budget headlines
whilst the frozen thresholds continue increasing the amount of tax people pay in the background.
That doesn't mean a 10% starting rate would be a bad thing. Depending on where the thresholds are
set, it could genuinely help lower earners. But I wouldn't judge this one from the headline. I'd
want to see exactly who qualifies, how much income gets taxed at 10%, what happens to the other
thresholds and most importantly, where the Treasury is getting the money to pay for it. Because we're
now starting to build quite a shopping list. Burnham's already announced two more tax cuts
that are definitely happening, which means our maths problem is about to get even bigger. So far
we've looked at things Burnham has talked about doing and things he already appears
slightly less certain about. But there are also tax cuts that are actually happening. From the
1st of October, that on domestic electricity has been cut from 5% to zero. That's expected to save
the average household around £45. So yeah, not exactly enough to retire on but I'll take the £45.
And Burnham's already announced a 20% reduction in business rates for pubs, social clubs and
qualifying live music venues in England from April 2027. Again, good news if you qualify.
But notice that word qualify. This isn't a 20% business rates cut for every small business. If
you run a shop, an accountancy practice, a manufacturing business or any of other businesses
with premises, you don't automatically get that reduction. This is where our maths problem gets
bigger. We've potentially got an expensive new 10% income tax rate. We've got pressure to reverse
employer NI. We've got VAT being removed from domestic electricity. We've got targeted business
rates cuts. Somebody has to pay for all of this and Burnham's already refused to rule out tax
rises. So if I were a business owner, landlord or investor, there are four areas I'd be watching
very closely on the 28th of October because this is where he could potentially come looking for the
money. Now, I want to be very clear before we get into this, none of these tax rises have been
announced. I'm not telling you Burnham is definitely going to increase any of them on the
28th of October, but we've already established that the numbers have to add up. So if Burnham
needs money but doesn't want a huge headline income tax rise, where are the tempting places to
look? And by the way, if you want to keep up with this as we get closer to the budget, make sure
you subscribe. I'll be covering any new announcements, rumours that actually have some substance
behind them and of course, exactly what changes when we finally get the budget on the 28th of
October. Let's start with the one that I think limited company directors should have firmly on
their radar, dividend tax. Dividend tax has already become considerably less attractive for company
directors over the last few years. The tax free dividend allowance is now only a paltry £500 and
dividend tax rates increased again from April 2026. The government wants to raise more money
from people who receive income outside of a traditional salary. Dividends are an obvious
area to watch and you don't need an enormous increase for it to hurt. If you're taking tens
of thousands of pounds in dividends every year, another single percentage point here or another
reduction in allowance there can add up surprisingly quickly. Capital gains tax, the next one I'd be
watching, particularly if you own investments, property or you spent 20 years building a business
that you eventually intend to sell. The temptation for governments has always been fairly obvious.
Why should somebody pay one rate of tax for earning money through work or potentially another
rate when the value of an asset increases? But there's another side to that argument. If someone
has spent years risking their own money, building a business, employing people and creating something
valuable, how much tax can you put on the eventual reward before you start discouraging people from
taking that risk in the first place? So I'd be watching not just the CGT rates but the allowances
and reliefs around selling businesses and other assets as well. Corporation tax is slightly
different because I wouldn't only watch the headline rate. This is something business owners
sometimes miss. A chancellor can stand up and say corporation tax isn't increasing, right,
but that doesn't necessarily mean your company's tax position hasn't changed. Capital allowances
can change. Reliefs can change. Investment incentives can change. The rules determining
which expenses receive tax relief can change. So on budget day, don't just look at the big
corporation tax number on the screen. Sometimes what happens underneath it matters just as much.
And finally, I'd be watching property and wealth. Landlords have already had a pretty relentless
few years of tax changes. People with assets are politically much easier to target than somebody
receiving an ordinary salary. So I'd be watching property taxes, investment income,
capital gains tax, and inheritance tax particularly carefully. And there's a reason
I've left this one to last. Because if Burnham wants to give lower earners a 10% income tax rate
while raising more revenue elsewhere, shifting more of the tax burden away from employment and
towards assets and wealth is one possible route. I'm not predicting that's what he'll do, but it'll
absolutely be something I'd have on my budget watch list. And this brings us back to the point
that I made right at the beginning. The biggest tax rise on the 28th of October might not actually
be announced as a tax rise. It could be a frozen threshold, a relief that disappears, an allowance
that gets smaller, or a tax that Burnham criticised before becoming Prime Minister that he simply
decides to leave exactly where it is. That's why I wouldn't make any major tax decisions based on
rumours before the budget. Wait until we know what's actually been announced, look beyond the
headlines at the detail, and then decide what, if anything, you need to change. If you're worried
about your business though and want to chat through the implications and get help in advance,
feel free to get in touch. The link's below. See you next time.
