Accountant Explains: Never Finance a Car This Way (2026)

Harmony Hive Workplace
33 followers
5 Video Views·Aug 10, 2026
In this video I share the different ways to buy a car and what the most cost-effective one is.
DISCLAIMERS & DISCLOSURES
This content is for educational and entertainment purposes only. Nischa does not provide tax or investment advice. The information is being presented without consideration of the investment objectives, risk tolerance, or financial circumstances of any specific investor and might not be suitable for all investors. Past performance is not indicative of future results. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.
AI Generated·May contain errors
So a while back I made a video on whether you should buy, finance or lease a car and it became
one of the most watched videos on this channel. Because on one side you've got people arguing that
buying the car outright is always the best move because you get full ownership and it works out
cheaper in the long run. But on the other side you've got people who still swear by financing
or leasing because you pay far less each month and you get to drive around a brand new car.
And thousands of you have said that you saved money from watching that video before buying.
But a lot's changed since then. So I went back, I re-ran every single number from scratch and
I was pretty surprised by what I found. Including one option that I never mentioned last time.
One that almost nobody at the dealership would bring up either because there's nothing in it
for them. So in this video we're going to cover the five main ways to pay for a car,
what each one actually is, which one works out the cheapest and finally the psychological factors you
need to weigh up before you decide. This is part of an accountant explained series on this channel
where every Sunday we break down all things personal finance and building wealth. Let's dive
in. Before we compare the numbers let's quickly go through the main options that you have available
when buying a car and how they work. Let's start with higher purchase. If you'd like to own your
car but you don't have the cash to buy it outright today you probably would look at this option,
a higher purchase. It's essentially buying a car in installments. So you put down an initial
deposit say 10-20% and then you spread the rest of the cost over several years making fixed
monthly payments. Once you've made the final repayment the car is yours to keep. The downside
is that you'll usually pay interest on the amount you've borrowed meaning you'll end up paying more
than the car's original price. The next option you have is a PCP or a personal contract purchase and
if your priority is keeping your monthly payments low you might feel like this is the better option.
With a PCP you're not paying off the whole car instead you're mainly paying for the amount the
car is expected to lose in value during the time that you have it. So again you'll put down an
initial deposit and make monthly payments and you're also told at that time the car's residual
value i.e how much it'll be worth at the end of the agreement. So your payments will stop once you
reach the end of your agreement and at that time you have three options. You could pay that residual
value to make that car yours, you can choose to hand that car back and not pay a single additional
penny or if the car's actually worth more than the residual value at that time you can trade it in
and put that extra value which is the equity towards your next car. So the payments for this
are usually lower than the option in higher purchase but you don't automatically own the
car at the end and as I'll show you in a minute a lower monthly payment doesn't actually automatically
make something cheaper either. The third option you have is leasing so if you enjoy driving a
brand new car every few years and you don't want to be responsible for any repairs you don't want
the hassle of selling it later on you might think leasing can be a great fit because since you're
not buying the car you won't need a deposit in the traditional sense. Instead you'll put down what's
known as an initial payment which is usually much lower than the deposit of a higher purchase
or what you'd have to pay for a PCP. Once you reach the end of your term there'll be nothing
left to pay you'll simply hand the keys back and then it's up to you whether you then lease another
car or you use one of the other options I talk about today. The fourth option which I never
mentioned in my last video and it's one that almost nobody at the dealership will mention
either this is a personal loan. This is where you borrow the money from a bank or a lender directly
totally separate from the dealership and the car itself and then you use that money that you
borrowed to buy the car outright. So the day you drive off that car you fully own it and then you
pay the bank back in monthly fixed payments with interest over the years of how long you've agreed
with the bank. The rates for a personal loan are often cheaper which is why this can make a lot of
sense but there are also times when a car dealership is running one of their low interest promotions
which may make buying a car from a car dealership and using the finance available from a car
dealership actually more cost effective. So whilst I'm not going to include this in the calculations
for the next stage it is such an important one to consider and when running the different options
for yourself but the interest rate really depends on who you are your credit score and the kind of
term that you're looking at. And then you have the fifth option which is buying outright. If you've
got the cash available buying outright is often the most straightforward option. You pay once,
you own the car immediately, you never have to worry about monthly payments or any interest again
for that car. So now that we've got that aside let's dig a little bit deeper and put each of
these options head to head to find out which one is going to be the best one for you when it comes
to the numbers. So to keep things fair let's compare the exact same car under each option
and we'll use the brand new Audi A3 Sportback. It's with a purchase price of £35,000.
We're assuming excellent credit and a four-year ownership period. So without using too much jargon
I've tried to keep it as simple as possible for you to follow and I'm using real examples of what
you'd actually pay today for the same car using the different financing options that I've just
mentioned. So let's start with the number every dealership loves to say first which is the monthly
payment. With higher purchase after putting down a £3,500 deposit your monthly repayments come to
around £791. With PCP you'll also put down £3,500 up front but because you're not repaying the full
purchase price during the agreement your monthly payment falls to around £545. Then you have
leasing where instead of a deposit you'll pay an initial rental equivalent to three months payment
which in this example works out at around £1,130. After that your monthly payment is just £377.
Finally if you buy the car outright there are no monthly payments at all you simply pay
the full £35,000 on day one so if monthly payments were the only thing that you cared about
leasing would appear to be the cheapest option followed by PCP. But now let's fast forward four
years and see what you've actually spent. Over the full agreement higher purchase costs around
£41,500. PCP is a similar ballpark around £43,815 assuming you make the final balloon payment of
Leasing it's much cheaper in terms of cash paid out costing around £18,830 over the four years
and if you buy the car outright you've spent £35,000 from day one. But that is still not
the full picture because as we said earlier with higher purchase and PCP and buying outright you
still own the car at the end of those four years. So based on average depreciation which is just
the rate a car loses value over time that Audi could still be worth around £17,000. It may not
be but I'm using this number to illustrate what the different scenarios would be if we could
assume this. In this case it means you could sell it and get a big chunk of your money back with
leasing you can't do that. You hand the keys back and then there's nothing left to sell because you
never owned it in the first place. So the number that actually matters isn't what you paid it's
what the car has truly cost once you take that resale value into account and once we subtract
what you get back from selling it the whole picture changes again. Buying outright comes out cheapest
at a net four-year cost of around £17,850. Leasing is next at around £18,837
then higher purchase at £24,318 and then PCP is the most expensive out of the lot
at around £26,665. And now whilst these exact figures won't hold for every car every deal
because of interest rates resale values and how manufacturer offer deal offers all move around
the principle around it never changes which is the monthly payment only tells you what
leaves your account each month it tells you nothing about what the car actually costs you
to own or whether a different option could have left you thousands of pounds better off in the
long run. And something else worth considering here is opportunity costs if you pay the full
£35,000 on day one and you buy the car outright sure that would be the cheapest option as we've
seen but there is an opportunity cost because that money is now locked up in that car well locked up
whatever you know what I mean. The alternative is you put down the £3,500 deposit and then you
invest what's left over into something like a low-cost index fund or another asset that earns
you a return and then the question therefore is can you make a better return on that money invested
than the extra cost that you'd pay off financing. If you can then financing can actually come out
ahead the word for that gap is arbitrage which really just means your money is earning more
than it's costing you and on paper that sounds great but there are two problems with this. First
the interest rate in your debt is guaranteed you know exactly what it's costing you the return on
the stock market is anything but especially in the short term it swings around one year to the next
so there's no way to make a very clean accurate mathematical decision here you're weighing a fixed
cost against an unpredictable short-term return. And the second thing here is should and actually
do are two very different things in theory you invest that leftover money sure and you leave it
alone in reality for a lot of people it just melts into everyday spending instead. So those are the
numbers and based purely on the numbers you might think that buying outright is the obvious answer
but personal finance is personal and the cheapest option on a spreadsheet isn't automatically the
right one for you. So before you decide how to pay for a car there are three questions I'd ask myself
number one are you focusing on the right number when you're buying or financing a car the dealership
or the broker is going to put almost all their attention on how affordable the monthly payment is
so even if you could afford to buy the car outright you might be tempted to finance it instead and
then keep your cash in the bank. But as we've just seen the monthly payment doesn't tell you what the
car really costs over the life of the agreement and focusing on it can actually trick you into
buying a more expensive car than you ever planned to. Say your budget was 25,000 and the salesperson
nudges you towards the one that's 35,000 pounds as a lump sum when I say those numbers that that
is a huge jump you'd probably say no I'm okay I don't want that but when it's framed as just an
extra 80 pounds a month suddenly it doesn't feel like that much it might even feel like you're
getting a bit of a deal so you always want to look at the bigger picture and not just the monthly
payments and when you could afford it but also the total ownership costs. Number two how important is
and for some people it might very well be worth paying more for from more for the latest safety
features for a manufacturer's warranty for lower maintenance costs or just the enjoyment of driving
something new. Nothing wrong with that as long as you're choosing it consciously rather than being
talked into it but on the flip side if you're the kind of person who keeps a car for the next 10
years buying often becomes far better value because you're spreading that big upfront drop in value
over a much longer period. And number three how does this car actually fit against my other
financial goals? Whether you're buying it outright or whether you're paying in monthly installments
you always want to weigh up how it fits within the holistic financial picture. How does it weigh up
against your other fundamentals things like your rent, your mortgage, your bills? How does it weigh
up against your savings and investments? Does it still give you enough leftover? How does it weigh
up against other things that you spend on daily that contribute as fun? Does it still give you
enough leftover to spend on the fun stuff or are you willing to sacrifice a little bit of the fun
spending to go a bit more premium on your car? This is the kind of thing you could run through
very quickly. I recommend using my intentional spending track card because it's already
categorized into buckets. Anytime I want to buy something big or take on any kind of credit this
is the philosophy I always work with and within seconds I know exactly where I stand and what I
can actually afford and where I want to cut back. If you want to use my one it's completely free
it's linked in the description. So before you sign any finance agreement I've run through four
questions. First, how long am I realistically planning to keep this car? Secondly, am I
prioritizing a lower monthly payment or a lower long-term cost? Third, how much do the latest
features a warranty and the convenience of a newer car actually matter to me? And fourth, will this
decision still let me build the other priorities that are important in my life? These four questions
will get you to a far better decision than the one everyone else is stuck on which is just can I
afford the monthly payment? If you get them right you'll never end up being caught out by shiny
monthly figure in a car dealership window again. Hopefully this helps. If it does help please send
it to someone you know who is also looking at buying a new car. I've had so many people say
the last video I made helped on this topic so much so I've made an updated version for anyone
who's in the same position right now and hopefully it again saves you lots of money before you buy
one of the most expensive purchases of your life. Thanks so much for watching, see you next week.
