What was it like inside the Pentagon when it was attacked on September 11th?
In this special episode of The Brief — part of our ongoing 9/11 25th anniversary coverage — host Shabbos Kestenbaum sits down with retired Lieutenant General David Deptula, Dean of the Mitchell Institute for Aerospace Studies and former U.S. Air Force commander, to discuss the 25th anniversary of the September 11th terrorist attacks.
General Deptula was inside the Pentagon on the morning of 9/11, just two corridors away from where Flight 77 struck the building. He describes watching the second plane hit the World Trade Center, realizing America was under attack, hearing the explosion at the Pentagon, evacuating the building, and later helping design and execute America’s military response in Afghanistan.
The conversation also addresses two of the most persistent 9/11 conspiracy theories: the claim that the Pentagon was hit by a missile instead of Flight 77, and the claim that Donald Rumsfeld’s September 10th statement about $2.3 trillion proved a cover-up.
They also cover: What Deptula saw, heard, and felt inside the Pentagon in the minutes after impact — and why people on the other side of the building didn't even know they'd been hit. Why he predicted, while watching the second plane hit the World Trade Center, that the Pentagon would be "a logical third target" — and then went back to work at his desk. The Iraq War: Deptula clarifies the distinction most Americans never fully understood — Iraq was not the military response to 9/11, and the 9/11 Commission found no evidence Iraq cooperated with al-Qaeda. The lesson of Afghanistan and Iraq: "Military effectiveness is necessary but not sufficient. If military objectives aren't tied to clearly defined political objectives, tactical excellence alone cannot deliver strategic success."
Lieutenant General David Deptula (ret.) is Dean of the Mitchell Institute for Aerospace Studies and a senior scholar at the US Air Force Academy's Institute for Future Conflict. He served 34 years in the US Air Force, flying more than 3,000 hours, including 400 in combat.
🔔 Subscribe to The Brief—and like 👍 if you think America needs to win the AI race.
On September 11, my office was in the Pentagon when I heard a muffled explosion.
American Airlines Flight 77 hit the building.
What was your immediate reaction?
I distinctly remember my next thought.
This was not an accident.
The United States was under attack.
Was it the right decision to have launched this war in Iraq and Afghanistan?
The fact of the matter is the threats facing the United States today are much greater
than what we faced on 9-11-2001.
How would you respond to those who suggest there was no plane,
but it was actually a missile?
And welcome back to The Brief.
We have a special episode pertaining to our ongoing conversation
on the September 11, 2001 attacks.
As we commemorate 25 years since the greatest terrorist attack on American soil,
it's really imperative that we have a multitude of perspectives.
And that's why we brought on today General David Deptula.
He's the Dean of the Mitchell Institute for Aerospace Studies
and a senior scholar at the U.S. Air Force Academy's Institute for Future Conflict.
He actually transitioned from the U.S. Air Force in 2010
at the rank of Lieutenant General after more than 34 years of service.
And General, we really appreciate you coming on today.
Well, thanks very much.
I'm looking forward to our discussion.
So before we get into that fateful morning of September 11, 2001,
I thought it'd be helpful for our audience
if you could just describe what were you doing in the Pentagon
and what was your role in the military?
Yeah, on September 11, 2001, I was a Major General or Two-Star General
serving as the Director of the Air Force's Quadrennial Defense Review.
I'll tell you what that's all about here in a second.
But my office was in the Pentagon.
It was room 5D-156 and was just two quarters away
from where American Airlines Flight 77 hit the building.
Now, the Quadrennial Defense Review was a major strategic assessment
of what threats the United States was going to face in the future
and what kind of military that we needed to deal with them.
Now, there's some irony in this or that, being it was 25 years ago,
we were sitting there trying to anticipate the future security environment.
And that morning, the future changed right in front of us.
General John Jumper, the new Air Force Chief of Staff,
called me into his office and he asked me to deploy to Southwest Asia
to take over command of the Combined Air Operations Center
and help design and execute the military response to those attacks.
So on the morning of 9-11, you're actually commanded
to take these counterterrorism programs seriously.
I mean, that's just fascinating.
So I have to ask then, 9-37 is when the plane hit.
What happened to you on that morning?
If you wouldn't mind just describing the moment of impact itself.
I mean, what was your immediate reaction?
You know, I mentioned that I was working on the Quadrennial Defense Review.
Matter of fact, what we were doing was I was writing up
some of the final conclusions for the Air Force portion of that defense review.
It was a beautiful day in Washington, all up and down the East Coast.
Clear blue sky, not a cloud in sight.
And my deputy, Brigadier General Ron Bath, called me
because he had not come in early that day.
He kind of had the late shift and told me, he said,
hey, turn on the television.
An airplane just hit the World Trade Center.
Now, my initial reaction was, you know,
with some sort of light airplane and the pilot must have had a heart attack
because, you know, how do you hit a building on a beautiful day like this?
So I went over to the TV and I didn't normally have it on.
I turned it on and I started watching it.
And as I was watching, the second plane hit.
And so in that instant, there was no longer any question in my mind
that this was not an accident.
The United States was under attack.
And I'll share with you, I distinctly remember my next thought.
And that was, you know, the Pentagon would make a logical third target.
Wow.
But, you know, there's not a whole lot I could do about that.
So I went back to my work, went back to my desk
and started finishing up the report that I was working on.
And about 20 minutes later, the Pentagon was hit.
I was sitting at my desk when I heard what I would describe
as a muffled explosion.
The building shook, but not very much.
Quite frankly, I don't even remember feeling a whole lot of anything.
But the alarm started going off.
Now, remember, my office was only two quarters away from the impact area.
And my first responsibility was to the people who worked for me.
So I directed my staff that I had there to account for everyone
in our organization.
And once we'd done that, knew where our people were, I released them all.
And getting out of the Pentagon was not as simple as just walking to the nearest door.
Some exits were closed.
You could see smoke and fire across the courtyard.
Cell phone service was useless.
I couldn't get a hold of my wife.
And eventually, I worked my way over to the river entrance.
And that's the entrance I got out and crossed over to the marina.
I'm just interested, at what point did you realize that this was a commercial airliner
that had just rammed itself into the Pentagon?
Did you just think this was an explosion, a fire?
When did you realize it was a plane?
Well, actually, right away.
Because, you know, obviously, I'd watched the airplane hit the Second World Trade Center
and made the connection, as I shared with you, that, hey, it'd be logical that somewhere in
Washington, particularly the Pentagon, would be a logical third target.
So, you know, when the plane hit, the alarms went off.
When the explosion occurred, because I didn't physically see the airplane hit,
but when the explosion occurred, it was just logical that it was another plane.
So let me ask, given that it just seemed so logical, of course,
the second tower of the Twin Towers is attacked at 9.03 a.m.
You then have roughly 30 minutes before the Pentagon is hit.
Why was there not any type of reaction amongst security, amongst, I don't know,
those at the Pentagon themselves that, hey, we have to evacuate as a precaution anyway,
even though we don't know that there's a deliberate attack on the Pentagon?
Nevertheless, as an abundance of caution, we're going to leave anyway.
That's a lot to expect from a security service.
Hindsight's 20-20.
I certainly wouldn't expect that kind of reaction because there really was no way to know.
Again, in retrospect, could someone have said, hey, we might be under attack?
Maybe, but that's not something that I would have expected.
So let me just go back to the evacuation just for a second.
The evacuation of the Pentagon is obviously markedly different than the evacuation of
the World Trade Center.
You're dealing with a much more complicated building with a lot more people.
I'm just curious, when it comes to the Pentagon itself,
your personal experience was relatively simplistic.
But do you know of other people or other stories
whereby evacuation was a lot more tedious?
Can you talk about some of the first responders on the scene?
The river entrance is 180 degrees opposite of where the airliner hit.
So the initial route that I chose to leave, and look, everyone inside the building.
As a matter of fact, people on that side of the building
didn't even know that the building had been hit when it was.
Wow.
That's kind of how solid it was.
I'll share with you something that I was discussing with someone not too long ago.
The Pentagon was in the process of being reconstructed,
and that particular segment of the Pentagon had just been reinforced and completed.
That's why it wasn't fully occupied.
We were fortunate in that it wasn't fully occupied,
or many, many more people in the Pentagon would have been killed.
And it was also a lot more sturdy, if you will.
But back to your evacuation question,
when I originally tried to get out the mall entrance, but it was closed off.
So that, you know, people rerouted out the river entrance and another side.
So, you know, it's relatively straightforward, people walking out of the building.
Now there's 25,000 people that work in the Pentagon.
So it's not like just a handful of people.
You're talking about, you know, 25,000 people.
So it's a lot of folk.
Well, this actually might be a silly question,
but comparing it to New York City, for example,
the question was, what do you do not only with the evacuees from the World Trade Center,
but from the millions of people in downtown Manhattan?
You know, where do they go?
So I guess I'm just curious.
You now have roughly 25,000 people on the lawn of the Pentagon.
Where do you all go?
What are you instructed to do?
You now understand that a plane has hit the building.
You understand America's under attack.
What now?
Well, people went home, obviously.
You use your mode of transportation.
Obviously, not everyone drives.
It's a good question.
I never followed up on bus service and how that went.
But in my particular case, you know, I commuted by kind of metro during that time frame.
But I had a good friend that lived over in Roslyn.
And I hung out over in the marina that is opposite from the river entrance
and then started to walk over to his house.
And that's how I ended up ultimately getting home.
I walked over to Roslyn, got in touch with my deputy.
It was Ron Bath, Brigadier General Ron Bath.
And then we hung out until the traffic kind of dissipated.
And, you know, he drove me home about five o'clock that evening.
So let me ask you something that I wish I didn't have to ask.
But we recently had an episode here on The Brief with a journalist,
Gerald Posner, and we went through all the conspiracies surrounding
the September 11th terrorist attacks.
And I think one of the most bizarre, frankly, conspiracies
is that the Pentagon itself was not hit by a plane, but actually a missile.
And there was no plane at all.
There was no Flight 77.
And for you and I, we might say that that's absurd.
But as I said, there's a significant amount of the populace,
at least on social media, who really swear by this theory.
So how would you respond to those who suggest
there was no plane, but it was actually a missile?
Let me answer that from two perspectives
in kind of taking a mature approach to this, not an emotional one.
First, I was there.
I mean, I was two quarters away when the Pentagon was struck.
Now, I want to be precise.
I did not personally see the airplane hit the Pentagon.
So I'm not going to claim that I did.
But the idea that a missile hit the Pentagon instead of American Airlines Flight 77
is simply inconsistent with an enormous body of physical, forensic,
eyewitness, and investigative evidence.
I mean, we know that Flight 77 departed Dulles Airport that morning.
We know who was aborted.
We know it was hijacked.
There were communications from people aboard the aircraft.
There were witnesses who saw the airplane approaching the Pentagon.
Aircraft wreckage was recovered inside and around the building.
The flight data recorder was recovered from inside the Pentagon.
And it provided the altitude, the speed, heading, and timing information.
And remains of the people aboard the aircraft
were recovered and identified through forensic methods, including DNA.
The FBI conducted the largest investigation in its history into the 9-11 attacks
and concluded that American Airlines Flight 77
was hijacked by five terrorists and crashed into the Pentagon.
64 people aboard the aircraft and 125 people inside the Pentagon were killed.
So when somebody says, you know, where's the evidence that an airplane hit the Pentagon?
My response is the evidence isn't one photograph or one eyewitness.
It's the convergence of radar, air traffic records, witnesses, aircraft wreckage,
flight recorder data, forensic identification of the victims,
the known history of the flight, and the physical damage to the building.
All of those independent lines of evidence point to the same conclusion.
And that's that American Airlines Flight 77 hit the Pentagon on September 11, 2001.
So I just have to ask one last question on that note, which again, I wish I didn't,
but I think it's really important for our viewers to hear it from someone who was there.
On September 10th of 2001, Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld was giving a press conference.
You can watch it. It's still on the internet today on C-SPAN.
And he talks about this untraceable $2.3 trillion that the Pentagon has lost track of.
And a lot of internet conspiracy theorists, they'll look at that and say,
well, the timing has to be something more than just coincidental.
You're talking about the loss of trillions of dollars.
And then no one remembers it because the next day, coincidentally,
there's this terrorist attack.
So again, I just think it's important to hear it from you.
How would you respond to those who say, well,
the timing here is just too odd to merely be random?
Well, that claim takes a real Pentagon accounting problem
and turns it into something that it was not.
Secretary Rumsfeld did refer on September 10th to roughly $2.3 trillion in transactions
that couldn't be adequately tracked through the Defense Department's antiquated financial systems.
But that did not mean that $2.3 trillion in cash had disappeared.
I mean, the underlying Inspector General work dealt with fiscal year 1999 financial statements.
The department had processed trillions of dollars in accounting entries,
and approximately $2.3 trillion of those entries
did not have adequate documentation or audit trails to support them.
Now, that's a serious accounting and financial management failure,
but it's very different from saying somebody misplaced or stole $2.3 trillion.
Here's another important point.
This was not revealed for the first time on September 10th, 2001.
The underlying problems had already been documented publicly
in Defense Department Inspector General work and discussed in Congress well before 9-11.
So the notion that the attack somehow occurred the next day to cover up
$2.3 trillion in missing money simply does not fit the fact.
So, General, in the few minutes I have left with you,
I want to move on to a little bit of the political space, but I'll be careful.
In the immediate aftermath, President Bush declares this war on terror.
He describes the axis of evils.
And I'm just curious, from your perspective, obviously hindsight is 20-20,
but right then and there, was it the right decision to have launched this war on terror,
culminating, of course, in the ground invasion of both Iraq and Afghanistan?
Well, I do think we need to correct any misperception that's developed over the years,
because the decision to invade Iraq was not the United States military response to 9-11,
and Saddam Hussein was not responsible for the 9-11 attacks.
The military response to 9-11 was Operation Enduring Freedom in Afghanistan.
And it began on October 7, 2001, less than a month after the attacks,
and was directed against al-Qaeda, the organization that attacked us,
and the Taliban regime that provided al-Qaeda sanctuary in Afghanistan.
Now, I know that personally, because as I mentioned, General John Jumper sent me back
to the Middle East shortly after 9-11 to command the Combined Air Operations Center
and to plan and execute America's airpower response to the 9-11 attacks.
The principal impetus behind the decision to invade Iraq in 2003 was the belief that Saddam
Hussein possessed weapons of mass destruction, and that he'd failed to comply with repeated
UN requirements to account for and eliminate those capabilities.
So certainly 9-11 changed the strategic environment and America's tolerance
for the risk of another surprise attack.
But that's very different from saying that Iraq was responsible for 9-11.
And I'd also add the 9-11 Commission subsequently found no evidence
that Iraq had cooperated with al-Qaeda in any way.
So if you ask me whether the decision was right, I think you have to distinguish several things.
One is the decision to go to war based on the intelligence and threat assessments
available at the time.
Another is what we subsequently learned about that intelligence.
And still another is how the U.S. managed the political and strategic consequences
after Saddam's regime was removed.
The initial military campaign itself was extraordinarily effective.
The coalition rapidly destroyed Saddam's forces and removed his regime.
But what followed illustrates a larger lesson that applies not just to Iraq,
but also to Afghanistan.
And that's that military effectiveness is necessary for strategic effect,
but it's not sufficient.
You can execute military operations brilliantly,
but if the military objectives aren't tied to clearly defined political objectives
and a coherent strategy for what comes next,
tactical and operational excellence alone cannot deliver strategic success.
So General, now that we're 25 years since September 11th,
we spoke about some of these strategic threats that faced the United States on that day.
What would you say are some of the greatest threats facing the United States today?
Well, it's a great question.
The fact of the matter is the threats facing the United States today are much greater
than what we faced on 9-11-2001.
Think back to where China was in 2001.
They were viewed increasingly as a competitor.
You know, in other words, they were a partner,
but they were also an economic competitor.
And their military was nowhere near where it is today.
In the subsequent 25 years, China has become not just an economic competitor,
but they're on track to exceed our military capability and capacity in the next couple of years.
So the threats today, and look, I could speak for hours
on the aggressive and threatening nature of Russia.
I mean, Russia is a declared adversary of the United States
and has the largest number of nuclear weapons in the world.
And we know what they did in Ukraine.
They're fighting a war of aggression that's completely unconstrained.
You know, their leader, Vladimir Putin, is an indicted criminal in the context of violating
laws of international armed conflict and crimes against humanity.
And he wouldn't change that if he changed his aggression toward a NATO nation,
to which the United States would be compelled to respond.
We know about the Iranians.
We're currently engaged in a contingency there.
And then there's Kim Jong-un, which is a rogue player armed with nuclear weapons as well.
So in addition to a continuous low-level terrorist threat,
we have these four other serious threats that we're now facing.
And quite frankly, it's not hyperbole to state that the United States today
faces a greater set of threats than it's ever faced in our entire 250-year history.
So that's why we need to correct the decline in the United States military.
The Air Force today is the oldest, the smallest, and the least ready it's ever been.
We've got to correct that if we're going to be able to not just deter,
but defeat any one of these potential adversaries
if they were to launch aggressive action against us.
Well said.
Just before I let you go, because on this show, we try to deal with objective reality and facts.
And I think having your perspective is critically important.
And I want to remind our viewers that here are what the facts are.
American Airlines Flight 77 was a Boeing 757.
The western facade of the Pentagon between Corridors 4 and 5 were hit.
184 total people were lost, including 59 on the aircraft itself,
and 125 military personnel and civilians inside the building.
For any of you who go to the Pentagon, certainly it is encouraged,
and I would argue mandatory, that you go to the memorial on the grounds of the Pentagon itself
and pay respect to the memory of those we lost.
General, I want to thank you, not just for making the time on this show,
but really everything you have done in the past for our country
and for what you continue to do.
It really means a lot.
Thanks very much.
I really appreciate the opportunity to share some of these perspectives with you.
Thanks for watching this week's episode.
Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.
And also tell us what topics you want to see covered, whether it's immigration, tariffs.
We have great episodes coming up, and we'll see you next week on The Brief.