Is combining multiple space telescopes the way to go? Can we detect ice-shell exoplanets? How feasible would a Starship space base be? And in Q&A+, why didn't CMB go past us?
00:00 Intro 00:39 [@estraume] Space telescopes flying in formation 08:53 [@goatlord51] Do we have anything that can detect ice shell exo-planets? 14:26 [@kipnielsen8752] How feasible would a starship space station be? 18:45 Final thoughts
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video explores advanced astronomical techniques, the search for habitable ice-shell and rogue planets, the physics of artificial gravity, and the societal implications of AI-generated misinformation.
Is combining multiple space telescopes the way to go?
Can we detect ice shell exoplanets?
How feasible would a starship space base be?
And in Q&A Plus, why didn't the CMB go past us?
It's time for the question show.
Your questions, my answers, as always, wherever you are across my channel.
If you have a question that pops in your brain, just write it down.
I'll gather them up and I will answer them here.
Hello from Birdlip in the UK, which is on the Cotswolds Way.
We are day five into our hike across this amazing country and another six days to go.
So maybe I'll still be recording after.
Anyway, I'm sure you can continue on.
Estrom, are there concrete plans for a space telescope that improves
aperture limited resolution by flying three or more telescopes in formation?
Yeah.
So, I mean, you are talking about the classic idea of an interferometer
and there is an interferometer that is in the works right now
that is going to be launched in the 2030s, but it's probably not what you're expecting.
And that is the European Space Agency's Laser Interferometer Space Antenna, or LISA.
This is a mission that's going to be able to detect gravitational waves.
And so you're going to have these three spacecraft, they're going to fly
15,000 kilometers apart and they're going to be firing lasers at each other.
And the lasers are going to be interfering inside the spacecraft.
And the spacecraft have these free-floating masses inside the spacecraft.
And they're going to try to keep these masses at exactly the same distance
and freely floating inside the spacecraft.
And then as a gravitational wave sweeps past these three observatories,
you know, one, then the other, then the other,
then the test mass is going to move around inside the spacecraft
or the spacecraft is going to move anyway.
And the distance of the lasers are going to change really subtly,
and that's going to allow them to detect, in theory,
the mergers between supermassive black holes,
which currently ground-based observatories like LIGO, Virgo,
CAGRA, they can't detect merging supermassive black holes.
We have the hint that they're there because of the pulsar timing network,
but we don't know, we don't have this direct evidence of these mergers.
When LISA launches, if it works as planned, it will detect a merger,
and you will know, oh, there are two supermassive black holes
that are merging right now in that galaxy over there,
which would be quite amazing.
But this idea of an interferometer has been thought about for quite a while.
And we know interferometers work here on Earth.
We have the Very Large Telescope, which is an infrared interferometer.
We have plenty of examples of radio interferometers.
Think about the Very Large Array, which is those big radio telescopes in the United States.
There's ALMA.
They're working on the Square Kilometer Array.
But there's a visible light telescope array in the U.S. called CHARA,
and I've done an interview with one of the people behind the CHARA array.
And the challenge with visible light telescopes is that you have to align the mirrors
so that they're essentially down to the wavefront.
When you think about the size of the wavelengths of visible light,
they're in the 400 nanometer range.
Think about how small 400 nanometers are,
and you've got to get these telescopes that are aligned perfectly down to 400-ish nanometers.
And the CHARA array works in this really interesting way,
which is that they have these telescopes that are separated by hundreds of meters
on the top of this mountain, and the telescopes will look at the same target.
And then you will get the light coming into the telescopes,
and then they go down into this combination area underneath the telescope.
And there are these carts that move back and forth
to change the length of the legs between the telescopes.
Think about it.
You've got two telescopes that are looking up at some object in the sky,
and the object is over to the west.
So one telescope has to look over towards the object,
and then the other telescope has to look over at the object,
and the distance that the light is coming from that object is slightly different.
And that is too far for them to act as an interferometer.
And the way they fix it is they have the light go through this additional step,
these carts, and they just move the carts back and forth
until the two telescopes are seeing the light at exactly the same distance.
It is a really difficult challenge.
And so nobody has been able to build an interferometer that would work in space so far.
And the big idea, back in the 2000s, we had the Kepler Observatory,
which was designed to find an Earth-sized world orbiting around a sun-like star.
And then they were planning a follow-on observatory from that,
which was going to be a better version of the Kepler mission.
And then they were going to build what's called the Terrestrial Planet Finder.
And this was going to be what you're talking about,
which is that they were going to build several spacecraft that were going to fly in formation,
and that they would observe a planetary system at the same time.
And they would try to use the distance, the baseline,
the distance between those telescopes as a way to observe,
to act as if you had a telescope that is the size of the distance between those telescopes.
And unfortunately, the Terrestrial Planet Finder was cancelled.
It was just too complicated and too expensive,
and that they just weren't going to be able to pull it off.
Fast forward 25 years, and now this idea has come back around.
And there's a couple of other ideas,
and I've reported quite a bit on these ideas for interferometers.
One is that you could do a very simple version of an interferometer for a Moon mission.
So you would have a lander that would go to the surface of the Moon,
and they would have a little rover, and there would be a telescope.
It doesn't have to be big, just like a 10-centimeter telescope on the lander.
And then the rover also has a 10-centimeter telescope.
And then it drives away from the lander,
maybe 100 meters, and then sets up and points at the same spot in the sky.
And now you've got a telescope that is 100 meters across,
because you've got these two telescopes.
Now you can only look at bright objects, but still, that is a fairly easy idea.
And there's a team that is proposing this,
we could see this fly on an upcoming NASA lander to the Moon.
The other idea, which is much more ambitious,
is called the Large Interferometer for Exoplanets, or the LIFE mission.
And this is essentially a new version of the Terrestrial Planet Finder mission.
And this is in development by European astronomers.
So this could fly as a European Space Agency mission.
And in addition to it being an interferometer,
it would also use a really cool technique to be able to block the light of the star.
And it's essentially called a nulling interferometer.
So you would be looking at the star from the perspective of two different telescopes,
and then you would be taking the light coming from the star,
and then you would interfere that together between the two flying telescopes,
and make it disappear.
Essentially, you know, wavelengths that are the opposite will null each other,
cancel each other out.
And then you're left with the observations of the exoplanet.
So there are lots of ideas for interferometers that could fly to space.
Another idea that's in the works is to fly an extension to the Event Horizon Telescope.
So this is this worldwide virtual telescope of radio telescopes that are observing,
you know, the event horizon of the supermassive black hole at the heart of the Milky Way,
or the event horizon at M87.
And you are limited by the size of planet Earth,
that you just can't make a telescope that is bigger than the Earth,
because that's, you know, that's as much land as we have.
But you could fly a telescope into space.
You send a telescope out that is, say, out to the L2 Lagrange point,
same place where James Webb is, where Euclid is, where Nancy Grace Roman is going.
And now you've built a telescope that isn't, I don't know, 15,000 kilometers across.
You built a telescope that is 1.5 million kilometers across.
Anyway, huge telescope, huge baseline.
It would be tricky because you have to align the radio wave frequencies,
but still, it would be incredible.
And that would get you tons and tons of black holes,
you could observe the event horizons around.
It's time to shout out all the new $5 patrons and above.
James Roger
Stephen Titmuss
John Juerz
Dougal
Neil Lafra
Adam Dadeby
Ray Bozinski
Drew
Amazed by it all
and Becky S.
Join the club at patreon.com slash universe today.
Goat Lord, do we have anything that can detect ice shell exoplanets?
Unfortunately, right now, no.
But it is absolutely the kind of thing that we could detect in the future.
So, I mean, what's really interesting, like, what you're getting at here is that,
you know, we're now looking at places like Europa and Enceladus,
you've got this ice shell surrounding this ocean of liquid water
as some of the most interesting places to search for life in the solar system.
You know, wherever we find liquid water on Earth, we find life.
And so it makes sense for us to look in places like Europa and Enceladus
that seem to have these liquid oceans underneath the surface as a place to find life.
And that, you know, here in the solar system, we have the Earth, which has water on its surface.
We have Venus, which is hellish and probably doesn't have life on its surface,
maybe in its cloud tops.
We have Mars, which is extremely cold, airless, no protection from radiation.
The surface of the regolith is filled with perchlorates, which are toxic to life as we know it.
It's going to be a really hard place for life to live.
But you look at Europa and Enceladus, you get under that ice,
you've got an ocean of water that has hydrogen gas
dissolved into it.
It has various organic compounds put into it.
It feels like this is the perfect environment for life.
And when you consider how many worlds, even just in the solar system,
like you're familiar with Europa and Enceladus,
but it's almost certain that there is an ocean of liquid water on Pluto.
There must be one on Titan.
And in fact, you look at Mimas and Triton and a lot of the moons of Uranus.
There could easily be 20, 30, 50 worlds in the solar system
that have an ocean of water underneath a thick shell of ice.
And so if you wanted to catalog the places in the solar system where you would look for life,
obviously you'd start with Earth,
but then you'd go and look at all of those ice worlds that are all across the solar system.
Well, let's do that, but out there in the universe.
And there's a bunch of problems, right?
So the first problem is just that when we observe planets orbiting around other stars,
the best we will ever get is a pixel,
like unless we build a solar gravitational lens telescope.
Until that point, all we will get is a single pixel.
And so you then are trying to spread out and enhance the light
coming from that single pixel that represents that planet.
And you're looking to detect the presence of various chemicals,
like are we detecting water vapor?
Are we detecting carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide?
You can't get much beyond that.
Is the water that we're looking at in the atmosphere?
Is it a shell on the surface?
It's going to be really hard to tease out any other information.
And a lot of these ice planets are farther away from their star.
We don't get the ice planets here in the solar system
until you get beyond the orbit of the asteroid belt.
Ceres, which is the largest asteroid, can have ice on its surface and farther out from there.
And once you get out to Jupiter, now you're what?
Five astronomical units away from the sun.
Think about how hard that would be to detect a planet
that is five astronomical units away from its star.
If you can use the transit method, you've got to wait.
I don't know, how long does it take Jupiter to go around?
Like 10 years to go around the sun?
Saturn takes 30 years, right?
And you're waiting for a transit of that planet,
or I guess if you have a planet that's that far out.
And so where you're going to get the ice to form,
it's going to be really hard to observe those kinds of planets.
So we're looking at the reflected light of a planet that is, you know,
like when you go to Jupiter and you want to use solar panels,
you need to have solar panels that are 25 times as big
as the solar panels that you need on Earth,
because there is 1 25th the sunlight that is falling on your solar panels.
And then you're getting the reflected light from those planets that are around there.
So it's just going to be a really hard observation.
They're the most intriguing, but they're going to be really difficult.
And the ones that I find even more intriguing than that are the rogue planets,
because, you know, the evidence is growing that there are free floating planets
orbiting around in the spaces between star systems.
And that you could have a situation that's kind of like Jupiter,
where you've got this gas giant that has been kicked out of a planetary system.
There are large moons, Earth-sized moons orbiting around this gas giant,
and they're going to be interacting, tidal flexing,
and they're going to have oceans of liquid water underneath a shell of ice.
This feels like the perfect place to go look for life.
And yet, if you think finding an ice planet orbiting around a star is going to be hard,
just imagine how difficult it would be to detect an Earth-sized world orbiting around a
rogue planet just in the darkness of the void in between stars.
So it would be amazing, and it feels like those are the places we should most look.
And yet, because they're so far away, so hard to observe,
we may never find any evidence of those kinds of planets.
But, you know, who knows how good our telescopes will become in the future.
Tip Nielsen.
How feasible would a starship space station be?
I picture two starships tied together with cables and spun up for some fake gravity,
but I can't get over how hard it would be to dock.
People have proposed this idea quite a bit.
That, you know, one of the big challenges of being in space
is that you're not going to have any kind of gravity.
And we know that a lack of gravity on the human body is a big problem.
And that you need to figure out a way to get some kind of artificial gravity.
And the classic idea is this giant rotating space station.
Think about 2001.
Or even think about, say, the Martian, where they had this spacecraft,
and it had this rotating chunk that went with it.
Or think about Project Hail Mary, right?
The spaceship was able to disconnect, it had this counterweight,
and then the whole thing could spin.
And I think that's pretty close to what you're talking about as an idea.
Now, what you want to do, though, is you want to get those starships
pretty far apart from each other.
So you're going to have your two starships fly out into space,
and then one's going to turn around, and then you're going to connect them
with some kind of cable.
And then they're going to reel out away from each other pretty far.
Like, they're probably going to be a hundred meters,
maybe a couple hundred meters away from each other.
And then they're going to fire their thrusters and start to go in this big,
kind of, I don't know, what's it?
A bolo?
I'm trying to think.
What is the thing where you've got two objects that are spinning around each other?
And then you will get artificial gravity.
You'll get this artificial feeling of gravity when you're standing
inside one of these spacecraft.
And then if you wanted to, say, go to the other spacecraft,
you'd have to climb this ladder.
We feel like you were climbing up a ladder, and the gravity would feel
less and less and less until you got to the very middle,
where you would be weightless.
And then you would flip yourself around,
and you would climb down to the other spaceship,
getting increasing gravity until you've gotten to the point.
And, like, I don't have the numbers in my head right now.
People have done this, but there is, like, a certain speed
that you would have to have these things going away from each other,
depending on the distance that you put them.
And the distance is really important because there is this effect,
this Coriolis effect, that if the spacecraft are very close together,
then the feeling of gravity that you're going to experience at your feet
is different than the feeling that you're going to experience at your head.
You know, if you tried to pour a liquid,
the liquid would sort of go in this really weird shape.
It wouldn't just pour down as if it was normal gravity.
But if you put the spacecraft really far apart,
then you wouldn't experience that kind of subjective difference
between your feet and your head.
But it's thought that if, you know, if you don't put enough space,
then you'll get, you'll feel nauseous.
And so this, you know, we don't know the answer to this question.
These are really interesting questions that we would like to find out the answers to.
And I hope that somebody soon comes up with some kind of
rotating spaceship, space station for us to be able to test artificial gravity.
Did you know you can watch the same video with no ads and get a bonus question
over on Patreon completely for free?
I'm going to call it Q&A Plus.
And this week's bonus question,
why didn't the CMB go past us?
And I'll put a link down in the show notes.
All right, those are all the questions that we had this episode.
I thank everyone who asked your questions into the YouTube comments,
everybody who joined me for the live show,
which is still happening from random UK hotel rooms.
Now I'm going to thank my patrons and then talk about AI some more,
because why not?
Thanks to Abe Kingston,
Andrea Pedretti,
Boldazard Galactic Invader,
Brian Bode,
Caridin,
Chuck Hawkins,
Grander Bailuck,
David Gilton,
and David Matz,
Evendup Pro,
James Clark,
Jeremy Madden,
Jim Burke,
Marcel Sets,
Mike Purcell,
Please follow my nephew at vbrick6994,
Rinkaidu,
Richard Williams,
Sean Sargent,
Team 49,
Telescopes Canada,
Vlad Chiplin,
Wolfgang Klotz,
Zelda,
Fraser Noe,
getting involved is what he wants,
who support us at the Master of the Universe level,
and all our patrons.
All your support means the universe to us.
Again, Zelda, we are involved.
This is our galaxy.
We live here.
You are defending us from Boldazard.
We're going to be watching this very carefully to see what happens.
It's possible that I am sort of researching the history of Zelda and Bolda,
and will give you a better understanding of this in the future.
All right.
I got this comment on a recent video.
Biker in Christ.
Wow, this AI-generated narrator looks and sounds so real.
Now, I suspect that you might be trolling in that,
like, obviously I'm not an AI narrator,
and that, I mean, the technology...
Well, I mean, you say it looks so real,
and yet, like, the technology is just getting so good every day
that maybe it's not that surprising
that everything now looks like they're an AI narrator,
and you can't tell the difference.
But there was a really interesting video
that Cool Worlds Lab just published,
David Kipping and team,
about his great concern with AI.
And, like, this is just one concern,
and his concern is essentially, we won't know truth from fiction, right?
That you will see things, you will hear things,
you'll read things, you'll watch things,
people say things are true,
and you won't know if those things are true.
And yes, obviously, right?
What does it mean if you're watching a YouTube video
and someone is telling you something is true
about space or anything in this world,
and you can't tell whether that is correct or not?
Whether this is just something some AI made up,
or someone made up and told an AI to say, or whatever.
And, you know, obviously I'm fortunate
because I've had my face plastered on this channel for quite a while,
and so people know that I'm real.
You go back through 28 years of my work,
and see that I've been here the entire time,
and nothing's really changed.
And, you know, if I had switched to AI,
you would probably notice that.
But, you know, the new stuff, it's going to be really hard to see.
So I don't think there is any way,
there's no solution to this problem, right?
That you're going to watch stuff,
and unless you know for sure who is behind the work that you're watching,
and the AI just keeps getting better,
that you won't know if this thing is real.
And so you won't know if anything is real,
and you won't know what to trust.
And there is one really straightforward solution to this problem,
and that is that the platform has to take a stand.
And the platform in this case is YouTube.
And so YouTube now can get access to things like Pangram,
that can tell you whether the writing of an episode is done by AI or not.
Both OpenAI and Claude will let you check against their stuff.
Google does this as well,
that you're going to be able to check the veracity of everything now,
and find out whether or not this stuff is real.
And that the platforms can broker these deals
to run all of the content that they are publishing,
that they are standing for,
on those platforms and say,
this is real, this is AI,
and then you can decide whether you just want it all filtered out.
And it has, you know, 10% or more AI included in it,
just filter it out.
And that will get people in line,
and hopefully we can kind of turn this direction around.
But who knows what's going to happen.
All right, we'll see you next time.