Explore a comprehensive scientific investigation into the ongoing geological controversies surrounding the true age of the Great Sphinx on Egypt's Giza Plateau. Hosted by Professor David Miano, this academic overview examines the fringe hypothesis proposed by Robert Schoch claiming the monument is thousands of years older than established historical timelines suggest. The analysis balances structural data from various independent geologists, mapping evidence of wind erosion, limestone precipitation, and salt weathering mechanics to separate empirical science from lost advanced civilization myths.
For regular videos on ancient cultures and forgotten civilizations, please subscribe.
If you would like to support the channel and become part of our ancient history fan community,
visit patreon.com slash world of antiquity.
The Sphinx is one of the best known icons of ancient Egypt.
It has been a magnet for popular attention for centuries, especially in more recent times
when it has been the subject of alternative suppositions about its origins.
According to archaeologists, it is a product of the Egyptian Old Kingdom,
specifically the very powerful 4th dynasty, along with many other artifacts on the Giza Plateau.
But some researchers say that the Sphinx is much older than that,
and could be an indicator of an earlier lost advanced society.
Today, I want to explore with you not the archaeological or historical
evidence for the age of the Sphinx, but the geological.
In the past 30 years, a number of geologists have weighed in on the subject,
but there has been considerable disagreement.
I want to introduce you to the main theories, examine them with you,
and maybe by the time I get to the end, we will have a better idea
of what the geological evidence indicates for the Sphinx's age.
So, let the battle of the geologists begin.
Robert Schock is a geologist from the College of General Studies at Boston University.
In the early 1990s, his research on the Sphinx caused a stir,
when he concluded that it was thousands of years older than the Egyptian Old Kingdom.
He was featured in the documentary Mystery of the Sphinx in 1993,
and has written several books on the subject,
including Origins of the Sphinx, which was published in 2017.
Here he is on the Joe Rogan Podcast, summarizing his findings.
Now that I saw it on the ground, in person,
there was something wrong with the Egyptological dating,
because when you look at the Sphinx as a geologist, with a geological eye,
this was not weathered by wind and sand.
This was not desert erosion and weathering that I saw on the Sphinx,
the body of the Sphinx, which is very difficult to tell
because it's been heavily repaired and reworked,
but particularly on the walls of what are known as the Sphinx enclosure.
The Sphinx enclosure is important because it preserves a lot of the details,
and if you haven't, if the audience has not been to Egypt,
they should realize that when they carved the Sphinx, it's all solid bedrock,
only the head initially was above the ground surface.
They carved down into the rock to free up the body,
what I call the core body of the Sphinx.
And it's that core body and the walls of the enclosure,
more or less the quarry around it, if you want to use that term,
that show these ancient weathering, precipitation, erosional features
that are incompatible with the last 5,000 years of climatic history
on the eastern edge of the Sahara.
Shock initially dated the creation of the Sphinx,
or more specifically, the age of the weathering patterns on the body of the Sphinx,
to the Neolithic period in Egypt, writing,
I believe the geological evidence is quite compatible with a date of 5,000 to 7,000 BC.
However, I'm not adamant about these dates whatsoever.
For me, the important issue is whether or not the Sphinx is pre-Old Kingdom.
However, more recently, he's moved the date further back in time
to make it contemporary with the site of Gobekli Tepe in northern Mesopotamia.
The Sphinx is not 2,500 BC. It is, my best date, at least 10,000 BC.
From what I've been able to discern,
this adjustment in dating was not motivated by new geological evidence.
Another geologist who weighed in on the subject was Lal Ghori, now deceased,
who argued that the weathering of the Sphinx enclosure was caused by haloclasty.
That's pressure generated in the pores of the limestone by salt crystallization.
In a published article, he and his team wrote,
The indicated mechanism of this exfoliation is that in the cool of the night,
with the arrival of the dew point, water vapor condenses on the stone surface.
The water is then drawn into the pores by capillary suction.
The salt, present at the surface as well as lodged in the pores, goes into solution.
As the sun rises and the water begins to evaporate,
incipient crystals of salt begin to form in the solution in the pores.
These crystals generate hydrostatic pressure directed against the pore walls,
which disrupt when the pressure exceeds the strength of the rock.
At that point, the fragmented limestone is free to fall off or be blown off by the wind.
Schock replied to this by saying firstly that
condensation affects all monuments in the Giza complex,
but very rarely do any show the same type of weathering features of the Sphinx
and its immediate environment.
Secondly, he argued that the process that Ghori posited
is relatively mild and insignificant and would not have produced such intense weathering.
Schock has asserted that the rounded surfaces on the wall are precipitation induced,
but Ghori and his team argue that,
because of greater weathering along the joints than in the space between them,
the internal pressure due to salt crystallization
has produced what may be called spheroidal weathering.
As a result, rounded surfaces have formed both in the lateral as well as in vertical direction.
Shock, however, says Ghori's explanation,
does not account for variations in the weathering profile or the presence of open fissures.
James Harrell is Professor Emeritus of Geology from the University of Toledo, Ohio,
who has made many research trips to Egypt and has weighed in on the matter as well.
He adds weight to Ghori's hypothesis, but adds one of his own.
Although Giza is arid, there are heavy rains that occur here at certain times of the year.
Depending on the intensity of the rainfall,
the water arrives either mainly as overland runoff or subsurface flow.
Harrell's view is that rainfall wetted the sand in the Sphinx enclosure.
Most of the runoff would have entered the Sphinx enclosure at the western wall,
and so that is why most of the weathering and erosion has occurred there.
Once the sand was soaked, says Harrell,
it would remain wet for many weeks or months due to capillary retention.
The mildly acidic rainwater would then cause dissolution of calcite in the limestone.
Because the lower part of the limestone bed has a greater porosity,
and smaller pore size, and therefore a greater internal surface area,
this would cause greater amounts of dissolution there.
But Harrell argued that the subsurface water that flows into the enclosure would be more important.
This would move not only through the subvertical fractures,
but also along the bedding planes that separate the upper part of each bed
from the lower part of the overlying one.
The water would thus be flowing through the weaker,
lower parts of the beds, causing further dissolution.
During those periods of time when the sand was removed from the enclosure,
the more deeply weathered material in the lower parts of the beds would be removed too.
Another geologist who has weighed in on the subject
is Colin Reeder from Queen Mary University of London.
Reeder takes issue with Harrell's theory, writing,
quote,
Harrell considers that extreme Nile inundation was capable of
introducing water into the lower-lying sand within the Sphinx enclosure.
He then relies on capillary action to carry this water up to two meters into the overlying sand.
Although in hot, arid areas, capillary fringes are present above groundwater and bedrock,
I have to question whether any significant capillary fringe
would develop in a loose, coarse, grained soil such as accumulated sand.
In soil mechanics, capillarity is modeled using the concept of soil suction
and is governed by particle size and the size and content of any inter-particle voids, unquote.
In other words, for sand above groundwater level,
suction effects would be fairly negligible.
Reeder agrees that rainfall would have generated runoff that would have caused erosion,
and structural damage of this kind can be seen at Menkaure's Valley Temple.
It would have done similar damage at the Sphinx enclosure.
However, says Reeder,
such runoff must have occurred prior to the reign of King Khufu of the 4th Dynasty,
because he had a quarry built at Giza, upslope from the Sphinx,
which would have caught the runoff and thus protected the Sphinx enclosure.
Evidence for this is seen at the 26th Dynasty tombs nearby,
which have not experienced intense degradation.
Therefore, he says,
the erosion at the Sphinx enclosure must have preceded the 4th Dynasty.
Reeder dates the Sphinx to the early dynastic period.
Mind you, his reason for that is not geological.
He dates it by historical context.
It's the only time prior to the Old Kingdom
that the Egyptians are known to have had the technology to build it.
He defends this dating by saying that there was enough time for the erosion to have occurred.
Agreeing with Gorey that salt exfoliation was involved, he adds,
As weathering progresses, soluble salts are removed from increasing depth,
leaving an increasingly insoluble matrix near the surface.
This process can, therefore, be seen to be somewhat self-limiting,
and it is only when a chemically weathered face is subject to erosion,
such as from rainfall runoff,
will the insoluble veneer be abraded off, exposing salt-rich rocks from the subsurface.
These newly exposed rocks will once again begin to rapidly weather, and so the cycle repeats.
In other words, you need the runoff for the salt exfoliation to have worked quickly enough.
Jørn Kristiansen is a geoscientist in the oil and gas and mineral exploration business,
and is currently employed at Spektrum ASA in Norway.
He too has examined the site,
though doing visual inspection only and not a quantitative analysis.
Kristiansen argues that most of the erosion that we see at the Sphinx enclosure
occurred prior to the carving of the Sphinx.
How is that possible?
It looks like the rain has run down the walls!
Ah, but he has found evidence that rain has also run down inside of the rock formation.
In other words, through fractures in the limestone.
It's not just on the outside.
What happened was that pressure and stress caused the limestone to fail,
forming a network of fractures.
Visible chemical weathering of the rock around the fractures
indicates that water penetrated into the fractures.
This can be seen on the walls of the enclosure,
where a network of fractures are visible on the surface,
uninfluenced by the carving of the enclosure wall.
And on the southern enclosure wall,
there are numerous exposures of colored, gently curved stripes crossing the stratigraphy.
The stripes are following the fractures,
and they are the visible evidence of a carbonic acid invasion zone,
resulting from rainwater finding its way into the fractures from above.
Some of these stripes are slightly elevated compared to the surrounding,
indicating a harder composition.
By the shape of the striping pattern,
Kristiansen determined that they existed prior to the carving of the wall.
So this appears to be evidence that the erosion took place
before the excavation of the Sphinx enclosure.
Of course, what that would mean is that the erosion we see on the walls
has no bearing on the age of the Sphinx enclosure.
Now, of course, Kristiansen agrees that erosion continued after excavation.
Wind, sand, and occasional rain made the weaknesses on the edifice visible.
Erosion took place horizontally along poorly cemented subunits,
and vertically where carbonic acid had been allowed to work along the fractures over time.
Robert Schneiker is a geophysicist who also has weighed in on the issue.
He agrees that the weathering processes at Giza proposed by the others have had an effect.
Before 3500 BCE, precipitation and now flooding would have had a major impact.
To a lesser extent afterwards, he also agrees salt exfoliation,
exacerbated by wind erosion, has operated continuously until the present.
But he doesn't think that Gorey's theory of salt exfoliation caused merely by morning dew
would be intense enough.
Schneiker's proposal is that the salt exfoliation was caused primarily
by the upward wicking of shallow salty groundwater.
He points to the evidence for bottom-up weathering, rather than top-down,
and says the weathering is still happening today.
Monuments that are higher in elevation have escaped this weathering.
Nile flooding has contributed to the groundwater problem.
The average of the annual flooding is 17 to 18 meters above sea level.
When the Nile rises 20 meters above sea level, the Sphinx enclosure is flooded.
The water table underground is currently at 17 meters above sea level,
and it's recharged each year by rainfall.
Scientists tested the recharging effect with the Seasoil Vadose Zone Modeling System,
and it showed that when the Sphinx was carved,
the floor of the excavation encountered the capillary rise zone.
This turned on the weathering, as shallow groundwater wicked up and evaporated at the surface.
The wicking process was turned off when the excavation was filled with sand.
But the acidic groundwater would have weathered the limestone bedrock below the water table
long before the Sphinx was ever carved.
So Christensen and Schneiker both agree that the majority of the weathering of the limestone,
both underneath and around the enclosure, occurred before the creation of the Sphinx.
But what about the erosion on the Sphinx itself?
Everyone agrees that the body of the Sphinx, underneath the brick exterior,
is not eroded as much as the western wall of the enclosure is.
Schneiker argues, and this is the most interesting part of his theory,
that the rough appearance of the Sphinx body was not produced by erosion, but by human hands.
If you notice, the neck of the Sphinx is covered by modern concrete.
But there are old photos of the neck before the concrete was put there.
Schneiker says there was no way the neck was weathered by precipitation.
How could it be? It's under the head.
And yet, that is the same rough appearance we see on the rest of the body.
Schneiker concludes that much of what has been described as erosion
is really part of the construction process.
So I looked at this photo.
This is at exactly the same time that I looked at this photo and said,
wait a minute, there's a hyperthermal in the head.
I went, I know how the Sphinx was made.
I just remember that.
It was like instantaneous.
Two things just as fast as I could think of them.
The way that the Sphinx was made is it was pounded back.
You have to understand the tools that they use.
Mark here is holding a two-handed pounder.
And it is just what you think.
It's just a rock.
And they would take that rock and they would bang onto the surface of the rock
and they would flake rock off.
Then he also used what's called a stone hammer.
So the stone hammer over here is just a rock and they cut two grooves in it
and they put some sticks on it and they tied the sticks together
with leather and then they would take that and they would bang
onto the rock again and they'd flake rock off.
The final thing that they had was down over here and that is the copper chisel.
And they only use that for detailed work because it's not that hard a tool.
They just use that when they were doing very detailed work.
So the Sphinx with this soft rock that's been weathered in and out of all these
Green Sahara periods, when they got around to carving it, it was so soft.
In fact, there's places it's so soft you could crumble it in your fingers.
That weathering occurred prior to the construction, not since construction.
So what everyone is considering as weathering is not weathering.
Part of the evidence is if you look at this fracture here.
So this bedrock fracture predates the construction of the Sphinx.
And if it were weathered by precipitation,
that also would have been altered by that weathering, but it's not.
It's fairly angular.
So this is not weathered by precipitation.
What everyone has been considering as weathering by precipitation
is actually part of the construction process.
Soft sections of limestone were pounded back using stone tools
and this produced a rough cut body.
A body that was never smooth.
It always looked that way.
What?
Are you trying to tell us that the makers of the Sphinx carved a beautiful head
and an awful looking body?
No, no, said Schneiker.
The brick veneer, which is usually thought of as a later addition to the Sphinx body,
is an original part of the design.
The common view is that the bricks were added after the Sphinx body eroded as a repair job.
And yeah, the brickwork appears to assume the existence of the body
in its apparently degraded condition.
Schneiker believes that the original Sphinx had the bricks.
Now, yes, the brick veneer has been repaired several times throughout history,
but the earliest bricks, he says, were placed there at the time of construction.
So the body, the core, has always had that rough appearance.
It was never intended to be seen.
Then you also have people that are trying to use the head
to try to figure out exactly who the Sphinx looks like.
But one of the things that's really important to look at here is that,
so the miko is at the base here at the chin.
Then you've got these bedding planes at the mouth and the nose and the eyebrows.
So to some extent, proportions of the face were controlled by the geology.
This is not a perfect material that you can make anything you want out of.
There's restrictions on it.
Nobody even knew what the pharaoh looked like anyways.
I'm sure they didn't, you know, because they didn't have photography or anything.
So unless you met the pharaoh, you wouldn't even know
that this doesn't look like the pharaoh.
So I don't think you can use the proportions of the face
to figure out what the age of the Sphinx is in terms of who made it.
For the last 4,500 years,
most of the time the Sphinx was buried up to its neck in sand.
And I'm suggesting that rather than having been weathered, the blocks were looted.
The same is true of the pyramids.
They used to be covered with a white limestone.
And all that's been looted to build the city of Cairo.
So it's not unusual.
Looting was a very common practice.
So I'm saying there's very little type of any...
And because it's buried in sand, there's no wicking going on.
So there's very little weathering at all going on for the last 4,500 years.
So where do I stand on all this?
Well, I'm not an expert in geology,
but so far, based on what I've read and heard
from the people who do have the knowledge,
I think they all have something valuable to contribute.
Schock and Christensen have made a solid case
that precipitation was a factor in the erosion we see
in and around the Sphinx enclosure,
and that geologically it began occurring a very long time ago,
long before the Old Kingdom.
But Christensen has shown evidence,
which seems to me to be solid,
that this erosion occurred before the Sphinx enclosure was excavated.
Reeder, I think, makes a good argument that runoff
would have been a major factor only prior to the reign of Khufu,
because the quarry that was excavated in his time
would have protected the Sphinx enclosure from much of the runoff.
The weathering process that Gorry proposed,
salt exfoliation, was probably a factor.
But I think Reeder is right that runoff
would have contributed to this more than morning dew,
and Schneiker is probably right that groundwater wicking
would have had a greater effect in salt exfoliation than morning dew.
And I find myself leaning towards Schneiker's proposal
that the body of the Sphinx, or its core anyway,
was not greatly eroded,
was always rough cut,
and that the brick veneer is part of the original design.
By no means do I think the geological work is done here,
but for the present, this is how things look to me.
What are your thoughts about all this?
Let me know in the comments below.
But of course, I never answered the question
about what the age of the Sphinx is
according to the geological evidence.
Most of the geologists agree on this question.
Gorry is convinced that there's no way to date
the creation of the Sphinx based on the geology.
We believe that an absolute age cannot be assigned to the Sphinx
on the basis of existing geologic evidence.
Reeder concurs,
What geology cannot do is provide an absolute date
for the original excavation of the Great Sphinx.
Schneiker says,
Weathering is the result of a sporadic interaction of various processes,
thus weathering cannot be used to estimate the age of the Sphinx.
Christensen says,
The Sphinx was carved as an integral part
of a larger construction master plan on the Giza Plateau.
In my mind, geological and geophysical work done so far
offers no help in answering the question as to when this plan was realized.
This is still best estimated by the science of archaeology and astronomy.
Even Schock doesn't believe that the geological evidence alone
is sufficient to estimate a date of origin,
as he has adjusted his estimated date by thousands of years
based on the carbon dating done at Gobekli Tepe,
a site he assumes to be related.
I realize this is somewhat disappointing,
but I think geology has helped to shed more light
on the construction process of the Sphinx and the Sphinx enclosure
and is a valuable tool in understanding what was going on here at Giza in ancient times.
If you haven't done so yet, please subscribe to the channel.
You might like my little e-booklet, Why Ancient History Matters.
It's designed to persuade people that the subject is important,
even in the modern world.
You might also wish to use it to help spread the word,
so feel free to share it with someone you know.
It's free for anyone who wants it.
I've left a link in the description box below the video for you to grab a copy.
Catch you later.