1982 cold case has link to Tylenol poisoning deaths say Ada Co. Sheriff
2 Video Views·Sep 24, 2026
I'm Ada County Sheriff Matt Clifford.
And for nearly 40 years,
a mystery has sat unsolved here in the Treasure Valley.
A man who died inside a Boise church back in 1982,
with no known name, no ID, and nothing but a note,
keys, and a pocket full of cash.
He became known as the Unknown Wanderer.
And today, we can finally tell you who he was
and where that answer eventually led us.
Our involvement in this case started in 2018,
after I was approached by a member of the Sacred Heart Church
who expressed an interest in this case.
Our partners at the Boise Police Department
and the Ada County Coroner's Office
assisted by locating the original case file,
which we used to move forward with the investigation.
So we thank them.
In 2019, we reopened the Wanderer investigation
and cross-referenced information from the case
with over 17,000 missing persons records.
As it turned out,
no one had ever reported the Wanderer as a missing person.
This key you see here is the break in the case.
It came, as the Sheriff mentioned,
there were 30 keys, almost 30,
that the Wanderer had in his possession
at the time of his death.
This was one of those keys.
Marking on the key indicated
that it came from a hardware store in Jacksonville, Florida.
An etching was also observed on the key
that had previously been misidentified,
although a close misidentification.
It appeared to have been made with a sharp instrument
or tool of some sort.
This etching led to a street in Jacksonville, Florida
called Mills Court.
Working with investigators and records personnel
in Jacksonville,
our office was able to acquire property deeds
dating back to the late 70s and early 80s
from Mills Court.
Our office attempted to locate everyone associated
whose names were listed on the past property deeds
from Mills Court.
One name stood out as a decedent
whose death was recorded in 1989,
so later than 1982.
Our office contacted his sole surviving
immediate family member,
a brother in the Los Angeles area.
When we contacted the man in Los Angeles,
we learned that his brother had lived in Jacksonville
and had, in fact, gone missing in 1982,
and he had been declared deceased in absentia in 1989.
A DNA sample was collected from the Los Angeles man,
and it was analyzed against DNA
obtained from the unknown wanderer's wallet.
This revealed that these two men had the same father
to a very high probability.
So the unknown wanderer was determined to be
Dr. Matthew Francis Betkowski.
I think, like everybody else,
they're looking for closure,
and that man came to their church,
to their sacred place,
and took his life inside of it.
It was probably somewhat traumatizing
to some of the parishioners there at the time.
We've heard that.
There were a lot of rumors in the church over the years,
and we've heard those, too,
and so I think everybody's just looking for some closure,
and again, as the sheriff said,
that's why we're looking for tips, leads,
information that people may have
both here in Boise and other places.

