Are smartphones affecting children more than social media itself? 📱 In this thought-provoking discussion, Erica Komisar explores how smartphones may influence children’s attention, relationships, development, and everyday habits.
The video encourages parents to think carefully about children’s technology use and consider healthier ways to create balance between screen time, family connection, learning, and real-world experiences.
The speaker warns that technology, not just social media, acts as a dangerous \"babysitter\" for children. By overstimulating the brain's dopamine system, devices diminish the joy found in real-world activities and create a craving for higher stimulation. Additionally, social media fuels a comparison culture that heightens anxiety and lowers self-esteem in adolescents.
You know, there's more to technology than just social media.
There's gaming, there's group chats, which are vile.
Group chats can be very bullying and teasing and toxic to children.
So, you know, to talk about social media alone is not exactly the whole story.
But, you know, to say that you're trying to reach as many parents as possible
with the message that technology for children at too young an age—
I mean, the American Pediatric Association said that children under two
should not be given an iPhone.
You know, parents do this thing where they give them an iPad or an iPhone, you know,
just to entertain them so they can get a break.
I'm like, don't do that.
It affects their brains in ways you cannot imagine.
And even then, incrementally, you know, handing your children technology
and just, you know, as a babysitter.
You know, in the 70s and the 80s, parents were using television as a babysitter.
Not a good idea.
But the difference is that because the technology today is so overstimulating
and interactive, it stimulates dopamine in children's brains in a way.
So think of it like this.
Dopamine levels are supposed to remain somewhat low with children.
And that doesn't mean they're not happy and they don't take joy.
If only they did.
We don't talk about that now.
Happy kids having joy, you know, running around the place.
But once you're exposed to technology, you don't get joy.
You don't produce the same levels of dopamine as technology does.
Meaning if you give—you know, we always say that marijuana isn't a gateway drug
to heroin and other, you know, more advanced drugs, but in fact it is.
And so if you start with marijuana when you're a teenager,
eventually marijuana doesn't do the trick,
and you need more and more and more, and you need more stimulation,
and you start doing, you know, molly, or you start—then maybe you try heroin
or cocaine or—so the point is that you are stimulating parts of the brain
and conditioning the brain to need a certain amount of excitement
to get to the same level.
And that's what you're doing when you give your children technology.
So the things that should give us joy—relationships, sports, play—
no longer stimulate our brain in the same way,
and we start to have cravings for higher levels of stimulation.
And so that's the problem with technology.
So let's say social media is bad for many reasons.
One of the main reasons is that it sort of creates a comparison culture,
which is very dangerous because adolescents are already—
their brains are in a state of hypervigilance, a threat state,
a very high level of threat state.
And so what you're doing with that comparison is you're stimulating the amygdala,
the threat-sensing part of the brain, to be overly active.
And that means that that adolescent is always worrying, more self-conscious,
and worrying about what other people are doing,
and feeling diminished and having very low self-esteem themselves.
So it's very dangerous on many levels.
But it's not just social media. It's technology overall.
It was really the invention of the smartphone.
So if you are going to give your kids a phone,
I have no problem with giving your kids a phone if they're taking a bus
and you need to reach them.
Give them a flip phone, the old flip phone.
It's like, in a way, going back to a technology that was less dangerous
but was still helpful.