-Michael Fishbach and his family were enjoying a peaceful Valentine’s Day trip through the Sea of Cortez when they spotted a young humpback whale floating almost motionless at the surface. At first, they feared she was already dead—until she managed one desperate breath.
Looking beneath the water, Michael discovered the whale completely entangled in a massive commercial fishing net. With no rescue team nearby and only a small pocketknife available, he entered the water and began the dangerous process of cutting her free.
After approximately 45 minutes, the final strand came loose. Everyone expected the exhausted whale to disappear into the ocean—but instead, she turned back toward their boat and began an extraordinary hour-long display that none of them would ever forget.
For almost 45 minutes, Michael Fishbuck had been cutting through the net one strand at a time,
his hands aching, his arms burning, and his small fishing boat slowly disappearing beneath piles of
wet nylon. Only a few feet away, a young humpback whale floated at the surface,
so exhausted that every breath seemed like it might be her last.
Thick commercial netting had wrapped around her tail, fins, and enormous body,
slicing deeply enough into her skin that blood drifted through the blue water beneath them.
Michael had entered the ocean with nothing more than snorkeling gear and a pocket knife,
knowing that one frightened movement from the whale could kill him. Yet he kept cutting because
there was simply no other rescue team coming. Then, finally, the last section of rope loosened.
The whale pulled forward, the remaining net fell away, and for the first time in who knew how long,
she was completely free. Everyone aboard expected her to disappear into the Sea of Cortez.
Instead, the whale vanished beneath the surface, turned around, and came charging
directly back toward the tiny boat. Michael had spent nearly 20 years studying whales,
but what this animal was about to do for the next hour would leave even him struggling to
explain what they were witnessing. It had begun on Valentine's Day in 2011, during what should
have been nothing more than a beautiful morning on the water off Baja, California, Mexico.
Michael, his wife Heather Watrous, their young son Galen, several companions,
and Captain Alberto Davis had left Loreto Marina before sunrise aboard a small 25-foot fishing boat.
The Sea of Cortez seemed determined to reward them almost immediately.
They watched an enormous fin whale interacting with a blue whale, encountered playful bottlenose
dolphins, and spent the early hours surrounded by the kind of wildlife Michael had devoted much of
his adult life to studying. Then, as the boat traveled east beyond the southern tip of Carmen
Island, Michael noticed something ahead. Large, dark, completely still, Captain Davis slowed the
boat. The conversation stopped. As they approached, the shape became unmistakable. A humpback whale
was floating at the surface. But it wasn't swimming. It wasn't rolling. It wasn't reacting
to the boat. For several painful seconds, everyone believed they had found a dead whale.
Michael had spent thousands of hours around these animals, yet even he felt his stomach
sink as the boat drifted closer. Humpbacks can grow beyond 50 feet and weigh tens of thousands
of pounds, but this one looked strangely deflated, almost lifeless as the current gently moved her
body. Then came a sound. A breath. Weak and forced, but unmistakable. Mist rose from the blowhole.
The whale was alive. Barely. Michael immediately leaned over the side, looking through the unusually
clear water to understand why she wasn't moving. What he saw beneath the surface changed the entire
morning. The whale had been caught inside an enormous commercial fishing net, approximately
12 feet wide and hundreds of feet long. Thick nylon mesh surrounded her body like a cage,
wrapping around the fins, cutting across the tail and tightening wherever the animal had struggled.
Even worse, the net appeared to be shark fishing equipment inside a protected marine area where it
should never have been placed. The injuries were already severe. Parts of the net had
sliced into the whale's skin, her tail carried deep cuts, and part of the dorsal fin had been
torn away. Blood was visible in the water, but the most immediate danger was breathing. Whales are
mammals. However enormous they become, they still have to reach the surface for air. The tangled net
created so much resistance that this exhausted animal was fighting simply to keep her blowhole
above water. Each time she surfaced, she managed another breath before the weight of the gear
threatened to pull her down again. Michael watched her struggle and understood what would happen if
nobody intervened. She would eventually become too tired to surface, and then she would drown.
The problem was that Michael and the others were almost completely unequipped for a rescue of this
scale. There was no specialized disentanglement team nearby, no crane, no winch, no professional
cutting equipment. The five people aboard their little boat had essentially one useful tool,
a pocket knife. Michael also knew exactly how dangerous approaching the whale would be.
A humpback doesn't need to attack someone intentionally to kill them.
A single panicked movement from a tail or fin could strike with tremendous force,
and an animal trapped, bleeding, and exhausted might react unpredictably to a human swimming
toward it. Michael looked at Heather, then at Galen, then back toward the whale. He had spent
years trying to protect these animals through conservation work. Before that, his life had
looked completely different. He had once competed as a professional tennis player, even attracting
international attention during his playing career, before a devastating back injury involving
ruptured discs forced him away from the sport. He eventually redirected that intensity toward
marine conservation, logging thousands of hours studying whales and later helping establish the
Great Whale Conservancy. Now all those years of caring about whales had brought him to one
die without trying was impossible. Michael put on snorkeling equipment. He took the knife
and slipped into the water. As he approached, the true scale of the animal became overwhelming.
From the boat, the whale had looked enormous. In the water beside her, Michael was tiny.
Then her eye turned toward him. For a moment, human and whale simply looked at each other.
Michael could never know what the animal understood, but he wanted her to sense that
he wasn't another threat. He slowly moved around her body, examining the net. Underwater,
the situation looked even worse. The nylon had tightened into a complicated web. Every attempt
the whale had made to escape appeared to have pulled another section deeper into her skin.
Raw wounds surrounded the areas where the lines had rubbed continuously against her body.
Michael surfaced and told everyone what he had seen. It was bad. But she was still breathing.
So they started. Michael positioned himself close enough to reach the net and began cutting.
One strand, then another. The nylon was thick, and every cut had to be controlled because the
whale's damaged skin was directly beneath it. If the knife slipped, Michael could worsen the
injuries. If the rope shifted around his own arm or leg, he could become trapped beside her.
Heather and the others pulled freed sections aboard. Soon the deck was filling with tangled
nylon. That created another danger. Loose loops began catching around wrists and fingers,
forcing everyone into a rhythm they repeated constantly. Cut. Pull. Check themselves for
tangles. Then cut again. Minutes passed. Michael's hands became sore. The whale remained
astonishingly calm. And then, as enough rope came free for her to move, she suddenly began swimming.
The small boat lurched. For a moment, everyone feared she was escaping with half the net still
attached. Instead, the whale traveled roughly half a mile while gently pulling the boat behind her,
then surfaced again. Michael couldn't escape the strange feeling that she understood.
As though she knew these people were trying to help. As though she was giving them another angle
from which to reach the remaining ropes. So Michael kept cutting. His arms burned.
His fingers hurt. Every time he thought he had reached the final layer, another strand appeared
underneath. But slowly the enormous web began disappearing. The tail loosened. Then the fins.
Then the lines across the body. Until eventually Michael reached the last piece. He pushed the
knife through the nylon. The strand snapped. And suddenly there was no tension anymore.
The whale moved forward. The final section of net slipped from her body. She was free. Everyone
aboard erupted with relief as Michael climbed back toward the boat, exhausted and overwhelmed.
They had found this animal almost motionless, struggling for every breath. And somehow,
with a pocket knife and 45 minutes of dangerous work, they had given her another chance.
They assumed that was the end. The whale disappeared beneath the surface.
Michael watched the water, expecting one final glimpse before she headed into the open sea.
Then the surface erupted. The humpback launched almost her entire body into the air and crashed
back down in an explosion of white water. Everyone screamed. Seconds later, she breached
again. Then rolled. Then lifted her enormous tail high above the surface. Michael stared.
The whale wasn't leaving. She had come back. And whatever she was doing,
she seemed determined to do it directly in front of the people who had just saved her life.
The first breach was so sudden that nobody aboard had time to prepare for it. One moment the water
was settling after the rescue, and the next the young humpback exploded through the surface,
launching her enormous body into the air, before crashing back into the Sea of Cortez with enough
force to send a wall of white spray toward the tiny boat. Michael stood frozen, still exhausted
from cutting the net, watching the place where she had disappeared. Then she came up again.
Another breach. Another thunderous impact. She rolled onto her side and slapped one enormous
pectoral fin against the surface, then lifted her tail high above the water before disappearing
beneath it again. Michael had spent thousands of hours observing whales, yet even he could
barely process what was unfolding. The animal they had found almost motionless less than an
hour earlier was suddenly behaving as though she had discovered every ounce of energy she had left.
And she didn't leave. That was what made the moment extraordinary. A frightened animal released
from a trap might reasonably be expected to put as much distance as possible between itself and
the place where it had nearly died. This whale did the opposite. She remained beside the boat,
repeatedly surfacing close enough for everyone aboard to watch her movements in astonishing detail.
For nearly an hour, the display continued. She breached again and again, sometimes lifting
almost her entire 40-plus foot body clear of the water. She rolled across the surface, slapped her
fins hard enough to create cracks that echoed over the sea, and repeatedly raised her tail before
diving. Her wounds were still visible. Blood remained around some of the cuts where the net
had carved into her body. But she was moving. Breathing. Free. Michael and Heather watched
with tears in their eyes. Their son, Galen, stared at the animal, almost unable to look away.
Even Captain Alberto Davis, a man accustomed to spending his life on these waters,
seemed stunned by the intensity of what he was witnessing. Nobody could scientifically
prove what the whale was thinking. Michael knew that. But emotionally, it was difficult
for anyone aboard not to interpret the behavior as something resembling celebration. Only an hour
earlier, every movement had cost the whale precious energy. She had barely been capable
of holding her blowhole above the surface. The net had turned her own size and strength against her,
tightening every time she struggled and slowly dragging her toward exhaustion.
Now, the same enormous body that had seemed almost lifeless was repeatedly launching itself
into the air. Michael later described the scene not simply as gratitude, but as the joy of an
extraordinary living creature realizing it was alive and free. And perhaps that was enough.
At one point during the display, a young voice from aboard the boat seemed to capture what
everyone was already feeling. The whale wasn't merely swimming away. She was celebrating.
The group eventually gave her a name, Valentina, in honor of Valentine's Day,
the day they had found her and the day she had been given another chance at life.
Eventually, the breaches became less frequent. Valentina began moving farther from the boat.
One final tail rose above the water. Then, she disappeared into the open sea. This time,
she didn't return. The people aboard remained quiet for several moments,
surrounded by the pieces of net they had dragged from her body.
The deck itself told the story of how close the rescue had come to failing.
Hundreds of feet of tangled fishing gear cut apart strand by strand with a single small knife.
For Michael, the experience became impossible to separate from the conservation work to which he
had already devoted his life. Valentina had been fortunate because a boat happened to find her
while she still possessed enough strength to breathe. Countless other whales entangled in
fishing equipment are never discovered in time. Lines and nets can cut into their bodies,
restrict feeding and swimming, cause infections, and eventually prevent them from surfacing for
air. That made what happened on Valentine's Day feel even more extraordinary.
Five people had begun the morning expecting to watch wildlife from a distance.
Instead, they became the only chance one young whale had. They had no specialized
rescue equipment, no elaborate plan, and no certainty that approaching her was even safe.
They had a small boat, a pocket knife, and the decision that leaving her there wasn't acceptable.
And somehow, it was enough. Michael had once spent his life measuring success through competition.
Later, after injury ended that chapter, he redirected himself toward protecting creatures
that could never know his name or understand the organizations humans created on their behalf.
Valentina couldn't thank him with words. Nobody could ask her what those breaches meant.
Perhaps they were simply the natural movements of an animal suddenly released after prolonged
restraint. Perhaps they were an explosion of energy after surviving something terrifying.
Or perhaps, in whatever way a whale understands the world,
she recognized that the tiny boat beside her had changed what should have been the final day of her
life.