Mazda Rotary Engine: Survive or Extinct?

Engine Nation
3 followers
This video explores the Mazda rotary engine alongside three extinct or nearly extinct engines.
00:00 introduction
01:31 3 extinct engines
08:22 Rotary engine Structure and Mechanism
10:04 Advantages
12:46 Disadvantages
15:42 Survive or Fade Away
#machine #engine
AI Generated·May contain errors
No one knows why. But Mazda, seems to have a DNA of creating innovative engines only to abandon
them after a short time. The Pressure Wave Supercharger, introduced in 1987, was highly
innovative. But it disappeared from the market within about 10 years. The Miller Cycle Engine
with a Lism Compressor, from 1993, was considered the engine closest to ideal at the time.
But it too was discontinued after only 7 years. The Skyactiv-X engine, combining the best aspects
of gasoline and diesel engines, was introduced to the market in 2019. While it is still available
in some markets, Mazda has already announced the development of its next generation engine,
so this engine's lifespan will likely end soon as well. As an exception, the rotary engine,
was produced from 1967 to 2013, and maintained a strong presence as Mazda's icon.
Considering that engine the first generation. The second generation rotary engine newly developed
for PHEVs in 2023, is also in a precarious situation, and will likely exit the market in
the near future. If that happens, the history of the rotary engine will truly come to an end.
In this video, we will briefly review these 3 extinct engines.
Discuss the pros and cons of the rotary engine. And consider its future.
Well, to be exact, 2 of them are extinct, and 1 is nearly extinct.
Superchargers generally fall into 2 categories. Turbochargers, which are driven by exhaust gas
energy. And mechanical superchargers, which are driven directly by the engine's crankshaft.
Although turbochargers have been significantly improved today, they suffered from the weakness
of failing to build boost pressure at low engine speeds. On the other hand, mechanical
superchargers had the drawback of creating large power losses at high engine speeds.
The pressure wave supercharger, adopted by Mazda in 1987, was an extremely unique supercharging
system that used exhaust gas pressure to force intake air into the engine.
First, let us examine its structure. A rotating cylinder filled with numerous cells,
is positioned between the intake and exhaust pipes, driven via a belt connected to the
crankshaft. How, exactly, does this device achieve forced induction? To make this easier to
understand, we will use a diagram showing the rotor flattened into a 2D plane. The pipe connected
to the engine's exhaust port is exhaust pipe 1, and the pipe discharging to the atmosphere from
the rotor is exhaust pipe 2. The pipe connected to the intake port is intake pipe 1, and the
pipe drawing air into the rotor from the atmosphere is intake pipe 2. Currently, the pressure inside
the cell is at atmospheric pressure. Exhaust pipe 1, the cell, and intake pipe 1 are connected.
When the engine's exhaust valve opens, exhaust gas enters the cell through exhaust pipe 1,
along with a pressure wave. The air inside the cell is pushed by the pressure wave and forced
into intake pipe 1. As the rotor rotates, the cell moves and the connection to intake pipe 1 is
closed. The pressure wave then reflects off the wall and exits to the atmosphere through exhaust
pipe 2. As the exhaust gas exits, a negative pressure forms inside the cell, causing fresh
air to flow in when the cell connects to intake pipe 2. It seemed like a dream supercharger,
without the delayed boost at low engine speeds seen in turbochargers, nor the mechanical losses
at high engine speeds seen in mechanical superchargers. However, it likely had more
disadvantages than advantages. In the end, it failed to survive the next generation of vehicle
models and disappeared after only about a decade. With the widespread adoption of hybrid vehicles
today, the term Miller cycle is no longer unfamiliar, at least among automotive industry
professionals. To put it simply, the Miller cycle is a concept that improves fuel efficiency by
reducing the effective displacement without changing the engine structure. While this
reduction in intake volume decreases power output, superchargers compensate for the drop in power.
In modern hybrid vehicles, an electric motor fulfills this role instead of a supercharger.
This channel has a detailed video explaining the Miller cycle. If you are interested,
please check the link in the description. In 1993, Mazda developed an exceptionally
efficient engine by combining the overlooked Miller cycle with a LISM supercharger which
had no prior mass production application. However, whether because its fuel economy
fell short of expectations or due to a lack of overall vehicle appeal, this engine was
discontinued after only 7 years. The advantage of a diesel engine is its low pumping loss
because it does not have a throttle valve. This is the fundamental reason why diesel
engines have good fuel economy. This channel has a video explaining pumping loss in detail.
If you are interested, please check the link in the description.
Eliminating the throttle valve in a gasoline engine draws in a large amount of air even at
low engine speeds, making the air-fuel ratio too lean for the mixture to ignite.
The concept of Skyactiv-X engine's SPCCI, spark-controlled compression ignition,
is designed to solve this issue. However, it is not as simple as merely raising the
compression ratio, like in a diesel engine. Depending on the market, this engine has a
compression ratio of 15 to 16 to 1. At this compression ratio, it is impossible to cause
the fuel to auto-ignite like a diesel engine. During the compression stroke, a layer of rich
air-fuel mixture is formed around the spark plug. The spark plug ignites, causing the rich
mixture to burn and expand. This combustion gas acts as a virtual piston, working alongside the
actual piston to compress the lean mixture and raise the cylinder temperature. Once the temperature
reaches the point of auto-ignition, the gasoline auto-ignites, rapidly spreading the combustion
throughout the cylinder. When the engine is cold or during hard acceleration, SPCCI mode is
suspended and the engine operates as a conventional spark ignition engine. In the early stages of
developing this engine, Mazda promoted that it was developing HCCI, homogeneous charge compression
ignition. HCCI is a combustion method based on auto-ignition, without using a spark plug,
similar to a diesel engine. However, after a while, the designation changed to SPCCI.
Around this time, doubts began to surface, making people wonder if something was off.
As suspected, Skyactiv-X was not a pure HCCI engine. Instead, it arrived as an engine that
achieved auto-ignition through an indirect approach and only under specific conditions.
As a trade-off, it required a supercharger, an ultra-high pressure 70 MPa fuel injection system,
and in-cylinder pressure sensors, along with additional steps in the manufacturing process,
ultimately making it an extremely costly engine. It would have been fine if it achieved truly
remarkable performance despite these drawbacks, but if this engine cannot survive the model
changes of the Mazda3 and CX-30, it will follow the same path as the Miller cycle engine.
See, that's the Mazda heritage, that's the true Mazda DNA. The history of the rotary engine is a
history of struggles, constantly at the mercy of fuel economy and emissions regulations.
In this section, we will look at the structure and working principles of the rotary engine,
its pros and cons, as well as consider its current status and future prospects.
A rotary engine mainly consists of the following components.
Rotor housing, rotor, eccentric shaft, and stationary gear. The eccentric shaft is the
engine's output shaft and corresponds to the crankshaft in a reciprocating engine.
The stationary gear is fixed to the side housing and does not rotate.
Intake and exhaust are routed through either the side housings or the rotor housing.
The rotor orbits eccentrically around the eccentric shaft while simultaneously rotating on
its own axis. The inner wall of the rotor housing and the rotor apexes form the combustion chambers,
which repeatedly go through the intake, compression, combustion, and exhaust cycles.
For every one revolution of the rotor, the eccentric shaft rotates three times.
Because one rotor forms three combustion chambers, there are three combustion strokes per
rotor revolution. With three engine revolutions per rotor revolution, the engine has one combustion
stroke per revolution. With a two-rotor configuration, there are two combustion
strokes per engine revolution, so the ignition interval is the same as that of a four-cylinder
reciprocating engine. One of its advantages is that it has a low component count, making it
lightweight and extremely compact. This diagram shows the mounting position of the 13B engine in
the RX-8. Thanks to its compact size, the engine is mounted entirely behind the front axle line.
Mazda referred to this as a front midship layout. There is no way this wouldn't have a positive
impact on the vehicle's dynamic performance. Because it lacks reciprocating components
like traditional engines, extremely smooth, low vibration rotation is another major advantage.
To offset the inertial forces generated by the rotor's eccentric rotation, counterweights are
placed 180 degrees out of phase on the eccentric shaft. Its superior vibration characteristics far
surpass an inline-4, and when accounting for the finer operational details, it even edges out the
idealized inline-6. The primary advantage is its higher power output compared to a reciprocating
engine of the same displacement. Let us compare a two-rotor engine with a single chamber volume of
600 cc against a four-cylinder reciprocating engine with a total displacement of 1,200 cc.
A reciprocating engine intakes 1,200 cc of air every two engine revolutions. This equals 600 cc
per single revolution. In a two-rotor engine, each combustion chamber is 600 cc, so it intakes
3,600 cc of air during one rotation of the rotors. Since one rotor rotation corresponds to three
engine revolutions, the intake air per engine revolution is 1,200 cc. In other words, a rotary
engine can theoretically intake twice as much air as a reciprocating engine of the same displacement,
allowing it to generate significantly higher output. This table compares the two-rotor
engine of the RX-8 with the flat-6 engine of a contemporary Porsche Cayman. As you can see,
the power output of the 1.3L rotary engine is equivalent to that of the 2.7L flat-6 engine.
On the other hand, the weight of the rotary engine is only about 60% of that of the flat-6.
This comparison clearly supports the advantages of the rotary engine explained so far.
However, what catches our attention is its low torque. This point leads directly to the
disadvantages discussed next. Low torque can be rephrased as low thermal efficiency,
and that means poor fuel economy. Put simply, the rotary engine's greatest drawback is its
poor fuel economy. One cause of this is the flattened shape of its combustion chamber.
In a reciprocating engine, the combustion chamber is shaped like a flattened hemisphere,
allowing the flame generated near the spark plug to reach the edges of the chamber in a short time.
In a rotary engine, however, it takes time for the flame to reach the edges of the combustion chamber,
increasing the likelihood that gasoline remains unburned.
Gasoline that should have generated force to rotate the rotor is discharged unburned.
Another cause is the magnitude of heat loss. A portion of the gasoline's combustion energy
escapes from the combustion chamber as heat. The larger the surface area of the combustion chamber,
the greater this heat loss becomes. Because the combustion chamber surface area of a rotary engine
is significantly larger than that of a reciprocating engine, large heat loss occurs.
In other words, the rotary engine discards a large amount of energy into the atmosphere via
the engine coolant and the radiator, energy that should have been used to rotate the engine.
To make matters worse, because the rotor rotates, the combustion chamber continuously
loses heat to the cool rotor housing. There is more. To seal in the combustion gas, piston rings
perform this role in a reciprocating engine. In a rotary engine, this role is played by the apex
seals, corner seals, and side seals. Let us compare a 1,300cc four-cylinder reciprocating
engine with a square bore and stroke against the 13B engine. This reciprocating engine has a piston
diameter of 74.5 millimeters, so the piston ring circumference is approximately 234 millimeters.
In other words, the distance along which combustion gas can leak is 234 millimeters
per cylinder. On the other hand, the 13B engine has a rotor width of approximately 80 millimeters
and a rotor side length of approximately 240 millimeters. Therefore, the leakage distance
for combustion gas per combustion chamber is about 640 millimeters, about 2.7 times that of
the reciprocating engine. Combustion gas that should have served as the force to rotate the rotor
blows past the seals in far greater amounts than in a reciprocating engine. For these reasons,
the rotary engine's thermal efficiency is low, resulting in poor fuel economy and low torque.
Lightweight, compact, sharp and smooth revving, and powerful, but with terrible fuel economy.
Naturally, it only ever made sense as a sports car engine. Yet Mazda, for reasons beyond human
comprehension, decided to use this very rotary as a dedicated generator engine for PHEV.
That's the MX-30 rotary EV. Of course, it failed commercially. Installing an inherently thirsty
rotary engine into PHEV, a vehicle explicitly designed to save gas, is sheer absurdity. Then,
in 2023, Mazda unveiled the iconic SP, an electric sports car concept, powered by a newly developed
two-rotor engine. Have they completely lost their minds? Who on earth is going to feel
the signature smoothness and sharp revving of a rotary engine when it's routed through an electric
motor? And why on earth combine such a lightweight engine with hundreds of kilograms of heavy
batteries? But don't worry. In all likelihood, this is a glorified figurehead never destined
for production. Still, if Mazda actually puts a two-rotor electric sports car into production,
let's look them in the eye with a smile and tell them this. Oh, there goes Mazda again.
Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed this video, please consider subscribing to the channel.
We'll see you in the next video.
