The second part of a two-part educational series evaluating the Indo-Aryan Migration Theory and the origins of South Asian civilization. This critical analysis systematically breaks down the Out-of-India hypothesis presented by Hindu teacher David Frawley, who claims that global ancient societies are cultural descendants of India. The presentation scrutinizes his arguments across literary records, geographical and astronomical markers, and archaeological findings to compare them against mainstream historical consensus (0:30).
This video provides a critical analysis of David Frawley's \"Out-of-India\" hypothesis, which posits that India was the cradle of the world's first civilization. The narrator refutes Frawley's claims by arguing that the evidence linking the Vedic people to the Indus Valley Civilization is logically flawed and lacks empirical support from archaeology, linguistics, and genetics.
This is the second part of an analysis of the talk The Myth of the Aryan Invasion
given by David Frawley in which Frawley presents evidence that India was where
the world's first civilization appeared. If you didn't see part one I think you
should go back and watch it first before you do this one as you'll be able to
understand what's going on in this one better if you do. I'll leave a link in
the description below and then come on back. In that first part I showed how
genetic and linguistic evidence did not support Frawley's claims, but he
asserted that priority should be given to the literary, geological, and
archaeological evidence. So we have to give him a chance to present his
arguments in those areas. Unfortunately, I think we will find as we discuss them
that his supports do not hold up as well as he thinks they do.
Myths of Ancient History is aimed at dispelling common misconceptions about
the past. If you're interested in ancient history, lost civilizations, and
secrets from antiquity, I encourage you to pause this video and subscribe to the
channel because you will get plenty of that kind of material. And if you find
this particular video valuable, please hit the like button and comment below
with your favorite takeaway. And feel free to ask any clarification questions
that you may have. So what are the literary, geological, and archaeological
evidences for Indian priority, that is, that India's civilization came first, and
the out-of-India hypothesis that all civilizations of the world came from
India? Let me be clear at the outset that I enthusiastically accept the evidence
for the great antiquity of civilization in South Asia. You can't ignore the
remarkable material remains of the Harappan, or Indus River Valley,
civilization of the Bronze Age, which archaeologists have dated as lasting
from the late 4th to the early 2nd millennium BCE, making it one of the
oldest civilizations in the world. And it was not a transplant from somewhere else,
but it was indigenous. Let me also say that I am equally impressed by the
complex, sophisticated society reflected in the Hindu holy books written in
Sanskrit, called the Vedas, and I do not view that Vedic culture as primitive, or
backwards, or weak, or simplistic. I just cannot go as far as Frawley, who posits
that the Arya, or Aryans, the people linguists call the Indo-Aryans, the ones
who composed the Vedas, were the inhabitants of the Harappan civilization,
and that the Aryans were the progenitors of all Indo-Europeans, and that South
Asia is where the first civilization on Earth appeared, and that no one migrated
into India throughout the entire Bronze Age and early Iron Age. Those are the
claims that just do not stand up to the evidence. Now, as I go forward, I will do
my best to steel man Frawley's arguments, that means consider them in the
strongest form that I can, and then I will show you the problems that
nevertheless are inherent in his arguments. I want you to understand why
the consensus in historical scholarship is what it is. As the excavation of these
so-called Harappan sites has continued, very many interesting things have been
found. They constitute the largest urban civilization in the ancient world, in
terms of size. You could take the Indo-Saraswati civilization and put all of
Egypt and Mesopotamia together, and still have extra room left over. We talk of
Sumeria as the cradle of civilization. All of Sumeria could be put in a small
portion of Gujarat, by that whole Surat region, there'd be plenty of room left
over. So, much larger in size, much more populated. It had probably five, ten times
the population of the Mesopotamian cultures, and a greater uniformity of
building practices, and artifacts, arts, and crafts.
Okay, so here he is establishing the great size of the Harappan, or Indus
River Valley civilization. As we continue, he'll also try to establish the great
size of the Vedic literary tradition, and then say that we should assume, therefore,
they are connected, because they're both large. By extolling the size of the
Harappan civilization in comparison with others, he also seems to be implying it's
older than the others. But, what does the fact that the Indus River Valley
civilization was large, and uniform, have to do with whether it was first? Does
that make sense to you? Like, oh, well if it's the biggest, then it's got to be the
first. Cities grow at different rates, and they also stop growing, and they may
grow and get smaller, right? Since civilizations grow at different speeds,
you can't say that the largest, necessarily, was the first one to ever
come into existence. It's just not a reasonable supposition. And when exactly
was it supposedly the largest? The Vedas are by far the largest ancient literature
we have from the ancient world. What the Greeks have preserved is much
later and much smaller. What the Bible and those traditions are much smaller.
What you have in the Mesopotamian culture, what they found is only a few
isolated texts. We have by far the largest literature from the ancient
world, but preserved throughout history with extensive commentaries and
redactions. Again, I don't follow the logic. Largest doesn't mean first. I
suppose he could be suggesting that because the body of literature is so
large, it must have taken a longer time to put it together? But since not all
literature of the ancient world has been preserved, and different cultures have
preserved different parts of their literature for different reasons and in
different percentages, we can't measure literary output by what literature just
so happens to be extant today. Having more of something doesn't prove its
antiquity. It just means you happen to have more of it. And yet we are told that
this was the literature of nomadic people and primitive people, which
there's no reason to preserve that type of literature in any case. Who says the
literature was preserved by primitive nomads? No one that I know of. Besides, we
know why the literature of India was preserved. Because it was considered
sacred, and it was preserved to this day because the religious tradition that
considered it sacred has survived until today. Is this not a universally accepted
conclusion? So the point I raised in one of my earlier books, it's been elevated
to something now people sometimes call Frawley's paradox. India has the largest
literature from the ancient world. It has the largest archaeological evidence, urban
sites from the ancient world. Both are centered on what is called the Saraswati
River. Why not just connect the two? Then the mystery of the civilization without
a literature and a literature without a civilization is solved. Frawley's paradox,
as he calls it, is that historians don't assign the largest body of literature to
the largest civilization. But what does geographical area have to do with
literary output? Nothing that I can see. What do brick buildings have to do with
a writing tradition? Why couldn't people living in wooden structures, and who were
spread out in smaller settlements, produce literature? Well, they could, of
course. Mud brick architecture and literature are two different kinds of
production. If you believe what he's saying, you would have to deny that the
Hebrew Bible was written by the Israelites because, hey, you know, their
kingdom was so small. They couldn't have produced such a large work like the
Bible. But of course, that's just silly. Surely Frawley realizes that if he
associates the Vedas with the urban society of the Harappans, he still has a
long non-urban period in India's history after the Harappans. He hasn't
eliminated it. That means he either has to accept that a great society can be
non-urbanized, or that the society that followed the Harappans was not great. It
is possible, you know, for a sophisticated culture to be subsequent to another
sophisticated culture. Then in the Vedic literature, we also have the references
of kings. Okay, but unless we can see evidence of those kings, or any kings for
that matter, in the ruins of the Indus River Valley civilization, then there is
no link between the Vedas and the Indus River Valley civilization. Show me one of
those kings' names written on something that comes from the Indus River Valley
civilization. Hey, then you've got something. We have mentions of great kings
and great emperors. Often we have the statement that the king had a hundred
thousand troops, and he conquers a hundred cities. Have we found evidence of
emperors in the Indus River Valley civilization, or armies of a hundred
thousand men? No, we haven't. The Greeks, like Alexander, they thought
India was a very advanced civilization, and there was one of their authors named
Megasthenes. He did a book called Indica. It hasn't survived, but one of its
passages said, he came about the time of Alexander, that he found a history in
India of a hundred and fifty-three kings going back more than 6,400 years.
Yeah, this Greek, Megasthenes, who lived around 300 BCE, is purported to have had
a list of kings going back more than 6,000 years. And Plato said that Athens
had an empire going back 9,000 years. Guess what? It didn't. If Frawley was
interested in studying Indian history in the same manner that historians study
the histories of all other societies, then he would have to admit that it is
very common for histories, which were written centuries after the events they
describe, to be expanded, exaggerated, twisted for propaganda purposes, and
sometimes just plain wrong because of poor transmission. Why would India be any
different? I know his answer, because India is superior to all other cultures.
Well, historians can't be biased like that. They have to be consistent, and they
should be criticized if they aren't consistent. And in the Puranas and the
Vedas, we have a list of kings. Puranic king lists are over a hundred, there's
well over a hundred kings before the time of Buddha, anyway, maybe even close
to a hundred and fifty, I don't know the exact numbers involved. India has the
longest king list of any culture in the world, much longer than the Egyptians.
In the Bible, they only have 42 kings between, what, Abraham and Jesus.
The Puranas are not from Vedic times and contain material that originally was
transmitted orally through a Bardic tradition, shaped and reshaped over
generations until finally written down. We can see how the Puranas contradict
the Vedas and thus know that the Puranic traditions altered earlier histories.
The Catholic Church has a list of popes going all the way back to the Apostle
Peter, but those lists post-date the time of Peter. They are not contemporary with
Peter. Therefore, historians rightly approach them with a certain amount of
skepticism. How would the king lists, which also are not contemporary, be any
different? And one of the things I did, it's still in my book, God, Sages and
Kings, I cataloged, there's over a hundred and fifty references to Samudra, or ocean,
in Rig Veda itself. Not only a hundred and fifty references, there's a heavenly
ocean, there's the Antariksha as the ocean, atmospheric ocean, earthly ocean,
there's two oceans, there's four oceans, there's the metaphor of Shataritra, the
ship with a hundred oars, there's travel on the sea, there's also travel on the
sea where Vashishtha prays, there's water all around me and I can't drink.
Why? Because it's saltwater in the ocean. So the mythology or the image of the
ocean pervades the Vedas and it pervades the symbolism of both the gods and the
Rishis. Yes, the symbolism of the sea is often seen in the Vedas. But now, if we
were to demonstrate that the people who composed the hymns of the Rig Veda live
near the sea, what evidence would we need to provide? Would simple references to
the sea in the Rig Veda be sufficient? No, of course not, because we would need to
demonstrate not merely that these people knew of the sea, but that it was in their
land. Knowledge of the sea is not the same as proximity to the sea. Well, how
would they know about the sea if they never lived there? In many ways, travelers
and migrants could have passed on such information, ancestors could have passed
down such information. Indeed, it is highly unlikely that a people on the move
would never have heard of the sea as they are today. People then were
fascinated to hear about faraway places. Moreover, it is well known that the
ancient peoples living in the area from the Mediterranean to South Asia had a
belief that the earth was surrounded by an ocean, that there was an ocean in
heaven, and that there was an ocean under the earth. It was part of their cosmology.
We can see this, for example, in the myths of the Greeks, the Levantines, the
Mesopotamians, and Persians. To demonstrate that the Rigvedic people
lived near the sea, we would need more than mere references to the ocean in
mythology. We would need unambiguous references to it being in the region
where these people resided. And if they did reside by the sea, it would be a
major part of their way of life. And so it is highly unlikely that they wouldn't
be constantly talking about it. How many of Frawley's 150 references fit that
criterion? None that I can see. A great number of them refer to the creation of
the world out of the sea. Other myths about the gods also mention the sea. On
occasion, the gods Varuna and Soma and Indra are called Samudras, which means
seas, or at least large bodies of water. Samudra means literally gathering of
water. The gods travel in ships in the heavenly sea, and there's reference to
divine boats of a hundred oars. But these are as mythical as the gods' 1,000
pillared houses and Indra's 1,000 testicles. The numbers 100 and 1,000 are
frequently used in the literature as a symbol of the gods' greatness. Sometimes
the Rigveda uses the sea symbolically, but nothing about everyday life by the
sea or humans traveling on the literal ocean. His comment about a verse in the
Rigveda concerning Vasishtha interested me greatly when I first heard it. If,
after all, we have a reference to Vasishtha being in the midst of waters
and being unable to drink it because it was saltwater, that would be a strong
piece of evidence. So I looked it up. Here's what the verse says.
I guess that's like fjords?
The pertinent line here, of course, is the one about thirst. I don't read
Sanskrit, so I can't tell you exactly what word is translated water fields, but
I do know it isn't samudra, the word for a large body of water. If you know the
literal meaning of the word, please let me know in the comments below. It would
make things a lot easier if it said something about the salt. As it is, it's
possible that the author means he can't drink the water for some reason, whether
because of salt or something else. But it's also plausible that he refuses to
The poem is about the author's poor state of mind as a result of his
transgression. He is forlorn and speaks of wandering aimlessly, deliberately not
seeking shelter, even though that causes him to suffer. So it makes sense that
just as he refuses to find comfort in a house, so he also refuses to find comfort
in satisfying his thirst. In fact, that was the first thing I thought when I read
it. Whether you prefer to interpret this as his being unable to drink or being
unwilling to drink, you have to admit that the saltwater interpretation is not
the only viable one. It therefore cannot constitute proof that the Rigvedic
culture resided near saltwater. Climate is the seasons of India. Monsoon is a
very big symbolism. In the Vedic texts, you don't have a monsoon in Central Asia.
Indra is the monsoon deity releasing the rivers. The monsoon is connected to the
summer solstice, which is also when it occurs in India. The Rigveda mentions
rains, not monsoons. What we would need to see is reference to the winds reversing
to bring the rains. That's a monsoon. But as far as I'm aware, this is not
mentioned in the Rigveda. I looked in Frawley's book, God, Sages and Kings, to
see what evidence he provides of monsoons. And his basic argument is that
since Indra is a monsoon god and Indra is mentioned in the Rigveda, then there
must have been monsoons then. But you see, he's not taking into consideration the
possibility that Indra, who was a storm god, became associated with the monsoons
after the people migrated into India. He just assumes that Indra is and has
always been associated with the monsoons throughout the entirety of Indian
history. But mythology about gods grows and changes over time and is adapted to
the people's living circumstances. Geographically, Vedas talk of a region of
Saptasindhu. But if you look at Saptasindhu, there are three rivers that
they mention give the most predominance to. Sindhu, Saraswati, and Sarayu. And
it's very easy to identify these at the Sarayu in the east of India, the Saraswati
in the center, and the Indus in the west. Some Western scholars tried to put
Saraswati and Sarayu in Afghanistan because there are rivers in Afghanistan
with connections to these Vedic names because you also had these in the Iranian
culture. But we all also have a history of Purus and Ikshwakus conquering,
moving to Afghanistan. And because these rivers are said to be oceanic and huge,
in the case of the Saraswati flowing all the way into the sea, we cannot identify
them with the rivers of Afghanistan. The term Saptasindhu means seven rivers and
refers to the land in which the people of the Rig Veda lived. Mainstream scholars
equate this area with the region called the Punjab. Several of the rivers
mentioned in the Rig Veda cannot be identified with certainty. There appears
to have been a practice among migrating peoples to name new rivers they
encountered after rivers they remembered from back home. For example, although
there is a Saraswati River in India, there was definitely one also in
Afghanistan. While scholars are inclined to think of the one in Afghanistan as
being named first, Frawley prefers to think of the original rivers as existing
in India. And then people migrating westward took the names with them and
applied them in Afghanistan. Whatever the case, it's probable that the rivers
referred to in the Rig Veda are in most cases the ones in India. And that is
where Rig Vedic society is to be located, so there's no problem there.
Frawley wishes to make the Sarayu River one of the main rivers of the Rig Veda,
though it is mentioned only three times. It's not one of the chief rivers of
early Vedic culture. The Drishadwati and Chhatudri are far more important. There
is a Sarayu River today in northern India, but without warrant he uses this
river name to stretch the eastern boundary of Vedic territory all the way
to the Bay of Bengal. Mainstream scholars are generally agreed that the Sarayu is
a tributary of the Indus River because it is listed in the Rig Veda along with
the other tributaries of the Indus. Saraswati was a great River of India that
dried up around 4,000 years ago. Most of these so-called Harappan or Indus Valley
sites are actually located on the dry banks of the Saraswati River, showing
there was once water that was located there. For those who know the Vedic text,
in Rig Veda, Saraswati is a great river flowing into the sea. In late Vedic text
in the Mahabharata, there's the Vinashana of the Saraswati, where it dries up in
the desert, and then later on Saraswati is not mentioned at all. So all stages of
the drying up of the river are also there. The Saraswati River is given more
praise in the Rig Veda than any other river, even the Indus. Though this need
not mean it was the largest river, but only that it was important to the
Rig Vedic people. The Rig Veda describes the Saraswati as flowing through the
high mountains into a Samudra, a large body of water. It's usually identified
with the modern Sarsuti, Gagar, and Hakra rivers, that is, they all once were
connected. The upper course of the Saraswati is in the Punjab, right where
mainstream scholars situate the Rig Vedic society. Although it's smaller than it
used to be, it still exists today. Now, because Frawley not only wants to push
the date of the Rig Veda back, but also extend Rig Vedic society southward to
the ocean, he emphasizes the fact that the river ran through the region where
the Harappan civilization existed, and that during the pre-Harappan period
appears to have been significantly large on its lower course, though there is some
dispute on that point. It's all dried up today. Settlements were being built
directly on the floodplain of the Gagar-Hakra River in the mature Harappan
period, which shows that it was no longer a major river at that time anyway. Maybe
I'm missing it, but I haven't heard anything from Frawley that conclusively
shows that the Rig Vedic people lived on the lower course of the river. In other
words, I'm not seeing any evidence that invalidates the current scholarly
consensus of the location or the time of the Rig Vedic culture. Harappa represents
the late Vedic culture in which the river was in decline, like the time of
Mahabharata. So, the ocean-going Saraswati represents an earlier period. So, even if
the Saraswati was in decline in the Harappan era, that doesn't disprove the
Vedic literature. Actually, it gives it a greater antiquity. The problem with dating
the later Vedas to the Harappan period is that there are explicit references to
iron in them, and our earliest evidence of iron technology in India is around
1200 BCE, after the disappearance of the Harappan civilization. The later Vedas,
not the Rig Veda, but the later Vedas, which mention iron, must therefore come
after 1200 BCE. The flora and the fauna of the Vedas, peepal tree is common,
Ashwata tree. So, you know what the Western scholars say? Ashwata was originally the
aspen tree in Central Asia, and when they came to India, they took that name and
gave it to the Ashwata tree. So, even if you have the evidence, then they negate
the evidence by changing the meaning of terms in order to suit them.
Frawley here refers to the peepal, or sacred fig tree, also known as the Bodhi
tree, which is native to South Asia and Southeast Asia. It is mentioned in the
Atharva Veda all the time, less so in the Rig Veda. I believe it's in a mere four
hymns out of over a thousand, but it is still in there. So, wouldn't that indicate
that the Rig Veda was composed in India? Well, it would indicate that at least by
the time those four hymns of the Rig Veda were composed, the people had now
entered the territory in which the peepal tree could be found. What the
exact limits of the people's domain were in those days, we can't know for certain.
But I'm pretty sure the peepal tree is in the region of the Punjab today. And
then there's this whole issue of what we call the Soma. Soma is the name of a
plant and of a drink made from that plant, which was and is used in religious
ritual. So I did an extensive study of Soma in the Rig Veda and another text.
In the Charak, in Sushruta Samhita, I think it is, 24 different types of Somas are
listed in their locations and substitute Somas. They exist in the mountains, they
grow near mountain lakes, they have abundant milk and juice, and they're
described as various orchid type plants, or lotus lily type plants, and certain
reed type plants. So the types of plants. And there's many types of Soma. And even
if you study this Sukta, this Vedic Sukta, the Rig Vedic Sukta, on the hymns of the
plants, Soma dwells in all the plants. Soma is the rasa, or the healing essence
of the plants. Because the practice of making Soma has continued in different
lands and to the present day, and over time different plants have been used to
make the drink, identifying the original plant has proved tricky. And there are
always new proposals being made. The word Soma in Sanskrit is a cognate of the
Avestan word Haoma. Avestan is the language of the Zoroastrian scriptures,
an early Iranian language. That Soma and Haoma are cognates, that is, words that
have a common etymological origin, is beyond dispute. Soma and Haoma, they're
referring to the same thing. How would we figure out what the plant was? Well, both
the Rig Veda and the Avesta provide clues by giving descriptions of the
plants, of the making of the drink, and of the effects of the drink upon
consumption. We don't have time to go over all the details. I will just tell
you that the majority of scholars are inclined to identify the plant as Ephedra.
It just seems to fit the descriptions best. Remains of Ephedra have been found
in a ritual context in Margiana. But because Ephedra is native to Central
Asia, and a bunch of other places for that matter, but not native to India,
Frawley cannot abide this conclusion. And because he cannot identify a more likely
candidate which is native to India, he argues instead that Soma is not an
identifiable plant at all, but is merely, quote, the healing essence in every plant,
unquote. The main problem with Frawley's approach is that he uses sources from
across a fairly long time period to establish that the descriptions of Soma
are varied. So, for example, when he says there were 24 varieties, that was in the
time of Sushruta, centuries after Rigvedic times. In other words, this
approach conflates many definitions of Soma, and many practices associated with
Soma, into one. But the descriptions given of the plant in the Rigveda and
Avesta, our oldest sources on Soma, are specific enough to be the
characteristics of a single plant, maybe two. Frawley argues that Ephedra doesn't
fit the Rigvedic description, because, if I understand him, the Rigveda says Soma
is a wet plant, and Ephedra is a dry plant. Okay, maybe it's not Ephedra. There
are other possibilities. Or the Rigvedic society had already chosen a new plant
to replace the old Soma. The identification of Soma is not an
important pillar in the argument that the Indo-Aryans came from Central Asia.
It can't be, because there's still considerable debate as to what Soma was.
By toppling the claim that Soma was Ephedra, Frawley isn't really
accomplishing that much. And more recent archaeology in Haryana has now
discovered these Harappan sites and pre-Harappan sites of agriculture going
back to 7000 BC. It's true that agriculture goes that far back in India,
and although India probably invented agriculture independently, it still was
after it was invented in the Near East. The main grain is yava, or barley, at an
earlier phase. That's also there in Rigveda. Yes, the staple crop of Rigvedic
society was barley. Guess what the staple crop of the Harappan civilization was?
Wheat. Not a match. In the late Harappan period, they started cultivating rice.
Rice is also absent in the Rigveda. What we have to understand is that the
literature we have cannot be regarded as exhaustive of everything. The Rigveda has
been preserved, but that doesn't mean there weren't other texts at that time.
And we cannot look to what is essentially a spiritual religious text
for every aspect of the life of the people. If a plant is not mentioned in the
Rigveda, people didn't know about it. And just because a plant is not mentioned,
that doesn't mean people did know about it. So some of the Western linguists have
said, look, there are no horses on the seals, therefore they couldn't be Vedic
people. Rigveda is full of references to horses, horse-drawn chariots, and horse
races, and speaks of even non-nobles riding horses. But horses are notably
absent from the material remains of the Harappan civilization. Our earliest
evidence of horse domestication, by the way, comes from Central Asia. Since 90% of
the seals are unicorns, there are no unicorns in India, then they must have
then they must have lived in a land where they were unicorns. In other words,
their iconography was symbolic. It was not a zoological set of specimen. Yes, it
may be that the Harappan images include both mythical and real animals, but you
still can't say that horses were a major part of Harappan civilization unless you
have evidence of the horses. Show us the horses. And it's interesting because we
have multi-headed animals in the symbols. We have animals with unusual
body parts, like the tail of a snake, and the arms of a deer, and then
the head of an elephant, things like that. But if you look at the iconography in
Rigveda, you have the same thing. Not exactly in terms of the symbol, but you
have like chatwari shringa, but with four horns, three feet, two
heads, and seven hands. We can find weird animal depictions anywhere. The question
is whether the animals match. They do not. And the other one that's common is the
three-humped bull, and the trikakut, the
three-headed, the three-trunked bull, is a common symbol. In Rigveda, I looked all
over for an image of a three-humped bull in the Harappan images on the seals
that we have. I haven't been able to find one, but maybe I'm missing it. So if
anyone can find me an image of a three-humped bull from the Harappan
culture, I would greatly appreciate it. And then in the Vedas, even in Rigveda,
there are certain battles going on. And there are the battles between what are
called so-called Aryas and Dasyus, or Dasas. So the Western scholars said, okay,
this is the incoming Aryans versus the native Dravidian people. Aryans are
suspect because they're connected to Jyoti, or light, and the sun. So they must
be fair-skinned people. Dasyus are connected to darkness, and so they must
be dark-skinned people. And if you look throughout the Rigveda, there's a certain
struggle between the northern peoples, like the Purus, and the southern people,
like Yadus, which we also have historically mentioned. In other words,
these other Vedic people, Anus, Juyus, etc., could also be called Dasyus or Dasas.
It had nothing to do with race or ethnicity. It was a matter of
terminology. Soma is symbolic. Animals are symbolic. Dasas are symbolic. It's so
easy to dismiss evidence by calling it symbolic, isn't it? Historians fully
acknowledge that the Dasas, or Dasyu, are portrayed in a half-mythical fashion.
They're called devils and demons, after all. But that doesn't mean every
description of them is fictitious. Let's take a look at the references in the
Rigveda about the Dasas being dark, and you tell me whether you think it sounds
literal, like they have dark skin, or symbolic, that they are dark only in an
evil sense. Indra made the black skin subject. Driving away the black skin. Blow
away the black skin hateful to Indra. Note that the color of the skin of the
Dasas is specifically referred to here. Some have pointed out that the word
skin sometimes can refer to the surface of the earth, and they suggest that
perhaps that is how the word skin is being used in these instances. Maybe, but
since it is the less common definition of the word, I would say it is less
likely. And then the funniest one they did is they said that, okay, these Arya
people are fighting Dasus who are Shishnadevas. They worship the phallus, and
therefore they must be indigenous Dravidian Shaivites, and they are also
said to be, they have anasa, they are said to have low-nosed, so they are the low-
nosed people. There are two references of this type in a thousand hymns of Rig Veda.
So, then the interesting thing, I researched those out, and the Dasus who
are anasa are also apada and ahasta. They have no feet, and they have no hands, and
they have no nose. What kind of people are these? It's a description of a
serpent. This argument has some validity when we're talking about the low noses.
If the lack of feet and hands are not to be taken literally, then yes, perhaps the
low noses aren't either. But that doesn't give you an excuse to dismiss all
descriptions of the Dasus. Skin color and religion are not coordinate with body
parts. I don't see the logic in the argument that because they're said to
have no feet and hands, then we shouldn't believe the Rig Veda that they worship
the phallus. It doesn't really go. I mean, let's say your position is that the dark
skin is not literal, but only a symbol of the evil of the land of the Dasus. If
darkness is associated with evil, how would that imagery not carry over into
real life when literal dark-skinned people were encountered? We know that
darker-skinned people in India exist. How is it that literal dark skin in Indian
history came to represent inferiority long before Europeans ever came there?
How did that come about? There is only one reasonable explanation for the
variety of skin colors in India. That people of different ethnic backgrounds
intermingled. That's the only possibility. You can't say that darker-skinned and
lighter-skinned people just happened to develop side-by-side in the same
locality. That makes no genetic sense. And given the fact that movement of people
into India is documented through historical times and to the present day,
it's unreasonable to suppose that no migration into India could have occurred
earlier. Genetic research has shown that the variation in skin colors in India
were due not merely to what altitudes people lived at, but also where they came
from. It shows also that the light-skinned gene found in South Asians
is the same one found in Europeans. If we look at the artifacts of the Harappan
civilization, the most common geometrical symbol they use is the swastika.
They also have the peepal leaf. They have all the basic motifs of the Indian art.
And they also have a lot of fire altars. Fire altars are common. And if we
look at the symbolism of the writing, they have the chakra symbol is very
common. We have very common the Pashupati, which is the yogi sitting in meditation
pose with animals around him. And what do the leftist scholars say? Oh no, you can't
identify him with Shiva. Shiva came so much later in time, we cannot connect
these images. It could be some shamanic figure. Even though he has three heads and the
same group of animals that he has at later times. So even the symbols and the
artifacts, we have a Vedic connection. Since historians accept that the Harappan
culture may have influenced later Vedic culture, none of what Frawley is saying
here contradicts their view. If he wants to demonstrate that the Harappan and
Vedic cultures are identical, that is that they are from the same time period,
then merely showing similarity of symbols or practices is not enough. The
swastika, fire altars, chakra symbol, meditation poses existed in India for
millennia. He needs something to anchor the Vedas specifically in the Harappan
time period. There were some earlier also criticisms of the Vedic literature. They
say Vedic literature mentions Ayas or iron and therefore it must come from
later period. If we look at Rig Veda, Ayas is compared to Hiranya or gold and
luster. And in many of the other Indo-European languages, Ayas means
copper or at most bronze. He's right. The word Ayas probably means copper or
bronze. And that being the case, the appearance of that word in the Rig Veda
does not mean it has to come from the Iron Age. However, the earliest evidence
of bronze working in India is about 3,000 BCE, copper too. Yet Frawley dates
the Rig Veda, which mentions bronze, to well before 3,000 BCE, thousands of years
before. He says it doesn't fit the Iron Age, but then puts it in the Stone Age.
I don't get that. I should add that the Rig Veda makes mention of ruined cities,
but not presently existing ones, other than those of the gods. How then could
Rig Vedic society exist before cities were built? In fact, now we know that iron
technology, India was one of the main sources of that. Steel also came from
India. The earliest evidence of iron working and steelmaking has been found
in Anatolia, not India. And then the other interesting thing they found out is
that in the 15th century in Syria, there was a group of people called the Mitanni
who had Sanskritic names and the Sanskritic language. So part of the Aryan
invasion scenario is that this was the Vedic people on their way to India.
It has several problems. One, they had a literature, for example, of manuals of
training horses, which was almost in pure Sanskrit. Two, they were a nobility.
They were the Maryada. They were the noble kings and aristocracy of the
region. They weren't nomads at all. They weren't primitive people at all. They were
the highest level of the aristocracy. While Mitanni had a language that was
related to Sanskrit, it was not, as Frawley claims, almost pure Sanskrit.
There are typical features of Sanskrit that are completely absent from Mitanni
and, in fact, absent from all Indo-European languages west of India. If
Sanskrit had been the original language, how is it possible that all Western
languages that supposedly came from it lost these typical features? It's far
more likely that the typical features of Sanskrit are innovations to an earlier
language rather than original, and that is why they can only be found in India.
There were also related Indo-European people where they were connected with
like Hittites, Kassites, also were ruling Mesopotamia at that particular time, and
all of them appear as urban princely elite, not as any primitive people, and if
we trace them, what we see these people are always moving to the west. They are
not going to the east, and they continued there as well. The Hittites didn't speak
an Indo-Aryan language. I'm not sure where he's getting that from. It's true
that the princely elites of the Mitanni and of the Kassites seemed to have
spoken an Indo-Aryan language, but the common people, the masses, did not. Most of
the Mitanni spoke Hurrian, and most of the Mesopotamians, where the Kassites
ruled, spoke Akkadian, and when Mitanni fell and Kassite rule ended, their
languages disappeared with them. So these cannot be used as evidence that the
Indo-Aryan language spread westward and evolved into the rest of the
Indo-European languages. And even later, when the Persians and the Scythians came
in, they were also groups and connected to all these people. And not only that,
the Sanskrit they were using appears to be a later Sanskrit, not an earlier
Sanskrit. These are claims which have not been sufficiently demonstrated with
evidence. But it's clear that we have room for people moving outside of India as
well. And it's also interesting that the closer they are to India, the more Vedic
the culture is. The further away they are, Vedic tends to be removed. Well, of
course, that would be the case whether they migrated east or west. If you study
the Zend-e-Vesta, the homeland of the Persians is Balkh or Bactria, not the
west. Balkh is also mentioned in the Tharva Veda and other texts. The
Arata was the name they used to call that part of Syria and Turkey, even
today Urartu Arata. So we have even literary evidence of the westward
movement of those people involved. Please keep in mind that just because scholars
believe that Indo-Iranians migrated eastward into India, this doesn't mean
that people could only ever have moved in an easterly direction at any time for
any reason. And then we have also astronomical references in Vedic text.
In the earlier times, they talked about, you know, India you have this soli-lunar
calendar. But you have references to earlier dates of solstices and equinox.
At Tharva Veda, and when the last book has a very interesting hymn, they start
out the list of nakshatras with kritika, and then they use the term ayana, which
means solstice, and the ayana is Magha. When kritika is the
vernal equinox, ayana is the summer solstice is in Magha. That can be very
easily dated to a period of around 2500 to 2000 BCE. We have a lot of
references to kritika equinox and even to ones before them. A quick primer on
the Vedas and astronomy. Observations of heavenly phenomena in the Vedas are
scarce. We do get the impression that the composers were interested in what was
going on in the sky, mostly in the sense of marveling at nature. They rarely do it
in a direct manner, as for example providing data in a scientific sense.
We find references to the heavenly bodies in religious hymns to the Sun, the Moon, and
the stars. You don't find much interest in making mathematical calculations from
the heavenly observations. There's nothing systematic about it that we feel
justified in calling it mathematical astronomy. So the modern practice of using
the Vedas to make precise mathematical calculations about chronology is bound
to be fraught with problems. You heard Frawley use the word kritika. This is a
nakshatra mentioned in the Vedas. What's a nakshatra? In early Vedic poems, nakshatra
is just a generic word for a star. In later Vedic literature, a nakshatra is a
special grouping of stars in a list of 27 or 28 sacred groupings, which
represent the groupings of stars the moon passes in a given month. Kritika is
one of the few nakshatras we can identify. It corresponds to the group of
stars that we today call the Pleiades. What Frawley is referring to is how, due
to the precession or backward tilting of the Earth's polar axis, the fixed
background of stars in the sky keeps on changing, and the equinoxes and solstices
over time gradually shift with respect to the background of stars. When he
speaks of kritika equinoxes, he refers to the time when during the spring equinox
the Sun rose with the kritikas in the background on the eastern horizon.
Circa 2500-2000 BCE, he says. And the Sun did indeed arise in kritika at that time.
How does he connect this to the Vedas? His evidence is that the Vedas count
their nakshatras from kritika. In other words, he thinks the nakshatra system was
invented at a time when kritika came first. And the Shatapatha Brahmana, which
is part of the Vedas, speaks of the kritikas rising in the east, which would
indicate that when it was written, the nakshatra system had only recently begun,
which would be circa 2500-2000 BCE. For his dating to be correct,
Frawley assumes first that when the kritikas are said to have appeared in
the east, they did so exactly on the eastern horizon with no deviation from
the center and exactly at the celestial equator, zero degrees Taurus, as if the
inventors of the nakshatra system happened to create it at the perfect
moment in time. I think it's more reasonable to assume that this was a
general observation that the Sun rose near the Pleiades, without any special
measurement being taken. Noting the exact position of that star group wasn't
necessary in order for the calendar to work, because their calendar was not
based on the stars. He's very big on the equinox, but the kritikas in the Rig Veda
are associated more commonly with the Moon rather than the Sun. All evidence
indicates that the early Vedic calendar was lunar. A solar year and a sidereal
year, that's a star year, are 365 days long, but a lunar calendar is 360 days
long. 360 are the days of the year. So great is the year. The Lord of Creation
is the year. The sacrifice is the Lord of Creation. Soma, that's the moon. The king is
the year. Coming with the seasons, he approaches. The moon is king of the year.
The fact that their year was 360 days long suggests 12 months of 30 days each,
which means that their lunar year was approximate, not exact. A true lunar year
is only 354 days, 8 hours, 48 minutes, 34 seconds. This is not to say that the
Vedic people didn't observe the Sun or the stars and make certain general
calculations based on their movements. It's only to say that their calendar
year was based on the movement of the moon primarily and not on the movement
of the Sun or the stars. To make things even more tricky, many different sacred
calendars developed in India, and it's hard to track the histories of all of
them. We do know that many of them brought the lunar year into harmony with
the solar year by adding an extra month every few years. It's reasonable to
suppose that they did a system of intercalation. That's what they call it.
Fairly early on. There may even be evidence of it in the Rig Veda, but
exactly how it was done is not known. Frawley's approach is merely to
retroject the later, fully developed system onto the Vedas and assume that it
was consistent throughout time. I think that's too credulous. Well, what if the
Vedic calendar did originate when Krittika rose at the beginning of the
year in the East? And what if we assume that this was a rough observation and
not a precise one? When would that place it? Well, it could have been as late as
the mid-2nd millennium BCE. Even in the case of a time when the moon rose at the
beginning of a month in Krittika, would that necessarily mean that parts of the
Vedas were composed at the time such moon rises occurred? No, because it could
equally mean that the people who composed the Vedas merely have a memory
of those times. Moreover, since a Krittika moon rise could have been
observed outside of India, there is nothing in this argument that would
pinpoint the location to India. So the astronomical observation of the moon
rise has no bearing on the question of the Aryan migration. So what does the
Western translators say? Hindus aren't good astronomers even today. Why should
we trust that they were good astronomers even then? This information has
absolutely no value whatsoever. Yet if we read the text, they also speak of, but
how can you have a calendar that doesn't work? How could you be following a watch
that is no longer running? Their lunar calendar did work, and their observation
of the stars had little to do with the calendar. The Aryan myth is still going
on. The Europeans would still like to be the original Aryans. The Germans would
like it. The Russians would also like to have that title for themselves so they
are not giving up on nationalistic grounds. Huh? How can this possibly be
true when scholars say that both Europeans and Indians have common
ancestors? That puts them on equal footing. There has been a concerted
movement to denigrate the native culture of India. It happened throughout
the world. Native Americans were totally denigrated. We grew up with the image of
Native Americans as massacring poor white immigrants. The opposite occurred.
The white immigrants and armies massacred the poor Native
Americans. It's time for that colonial scenario to change. India is the only
country that's maintaining the colonial anti-native scenario of its own culture
even though it has the most magnificent of the native cultures and has been able
to preserve its native culture the best. So that is why this issue needs to be
addressed and to be changed. Can Frawley present evidence that the current theory,
the Aryan migration theory, presently promotes colonialism? If so, I would like
to see it. All he has shown in this talk is how an old theory was used to promote
colonialism back in the days of colonialism. And finally I was told by
some of the scholars, scholars, Western scholars, yes we know our Aryan scenario
was incorrect but we don't know what else to put there and until we do we're
going to leave it there. This is similar to climate change deniers pointing to a
couple of scientists who depart from the consensus as proof that the consensus is
wrong. Anyway, these two videos have been quite long and if you stayed all the way
to the end I applaud you and thank you very much. So much more could even be said
on this and maybe I will revisit the topic one day. But don't worry, we'll be
moving to another part of the world next time. If you'd like to see the next
episode of Myths of Ancient History, please hit the subscribe button and the
bell and you'll be notified when it comes out. We'll see you next time
everybody.