Titan Dragonfly is one of the most exciting missions in development. But it'll have its limits. For example, it won't go into caves on Titan. Which are super interesting. But this NIAC project will study a robot that should be able to go there.
00:00 Intro 01:31 What is karst 05:59 The NIAC project 23:28 Alternative use cases 27:48 Earth-based version 32:27 Current obsessions 39:49 Final thoughts
📰 GUIDE TO SPACE NEWSLETTER Read by 70,000 people every Friday. Written by Fraser. No ads. Subscribe for Free: https://universetoday.com/newsletter
⚖️ LICENSE Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)
You are free to use my work for any purpose you like, just mention me as the source and link back to this video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This video features a discussion with Dr. Daniel Drew regarding SPARC, a NASA NIAC-funded project. The project proposes using autonomous, spherical micro-airships powered by ion propulsion to explore the \"karst\" (cave systems) of Titan. The conversation covers the physics of electro-hydrodynamic propulsion, the unique environmental advantages of Titan, and the broader future of autonomous robotic persistence.
If you've been watching my channel, you know that I am obsessed with Titan. We've only had
some glimpses of Titan, one mission down to the surface, an orbiter that was in the vicinity and
was able to give us some better images of Titan. And of course, we've got a Titan dragonfly,
which is going to be this octocopter with a nuclear RTG that's going back to explore it.
But there are so many places on Titan. And one really intriguing possibility
is that there are cave systems on Titan. The technical term for this is a karst,
where you've got some kind of fluid is wearing away the landscape and you can have revealed
terrain or even a subsurface series of caves. Imagine that, caves on Titan. But how do you
explore them? So my guest today is Dr. Daniel Drew, and he is the recent recipient of a Phase
One NASA NIAC grant as part of the 2026 Phase One Awards. His proposal is called the Solid
State Propulsion for Autonomous Reconnaissance of Karst or SPARC. And if you look at it,
it is a about a meter across a sphere that has electric propulsion systems that allows it to
maneuver in the kind of terrain that will allow it to explore the inside of a cave.
It is an extremely cool idea. It's an ion propulsion system, but air breathing
and exploring Titan. It's like everything I love all mixed in to one idea. So enjoy this conversation
with Dr. Daniel Drew. Daniel, thank you so much for taking the time to chat with me. I mentioned
this to you beforehand that of like of all of the winners this season of the NIAC grants,
this was the one that I'm most excited about. And so I'm really glad that you agreed to talk
with me. Yeah, thanks. I mean, that's exciting to hear, and I'm excited about this project.
Yeah, it's got everything I like. It's got Titan. It's got flying robots. This is all perfect.
Before we talk about Titan, we're going to talk a lot about karst. So what is a karst?
Yeah, okay. I'll preface this, this entire interview by saying, you know, I'm not a
planetary scientist. I'm not even a space person to the degree that many of your viewers, I'm sure
are. So if I say something that's egregiously wrong, you know, you can jump. If I say something
that's a little bit wrong, just tell me some slides. Okay. Yeah. I mean, for me, it's cave.
That's as far as I get. Karst is broader, right? So this like labyrinth terrain, which covers a
huge percentage of Titan's surface, is geometric, well-formed, structured surface material that's
maybe erosion or mechanical erosion driven. So liquid erosion or mechanical erosion.
So karst does include caves and also just this broader kind of labyrinth terrain idea,
so like cliff sides. And why it's interesting on Titan is because you know that Titan is the
only other place with surface liquid. It's like this bizarro earth, right? With liquid methane
instead of water. So we can directly observe from Cassini imagery that there's a ton of this
labyrinth and karst terrain that's driven by erosion, presumably from the liquid cycling.
And on Earth, that creates caves on Titan. This is never, this literally never occurred to me
that there would be the liquid on Titan would be eroding, I guess the ice mountains
and creating cave structures, which then gives you layers that you can look at and
analyze geologically to look into the past of the history. That's exactly right. So these caves,
these theorized caves, and I'm going to be cautious here because Cassini imagery had
a resolution that was too coarse to directly image entrances to caves. We have some inventory
of potential subsurface access points, something like 20,000 potential subsurface access points.
And those might look like, you know, rounded structure with a conic shape, but we don't
actually see the entrance to a cave. Like on the moon, we can see the entrances to caves.
We don't see them on Titan. So that has to be confirmed before we say, oh yes, there are tons
of caves to explore. We can see stratification on the sides of these karst structures. Yeah,
so they're scientifically valuable regardless of whether they're caves. But yeah, you touched
on it exactly. So there are windows into the climate history of the planet. So it's really
interesting to be able to directly observe the stratification, and that's even easier in a cave.
And Titan's interesting because we're still kind of learning about its weather patterns, right? I
feel like new stories are coming out every month about things we're just now understanding about
the weather patterns on Titan. So we'd learn a lot about that hydrological cycle time
from direct observation in a cave. Yeah, yeah, wow. Yeah, this is literally
blowing my mind. When I think about how you, like, when I think about Titan, I think about
those pictures that came back from the Huygens mission, that you just had this terrain of little
pebbles that stretches off into the horizon. But I mean, we know that there are seas of liquid
methane on the surface, that it rains, that there are potentially streams, that you've got all of
the kinds of features that you'd see in a, I don't know, like a series of caverns or whatever,
wherever water or liquid is acting on the surface for a long time, you're going to get some kind of
erosion, you're going to get interesting stuff, shenanigans.
Yeah, shenanigans, that's right. There's interesting shenanigans on Titan,
I think that's what everyone's saying. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, oh man, that is so cool.
If you rewatch the Huygens descent, before it lands and you see that huge field of pebbles
that's so amazing that it looks like, you know, it could just be on earth, you'll also see there
are these distinct kind of rivulets and these fluvial processes have driven fluid erosion,
you can just see it, it like looks like you're looking down at something that's been eroded on
on earth as well. Yeah, okay, yeah, yeah. So then let's talk about your mission. So
you have won a phase one night grant, and just a reminder to everybody, that just means that you
are now funded to try to research your question. So, you know, a lot of the stuff is going to be
the question that I'm going to ask you is like, we'll know in nine months.
Yeah, we'll hopefully know in nine months. I think we'll have the concept of a plan in nine
months. We'll definitely confirm some of the basic science or test our hypotheses. Yeah,
so the basic idea is that current flagship vehicles are unable to directly enter and do
that interesting science inside caves. Dragonfly is not going to be able to enter a subsurface
access point and observe for us that stratification that we talked about.
They're too expensive, that's too high risk of emission profile, and they're too large. So
our general idea is we're going to design a new autonomous robotic platform for subsurface
exploration on Titan. And there are a couple interesting innovations in NIAC we talked about
like these core innovations, right? One, it's a micro airship. So airships have been explored
on Titan for a while, this idea of using airship. And I can get into this, but the atmosphere on
Titan is conducive to airships in general. So we're talking about a meter scale. Two,
it's going to use distributed atmospheric ion thrusters. So instead of rotors like Dragonfly,
we're talking about these solid state actuators, which produce a plasma, accelerate ions and
generate thrust that way. I'm sure we'll talk more about that. And yeah, the third is this
general idea of distributed propulsion for maneuverability and downwash protection inside
of geologically interesting sites. So if you've ever been inside a cave, I mean on Earth and on
Titan, we think they probably look similar just based on the processes. Stalagmites, stalactites,
these kind of narrow tortuous pathways. And that's all unknown right now, but that's obviously
extremely challenging for a scientific mission. Distributed propulsion is this idea of putting
our thrusters all over the surface of our vehicle. So instead of an airship, which you might
conceptualize as kind of clumsy and unwieldy, you know, a blimp has that under-actuated system
where it's just moving forward. It's got to turn over a long period of time. And that maneuverability
is even more challenging on Titan because of the atmosphere. We have omnidirectionality. So we have
holonomic control. We can move that robot any direction in space, rotate it in place using
distributed propulsion. And that also removes some of the downwash problems you might get from
a rotor where you're throwing up all that hydrocarbon particulate matter, which you want
to be able to view directly. So I'm envisioning the little spherical drones that they have on
the International Space Station or, you know, Star Wars, the drone where he's practicing his
lightsaber technique. Yes. So Astrobee is a good connection, right? The propulsion is different,
but this idea of distributed propulsion on a roughly kind of human scale, submeter scale
platform is directly applicable. Although, you know, of course that's on the space station,
so it's totally different propulsion technology. And then, yeah, it could be a Jedi training tool.
Maybe we'll get into that when we talk about terrestrial connections. But yeah,
that actually came up a lot when I was just at the NIAC orientation. And you know how many Star
Wars fans are over at NASA, so everyone is excited that it could help them with their lightsaber
dueling. Right. That's probably 50% of the why you got funding. Yeah. Okay, so we've got this
sphere that you're sending to Titan, and it is an airship with some kind of propulsion, an ion,
air ion propulsion system. So let's break this into two parts. Let's talk about the airship
side of this. So how big does it have to be to be buoyant in Titan's atmosphere with the kind of
hardware loadout that you're expecting? Luckily for me, this is, I could just say,
the easy answer, which we don't know yet. You know, part of the NIAC phase one is performing
this kind of subsystem analysis, this scientific traceability matrix, where we're trying to learn
what is the minimum payload on this extremely size, weight, and power constrained platform
that will enable us to do the science we want. So I have an expert in Titan Karst and caves,
Michael Malaska at Blue Marbles Space, who was previously at JPL, and he's really driving this
scientific question. What do we need on board? It turns out, I think we can do a lot of the
interesting science with not too much payload. Under UV fluorescence, a lot of these hydrocarbon
deposits will show up very clearly. So we'll be able to directly view them with maybe just
one hyperspectral imager or multispectral imager. Right. But I mean, the conditions on Titan are
really making airships look good. You've got an atmosphere that is more thicker than Earth,
gravity that is less. Gravity kind of falls out of this equation, but the surface density is four
times higher. So when you fill it up with hydrogen, you get about four times more lift per
unit volume than you would on a terrestrial airship. So we get four times the amount of lift
from an airship. And we know that 20 years ago, I think 15, 20 years ago, they were floating a lot
of Titan airship missions. There were a lot of ideas for Titan airships, right? We kind of have
the science of this design down. We understand the envelope materials that will survive cryogenic
temperatures. And I guess we should talk about cryogenic temperatures. We know that those
airships were targeted towards upper atmosphere or middling atmospheres. We're targeting subsurface
where to our favor, it should be practically still. Inside a Titan cave, we expect it to be
completely isothermal and no air movement essentially, which is one of the big downsides
of an airship, right? A lot of drag hitting that big bluff body. But inside a cave, we don't think
that should be a problem. Right. And so really it'll be however big you can make it so that
we don't know exactly how big or how small it needs to be because we don't have direct images
of these subsurface access points. We should make it as small as we can and still accomplish
the scientific mission based on the gravity. We think features should be larger, but we don't
know that. Yeah. But like in your mind, how big is a meter, a meter? I float a meter, a meter and
that, and that'll lift about two kilograms on Titan, which should be enough for a multispectral
and we have these thrusters, which we'll get to right, which are super high efficiency and
high thrust weight ratio, and that'll help us push it forward. Right. So I think my audience
is very familiar with a traditional ion engine where you've got, you know, you've got an electric
field, you have some propellant source like xenon, you are accelerating the ions out the back and
then you're getting a thrust in the opposite direction. So how does an atmospheric ion
engine work? Yeah, that's a good question. So they are very different. And there are a couple
of names for this. We can call it electro-hydrodynamic propulsion or electro-aerodynamic
propulsion, EHDEAD, atmospheric ion engine. They call the effect the ion wind sometimes. I'll just
lay it out like I usually lay it out for people who aren't familiar at all with ion thrusters.
Assume we have two electrodes separated by some distance in atmosphere. One of them is going to
be sharp. It's going to have geometric asymmetry, right? So there might be a plate and a wire.
We apply a high voltage between the two and the surface charge density on the sharp electrode
drives a strong electric field that's local to the electrode. So the electric field is much
higher intensity by that top electrode and it drops in the gap. If that electric field
magnitude is high enough, we can pull an electron with enough energy to initiate impact ionization
with the atmosphere. So an electron will get pulled in the electric field, hit a molecule,
ionize it, and that'll release another electron. And that'll get pulled and ionize another molecule.
And that's called Townsend avalanche breakdown. These electrons are multiplying, generating more
and more ions. And what you end up with is a stable plasma around the top. So turn out the
lights and the top electrode is glowing purple because there's a plasma around it. But outside
of that plasma region, there's not enough energy for the impact ionization. Okay, so we have this
stable atmospheric plasma. This would be called a corona discharge. Ions are being ejected from
the plasma based on the polarity of the system. And so let's say these are positive ions. They're
ejected from the plasma. They drift towards the bottom plate. Along the way, they're following
these electric field lines. Along the way, remember, this is all filled with neutral
molecules. So they're hitting those molecules, knocking them out of the way. And then the
electric field gives them more momentum and they keep moving. So you're dragging these ions
through a sea of neutral molecules. And at the end, you entrain the air by its collision through
ions. And the air, the neutral air, is what you feel below the thruster. It's not ions. So in a
space ion thruster, you're tossing ions out the back of the system, right? You're using mass
ejection to generate your thrust. Here, we don't need to carry a tank of gas. We ionize the air
that's already around us. And we use the ions momentum to generate an entrained airflow. So
you can really imagine it. It's a lot like a propeller. You know, it spins around and then you
put your hand down here, you feel air that's been accelerated from collision with the
rotor. We are colliding ions into air to accelerate it.
And like you mentioned propeller. And so I've got to assume that you sort of are imagining
the comparison of a propeller versus this system.
Yeah, of course. So Dragonfly uses rotors. Propellers are super efficient on Titan because
of that atmosphere. We've got the extremely low temperature is driving high atmospheric density.
You also have a relatively thick atmosphere. So it's like 1.44 bars. And so it's 40% more dense
atmosphere. And then the surface density. So the number of particles you have per meter cube is
much higher, four times higher at least. So that makes propellers something like 40% or 40X,
4,000 times more efficient, 4,000 times better. And our electro aerodynamic thrusters are roughly
100 to 200 times better. So that's driven by a couple of processes. So imagine we have these
ions that we're generating in that plasma. You pull the ion through the air. When there are more
neutral molecules to hit, you increase your efficiency just by that density. And the reason
why is because the mobility of the ions going down. So every time I'm pulling it, it's colliding with
more and more air per unit distance traveled. And it's very, based on first principle analysis,
you can show that the efficiency of these atmospheric ion thrusters or HD thrusters
scales very clearly with ion mobility. So we have very immobile ions, 20X less mobile ions on Titan.
And that's based on a combination of kind of first principle modeling and Cassini data.
We also have one seventh of the gravity. So if you combine those, you have 140X improvement
in hover power requirements. Right. So in other words, you get more thrust with less energy.
You get way more thrust with less energy expended. At least 20X more.
Okay. At least 20X more. Yeah. Wow.
You know, that's predicated on one, this ion mobility being accurate. And that's not directly
confirmed by spectroscopy on Titan. And two, it's predicated on this effect working as we expect
at the 94 Kelvin surface temperature on Titan. So we have to generate that plasma around the
top wire. Doing that at extremely low temperatures is challenging for a couple of reasons.
I talked about the initiation of the plasma being driven by these electrons that we have to get
enough energy to impact ionize the air. When they're colliding so many times, when the mobility
of them is so low, their mean free path is so low, it's hard to give them enough energy to
initiate that ionization process before they lose it all in another collision. So we're going
to have to increase the electric field magnitude up quite a bit. That's just based on the physics.
That means a higher voltage. And when you design with higher voltage, higher electric field
magnitudes, everything just becomes a little more challenging. And the way these fail is like
lightning between the electrodes or between your high voltage electronics. You're just failing
destructively. So our breakdown voltage on Titan is much higher. That makes it a little more
challenging to design these plasma actuators. Right. Okay, so let's talk about a power source
then. Dragonfly's got an RTG. It's got this decaying chunk of plutonium that's going to let
it last for the age of the Voyagers. What kind of electricity source are you probably going to have
to use? Yeah, that's still, that does depend on the outcome of the trade study. We're going with
the idea that an RTG is too large and maybe too limiting in terms of what it means for our system
design to have on board. Even these ultra compact RTGs are just not going to work for a submeter
scale dirigible that has to go through a torturous cave. Batteries are challenging because it's super
cold. Ingenuity gets away with something that we might not be able to do. So I don't know. There
are lots of potential avenues. Cryogenic compatible fiber optics cables that can deliver power and
communications from a lander craft may be the right solution. So imagine Dragonfly lands or
future Dragonfly lands in some labyrinth terrain and this balloon essentially flies out of it
and is connected by a tether and it enters the cave and that's delivering power.
I sort of imagine that like the fiber optic cable spider webs in Ukraine and Russia. Exactly, yeah.
So that's, yeah, we've been, we talked about that a lot actually at this NIAC orientation we just
had because a lot of the different people are talking about these kind of new conceptualization
of what we can do with optical fiber or fiber cabling for tethering just because we know now
that it's much more robust and works over much larger distances than we would have necessarily
thought. So there's a project working on using it for lunar cave exploration which is pretty cool.
And this like total rabbit hole, but like could you run power down the fiber, like run a laser
down the fiber optic cable and then harvest that as energy on the other side? Yeah, you can deliver
power, for sure. We can deliver enough power through the fiber optics. So we can do communication
and power through the same cable. I don't want to say that we've broken that up. So it's like
power over ethernet. I don't want to say that we've decided that's the right thing to do because
No, no, no, but it's feasibly possible. That's interesting. And then you could reel in your,
so the two would like your, your lander would sit just outside the cave. It would release the,
the blimp. It would go in and then it would make his way back out and reel it back up.
And then maybe it can move on to its next project. That's, that's, that's the dream,
right? We want persistence, which we get from a cable and maybe we have some benefit from
that'll help us keep the cable free of entanglement. And we want to recover the
vehicle on that. That can be challenging to guarantee if it's on battery power deep in a
cave. So maybe they're reeling it in as a cool idea. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I, it's funny. I actually
looked at this technology and it's kind of amazing that these little drones are carrying 10 kilometers
of, of fiber optic cable and the only way like a killer, like it's kind of amazing.
So you could almost like that you're consumable on this mission is just how much of this fiber
optic cable you're able to deploy and use up. And then the, the dirigible just sort of flies back
and then I guess grabs a new tether and away it goes. And maybe you have hundreds of kilograms
of, of tether and that's, it's, and that's what limits the amount of power you can get to this
thing. But, but, but it would be interesting, you know, if you did go the RTG route and go like,
well, what could we pack in there? Cause that also gets your heat, right? For your plasma.
Yeah. So an interesting part about these solid state actuators, these
ion thrusters is that they don't have any moving parts. So in theory, we don't need onboard heating
to help us stay alive in the same way that maybe a rotor craft does a 94 Kelvin. Your
rotor is going to stick. It's going to kind of almost cold weld to itself. And you need to use
that heat from the RTG to keep yourself able to move. Dragonfly is kind of recycling some of that
heat to, to keep its propellers able to rotate. We can save a lot of that power budget by not
needing any heat. This is a cold plasma, so we don't need to heat up any wires and the plasma
itself doesn't provide a lot. So let's put it all together then you know, we're 20 years down
the road, 10 years down the road, five years, five years down the road, um, nine months,
nine months down the road, you wrap it up and they're like, this is a no brainer. Let's get
working on this right away. Uh, mission gets built and, and now it's sitting on the Falcon
heavy, ready to go to Titan. Talk me through the mission.
Right? So it depends on what the, the, the larger craft is, but I think you, you,
you kind of stated it pretty well there. Imagine we have a future mission that might not be to a
polar Lake, but it might be to some of this extremely interesting labyrinth terrain.
And we might be interested in looking at, uh, hydrological cycling and geology of Titan directly.
What the main mission craft would do is check this subsurface access point inventory and try
to directly image a cave entrance. And once it sees an entrance that it might not be able to
enter, but it has a high confidence has a lateral component or conduit attached to it,
then it would land and deploy this spark airship. And, you know, which might be connected by a
tether can maneuver at low surfaces. There's not too much wind on Titan at all times. Sometimes
it's, it's quite still and navigate into the Cape explore image come back. And this is all
autonomous because we have that long round trip or maybe driven by some centralized controller
on the plat, the lander, which can do higher processing. Um, and that's incredibly valuable
data that we have no other way to get. There's, there's simply no way to get inside a cave on
Titan besides, uh, something that's maneuverable and small and can get us high payload with low
power because we just don't know what's inside. And we don't know the tortuosity, the narrowing
and, you know, NASA doesn't like risk, especially when you send something to Titan.
So we need something that's, that's cheap. It's a tech demo. It's a tech demo like ingenuity that
hopefully will surprise us like ingenuity and end up being extremely valuable and revolutionized the
way we explore other worlds. And so, I mean, Titan is the obvious place for this, but have you
thought about any other places in the solar system? I mean, I guess Venus is the only other place that
this might even possibly, yeah. Venus is the only other place that an airship based mission will
really work. Although then your problems are, you know, totally different and awesome. Uh, yeah,
Venus has got its own set of challenges for design. It, it doesn't have the same, you know,
extreme benefits to propulsion that Titan does. Um, but it, but it's interesting. It has, it has
this, this, this hot atmosphere that an airship would work. Um, it's still interesting to have
miniaturized solid state actuator. If there's any atmosphere, then it's possible to generate
an atmospheric ion propulsion and it might be useful as a small distributed, uh, maneuverability
assistant to something that's, I mean, we have a, we have a hundred different hopping robots
potentially for Enceladus and whatever in Europa. So maybe we, we help those by adding distributed
thrust on board. On Venus, now you've got tons of power. You have tons of solar power. It's also
extremely hot and ion mobility is going to go up with the heat, almost certainly. So I haven't done
the, I haven't run the direct numbers on, based on our back of the envelopes for what we think
their, their propulsion efficiency should be. But the cold is helping us in some ways because it's
improving the efficiency of that ion drag effect. And I'm not sure that we'd see the same benefit
on Venus. I mean, you would die. I mean, this wouldn't go down to the ground, but you could
dial in the app, the, the altitude, and maybe then you've got some kind of radar imaging and
you're doing a better scan of the surface of Venus than anything that's been done to date.
I mean, the Magellan spacecraft in 1990 gave us whatever, a hundred meter resolution, like it's
terrible. Right. And yet all of the geology is still just looking at what, about what happened
from Magellan 35 years ago. Right. And so there's Da Vinci plus and so on, but still, yeah.
Yeah. An adjustment propulsion system for a higher atmosphere airship could be interesting.
Yeah. That's very cool. So, and you mentioned this briefly that you're thinking about how
this might apply to, to earth. So what would a, an earth-based version of this airship?
Yeah. I mean, I've been working on these atmospheric ion thrusters on earth since
grad school for quite some time now. It's kind of quixotic. I've been tilting at this,
windmill of getting these stupid atmospheric ion thrusters to fly on earth for quite some time.
It turns out that they're just not very efficient compared to a propeller on earth. We're so good
at making flying machines now, right? That it's hard to sell a competitive technology unless it's
notably better. So Titan, great. It's going to be seven times as good. That's, that's amazing. Or
at least in theory. On earth, we have to sell it based on, you know, sell it. We have to motivate
this project based on other aspects. So the big one for me is that it's silent. You've been around
drones. I'm sure it's the worst, right? No one likes a drone flying close over their head.
No one is buying into this idea of ubiquity in the drone space. The first thing you'll hear
if we talk about package delivery is, oh, I don't want a thousand drones flying over my head.
NASA itself has done studies on the psycho-acoustic noise problem. It's just like,
how stressed do people get from drones low flying? And they found that it's comparable
to a jet flyover. When you hear a drone over your head, you cannot help yourself, but oh,
and that's not going to get any better. Now that we're using them in warfare ubiquitously,
no one wants a drone. So human proximal operation of robots is going to be greatly
benefited by having a propulsion mechanism that's silent and solid state. It's got no
propellers flying near your eyes and it's not making that high pitched line. It's completely
silent. It's just not very efficient. So an airship that provides buoyant lift to help that
efficiency might be good on earth too. Obviously it's, you're still, you're fighting earth's
gravity and density, and you're just not going to be able to carry as much.
So preliminary design sizing shows, you know, a similar half meter to a meter scale airship
with ion thrusters might work on earth carrying very little, carrying very little besides battery.
I mean, carrying a camera. I mean, like most drones, what do they carry? They're not carrying
anything. I've got a lab full of these micro drones that only fly for seven minutes and they
can carry a small camera and we can do all kinds of cool stuff with them. So yeah. And would you
need a battery? I mean, or will the solar power keep you... You won't get enough solar power to
operate persistently from that. You definitely need onboard energy storage. You're fighting this
miniaturization, right? You're presenting less and less surface area directly to the sun. You're
always going to need a high discharge rate battery on board for a rotorcraft or a atmospheric ion
thruster. Maybe we can recharge in low duty cycle, your flight, you know, recharge in the day, but
I'm kind of moving away from that as a design paradigm for these robots. I think we've just
found that it's not, it's not attractive for the way that we actually use robots.
Right. So you more think of like the ingenuity route where you've just got this tiny little,
very powerful battery that keeps the whole thing running and then you plug it back in or,
or let it sit. It sits on the ground and fills up its solar power and then takes off again and
does something. But, but how, like how fast, like obviously it's as seaworthy as a sphere,
which is not great, but how, but I guess you can make it in different shapes. It doesn't have to
be a sphere. Um, how, like how, what kind of thrust do you get on these? Like drones are fast.
And that's, yes, that's a, that's a great connection here. So why was dragonfly selected
instead of all the other competing Titan technologies? I mean, we trust rotor craft.
We know they're fast. They can go long distances. It's a proven control system. Uh, it's the same
on earth. It's always going to be the same on earth. We can do so much interesting stuff with
drones. If they're high altitude, they're flying quickly, you know, a fixed wing UAV or a rotor
craft is definitely, it's a no brainer. They're they're super efficient. There's we're just good
at making them. Um, but now imagine when that's in your room, if there was a drone flying in that
corner, it'd be worse than the clicking noise in my chair, right? We wouldn't be able to
have any conversation. Uh, we're envisioning robots that are used in warehouses and agriculture
in education, assistive technologies. They're not all going to be giant humanoids walking around.
It would also be beneficial to have small distributed sensing and, and communication
platforms. So imagine a drone that's in your house that is propelled by ion thrusters,
and it's able to more effectively, you know, instrument the world around us.
That's really cool. Well, Daniel, question I ask all of my guests, what are you obsessed
with right now? What am I obsessed with? Okay. So my, I have a pet project that's been going
on for a while and it's kind of related to some of the concepts we've been talking about,
about robotic persistence. I am discouraged by the continued, uh, short duration of our
flying vehicles and robots in general. You know, we're talking about battery lifetimes from
10 to 30 minutes, pretty much any way we cut it, we end up with all these
drones and dogs and humanoid robots that just need to recharge a lot.
We talk about solar power as a way to get around that. And we even talked about that in this and
solar power is used by ingenuity, right? But, uh, we know on earth, right? That the things that
use solar power directly don't fly around and they don't move. The things that use solar power
are trees. And then, uh, eventually it produces food with higher energy density that the big
moving thinking creatures use, right? So we have that pyramid of, of energy density, um, predators
eat very high density material because we're, we're just doing so much. We're burning so many
calories. So it's kind of against the grain to make these, these high powered robots that are
then waiting slowly for the sun to trickle charge them over the day. Um, how can we extract energy
from either organic materials or high density artificial materials? Imagine a robot that can
collect beach trash. Maybe it's a plastic water bottle that someone left them and using a compact
thermoelectric generator, turn that into energy to charge itself. Can we design a persistent
system that will, we put it down with its little base station and we leave and we never come back
and it is using scavenged energy to replenish itself. And then, you know, potentially this is
the, maybe this is where it gets a little weird. Uh, they've been talking about this idea of like,
uh, swarms on the blockchain selling services. Maybe these are truly autonomous agents that
are then selling sensor data or selling energy back to the grid and then using that money to buy
themselves new parts off of the internet. Can we design artificial life in a more way that is
inspired by the way life works here, which is energy extraction? Huh? Yeah. I mean, it's like,
if, if I was sort of imagined, like say you made a, uh, a fish and, and its job was to swim the
ocean and find microplastics in the ocean and then could, could burn the micro chemically and burn
the microplastics, that's its job. And the only way it stays alive is if it can find more of these
microplastics to consume. And then as you said, you sell the sensor data from what it's finding
in the ocean while at the same time, it's specifically using whatever the garbage it
can find as its power. So it's just, it more holistically uses the ecosystem that we're
putting the robot in, right. To make it do its job better and to allow us to have greater
confidence that it'll work autonomously for a long time. And that's the dream, this ubiquitous
robotics stream is robots distributed that are doing interesting services that we don't have
to constantly, you know, SSH into and fix or charge. Yeah. I mean, it's interesting. Um,
I mean, you sort of see this concept of a lot in video games where you, like when you think about
your own labor, when you're out doing something, you're out there physically, you're doing the
dishes, you're, you're gardening, you're, you're growing things, whatever, right. That it's the
wear and tear on your body. But if the machine is just running 24 seven, it just doesn't care.
Then as long as it is revenue neutral or like a little bit positive and can run continuously,
then this thing can go 24 seven and do it. And as long as it's at the end of the day, it is,
you know, producing more value than it costs, then it's a virtuous cycle. And then you just
keep spinning it up and you, and so a lot of the times it's human beings that are the,
are the sort of weak link on these, on these projects, because we have to be there to fix
and repair them, swap out parts or process the results by hand or whatever. And if you can
put more of that automation into the chain itself, into the, into the actual hands of the robots,
then you can kind of walk away and say, you know, organize all of those rocks or whatever it is you
need done. And as long as you know, and the only cost you're paying is electricity. And if it's
getting its power from the sun or it's getting its power from eating wood that it finds around or
whatever, then at the end of the day, there, there are probably, there's like, I don't know,
like value to be extracted. That's right. If the value is based on the robot's labor,
we want the robot to be able to work as hard as it can, as long as it can,
as efficiently as it can in the field. And if it's just waiting for the sun to recharge it
after a day of sitting around and it works for a couple minutes at night,
we're not going to get there. Yeah. Here in Canada, I'm not sure if it's the same in the U.S., but
we have a deposit on everything that can be used to hold a beverage, right? All alcohol, all pop,
juice, even milk containers, they're all returnable for a refund. And so you just,
you don't have that garbage anywhere because if, you know, either people actually can make enough
money just pulling those out of people's garbages, people return them at the recycling centers that,
that type of garbage has essentially been eliminated from just sitting out on the road
and so on. There's plenty of other garbage. And so again, same thing where it might not be worth
the time of a person to pick up trash at the side of the road because, but it might be worth
the time of the electricity cost to have a robot do it. And if you can then make the incentive,
well, if your robot brings in trash and it's nicely sorted and it's nicely washed or whatever,
then we'll pay you for that. Then you literally have just like, what is the price to remove all
paper waste from the environment? What is the price to remove all plastic waste from the
environment? You're seeing the vision. You're here. You're with me on this. Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
I get it. Long-term persistence is going to enable a lot of new applications for robots.
You can buy a camp stove now that you can put sticks inside and recharge your phone off of the
waste. Yes. Terribly. Yeah. Poorly. But we're, we're improving our thermoelectric materials.
We'll get there. But I do like that idea that, that like a government or even the corporations,
like say the corporations are the ones responsible for producing the plastic waste.
And then they have to then pay out of pocket to reclaim that waste from the environment.
And so then people can buy a robot and they'll go look, turn the robot loose. And it just
scours the undergrowth for plastic, turns it in the gut. The corporation has to pay for it.
And your, your robot makes you a tidy profit every month. Let's do it. All right. I'm in. Yeah.
All right. I'll, I'll join the program. You want to go, do you want to get a PhD at the
university of Hawaii? It's pretty nice. Do I ever? Yeah. Yeah. That sounds great.
Well, Daniel, so much fun to talk to you. Congrats on the NIAC grant. Good luck with the project.
And I look forward to all of these projects working out. Well, I can't wait for a dirigible
on Titan. That sounds amazing. Thanks. It was great to talk to you as well.
I hope you enjoyed this conversation with Dr. Daniel Drew. As always, we had a much longer
conversation where we rabbit hole down into other ideas. And so Daniel is working on technology that
would allow people to search for unexploded ordinance on the big Island of Hawaii, which
was used for target practice over the decades. And it's a very tricky problem. You've got to
have people walking along with very heavy equipment to try and scan under the surface
and that they are now exploring if they can use the kind of dog robots or drones
to do this more autonomously and limit the risk of people and be able to move around on the terrain.
So if you're interested in that additional topic, we've got that over on Patreon. Again,
as always, these extra interviews are completely free. You can just go over and watch it right
now. Put a link down in the show notes. I'm going to give you some final thoughts,
but first, I'd like to thank our patrons. Thanks to Abe Kingson, Andrea Pedretti, Brian Bode,
Caridin, Chuck Hawkins, Commander Baylock, Darkfinger, David Gilton, and David Maths,
Thraller Reading, Math for Toddlers, EvanDocPro, James Clark, Jeremy Mattern, Jim Burke,
Marcel Smith, Michael Purcell, NasaOceanGuy, NordSpace, OneStepAnimals.org. Please follow
my nephew at vbrick6994, Rankidu, Richard Williams, Sean Sargent, Stephen Fowler-Munley,
Team 49, Telescopes Canada, Vlad Sheplin, Wolfgang Klotz, Zelda, Fraser, blink twice if
Ottawa is making you deny the aliens, who support us at the Master of the Universe level, and all
our patrons. All your support means the universe to us. Yeah, I am excited about Titan. I talk a
lot about the Dragonfly mission and other ideas, sending submarines, airships, other kinds of
craft to Titan to try and explore it. And Titan is so great because it is this sort of perfect
onion. At the very center, you've got this rocky core. Then you've got potentially an ocean of
liquid water surrounded by a shell of ice and then surrounded by a layer of hydrocarbons. And
hydrocarbons are the building blocks of life on Earth. And there could be ways that you've got the
water inside mixing with the hydrocarbons on the surface. And this is all maybe giving the same
kind of chemical environment that might have been present on the early Earth and just more ways to
explore this planet. And then at the same time, I'm really excited about airships. And I really
like electric propulsion systems, ion engines. And I didn't know how these work very differently
from the kinds of ones that you use in space, that you're just pulling in the air and then you
are putting electricity, creating this plasma and using that as an acceleration for your craft. And
this could have really interesting implications across here on our planet and then on Titan.
And I think that's where this magic always happens, where we have interesting investments
in technology by NASA and other research to try and solve some technical problem off planet. And
yet it has applications back here on Earth. And every part of this sounds like it could have
value back here on Earth. Anyway, hope you enjoyed the conversation. We'll see you next time.