The House Appropriations Committee’s Subcommittee on Financial Services and General Government holds a hearing titled “Oversight Hearing—The Economy Act” at 10 a.m. ET on Sept. 15.
Witnesses: Shirley Jones, managing associate general counsel, U.S. Government Accountability OfficeDominick Fiorentino, analyst in government organization and management, Congressional Research Service
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This oversight hearing examines the origins and application of the Economy Act, which allows federal agencies to procure goods and services from one another to increase efficiency. While the Chairman emphasizes the Act's potential for cost savings and flexibility, the Ranking Member argues it is being misused as a loophole to bypass congressional appropriations and executive overreach.
Extend their remarks and insert extraneous material into the record.
I now recognize myself for an opening statement.
I'd like to welcome both of our witnesses here today and for taking the time to be here.
Today's oversight hearing is intended to help us better understand the origins of the
and the use of the Economy Act since its enactment.
The policy behind the Economy Act is simple.
It allows government agencies to order goods or services from other agencies.
An agency can utilize the Economy Act when funds are available,
if it is in the best interest of the government.
Another agency can fill the order,
and the head of the agency decides the goods cannot be provided
as conveniently or cheaply by a commercial enterprise.
The Economy Act provides powerful flexibility that allows government agencies
to take advantage of another agency's expertise,
potentially saving taxpayer money and leading to better policy outcomes.
These transactions occur all over government for a variety of purposes,
and there are substantial benefits.
It is important for Congress to understand how these agreements work
and whether the Act can and should be strengthened.
We are always encouraged by ways to save the government money
and to utilize the federal government's vast resources to be more efficient.
From an appropriation standpoint,
it is important to understand how Economy Act transactions are being used
and impact current agency operations and funding levels.
As policymakers, we need to understand the Economy Act's limitations and its strengths
so that Congress can ensure the Economy Act is effective.
We want to make sure that we support agencies
that are undertaking additional work under the Economy Act.
I look forward to learning more from our experts here today,
and I now recognize the Ranking Member, Mr. Hoyer, for his opening statement.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
I'm pleased that we're having hearings.
I'm pleased we're having the hearing on the Economy Act.
While nearing a century old, it is relevant today as it has ever been.
While its original attempt was to help the federal government economize
and become more efficient, it is now increasingly being used, in my view,
as a loophole to get around Congress's authority over appropriations.
It has become a tool of executive overreach,
exploited in ways Congress never intended.
A prime example has been the administration's effort
to purge the federal workforce through DOJ.
The Trump administration used the Economy Act to move funds
from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau to pay DOJ employees.
Another example is the Department of Education, which has used the Economy Act to
outsource critical department-specific functions to other departments and agencies.
The Economy Act does not authorize such transfers or functions.
Only transfer of funds under very limited, specific circumstances,
which have not been met in this case.
It's clear, Mr. Chairman, that the Economy Act is being misused and misapplied.
As an institution, Congress cannot and should not allow it to be exploited in such a way as
to circumvent our power of the purse and seize control over key aspects of the appropriations
process.
No administration should be able to use an efficiency statute as a substitute for coming
here and asking the people's representatives to determine how taxpayers' funds should be spent.
We cannot and must not allow the executive branch to make congressional restrictions
or directions disappear by routing implementation through agencies other
than the original recipient of funds.
This is especially serious given the current administration's rampant disregard for law
and constitutional norms and its track record of seeking any and every loophole possible
through which they can make an end run around Congress.
This is the unitary presidency that folks speak so often about.
I'm looking forward to hearing from our expert witnesses today.
I hope they can help us shed some light for ourselves and for the American people
on the mechanisms by which this administration is using the Economy Act
to engage in actions that undermine our system of checks and balances.
And I hope I'll be hearing your observations on that specific issue.
And I hope we will take away from today's hearing both a greater understanding
of the problem and a determination to fix it.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman.
I yield back the balance of my time.
Thank you very much, Mr. Hoyer.
Today we welcome the testimony of Dominic Fiorentino,
Analyst in Government Organization and Management, Congressional Research Service,
and Shirley Jones, Managing Associate General Counsel, U.S. Government Accountability Office.
Without objection, your written testimonies will be entered into the record.
With that in mind, we ask you to please summarize your opening
statement in five minutes or less.
Mr. Fiorentino, you are now recognized.
Good morning, Chairman Joyce, Ranking Member Hoyer, and members of the committee.
Thank you for the opportunity to testify on the Economy Act.