The Secret to Making Better Homemade Gummy Bears

Bigger Bolder Baking with Gemma Stafford
2 followers
1 Video View·Sep 14, 2026
Hi I'm Chef Gemma Stafford and welcome to my test kitchen. This is where my team of
experts and I have fun experimenting, geeking out and solving your baking questions. This
week we are talking about the gummy bears on my website. Ami help! Hi! Okay so this
is Ami and Ami is my culinary superhero and she's going to solve this problem for us.
We have all natural gummies on our website and for a few years now a lot of people have
different issues with them. One issue is they're not setting and another issue is when they
make sour gummies the sugar is dissolving and we're going to solve those problems right
here today. We were talking about this recipe earlier and I'm looking at a few different
things. One of the things I learned from you Gemma when I started working with you is with
gelatin you can't just put it right into liquid. You should always bloom it. This is something
that you had told me about. So I'm looking at this recipe and it says that you just stir
in the gelatin without blooming it first which activates the gelatin. So I'm wondering if
we can change up the technique. I've also looked at some other recipes for homemade
gummies and they use a little more gelatin so I think maybe upping the gelatin. Yeah.
Really getting a precise weight on that so that we have the correct ratio of exactly
one cup of juice, our lemon juice, honey or agave, a little more gelatin, a better technique
to mix in the gelatin. So why don't we start out doing a batch of orange juice gummies
and make those edits. So the first thing I'm going to do is bloom our gelatin. So I'm going
to take two tablespoons plus two teaspoons of gelatin powder. I'm going to bloom that
in two tablespoons of water. So while that is blooming I'm going to measure out all the
rest of my liquid. I've got my orange juice. I'm going to measure out a cup of that. So
you can use any fruit that you want to make your gummies but just keep in mind certain
fruits specifically like pineapple or papaya are really high in enzymes and that can make
it difficult for your gelatin to set. To the orange juice I'm going to add a tablespoon
of fresh squeezed lemon juice and then I'm going to add in two tablespoons of agave.
You can also use honey. So I know that my juice is hot enough when I start to see some
bubbles form around the edge of the pan and the liquid is steaming. You don't want a full
rolling boil. Once I've reached temperature you can turn the stove off and put in your
bloomed gelatin. Now we're going to stir this for a few minutes until it's dissolved. And
just to make sure that there are no lumps of gelatin and any bits of fruit, pulp from
the lemon juice, I'm going to pass it through a strainer. And now we're ready to set it
in our molds. So this looks like this is going to be a little messy which is why I've set
this on a tray to catch any drippings. It'll make cleanup a lot easier. The silicone mold
is really bendy so once you fill up all of your molds you'll find it absolutely impossible
to lift up. So definitely put it on the tray before you pour. Air bubbles removed and I'm
going to get this in the fridge. I can't wait to try them. So some of you have asked questions
about gelatin substitutes because you're vegetarian, you're vegan, you don't want to use gelatin.
Agar agar comes from a seaweed and is commonly used as a gelatin substitute. From the research
that I did, you would swap out one for one, gelatin to agar agar. So I've measured out
my liquid into this pot and I'm going to use the same amount as I had used gelatin. The
other thing that I read is that we don't have to bloom the agar agar. How we activate it
is to bring the liquid up to a boil and let it boil for five minutes. I'm going to modify
that slightly and instead of bringing it to a rolling boil because I don't want too much
of my liquid to evaporate, instead I'm going to keep it up to a simmer and let that go
for five minutes. So we can see that the liquid itself looks thicker almost instantly, almost
as if I had put cornstarch in it or something. This is much thicker than the gelatin mixture
that we made. So here we have our molds and same as the gelatin, once I get everything
filled up, I'm just going to run my spatula. Okay, I have high hopes for this one. I'm
going to get this in the fridge too.
So it's been a little bit of time and our jellies are set. Let's talk about the main
one first, the orange juice with gelatin, the regular recipe. Let's pop these guys out.
They did set. That set really well. There's no lumps of jelly. I think that's really good.
Bumping up the gelatin, Ami, worked. And then blooming the gelatin didn't hurt at all.
So now we've rectified, I think, this problem. Okay, Ami, talk us through the vegan vegetarian
option.
They are definitely set, but I would say they seem almost too set.
What we saw online was gelatin and agar agar are one for one and I don't know about you,
Ami, but that does not seem to be the case here. It's too firm. You can't eat this.
I can press into it, but I would cut it in half.
Yeah, do half the amount. And we'll put this information on the written recipe. This is
a great option. It's plant-based, isn't that right? It's seaweed? Agar agar?
Yes.
And just do half the amount and that will make a really good gummy. Now, the second
part of our test is we're going to show you this. The one big issue we had was the gummies
dissolving, coating the gummies and then the sugar dissolving and then therefore dissolving
the gummy itself.
So here's what we're going to do. We set up a few different types of sugar. Granulated
sugar, powdered sugar, corn flour and then sanding sugar. So Ami, I'm going to do granulated
sugar and you do powdered sugar.
Granulated sugar, people are saying it's dissolving and making the gummies mushy. Let's see what
happens. So straight away, these two are dissolving. The gummies are too wet and you can't coat
them with these sugars. Let's just see what happens when you coat one in corn flour.
And that's what this is made for. It's made for showing in bakeries and things like that
for staying on desserts. The cornstarch, just cornstarch alone, kept the gummy dry. But
you can't eat just cornstarch alone because it tastes gross. So here's what we're going
to do. Let's dip this in a little bit of powdered sugar and see if that coating of
cornstarch is enough to keep it dry. And let's see what happens. Ami, how's your sanding
sugar one doing?
Oh, no, that looks, oh, it's so wet it's sort of dissolving off, it's not even staying.
So there you go, it just took two minutes and the one that was coated in cornstarch
and then powdered sugar also dissolved. Ami, let's just, for the sake of it, let's try
the agar agar ones.
Okay, I think I'm going to just, I know it's too hard, but we're going to just try it in
regular sugar. Then I'm going to go to the powdered sugar. And then finally, I'll try
the sanding sugar. Just to see what happens with the different sugars.
And instantly...
No, this is, it's not going to work.
No, because it's so dry. But look at that. Instantly, they're starting to dissolve.
A lot of people have wanted to create a sort of a sour patch kit by coating the gummies
in sugar and citric acid. But the problem is both sugar and citric acid are extremely
water soluble. And so what they end up doing is drawing all the moisture out of the gummies.
If you want a sour gummy, then I say add the citric acid into your gummy and then eat it
that way. If you want gummies that don't dissolve in your fridge and have 36 ingredients, then
go to the shop and buy some. Apart from that, I think we have rectified the problem with
the gummies. They've set firmer. We have a vegetarian option now that works. We're going
to adjust the recipe on BiggerBolderBaking.com. And you guys should be good to go with your
gummies from now on.
So I'm glad that we finally sorted this out for you guys, for the website. We are good
to go. Let us know in the comments what else you'd like to see us test and solve in our
test kitchen. And we'll see you back here again really soon.
See ya. Thank you.
Bye.
