Practical Magic 2 - Movie Review

Movie review
9 followers
30 years later, we have a sequel to Practical Magic. But is the magic still alive?....you already saw the thumbnail, so let's talk about it.
#PracticalMagic2 #movie #moviereview
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker provides a highly critical review of *Practical Magic 2* (2026), the sequel to the 1998 cult classic. While acknowledging the chemistry between Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman, the reviewer finds the film to be a disjointed, uncharismatic mess that fails to capture the charm of the original rom-com, citing poor pacing, weak comedy, and a confusing timeline.
This one's either for the 10% female demographic who watch my videos or letting the other 90%
of men who watch my videos know this might be what your girlfriend drags you to this weekend.
Don't know. I guess we'll find out.
So Practical Magic 2 is directed by Susannah Beer.
I believe it's Susannah, not Suzanne.
Right?
This is the 2026 sequel to the 1998 cult classic Practical Magic.
I'm gonna be honest with you.
I had never seen Practical Magic until a couple days ago.
Seemed pretty important to watch it before I watched the sequel.
Like, right, but why would I watch-
Why in 1998 would I have watched Practical Magic?
Hey, teenage Jeremy, what do you want to watch?
Practical Magic or Con Air for this -----tillionth time?
The answer is clear and simple.
Yeah, I watched Practical Magic for the first time a couple days ago.
And you know, for Practical Magic, I kind of get it.
It's a charming rom-com revolving around a couple of sisters played by Sandra Bullock
and Nicole Kidman.
There's a family curse in which any time they love a guy, that guy will die.
Or something to that effect.
I believe that's the wording.
Sandra Bullock's character has accepted that she's gonna be alone.
Nicole Kidman's character has also accepted that she's gonna be alone,
but she's still helping the working force of guys out there lay all that pipe.
So now, all these years later, an undisclosed, unknown amount of years later.
I'll get to that in a second.
The daughters are grown up, played by Joey King and Maisie Williams.
Joey King falls in love with a dude, dude from Cobra Kai.
And Blue Beetle.
But, always know Ms. Miguel from Cobra Kai.
The speedrun backstory in between the two movies is that Sandra Bullock has
obliviated all knowledge and memory of magic from her daughter's minds.
Because, you know, what you don't know can still hurt you.
Because putting your head in the sand is a solid way to avoid problems.
So now, Joey King's character wants to break the family curse.
And so now, it's just kind of a scavenger hunt of,
she's out there trying to break the curse.
Her boyfriend's in a coma.
Her mom and her aunt are trying to find her.
It's a lot.
A movie can be a lot and not feel like it's a lot.
This movie feels like it's a lot.
It feels like there were multiple scripts to Practical Magic 2 out there.
They spent decades trying to figure out and decide,
all right, which script do we actually want to use?
They said, ah, screw it.
We'll cram them all together into one movie and we'll do that.
Not saying that's what happened.
Saying that's exactly what it feels like.
To be fair, Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman, they have good chemistry together.
But whereas the first movie was a magical 90s rom-com,
this movie loses those elements.
I mean, it's still rom, but it's not really common.
The comedy's in it.
It's just not funny.
Even the magic when you're seeing magic is just a lot of CGI mist.
It's not funny.
It's not charming.
It has all the magic.
None of the charm.
There's your bumper sticker quote.
A lot of conveniences in terms of people running across other people
that kick off the plot in other ways.
It's just, okay, I guess, happenstance.
Glad they ran across them.
Actually, I'm not.
If you didn't run across that dude, we'd just be dealing with one movie right now.
A big problem I run into, we'll call this nitpick territory.
Absolutely.
I just don't know how the timeline actually lines up as a timeline should.
I'm a fan of timelines, continuity and such, and this one just makes me scratch my head.
Practical Magic came out in 1998.
This is out in 2026.
That's nearly 30 years later, but the daughters in the first film were around 10 or 11.
Joey King and Maisie Williams are both in their late 20s,
but it looks like Joey King's character is in college in this film.
Put her in her early 20s, so is this just around 10 years later?
Now, I'm no phone or tech expert, but looking into it, I guess that phone she has in the trailer
is an iPhone 7, 2016-ish.
Maybe she had a two-year plan.
Might be 2018.
But I swore I saw someone in the movie using a phone far more modern than that.
Big, flat, had all the cameras in the back.
But okay, based on the phone in the trailer, let's say the movie takes place in 2016 or 17.
That would mean the sequel takes place 20 years after the first movie, not 30 like it is for us.
Which would make these daughters 30, though?
But are they supposed to be?
Or does Practical Magic 1 take place in the 2000s and no one knew it?
Or maybe Practical Magic 1 takes place in 1998, this takes place in 2026,
and Joey King and Maisie Williams play 40-year-olds-ish.
Point is, this becomes more important when you're trying to determine how
smart and or mature the characters in the film are supposed to be.
Because to me, it looks like Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman's characters just
haven't matured at all from the years, possibly decades.
Because is Nicole Kidman's character supposed to be around 40 or around
Blanche from the Golden Girls?
We all love Blanche from the Golden Girls.
I just need to know how to deal with the character mentally.
Point is, it always frustrates me when these legacy sequels come in decades later
and it feels like no one really had any growth.
Practical Magic 2 feels like this sequel that just missed the boat by about 20 years.
I get it, legacy sequels, hot commodity right now.
But the first Practical Magic, like if a girl dragged her boyfriend to Practical Magic 1
in the 90s, he'd probably be like,
All right, yeah, she picked the movie this week and it was cute.
You drag your dude to Practical Magic 2, it's gonna result in a breakup.
Don't do that.
If for nothing else, the fact that Practical Magic 2 is 25 minutes or so longer than the
first film and feels twice that, it's just because there's a lot going on,
not a lot of threads connecting it.
You feel like you get dragged into a Euro trip scavenger hunt at a point that had nothing
to do with the first act of the movie at all.
Yeah, it's a disjointed mess and you're not gonna remember it in T-1 Mimosa.
Yep, already forgot.
All right, so Practical Magic 2, have you seen it?
What did you think about it?
What'd you think of the first movie or the first movie compared to the second movie?
Or what'd you think of Con Air?
Whatever it is, whatever you think, comment below, let me know.
And as always, if you like what you've seen here and you want to see more,
click right here to see more.
