Symbols are cool, but they're even cooler if they can be interpreted within the narrative and can stand on their own without being 'metaphorical'. Here's how the legendary South Korean director Park Chan-wook (Oldboy, Thirst, Sympathy for Lady Vengeance, etc.) uses symbols in his 2016 drama / thriller, The Handmaiden...by not really using them.
Timestamp 0:00 Introduction 1:13 Symbolism 2:09 i. Costume Design 2:45 Gloves 4:28 Tailcoat Suit 5:02 ii. Set Design 6:57 iii. Recurrence 7:54 Repeating Images 8:56 The First Jump 9:46 The Invisible Layer
I will never forget the first time I watched The Handmaiden
and how it completely blew me away.
It's been described as being romantic, dramatic,
thrilling, and at times very disturbing,
but for me, the film was secretive more than anything else.
And this is important
because The Handmaiden reveals its themes of love,
history, patriarchy,
etc. primarily through the characters' hidden intentions.
If you haven't watched the film, well,
you really shouldn't be here, 3, 2, 1.
The film runs for a full hour before revealing its first twist
and restating the story from a completely different angle.
Park Chan-wook masterfully implements flashbacks,
voiceover narrations, and the likes to gradually
disclose the characters' motives and desires,
but these are not central to the film's
cryptic and memorable atmosphere.
In fact, even after the final revelation
that puts everything in its place for a climactic
finale, the experience continues and lingers in our minds,
forcing us to question our success
in solving the film.
So, we go back to the start
and examine all the symbolic elements of the handmaiden.
The snake, the gloves, the gaze, the wall.
But decoding the rather easily discernible symbols
is secondary to examining Park's
truly impressive mise-en-scene.
What we need to focus on is the layer beneath the symbols,
an extra layer of mystery that
besides serving as a metaphor, always has a purpose of its own.
You see, the film's greatness comes not from the way
the intentions are unveiled within the plot,
but from the way they're kept hidden within the frame.
The frame that moves and shifts with the
carefully paced
and boldly told narrative.
This is the moment the film
reveals its first twist.
Hirako has been working with Fujibara behind Suki's back.
But not long after,
we'll discover that Suki
and Hirako have made yet another deal to betray Fujibara.
The two women are already aware of their arrangement
and have no need for reassurance.
But we, the audience, are completely blind to their plans.
So how do you communicate their exclusive knowledge
to the audience without being too overt?
The answer is in Hideko's gloves.
These gloves, a vital tool for handling Kawazuki's books with care,
are also very symbolic,
representing the ideas of restraint, suppression,
and hiding of the desires and wishes.
But the symbolic aspect of Hideko's gloves
are never once forced upon the viewers. It just
exists, beautifully blended into the story
with the rest of Park's elegant costume design.
Hidako, Fujibara, and Suki head towards the hospital together in a car.
It's barely detectable,
but Hidako actually has her gloves on at this point.
It's only when they arrive at their destination
that Hidako is suddenly barehanded.
Having to hide their plans and their love for each other,
she only unconsciously reveals herself,
her true self, to Suki by removing her restraints.
And therefore, after the send-off, she puts her gloves back on.
This is good storytelling.
It's subtle, unforced, and meaningful.
Once you fathom Park's brilliant use of the gloves,
you can foresee many things before they're actually revealed.
Here the implication is that although Hidako
is physically freed from the mansion,
she is yet to be freed mentally and that the tale must go on.
The true freedom comes only when Suki
and Hidako throw the gloves out in the ocean
along with her ring and the fake mustache,
ridding herself from the controlling men of her life
and enabling herself to move forward.
The costumes, as exquisite as they are,
always tell a story about the characters wearing them.
The men who listen to the stories read
by Hideko are all dressed in tailcoat suits,
almost as if they're in a straight jacket.
Their fantasies are being pushed down,
causing them to mutate and their desires imploding.
The scene itself is repulsive and
is designed to feel patriarchal,
but the meticulously crafted costumes further augment
the overall effect without appearing artificial.
And behind this perverted practice stands Kozuki.
Anyone who's seen the film knows that the snake
that's in front of the door is meant to be seen
as a phallic symbol, which later gets destroyed by Suki.
And this snake openly gets connected to
Kozuki's character as a controlling antagonist of the film.
But as Park did with the costume design,
what uncovers this character isn't the snake per se,
but the stylized set design that surrounds
him. It's Kozuki's intentionally grandiose library
that best describes his traits.
This theatrical space featuring a stair set,
a dokonoma where Hideko reads her books,
and in the middle, dadamimets that are neatly placed on the floor,
which, if you remove them,
reveal water. Kozuki's library is natural
and typical to the setting of the film, but at the
same time exposes his concealed personality
and unwittingly spells out his perverted attributes.
Kozuki is an inherently ritualistic
and obsessive character with excessive repressed desires.
Every time the reading happens,
he reveals the mats and redesigns the stage,
visually telling that he is about
to unleash his wishes through this space.
By carefully observing his private territory,
we can presuppose that he is a relentless oppressor
with twisted ideals and unfathomable sexual appetites.
This is why the scene with Kozuki drowning
the books feel cathartic to us.
Kozuki's object of obsession colliding
with his now public fantasies effectively
uncovers the character's iniquities
and marks the end to his destructive behaviors.
When I ask people to name a pivotal scene
of The Handmaiden, they always mention
Suki and Hideko's escape where they jump over the wall
and leave the mansion.
This scene comes right after the two women destroy Kozuki's books,
following their confession of selfish plans
and decision for cooperation, now as lovers.
The wall they must pass stands very short.
Yet, Suki makes sure to give a hand by placing
her bags on the ground for Hideko to step on.
This clearly suggests that the pressure
and the abuse Hideko had to endure were
more psychological than physical,
disabling her from even attempting an escape.
But again, this is just the outermost layer that protects
the nucleus of what makes this scene truly powerful.
Throughout the film, we're given plenty
of hints that Park Chan-wook uses
repetition to quietly convey a certain message.
The best example of this would be the moon
that's drawn on Hideko's door,
referred to by the characters, and shown by the camera.
But there are other less
prominent examples like the shoes, the bees,
and of course, the cherry blossom tree.
Ever since her aunt's death,
the tree has become a tragic form of freedom for Hideko,
that the best and the only option of escape is suicide.
And Park brings us to this tree in every chapter
of the film to remind us of this concept,
burning the violent image of death by hanging in our heads.
But despite constantly teasing the idea,
he never explicitly shows us the suicide in action.
Having the character jumping off
and disappearing from the frame, until now.
After the stacking of the bags, the camera moves in,
almost chasing Hidako like a hurricane,
generating a sense of urgency and decisiveness.
Right as the camera is about to crash into Hidako's face,
she jumps off the wall and the frame.
The entire sequence is shot as if Hideko
is falling straight down an endless abyss,
purposefully dramatic and climactic in its presentation.
In a way, what is being depicted here is not of her burdens,
but of her determination to face her fears and stand up.
Hideko, instead of killing her physical self,
decides to kill her past self, to be reborn as a new person.
The handmaidens' artistry comes from its ability
to play with our minds without risking its flow.
Everything is in its right place for us to notice, consciously or not,
and the appreciation for the details grows as we comprehend both
their metaphorical and narrative significance.
Like how Count Fujiwara recalls the moment
in time he fell in love with Hideko,
learning that Hideko's first portrayal of genuine desire
was meant for Suki,
we too learn that this love was truly a love at first sight
by recalling what Fujiwara passingly stated.
I'm going to read a woman's eyes.
Thanks
for
watching.