For more than 30 years, Chambolle-Musigny Premier Cru Les Charmes was one of my favourite vineyards in Burgundy.
Today, I have almost stopped buying it.
Not because the producer changed or the wine became worse, but because Burgundy’s climate has changed—and I believe that is quietly reshaping which vineyards collectors should consider for the decades ahead.
In this video, I explore how warmer growing seasons are affecting Chambolle-Musigny and compare two higher-slope Premier Cru vineyards that I now find increasingly compelling: Chambolle-Musigny 1er Cru Les Cras — Domaine Ghislaine Barthod Chambolle-Musigny 1er Cru Les Fuées — Domaine Gilbert & Christine Felettig
Les Cras sits near the entrance of the Combe Ambin, where cooling air and thin limestone soils help preserve freshness, minerality and tension.
Les Fuées lies beside Grand Cru Bonnes-Mares, with deeper clay soils that retain more water and produce wines of greater richness, concentration and texture.
In this video, I discuss: Why I have largely stopped buying Les Charmes How climate change is affecting Burgundy wine Why higher-altitude vineyards may become increasingly attractive Chambolle-Musigny Les Cras vs Les Fuées Ghislaine Barthod vs Gilbert & Christine Felettig Why both may represent compelling value in modern Burgundy
For me, Les Cras represents the more mineral and energetic side of Chambolle-Musigny. Les Fuées is broader, richer and closer in spirit to Bonnes-Mares.
Both illustrate how vineyards once considered firm or slow to mature may become increasingly complete as Burgundy grows warmer.
Chapters 00:00 Why I Stopped Buying Les Charmes 02:19 How Climate Is Changing Burgundy 03:07 Chambolle-Musigny 1er Cru Les Cras 04:09 Domaine Ghislaine Barthod 04:45 Les Cras Tasting and Prices 05:36 Chambolle-Musigny 1er Cru Les Fuées 06:32 Domaine Gilbert & Christine Felettig 06:56 Les Fuées Tasting and Prices 07:46 The Future of Burgundy Collecting 08:32 How To Choose
Wines Featured Chambolle-Musigny 1er Cru Les Cras — Domaine Ghislaine Barthod Chambolle-Musigny 1er Cru Les Fuées — Domaine Gilbert & Christine Felettig
The speaker discusses how climate change is shifting the value and appeal of Burgundy vineyards. While once-favored lower vineyards like Les Charmes are becoming too rich, higher-altitude vineyards such as Les Carres and Les Fouets are now achieving a perfect balance of ripeness and freshness, offering exceptional quality and value for modern collectors.
For more than 30 years, one of my favorite vineyards in Burgundy was Chambon-Musigny,
Premier Cru, Les Charmes. I bought it across multiple vintages. We commanded it to friends.
And if you had asked me 20 years ago which Chambon-Premier Cru I wanted most,
Les Charmes would have been near the top of my list. But today, I have almost stopped buying it.
Not because the producers changed. Not because the wine became worse. Because the climate changed.
And I think that has quietly changed the future of Burgundy collecting.
Over the past two decades, Burgundy has become noticeably warmer. Harvests are happening earlier.
Sugar levels have risen. Alcohol levels have increased. Many vineyards that once struggled
to ripen now produce wonderfully expressive wines. Others have become richer and more powerful than
they used to be. As a collector, that forced me to ask myself a difficult question. What if the
vineyards I loved in cooler vintages aren't necessarily the vineyards I would want to buy
over the next 20 years? That question led me higher up the slope, eventually to two vineyards
that I believe deserve far more attention than they currently receive. Les Carres and Les Fouets.
The remarkable part? Recent releases from outstanding producers in both vineyards still
sell for around 160 to 235 US dollars. For Burgundy of this pedigree, that's exceptional value.
If I were rebuilding my cellar today, I would buy these before I would buy another bottle of Les Charmes.
Today, I will explain why. We will look at how climate has changed these vineyards, compare two
bottles from my cellar, and I will tell you which one I would recommend depending on your budget and
the style of Burgundy you enjoy. And before we begin, if you are still discovering your own palate,
buy three or six bottles rather than a full case. A cellar should evolve alongside your taste.
Why climate is changing Burgundy? For generations, Burgundy lovers searched for vineyards that
achieved the perfect balance between ripeness and freshness. Not too cool, not too warm, just enough
sunshine to ripen Pinot Noir without sacrificing elegance. As temperatures have risen, that balance
has started to move. Some lower vineyards now produce wines that are richer than ever before.
Meanwhile, higher vineyards that were once considered firm, austere, and slow to mature
have become beautifully complete. For me, that's one of the most fascinating changes happening in
Burgundy today. And nowhere do I see it more clearly than in Les Carres and Les Fruits.
Chambon-Musigny, Premier Cru, Les Carres. Les Carres sits between 280 and 300 meters above sea level
at the entrance of the Combe-Ambal. Every evening, cold air flows down through the valley.
Think of it as nature's air conditioning. Even during scorching summers like 2019 and 2022,
the vineyard rarely loses its freshness. Its thin limestone soil and wine marl have always produced
wines with pronounced minerality and tension. For decades, that could make Les Carres seem severe,
almost uncompromising. Today, those same characteristics have become its greatest
strength. Warmer summers now give the vineyard a generosity of fruit it rarely achieved in the
cooler vintages of the 1980s and 1990s. What was once austere has become beautifully balanced.
That's exactly why I have become increasingly excited by this vineyard. Domaine Ghislaine
Bartheaux. Few producers in the stand Chambon-Musigny better than Ghislaine Bartheaux.
Founded by Marcel Noëlla in the 1920s, the Domaine has remained one of the village's
benchmark estates for generations, thanks notably to the leadership of Ghislaine Bartheaux,
Marcel's granddaughter, who took charge in the 1980s. Today, under Clément Bartheaux, Ghislaine's
son, it continues producing some of Chambon's purest expressions of terroir. Bartheaux owns
0.86 hectares of liqueur. The nose opens with earthy red fruits, violets, sweet spice,
raw cocoa, and striking limestone minerality. The palate is wonderfully layered. Morello cherry,
fresh raspberry, plum, clove, hints of bergamot. Everything carried by remarkable freshness and a
beautifully textured finish. To me, this wine perfectly illustrates what climate has done
for liqueur. The fruit has become fuller, the texture more generous. Yet, the vineyard's
trademark freshness and mineral precision remain completely intact. The 2024 currently
sells for around 200 US dollars. The 2023, around 235 dollars. The 2022, approximately 300 dollars.
Just a short distance away lies Les Fruits. At first glance, the two vineyards seem remarkably
similar. They are roughly at the same altitude. They share the same southeast exposure. Yet,
they produce completely different wines. Les Fruits is continuous with Grand Cru Bonne-Marre and shares
much of its geology. The deeper clay soils retain considerably more water than the stony soils of
liqueur. As summers become hotter, that water reserve has become increasingly important.
Instead of emphasizing freshness, Les Fruits develops remarkable richness and texture
while still preserving balance. To my palate, it becomes closer to Grand Cru quality than almost
any other premier cru in Chambord. Only Les Amoureuses consistently sits above it.
Domaine Ginbert and Christine Feltig. The Feltig family has quietly become one of Burgundy's most
exciting producers over the last 15 years. Today, the estate covers 13 hectares across the Côte-des-Nuits,
including several outstanding Chambord Pony Cru's. Their parcel in Les Fruits measures just 0.33
hectares. The wine combines red and black cherries, violets, cocoa, herbs, and delicate chalky
minerality. The palate is richer than liqueur. Dark berries mingle with subtle notes of dates
and fig. Despite the greater concentration, everything remains remarkably precise.
This is a wine that consistently reminds me how close great premier cru can come to Grand Cru
quality. The 2024 sells for around 160 US dollars. Both the 2023 and 2022 remain around 170 dollars.
Remarkably, the outstanding 2020 can still be found for roughly 120 US dollars. For me, that's one of
Burgundy's best bargains today. The takeaway. This video isn't really about Bateau or Feltig.
It isn't even about liqueur or Les Fruits. It's about recognizing that Burgundy is changing.
If you have watched this channel for a while, you will know I don't simply buy famous vineyards.
I buy where I believe the future is. And I believe climate change is quietly reshaping Burgundy.
Some vineyards have become richer than ever. Others have finally achieved the balance they
struggled to reach in cooler decades. That's why I no longer buy Les Charmes the way I once did.
Instead, I'm increasingly drawn towards higher vineyards like Les Carres and Les Fruits. If I had to
describe them in one sentence, Les Carres is where Burgundy preserves its elegance. Elegant, mineral,
energetic. The vineyard whose greatest strength today is its ability to preserve balance. Les
Fruits is where Burgundy embraces its richness. Broader, richer, closer in spirit to Bodmer.
The premier cru that frequently delivers near Grand Cru satisfaction. At today's prices, I think
both represent outstanding value. And if I were rebuilding my cellar, I would happily buy more of
both. If Burgundy continues getting warmer over the next 20 years, which vineyards do you think
will benefit most? I would love to hear your thoughts in the comment section below. I believe
the next generation of red Burgundy buying opportunities won't necessarily come from the
vineyards everyone has always chased. They will come from the vineyards we are only just beginning
to understand. You will also find more of my cellar insights and tasting notes on Instagram.
Massive thanks for watching today and I will see you in the next one.