A German government survey found that nearly nine out of ten salons charged a woman more than a man for the exact same short haircut. Same length, same chair, different price. The usual explanation is that women's hair takes longer — so what happens when a woman with a two-inch buzz cut calls and asks? We follow one customer's phone call, then trace the price back through a 1994 California survey, a vetoed bill, and the one clause every ban on gender pricing has to contain. The answer isn't about hair at all. It's about what a price list is actually measuring.
Sources: German Federal Anti-Discrimination Agency (2017), California Senate Judiciary Committee records, BC Human Rights Code, CBC News, Journal of Consumer Policy.
---
Financial Minds explains why things cost what they cost — the business model behind it, the design decision behind that, and the person who figured it out first.
No advice. No lectures. One question per video.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The video explores the persistence of gender-based pricing in hair salons despite legal bans in places like Germany, California, and New York. It argues that salons bypass these laws by attributing higher costs to \"time and difficulty,\" effectively pricing the customer's identity rather than the actual work performed.
That's the share of hair salons in a German government survey that charged a
woman more than a man for the same standard short haircut. Not a longer cut,
not a fancier one. The same cut, the same length, the same chair. Nine out of ten
salons had one price for him and a higher price for her. The only thing
separating the two was who sat down. That finding was published in 2017 by
Germany's federal anti-discrimination agency and it came out of a very boring
question. When the service is identical, does the price stay identical? It did not.
Germany, to be clear. Not California, not New York. Which points at the real
question here and it isn't why salons do this. It's what a ban actually bans.
Germany has an equal treatment law covering the pricing of services offered
to the public. California banned gender pricing of services in 1996. New York
State did the same in 2020. Three places, three separate sets of rules and in one
of them a government agency went looking anyway and found it in nine salons out
of ten. These laws aren't sloppy. They're written very carefully. That's the
problem. Start with a woman in Surrey, British Columbia and a phone call about
a haircut. In 2014 Ruth Krulicki cut off her long hair. Buzzed it. A few months
later she needed a trim so she called her salon and asked something
reasonable. Two inches of hair on her head. Would she still be charged the
women's rate? Yes, she was told. Women's cuts there ran $60. Canadian, a man's cut
cost half that. Krulicki had less hair on her head than most of the men paying
$30. She called around of other salons. Every one of them priced the same way
and the reason she was given is the reason everyone gives. Women's hair takes
longer. More length, more layers, more skills, more time in the chair. It sounds
airtight and it sounds airtight because most of the time it describes something
real. A cut that takes 90 minutes should cost more than one that takes 15. Nobody's
arguing about that but watch what happens when you test it. Krulicki's hair
was two inches long. There was no extra hour of work hiding in there and the
answer she got wasn't really about her hair. She was told that women generally
need more time for their styling and for the complications of the cut regardless
of the length. That last part is the whole thing. Regardless of the length
that's where the obvious answer stops working. If the price were attached to
the work a shortcut would cost what a shortcut costs. Instead the price is
attached to the customer and the hair is just something that usually comes along
with her. The German agency found the same thing at scale and it found it the
fairest way available by pricing the simplest comparison there is. One
standard short haircut. Him and her. The gap survived anyway. Not everyone
explains that pattern the same way. A peer-reviewed study in the Journal of
Consumer Policy published in 2000 reviewed the evidence and argued that
cross-cutting costs offer alternative salons some pricing. Frost, in the
author's view, possibly a more satisfactory one than discrimination.
That's a serious challenge from people who looked at this hard. But it doesn't
explain a price quoted down a phone line to a woman with a buzz cut before anyone
has picked up a comb. So where did the two-column menu come from and why is it
so hard to kill? In 1994 California's Assembly Office of Research surveyed
businesses across five major cities. On average women paid five dollars more for
a haircut. Five dollars. That's a tip. It's the kind of number you notice at the
counter and then do nothing about because arguing costs more than the
money does. An assemblywoman named Jackie Spire read that survey and wrote a law.
It passed in 1995, took effect the following January, and it did the obvious
thing. A business can't charge you a different price for a service because of
your gender. Clear, short, and by any normal reading the end of this story,
except the law has a second part. Prices are still allowed to differ based on the
amount of time, difficulty, or cost of providing the service. That's not a
loophole somebody snuck in. That's the Fairness Clause. The law forbids charging
more because the customer is a woman. It permits charging more because the job
takes longer. And the industry's explanation for the higher price has
always been that the job takes longer. The exemption and the defense are the
same sentence. Now go back to what Krulicki was told two decades later and a
border away. British Columbia has no statute aimed at pricing the way
California does. What it has is Section 8 of Calumet's Human Rights Code which
says a business must not discriminate over a service open to the
public because of someone's sex unless it has what the code calls a bona fide
and reasonable justification. And those aren't the same standard. California asks
a business to show the difference really came down to time or difficulty or cost.
British Columbia asked for that and then keeps going. The business has to prove
its reason in front of a tribe journal right down to showing there was no way
to serve her this avoided the difference at all. Look at what the salon
said anyway. Not because you're a woman. Styling and complications in time. The
language of justification turns up in the answer whether or not anybody would
ever have to stand behind it. And the American carve-out has to be there.
Without it every business that charges by difficulty would be breaking the law
every time a job ran long. So when New York wrote its own ban in 2020 it
included the same one in almost the same words. Time, difficulty, cost, labor, any
gender-neutral reason will do. So a ban does one thing extremely well. It makes
the reason unsayable. It does not make the price move. What's left is a price
list that says long hair where it used to say women's. Same numbers better
label. Sometimes those categories track real work and honestly most of the time
they probably do. And sometimes a woman with two inches of hair on her phone which tells you the
category isn't measuring hair. Five dollars a haircut isn't a scandal.
Nobody's life is changed by five dollars and that's the whole trick of it. It sits
under the line where a person pushes back. At the count it isn't worth a
sentence. Now look at what it took to go after it. When California's legislature
picked up Speyer's bill the figure sitting in this analysis in front of it
came from a hearing the year before. An estimate woman was paying about one
thousand three hundred and fifty one dollars more a year across all goods and
services. Not haircuts, everything. A flight or a month of groceries or a car
repair you'd have felt. That's a 1994 estimate and the record gives the total
with no breakdown. So nobody should pretend to know what's inside it. And the
law that finally passed covered services only. Not because anyone forgot about
goods. Speyer had already written the goods and services version the year
before and the governor vetoed it. So the next one came back narrower to get
through. That's the strange size of this thing. At the counter it's five dollars
and not worth mentioning. Above the counter it's a vetoed bill, a rewritten
bill, a governor, a legislator and two decades later separately a federal
agency in Germany and a statute in New York still pointed at the same practice.
Small enough that nobody argues in the chair. Big enough that governments keep
writing laws about it. Both true and neither one cancels the other. Which
suggests a different way to look at every price list you've ever stood in
front of. A price list isn't a measurement of work. It's a set of guesses
about who's going to walk through the door. The salon isn't pricing your hair.
It's pricing its guess about you. Made before you sat down. Written on a wall
months earlier by somebody who never met you. Here's my opinion and it is only
that. I don't think gender pricing outlived the laws written against it
because anyone fought hard to keep it. I think it lasted because it was set at
exactly the amount where objecting costs more than paying. A $10 gap gets argued
about. A $5 gap gets absorbed forever by everyone. And I'd say the length of
menstruation replacing gendered ones now are only half a fix. Because a menu is
still a guess made at the door. The honest version of this business would be
a clock on the wall and a rate per minute. Almost nobody wants that. Including
customers. Because then you'd watch the clock instead of the mirror. Krulitsky,
by the way, still hadn't gotten the haircut when her story ran. She hung up
and instead of hunting for a cheaper chair, she wrote to her mayor, the mayor
of Vancouver, to the Premier of British Columbia and to the Prime Minister. Two
inches of hair and a letter to a head of government. Because the number on that
wall never had much to do with her head. She was in the wrong column before she
walked in. Not because of what she had up there but because of who was expected to
be under it.