For the first time in history, the legal system can go after Meta and other social media platforms and demand them to change the way their apps operate and are designed. In this episode we take a look at what this means and how we got here.
Meta is facing a massive legal crisis, likened to the \"Big Tobacco\" era, with thousands of lawsuits and billions in settlements over the addictive design of its platforms. Courts are now holding the company accountable for the psychological harm caused to youth and the societal polarization driven by engagement-focused algorithms that prioritize outrage over safety.
Hi, welcome to another episode of ColdFusion.
Imagine a company's product breaking so many laws
that it's received $29 billion in fines since 2019.
Imagine that same one company
having not 100 active lawsuits against them,
but 7,000.
That company is, of course, Meta.
Mark Zuckerberg, you've been served
with a summons and complaint.
Excuse us, sir.
Mark Zuckerberg, you've been served.
Excuse us, sir.
You've been served.
Incredibly, the number of lawsuits against Meta
is currently growing at a rate of roughly 200 per month.
These lawsuits cover everything from wrongful death
and the decline of teen mental health
to a surveillance-backed door inside of WhatsApp.
But that's not all.
In addition to all of that,
the company is also facing 100,000 other legal proceedings
outside of court in the form of arbitrations.
That 100,000 figure comes from Meta's own SEC filings.
One of the latest lawsuits ordered Meta
to pay up to $18 billion in a settlement.
It's the landmark social media trial
that now has Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg on the stand
facing tough questions and grieving families.
What's worse is that the company has spent
all of their free cashflow on AI ventures
with off-balance sheet commitments
nearing half a trillion dollars.
But the thing is, though, in all of this,
the money is not the problematic part for Meta.
It's important to note and critical to understand
that there was a pivotal point earlier this year
that changed things for Meta.
A March 2026 case against Google and Meta
found them liable for a teen's harm.
Just because of the features alone that drive addiction,
these companies can be held accountable.
That's a huge message for these companies.
Hugs and tears were shared outside a Los Angeles courthouse
as those gathered learned that Meta and Google
have been found liable for causing harm to young people.
In a legal first, the jury determined
that the design of the apps, and not just their content,
was harmful to their users.
Parents, we need you to join in with us
because it stops today.
Big tech, your gig is over.
Yep.
The fine was small at six million,
but that ruling opened the door for an onslaught of lawsuits
from which Meta finds themselves in a bit of trouble.
They're going after the very features
that makes Meta so profitable.
The plaintiffs want to force an end to the like counts,
kill infinite scrolling and autoplay,
and change the recommendation algorithm.
These alongside many other changes.
All of these addressing things that the states had said
contributed to this youth mental health crisis.
Many analysts have called this Meta's big tobacco moment.
This is a huge deal because these latest cases
are forced changes by the US government.
In this episode, we'll put into context
just how high the social cost of Meta has become
and the long overdue legal response.
I think this is a moment where the social media giants
are starting to admit that, yeah,
our products are not designed
for the wellbeing of all our users
and we need to be more proactive
about doing something about it.
Two decades ago, social media was seen
as a connective technological wonder
that brought people together in ways we've never seen before.
Mark Zuckerberg was once the unlikely architect
of that change.
To say that perceptions have completely shifted today
is an understatement.
Today, Instagram and Facebook
have three billion monthly active users on each platform.
To put it another way, around 70% of all humans on this earth
that have an internet connection and aren't in Russia or China
use one of Meta's products daily.
But things aren't going to stay the same.
The company behind Facebook and Instagram
have reached a settlement totaling nearly $18 billion
to end a lawsuit centring on the harms of social media to children.
The most recent case that was brought against Meta
involved 29 US states and the settlement forces Meta
to change their app designs for teens.
This includes a two hour daily limit,
disabling posting and viewing content
between midnight and 6 a.m.,
hiding likes and an option to have a feed
without an algorithm.
Earlier in August, 2026,
a separate ruling by New Mexico judge Brian Bescheid
fined Meta almost a billion dollars.
$942 million.
That is how much Meta,
the parent company for Instagram and Facebook,
has now been ordered to pay for harming children.
And they ordered similar changes,
like eliminating the like counters for under 18s.
The judge went further, declaring Meta a public nuisance,
comparing it to a polluting factory harming an entire population.
Meta is appealing that ruling.
Of course, these changes are a welcome start,
but some say they don't go far enough.
Many people do forget just how much carnage
this one company has caused the world.
Throughout the decades, Meta as a company
realized that they had built the ultimate money machine,
a set of software systems and an algorithm
that could exploit human behaviors.
The goal was simple.
Let the algorithm optimize for the maximum amount of hours
spent on their platforms,
and hence, the maximum amount of time taken from people's lives.
More hours on the platform
meant more targeted advertising dollars.
The algorithms are very smart in the sense that they
latch on to things that people want to continue to engage with.
As early as 2017, the algorithm found a key exploit.
Humans stayed longer if they were outraged or divided.
The reason being is that psychologically,
our brains can't help but give its attention
to things that are a threat or a social violation.
That kind of content grabs our attention
way more than neutral or positive content.
This has been well established in studies.
For example, this study showed
that posts about political outgroups
were up to 6.7 times more likely to go viral
than other major drivers of engagement.
Posts of these kinds would also result in angrier reactions.
We kind of knew something bad could happen.
Chamath Palihapitiya, a former Facebook executive
once in charge of user growth,
now says he has tremendous guilt
about the social network he helped build.
We have created tools that are ripping apart
the social fabric of how society works.
The short-term dopamine-driven feedback loops
that we have created are destroying
how society works.
Now Meta had a choice.
They could either alter the algorithm
to show more balanced content or do nothing.
And of course, they chose to do nothing.
As the recommendation algorithm
got better at optimising engagement,
the users felt psychologically worse,
but the advertising dollars rolled in.
This algorithm still exists today
and we've seen the consequences.
I think almost everybody can agree
there is a lot less trust in the world now
than 10 years ago.
Not just the international order is collapsing.
We see country after country divided against itself.
It is clear that there is a connection
between the technology and the collapse
of human trust and human conversation.
One thing that almost everybody realised by now
is the major role played by social media algorithms,
which are very primitive AIs,
but they still created so much havoc around the world.
Basically, these primitive AIs,
they were given simple tasks
by the social media platforms,
increase user engagement,
make more people spend more time on the platform.
And the AIs went into the world
and experimented on millions of human guinea pigs
and discovered that the easiest way
to grab human attention is to press the hate button
or the anger button or the fear button in the mind.
And this is what they started doing and filled the world.
In 2021, former product manager
testified that engagement-based algorithms
were shown to intentionally push users towards extreme,
divisive and inflammatory content to keep them scrolling.
Facebook's products harm children,
stoke division in our communities,
threaten our democracy,
weaken our national security and much more.
It is about families at home and around the world
who live in places where hate, fear and conflict
have been ratcheted up to a fever pitch
as a result of online radicalisation.
The Facebook platform knew that
Facebook knows what is happening on the platform
and they have systematically under-invested
in fighting those harms.
They know they do far too little about it.
In fact, they have incentives for it to be this way.
Previous reports state that Meta
had been studying the phenomenon since at least 2016.
An internal task force was even assembled in 2017.
Its purpose was to study if maximising user engagement
on Facebook was causing political division.
The answer was a clear yes.
And it turned out that reducing political division
made people less engaged.
In 2018, potential solutions to the problematic algorithm
were recommended,
such as showing users a more diverse range of viewpoints.
The only problem was that it would slow user growth.
So Meta didn't show much interest
and the idea was scrapped.
Over the years, ever more studies showed the same thing.
The algorithms that were trained to maximise engagement
figured out that the best way to do that
was to drive us apart
and drag an increasing subset of users
into more extreme views.
The worst case of this was the horrific events of Myanmar.
In 2017, fake viral news and inflammatory comments
against an ethnic minority in the region
escalated into a full-blown genocide.
It resulted in over 9,000 deaths in a short period of time
and caused the displacement and refugee status
of 700,000 people.
And they're a bit concerned about the idea of federation
or ethnic unity in Myanmar.
The Facebook platform later admitted fault
after previously downplaying its role.
That was almost 10 years ago now
and the practice is still ongoing.
In 2026, an ex-engineer turned whistleblower told the BBC
that he'd been told by senior management
to allow more extreme content in users' feeds
simply to compete with TikTok.
Quote,
they sort of told us that it's because
the stock price is down, end quote.
A recent internal Meta report
acknowledged that their algorithm
had learned to reward outrage
because it maximises engagement.
They state that this isn't aligned with their mission,
but they go on to put the onus on content creators
to make less negative content.
To Meta, their algorithm isn't the problem.
But what about X, TikTok and even YouTube?
They all have algorithms
that are capable of similar things, right?
Yes, but Meta affects the most people on this planet
and the company knowingly has harmed the mental health
of adults and especially teens.
Documents from another recent court case
reportedly include Meta's own internal research
linking like-driven social media comparison
to increased loneliness, worse body image
and negative mood among teens.
And again, they didn't do much about it.
Since 2021, internal documents showed
that over 100,000 kids a day
are sexually harassed on the platform.
And again, they chose to do very little about it.
It's just sad at this point.
The latest federal lawsuit
alleges that Meta made its platforms addictive to children,
misled the public about the dangers
and violated kids' data privacy,
allegedly driving youth depression, anxiety
and in some cases, suicide.
Now, the case was brought by a group of 29 US states
alleging that Meta intentionally designed platforms
to get young people addicted to them,
harming their mental health.
Now, four other states were seeking
as much as $1.4 trillion in damages.
In August of 2026,
whistleblower and former Meta engineering director
Arturo Bejar testified that Zuckerberg prioritised
growth and engagement over child safety.
I think these are going to be the verdicts
that are heard across the world.
When my daughter was 14, she asked if she could go on.
I did it very thoughtfully.
We spoke about it regularly.
And soon she started to get unwanted sexual advances
from strangers, deep, horrible misogyny
because she cares about cars
and people attacking her and her body.
And for me, the most important thing was
because I used to be the person responsible
for safety and security.
I knew that if my daughter was experiencing,
millions of kids were experiencing it as well.
And that was the research I did at Instagram
that found that one in eight kids
get unwanted sexual advances.
One in five feel worse about themselves.
All the harms that we know as parents
and we see are happening at a staggering rate.
So I took to Mark Zuckerberg,
these numbers saying 13 to 15 year olds,
one in five, one in three,
all experiencing these awful issues
that you can prevent.
I know how you can prevent this.
And he didn't even reply to the message.
Wow.
At the start of this episode,
I mentioned the 7,000 lawsuits.
Over 3,100 of them are before Judge Gonzales-Rogers
and the California state alone has roughly 3,300 more.
So together, that's around 6,400 individual court cases.
But there is some nuance here.
A lot of these cases also involve Snapchat,
YouTube and TikTok as defendants.
Although the plaintiffs say Meta has 70% of the blame.
For Meta specifically,
there's many more in the US, the EU and around the world.
Adding those up together,
that number easily crosses the 7,000 mark
at a conservative estimate.
The most recent $18 billion settlement
with those 29 states opens the door
to even more meaningful changes
within the core design of the Instagram
and Facebook platforms themselves.
Hopefully, this puts more focus
on the negative aspects of the software design
and algorithm.
Meta is also facing a separate lawsuit
alleging that the company can access
virtually all private communications on WhatsApp.
Though a spokesman told The Guardian
that Meta strongly denies this
and has called the claims, quote,
categorically false and absurd, end quote.
Many experts have called this Meta's big tobacco moment.
Now, I don't think this is the end of the road.
There's other settlements coming.
There's hundreds of lawsuits still in the works.
But in reality, that might not mean
what most people think it does.
While the 1998 big tobacco $400 billion settlement case
did reduce smoking rates,
Louis Karayakides,
director of the Albert Gore Research Center
at Middle Tennessee State University states, quote,
the settlement wasn't in the interest
of the tobacco companies.
They bought themselves out of significant litigation
and were allowed to go forth and do business, end quote.
Robert Proctor, a Stanford professor
who wrote about and studied the big tobacco moment
adds that, quote,
Americans still smoke
more than 170 billion cigarettes every year, end quote.
So really, Meta and social media
by extension as a whole
will find it harder to continue business as they have been.
But these legal issues do not mean that they're over.
Unfortunately, Meta has the advertising income
at $200 billion in revenue per year
to stick around for a long time to come.
If they reduce AI spending,
they do have a lot of financial wiggle room.
But if the cases keep piling up
and Meta's upper management become distracted
with all the lawsuits,
it could negatively affect the focus of the company
over the coming years.
It also must be stated that Meta admits no wrongdoing
in all of this.
There's a saying that goes,
watch what they do and not what they say.
Even Zuckerberg himself has restricted his own kids'
access to phones and social media screen time.
What does that really say?
So here's a question to ask yourself.
What would a world look like without Meta?
There would be no Facebook, obviously,
but Instagram possibly could be
still an independent photo sharing app.
There would be some videos, yes,
but it's possible that there wouldn't be
an endless stream of Shorts like today.
WhatsApp would also be an independent company.
Sure, some genuine societal good
has come from Meta's products,
small business ad reach,
diaspora communities staying connected,
disaster response coordination, and more.
But this all comes at such a sad cost to our society.
We've seen proof that over and over again,
Meta knew that they were feeding
into radicalisation and polarisation.
During the last decade, these things would have existed,
but the algorithm made it spread faster and wider
than it otherwise would have.
Teens and young adults would have had better mental health,
and the data of billions of people
wouldn't be harvested for targeted advertising.
The 7,000 collective lawsuits
are aiming to bring some of this old world back.
Depending on how effectively the law functions,
we could see some real change in the software design,
first for teens, but hopefully for the rest of us too.
And this isn't just about Meta.
Many lawsuits are targeting the negative aspects
of TikTok and other apps.
Meta's deal could set new industry standards.
About 30% of the total payout is contingent
on whether other social media companies,
such as TikTok, YouTube, and Snapchat,
adopt matching safety restrictions and financial penalties.
Now, this won't happen overnight.
They have up to six months to make these changes.
Hopefully, brighter times may be on the horizon.
We've collectively seen modern social media for what it is.
We've agreed that it has some positives,
but the negative parts have affected billions,
and we all live in the world that's resulted from it.
No one is saying to get rid of social media,
but we're just saying make the experience less damaging
for the most susceptible child or adult.
How much things really change remains to be seen.
What do you think about the lawsuits and the verdict?
Do you think they're too harsh, too lenient, or just right?
Feel free to let me know your thoughts
in the comment section below.
Anyway, that's about it from me.
My name is Dagogo, and you've been watching ColdFusion,
and I'll catch you again soon for the next episode.
Cheers, guys.
Have a good one.