Are you having trouble with your rock tumbler? Trying to figure out why your rocks aren't getting shiny? I have about a dozen years of experience helping people learn to tumble rocks and troubleshooting their problems. Let me help you figure out what you might be doing wrong. There might even be a tip or two in this list for more experienced tumblers.
– HIGHLAND PARK LAPIDARY – Highland Park makes some high quality tools at reasonable prices. They also have the best price on grit that I have found. I make a commission if you buy something through this link. It doesn't cost you extra. https://hplapidary.com/?ref=ROBERTABRAM Use promo code MICHIGANROCKS for 10% off rough rocks and accessories.
– KINGSLEY NORTH – Kingsley North is a lapidary store in Michigan's U.P. They make a great cab machine and sell many other brands too. They have a huge selection of rough rock, tumblers, grit, jewelry supplies etc. at good prices. If you buy using the following link, I make a small commission. https://fas.st/t/u7uaxb5V
– THE ROCK SHED – I buy a lot of lapidary supplies and rough rock from The Rock Shed. I don't make money from your purchases there, but they have good prices and good service. This is where I buy my finer grits and polish. http://rockshed.com
– AMAZON STOREFRONT – I also have an Amazon storefront. This is where you can find other products you may have seen in my videos. As an Amazon Influencer, I earn from qualifying purchases. It doesn't cost you extra. http://www.amazon.com/shop/michiganrocks
So you're having a little problem with your tumbler huh?
Looking for some guy on YouTube to tell you where you went wrong?
Hi my name's Rob and I've been helping people learn how to tumble rocks for about 10 years now.
First on the rock tumbling hobby forums and more recently with my YouTube videos.
I think I've got it narrowed down to about eight common mistakes that people make.
So I'll be assuming that you're using a rotary tumbler kind of like one of these.
So let's get started.
Did you carefully follow the instructions that came with your tumbler?
If you did that was your first mistake.
You'd think that'd be a good idea but they're just really bad instructions usually.
I think the manufacturers want to make it seem like it's a really quick easy process.
It is pretty easy but it's not the same for every batch of rocks and it's really not quick.
Patience really pays off here.
So we'll cover some of the bad advice given by tumbler manufacturers in the upcoming items.
Maybe the biggest piece of bad advice I see in tumbler instructions
is that they say the first stage is a set number of days.
Usually somewhere between three and ten days depending on the manufacturer.
One of them said that you can repeat the first stage but they didn't say why
and it wasn't emphasized that that would be a good idea.
My personal preference is to end up with rocks that are completely smooth.
No holes no cracks or anything.
So to do that I run the first stage over and over and over again.
Each week I look through every single rock.
I pick out the rocks that look like they're they're good to go on and I set them aside
and then I put in more rough rocks and then only when I get enough rocks set
aside that are perfectly smooth do I start the second stage.
Not everyone likes the rocks to look as perfectly smooth as I do.
I've actually had a lot of people tell me they would prefer the rocks to look a little more natural.
Even if that's what you like I'd still suggest looking them over before you move them on to the
next stage and you might find that running them for two or three weeks actually gives you better results.
After the coarse stage all the other stages can be run for a set amount of time.
All you're really trying to do there is just remove the scratches from the previous stage.
I still like to run mine longer than most people do though.
I run the second stage for a week, the third stage for 10 days,
and the polished stage I go for two weeks.
It might be overkill but I'm really happy with the results I get so that's why I'm going to keep doing it.
How do you clean your barrel out between stages?
Cleanliness is really important in rock tumbling.
You want to make sure the rocks are really really clean,
there's no grit left on them before you go to the next stage.
Just imagine having a couple pieces of really coarse grit rolling around in your rocks with
a finer grit and that coarse grit is going to be scratching the rocks so the finer grit is
trying to get the scratches out and that fine grit is just never going to keep up with the
coarse grit right in there with it.
That's one of the reasons I like to grind all the holes and cracks out of my rocks
because then there's no place for the grit to hide and accidentally move on to the next stage.
It's a lot easier to clean them.
If you are moving on rocks with holes and cracks in them,
you got to make sure those holes and cracks are really cleaned out well.
I use a sewing needle sometimes to get into some of the deeper holes
and I use my wife's toothbrush to clean them out too.
That seems to really do a good job.
Of course between each stage you need to rinse your rocks off really carefully.
So I just put the rocks in a colander over a bucket.
I rinse them off as well as I can.
When I get them as clean as I think I can get them,
I'll put them back in the barrel and put in either some borax or ivory soap.
You can just shave some ivory soap into the barrel and run them for three,
four hours or even overnight and you'd be surprised how dirty the water comes out after you do that.
That's more important to do if you've got any holes left in your rocks.
If your rocks are all completely smooth and there's not really a lot of places for the
grit to hide that's not quite as important but it sure doesn't hurt to do it.
And as far as cleaning the barrel, you don't need to scrub the inside of the barrel.
Just fill it with water, swish it around, fill it right up with water and dump it out quick
so anything in there will come out with it.
Do that several times and you should be all set.
The only place I do scrub is right around the rim.
I'll take a toothbrush and just scrub that part because it tends to get,
the slurry gets a little caked on there sometimes.
So clean that out but you don't have to scrub the inside.
Then you should be all set for the next stage.
Also be careful you don't contaminate your whole container of grit.
You don't want to do something like dip a spoon into the coarse grit
and then later take that same spoon and dip it into your polish.
You might take a piece of coarse grit and move it to the polish when you do that.
So you got two options.
You can either clean the spoons off really well in between
or what I did is I went to the dollar store and I bought four sets of spoons
and so I have different spoons for every grit.
I just label them on the back so I know which one's which.
Also make sure you cover your grit containers as soon as you get done using them
so you use your grit container.
Don't leave it laying out.
Put the lid on right away so that nothing can get in there.
Another mistake I see people making is adding some sort of media to the first stage.
By media I mean either these little plastic beads or these little ceramic cylinders.
One of the reasons to use these is that they cushion the rocks
and they make everything more gentle in the tumbler.
In the first stage your whole goal is to grind the rocks as aggressively as you can
so making it more gentle in any way is a bad thing.
I remember when I first started tumbling I put some of these in my tumblers
about three different times and I had something that I thought
needed a little more cushioning and it was a little fragile
and all three times when I opened up the barrel
all the grit was just sitting on the bottom of the barrel
and the rocks looked pretty much the same as I was when I put them in.
Even if you add little too many little rocks
these are some saw scrap site from cutting things out
and I'll put those in the tumbler sometimes
and if I put too many of these in the barrel the same thing happens.
I open it up at the end of the week and there's a lot of grit just sitting there
that hasn't even been used.
Another reason not to put ceramic media in the first stage
is because this stuff's kind of expensive
and if you put in the first stage it's going to wear out a lot quicker.
It's pretty hard and it lasts a long time.
It can be reused a lot but you don't want to wear it out more than you have to.
So what you want is rock against rock in that first stage grinding.
You don't want rock against ceramic grinding this instead of your rocks.
I start using some sort of media in the second stage
whether it's the plastic or the ceramic.
At that point you do want to make it a little more gentle on the rocks.
You're not trying to aggressively grind the rocks down.
All you're trying to do is grind out the scratches left from the previous stage.
So getting some of these things in between the little nooks and crannies
helps polish a little bit better.
It helps everything just sort of flow around there better
and it's a good thing.
So you definitely want to use either plastic or ceramic media.
Just don't use them in the first stage.
Speaking of media, make sure you're not moving your plastic media
from one stage to the next.
Plastic's really soft and it's going to get grit embedded in it.
So when you run this stuff in your 220 grit
a little piece of 220 grit will get stuck right in the sides of the plastic.
And so what you really don't want to do is move that out all the way to the polish stage
because it'll be rolling around the polish stage
with a little 220 grit sticking out, scratching everything up.
You can reuse it.
You just have to reuse it in the same stage.
So I have these labeled 220, 500, and polish.
So when I'm doing those stages again, I can reuse these there.
On the other hand, ceramic media actually should be moved along with your rocks.
This is really hard.
There's no chance of grit getting stuck in it.
And what you want is this to polish with your rocks.
So it'll be as smooth as the rocks in that same stage.
Just move it right along with the rocks.
I actually much prefer, I almost never use this.
I pretty much only use ceramic media at this point
because it's so much easier to work with.
I don't have to separate it from the rocks at every stage like I do with this.
These are a pain to separate.
I've tried floating them off.
I've tried picking them out, tried all kinds of stuff.
And it's just a pain every time.
So I use this.
But I'm not telling you not to use this
because I know some people that use plastic media
and swear by it and get really good results.
So you'll have to make up your own mind.
But for me, ceramic all the way.
I think the biggest problem I'm seeing lately
with people getting a good polish on the rocks
is that they're using the wrong grits and polishes.
I don't want to name any specific manufacturers here.
But the problem usually starts at the third stage.
So in the first two stages, you should be using silicon carbide
which is really good at grinding rocks.
By the third stage, you should be switching over to aluminum oxide
which starts to get the rocks a little bit of a polish
and then you finish it up with a polish stage.
So a lot of manufacturers are selling some sort of silicon carbide for the third stage.
I like to use 500 aluminum oxide there.
Something around that size does a really nice job.
Then when you get to polish,
traditionally people have used like cerium oxide or tin oxide.
There's a couple others I think.
I've not used those very much because they're really expensive now.
So by the time I started tumbling, most people are using aluminum oxide for polish.
So that's what I use.
If you have some tin oxide or cerium oxide, by all means use it.
But most of us that are just getting started are going to be buying aluminum oxide.
So what you want is really fine aluminum oxide.
So what I have here is aluminum oxide polish.
I always say two microns, but I think it ranges from about one to three microns.
So most things are measured in grit size, not microns.
So I found a table that converts from one to the other.
And on the table, it said that one micron was 14,000 grit
and three microns is about 8,000 grit.
So you've got a range from 14,000 to 8,000.
And that's going to really do a nice job.
What a lot of people are selling is 1200 aluminum oxide.
And 1200 aluminum oxide is more of a pre-polish in my opinion.
I have some 1000 aluminum oxide that I don't use so much anymore.
Once in a while I'll use it.
But that's good as a pre-polish and I still follow it up with an actual polish after that.
There's one manufacturer, a very common one,
that includes 1000 silicon carbide as a polish.
And that simply is never going to polish a rock.
So anybody trying to use the little packets that come with that particular tumbler
are going to be disappointed because unless they switch to a better polish,
they're never going to get a shiny rock.
So good grit and polish really matter.
If you want to know what I use, check the description of any of my videos.
And I've got two different places that I buy all my stuff from.
Buy something from one of those and you're going to be happy with it.
It doesn't cost any more and it's good stuff.
And if you buy in bulk, you can save a lot of money.
So consider that also.
How much have you been filling the barrel up?
It should be about three quarters full.
So in the first stage, as you get done with a week of tumbling,
you're going to see that all the rocks got a little bit smaller.
And you might take some rocks out that you think are ready for the second stage.
And you're going to have to replace those rocks with something.
So just put in more rough rocks.
You don't have to worry about scratching up the other rocks
because that's what happens in the first stage.
The silicon carbide is scratching the rocks.
And if other rocks scratch your rocks, well that's good too.
Once you put them in the 220 stage, you shouldn't add any extra rocks.
That shouldn't really, the volume shouldn't go down much from there on out
because the grits are all a little finer and they just don't wear the rocks down as much.
If you fill your barrel too much, you know, like 80 or 85 percent full,
the rocks won't have as much room to move around in there.
And that can be a good or a bad thing.
If you're trying to grind stuff away really fast, that could be bad.
But if you're trying to cushion some rocks and give them a little more gentle ride,
there's not as much room for the rocks to roll down if the barrel is really full.
So it slows things down, which might be good.
If the barrel is too empty, the rocks can crash around in there a lot more.
They don't really quite get the same tumbling action.
There's not as much weight on the top pushing down to make the grit work better.
So less full isn't really a good thing.
How big of rocks are you putting in the barrel?
It's okay to put like one big rock in the barrel,
but you should balance that out by making sure the rest of the rocks
are maybe a little smaller than usual so everything has room to move around in there.
The best thing is to have a mix of sizes and nothing too big
so everything can move the way it should and tumbling action can happen.
None of the advice I've given you so far is going to do you any good
if you're tumbling the wrong kind of rocks.
Some people start out by buying rocks that they think look really cool
and they don't realize they're really hard to tumble.
Some examples are Labradorite, Obsidian, Fluorite.
Here in Michigan people try to tumble Petoskey stones.
Those are all really difficult rocks to tumble and they're just not good for a beginner.
They might be fun to try later on though.
I still haven't quite gotten Labradorite the way I want it.
I can kind of get it shiny but it's not quite as shiny as I'd like.
So beach rocks or rocks that you pick up on your own, they can be good choices or bad choices.
Granite is something a lot of people pick up when they first start collecting rocks
because it's really colorful.
It's a beautiful rock.
It's not great for tumbling.
You can get it to shine but it's going to have little dull spots all over it too.
Most people that are into tumbling will agree that good rocks to start with are either agates.
These are Bahia agates or some sort of jasper.
This is desert jasper which I think is pretty much the same thing as polychrome jasper.
Agates and jaspers are great to start with.
They're very hard which makes them take a little bit longer
but harder rocks are much easier to get a shine on.
Be a little careful with jasper though.
There's a lot of things that are called jasper that aren't actually jasper.
So do a little research.
Make sure you're getting something that's easy for a beginner to tumble
and you're much more likely to have really good success right off the bat.
I tried to keep this list focused on reasons your rocks might not be getting shiny.
I'm sure there's some other ways you could mess it up but I think it covered the big ones.
What I didn't cover are some other mistakes you could make
like dumping slurry down your drain and clogging your pipes
or buying a tumble that's made for metal and not for rocks.
Tumbling isn't all that hard.
If you stick with it try to have a little bit of patience.
I think everybody can turn out some really nice shiny rocks.
I put together a playlist here of some other rock tumbling topics that I think you'll like
and there's also a link to a complete tumbling video.
So click on one of those and I'll see you in the next video.