Making The Chick-Fil-A Chicken Sandwich At Home | But Better

Street Food
4 followers
9 Video Views·Sep 3, 2026
In your opinion, who is the winner of this "chicken banh mi showdown"?
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe creator challenges the popularity of the Chick-fil-A sandwich, arguing it is overrated and dry. By upgrading the ingredients—using chicken thighs instead of breasts, homemade brioche buns, and MSG-enhanced pickles—they demonstrate how to create a superior, juicier version of the classic fast-food sandwich.
So we did the nuggets and we triumphed.
But I think that it's time that we go after the big boy.
OK, so today we are making the Chick-fil-A sandwich.
But I've had conversations with many people,
both professional and unprofessional,
in the world of cuisine.
And I've expressed my concerns about this sandwich.
Not that there's anything wrong with it.
I just think that it's overrated.
So today we're going to prove why we can make it much better.
I don't know why I'm talking in that cadence.
With all that said, let's make this, shall we?
Oh my god.
Is that the line?
What's with the chicken line?
I like chicken.
I mean, I get it.
Chicken is yummy.
Can I just get two Chick-fil-A sandwiches?
Thank you.
Thank you, Josh.
Stay warm.
God damn it.
They're so polite here.
Looks like somebody took care of that sign.
When those Chick-fil-A employees go home, they throw up.
After having to be nice for so long, I would throw up.
Hello.
Hey, Josh?
Yes.
Do you have an ice cream?
Thank you so much.
OK, we have a sandwich.
Time to go and have fun.
OK, so we have the bag.
You're the best part of the day.
Like, for them?
Or like, are they saying to focus on yourself?
Or are they saying like, you're the best part of the day for us,
for our employees?
I highly doubt that.
Who's reading this and like, oh, it's probably somebody's mom.
It's very sweet.
A real classic.
What's all the weird small text?
It's almost like a threat.
It's threatening.
It's like, a real classic.
OK, so here we go.
This is the clout sandwich.
This is what y'all are worried about, OK?
Everyone's like, oh, the best chicken sandwich.
This, come on.
Untoasted bread, chicken.
The chicken looks pretty good.
And then two lazily placed pickles.
50% of the sandwich is covered in pickles.
The other 50 is just dry.
No sauce.
And this is what everyone goes crazy about.
I'm a big fan of beauty and simplicity.
I don't know if this is it, chief.
Cheers.
Here's the verdict.
At the end of the day, it's a beauty and simplicity thing.
Yes, it tastes good.
Is it as good as it could be?
Not even close.
Is it as juicy as it could be?
Absolutely not.
This is what I would call dry chicken.
If we're going to be riding the clout mobile,
we might as well be riding in the biggest, baddest clout
mobile we can.
And I think we can do better.
All right, folks.
We can't just flex on them without our classic god
tier buns.
You know them.
You love them.
Since we've made them so many times on this channel,
my full detailed buns, the recipe,
will be in the link in the description.
It's easy, so I'll give you the gist.
You get a small container, half cup of water,
add a half cup of milk, get it lukewarm,
dissolve 2 and 1 1 teaspoons of instant yeast.
Then in the bowl of a stand mixer,
whisk together 3 and 1 half cups of bread flour,
1 tablespoon of granulated sugar,
and 1 and 1 half teaspoons of fine sea salt.
Pop that on your stand mixer with the dough hook.
Begin mixing.
This time I added 3 tablespoons of vegetable oil
instead of butter, followed by my yeasty milk stuff,
one egg yolk, and one whole egg.
Let that mix until you get a nice, smooth plump boy.
Pop it out, shape it into a light ball,
toss it into a greased bowl, cover with plastic wrap,
and rise for one hour.
Then just punch it down, divide, and shape it
into six evenly sized balls.
Place it on a baking sheet, cover,
and let proof for 30 minutes.
Finally, give them a light brush of egg wash,
toss them in a 375 degree oven for 15 minutes,
pull them out, and brush them with melted butter.
That's the gist for the most beautiful popping buns.
Okay, the pickles at Chick-fil-A are just downright shameful.
That's all I gotta say.
For ours, you're gonna start with one English cucumber.
Pickling cucumbers are better, but work with what you got.
Then just cut that bad boy, oop, sometimes they run away.
Goodbye.
Into about half inch thick coins.
I want these to be some fatty gentlemen.
Now place those in a one quart mason jar,
separately in a medium saucepan,
add one and a half cups of distilled vinegar,
three quarters of a cup of water,
one tablespoon of salt, one tablespoon of sugar,
and voila, the magic ingredient, two teaspoons of MSG.
Chick-fil-A uses MSG, so we will too.
Bring that to a boil over high heat.
As soon as it reaches a boil, take it off the heat
and pour it over your cucumbers.
Let that sit for one minute,
then add two cloves of garlic
that have been crushed and rough chopped,
two to four sprigs of dill,
depending on how dilly you like it.
Then just let that sit at room temperature
until they're completely cooled.
Now you have a beautiful MSG dill pickle.
Then just store these guys in the fridge
and they stay good for, well, months.
Now, for our chicken.
First, begin with a small bowl,
add three tablespoons of kosher salt,
one tablespoon of sugar, and two teaspoons of,
you guessed it, MSG.
Next, instead of chicken breast,
we're using juicy, chonky, boneless chicken thigh,
boneless and skinless.
Season your chicken generously with your cure mixture
on both sides, of course.
You likely won't use every last bit of your seasoning,
but don't throw it away, put it to the side.
Now, either keep your chicken on a small tray
or in an airtight container
covered with plastic wrap or a lid
and let them cure in the fridge for 30 minutes,
but ideally overnight.
This is important to generating
that classic taste you would expect.
Now, time to fry.
Get yourself a six to seven quart Dutch oven.
Fill it up with about two and a half inches
worth of vegetable oil.
Heat that guy to 350 Fahrenheit.
Then while that's heating,
let's make our breading station.
For the flour dredge, get a medium bowl,
add two cups of all-purpose flour,
one tablespoon of powdered sugar, yes, that's correct,
two tablespoons of garlic powder,
one tablespoon of smoked paprika,
two teaspoons of...
♪ In his cheese ♪
One tablespoon of brown white pepper
and one tablespoon of kosher salt.
Whisk that together until thoroughly combined.
Now, for the chicken wash,
get a separate bowl, crack in two eggs,
whisk them together, then whisk in one cup of whole milk.
Then finally, whatever remaining chicken cure seasoning
that you didn't use, go ahead and add that too.
Breading your chicken is as easy as hopscotch.
But first, a little trick for you.
Get a couple tablespoons of your chicken wash
and drizzle and stir it in vigorously into your dredge.
This will create tiny little lumps
that will then attach to the chicken
and create a flaky crust that we all desire.
Now, lightly dust a small baking sheet
with your flour dredge,
dunk a piece of chicken in the milkmaid juice.
That's a chicken wash.
Then drop it into the flour dredge,
toss to coat, pressing the flour into the chicken
aggressively, coating every little crevice.
What does Papa say about uncoated spots on chicken?
No geese!
Once that's coated, shake off the excess flour
and place on your sheet.
Then simply repeat with the rest of your chicken.
Now, once your oil's to temp,
simply drop your chicken in one to two pieces at a time
depending on how big your pot is.
These were some big boys
and my pot was a little bit too small,
so I fried one at a time.
Then just fry for three to five minutes at 350 Fahrenheit
or until golden brown
and the chicken is beautifully cooked through.
I mean, look at that.
Ooh, little chicken man.
Now, remove your chicken using a spider
and treat it on a wire rack set over a baking sheet.
Then repeat with the rest of your chicken.
Now, for assembly, I know there's not really sauce
that they put specifically on their sandwich,
which really annoys me.
Of course, you could do Chick-fil-A
and I have a recipe for that
in my Chick-fil-A chicken nugget video,
link in the description.
But instead, I made a very simple mustard mayo
by literally combining half a cup of mayo,
half a cup of whole grain mustard
and a touch of salt and pepper.
That's it.
You just mix that together and it's jammy.
Now, get yourself a nice glossy bun.
Slice it in half, butter it up
and get it nice and roasted toasty in a pan.
Now, get your toasted buns.
Start by first putting a small layer of sauce,
if you chose that route, on your bottom bun,
then your pickle rounds,
which yes, I do hate pickle rounds, okay?
It's very annoying.
Look, I have to put this stupid tiny little piece
in the middle to cover the whole gap,
but I'm trying to be accurate
with the whole Chick-fil-A sandwich depiction.
Now, hit the top bun with a touch of sauce,
add on your beautifully voluptuous chicken
and of course, gently crown your king.
Now, that looks like a chicken sandwich
that I want inside my body,
which is precisely what we'll do.
Ah, this feels good, fellas.
This feels real good.
My sandwich, I mean,
I think we know where this is gonna go.
Let's just do this.
I did break my pickle cutting rule.
I've always said to cut them lengthwise
to fill out the whole thing
and do you see how annoying it was
to get that last bit on there?
All right, that's why you follow that rule.
I don't know why I broke it.
Never break a papa rule.
All right, this is a thick Sandy, so.
Where am I?
Hello?
Mama?
I'd like to use a special word.
I'm befuddled.
This is yummy.
Yeah, we slam dunked this.
I have nothing to say other than the chicken is crisp,
the buns are rich, soft and pillowy
and these MSG pickles, they make your mouth wet.
We need a taste tester.
TJ, get on in here, buddy.
Okay, so TJ, how do you feel about Chick-fil-A
before we even do this?
Kind of indifferent.
When it comes to chicken sandwiches,
I always preferred Popeye's over Chick-fil-A.
Numero uno.
Un champiano.
Boom, bam, piano.
It's not really a language.
Just disrespectful.
Okay.
Oh, yeah.
Whoa, okay.
Numero two.
And again.
Yeah, that's obvious.
That's poopy.
Dude, the pickles is what set this off for me.
Like, the chicken's juicy, it's good,
but the pickles just added that extra to it.
And that's, well, and that's what we did.
We slam dunked this.
What better?
We won, yet again, Chick-fil-A.
What are you gonna do about it?
The Chick-fil-A people are gonna be all over us
saying that, oh, there's no way it could be better.
There's a lot of ways that it could be better than this,
all right?
And we donk undid it.
You wanna know what else is full of big, juicy thighs
that you want in your mouth?
I'm talking about chicken thighs, by the way.
Nasty.
B-roll.
All right, guys, that is it.
So today, we made the Chick-fil-A chicken sandwich.
It wasn't really that hard.
I mean, it's literally just two buns,
chicken, pickles, that's it.
If you really break it down,
it's kind of a boring sandwich,
and I don't know why people are so cultish about it.
They see this sandwich and they're like,
oh my God, it's the best sandwich ever.
Half-ass toasted buns.
Tiny little one pickle.
Why does this have so much hype?
So with all that said, if you enjoyed this video
or you learned something, leave a like, subscribe,
and I will see you next time.
