Canada-US Trade Deal Falls Apart

Business, Lending & Investing
2 followers
Sep 1, 2026
Following weeks of negotiations, trade talks abruptly fell apart between Canada and the US last week. Today's video breaks down what happened, and what it means for the two countries.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTrade negotiations between Canada and the US have collapsed, triggering a trade war characterized by mutual retaliatory tariffs. Despite initial progress, disputes over sovereignty, cultural protections, and internal US policy disagreements led to a breakdown, with both nations now implementing significant duties on billions of dollars worth of goods.
What the hell?
Guys, I take one week off as vacation.
One week to take my family on a nice trip
to go see a big rock in the middle
of the Gulf of St. Lawrence.
And this is what I come back to?
Trade talks between Canada and the US abandoned.
New trade war between the two countries.
Lake of America?
One week I'm gone and everyone starts losing their minds.
Anyway, I'm back now.
Did you miss my tariff videos?
Because I didn't.
But let's talk about it.
Let's talk about what the hell happened
between Canada and the US.
Because as most people know by now,
trade talks fell apart last Friday.
And since then, we've had a lot of details come out
about what exactly caused things to collapse,
seemingly in the 11th hour.
By the way, the trip was actually very nice.
I'm feeling very rejuvenated.
So, ready to dive back into the sludge.
To catch everyone up to speed,
in early August, amid an upcoming deadline from the US
for the imposition of new 50% Section 338 tariffs
against 20 billion US dollars worth of Canadian exports,
we saw the two countries start to meet up
for trade negotiations.
And for a while,
it really looked like a trade deal was gonna happen.
Canadian negotiators were frequently traveling
to Washington leading up to the deadline of August 19th.
And on the Tuesday, the day before the deadline,
Trump announced that he would be pausing tariffs
until the Saturday,
as the two countries had seemingly agreed
to a framework of a deal.
With the president adding pretty randomly
that Canada had agreed to kickstart
the Keystone XL pipeline project,
which for those unfamiliar was a long existing project
to expand the existing Keystone pipeline system
and create a more effective route south to the US
to the Gulf Coast,
which was a bit of a weird thing to bring up with all this
since it was actually the US
that vetoed the project back in 2021.
And Canadian oil is the only reason
the US has a trade deficit against Canada.
So celebrating that the US might be getting
more Canadian oil when the president keeps lamenting
the trade imbalance is a bit odd.
But nonetheless, it seemed to suggest
that things were progressing,
that the two countries had at least agreed
on this other project
and that seemed to be benefiting this trade deal.
With top negotiators for both countries highlighting
that it was just a matter of finalizing the specifics.
Now, the details of the trade deal
weren't published publicly,
but we did have both sides coming to the table
with some offers.
The Canadians willing to drop retaliatory tariffs
against steel, aluminum, and auto parts,
encourage provinces and territories
to undo the ban on alcohol sales
and amend dairy tariff rate quotas
to allow US retailers to sell directly into Canada
given that currently only distributors can.
While the Americans seemingly unwilling
to completely abandon tariffs
were at least offering some reductions.
Agreeing to reduce the steel and aluminum tariffs
from 50% to 25%,
though that would be subject to a tariff rate quota
to completely drop the 10% section 232 tariff on lumber,
although the commodity would still be subject
to other US tariffs specifically around anti-dumping
and countervailing.
And auto parts could see their tariffs reduced
from 25% to 15% and possibly even further to 7%
depending on certain conditions.
But on Friday, we got the pretty shocking update
that Prime Minister Mark Carney
had recalled his negotiators back to Ottawa
with the Prime Minister issuing a statement later that day
highlighting that he had cut off negotiations
with the United States
and would be retaliating
to the now to be implemented 50% tariffs
coming from the US effective August 22nd.
With all the trade talks seemingly falling apart
in just a matter of hours.
So what the hell happened?
Well, here it's a bit of he said, she said.
Mark Carney for his part has accused the US
of implementing some last minute demands
that were unfair, uneconomic
and called him to question the reliability of any deal
with Quebec's Premier Christine Frechette
highlighting that the US was going after matters
that would affect the country's sovereignty
and even Quebec's French language legislation.
While on the US side, America's top negotiator here,
Jameson Greer, likewise accused Canada of additional demands
and walking back other commitments.
So depending on which side you subscribe to
very different tellings of what caused things
to fall apart here.
But since trade talks were cut off last Friday
we've since had a number of details come to the surface
thanks to journalist interviews of insiders
and industry members who were briefed on the details
highlighting just how many gaps there were
between the two countries
and their positions with this trade deal.
With there seemingly being four main irritants
that resulted in Canada walking away here.
With the first being Howard Lutnick,
the US Secretary of Commerce who seemingly intervened
after being dissatisfied with Greer's negotiated terms
on a number of areas,
specifically steel, aluminum and automobiles.
You see these areas actually fall
under Howard Lutnick's jurisdiction
as again, the US Secretary of Commerce.
And Lutnick has taken a very hard line approach
regarding moving manufacturing
from Canada to the United States.
And according to some reports,
when negotiators initially agreed
to reducing the headline tariffs for automobiles
from 25% down to 15% on the US side,
right before the deadline for a deal,
US negotiators at the behest of Lutnick himself
revealed that they'd be excluding medium
and heavy duty trucks from the tariff reduction.
Something that would impact pickup trucks,
a very key and lucrative category for the automotive sector
and an area that Canada has very well established
manufacturing facilities for,
including for the Ford F-Series and GM Silverados.
Now, beyond this just being a less favorable condition
than the originally agreed to terms,
it also demonstrated to the Canadian side
that there were seemingly two US chefs in the kitchen.
While the US administration has argued
that Lutnick and Greer are aligned
in their negotiation priorities,
reports suggest some disagreement
over the terms Greer had negotiated,
which led to Prime Minister Mark Carney
describing the US negotiation team as disjointed.
The Canadian team, unified.
You cannot say that about the United States administration.
Now, beyond the auto sector specifically,
the Canadian side just generally expressed dissatisfaction
with the degree of relief being offered on the US side.
With the, again, the Canadians offering
a complete abandonment of the retaliatory tariffs,
but the US side still looking to maintain
pretty intensive tariffs on steel, aluminum, and lumber.
With there, again, being some who believe
Lutnick is driving this hardline approach.
Secondly, there were major concerns
over the sovereignty implications
of some of the US trade terms.
Namely, US negotiators were wanting to have influence
over the trade deals Canada struck with other countries.
Pushing, for example, for the country
to implement similar sectoral tariffs
to those implemented in the US
on things like steel and aluminum
to ensure that they had a sort of united front.
And even pushing to have the right
to update these Canadian tariffs
should the US update its own policy.
Even if Canada already had a trade deal
with that other country.
Which from the US side was geared
at ensuring cheap foreign products didn't flood into Canada
and then later into the United States,
given the sort of discrepancy between the trade arrangements
but for Canada was a bit of a non-starter
given that the country is trying
to actively diversify its trade relations
and actually a condition like that
would make Canada much more dependent
on the United States than it already is.
Which is not really what the country
is looking for at the moment.
Thirdly, there was the French language thing
which we have mixed reports in terms
of what the US was actually calling for here.
But to an extent, it does seem like it was something
that would have been impacted by, again,
some of the US terms brought with the deal.
You see, Canada has a number of French language laws
at both the federal and the Quebec provincial level
aimed at preserving the language within the country.
And so there are rules around things
like having bilingual labels,
ensuring certain product information is available
in both languages on product packaging.
And in Quebec specifically, there are much stricter rules
in terms of how French is used over the English language.
Now, according to the Canadian side,
Americans took issue with the bilingual labeling requirement
something that the US side denies.
However, the US negotiators did allegedly ask Canada
to drop its requirement for US streaming services
like Netflix and Amazon Prime to promote Canadian TV,
movies, and music to Canadian users.
You see, Canada has long had CanCon
or Canadian content requirements
that require traditional broadcasters
to ensure that a minimum percentage
of their music or TV came from Canada
with these rates ranging anywhere from 35 to 60% of content
depending on the medium or outlet.
And in 2023, the laws were updated
to ensure that platforms like Netflix
would at least promote Canadian content
since obviously streaming is a bit different
from TV broadcasting,
all of which is intended to preserve Canadian culture
given that the country resides beside a media juggernaut
that exports probably the most media internationally
and would otherwise likely flood Canadian platforms
with American content,
with Quebec having similar requirements
for French language content within the province.
Now, CanCon rules are no stranger to controversy
or protest from the United States,
but it was a subject that came a bit out of left field
with, again, US negotiators seemingly introducing
in the last few hours of talks
demands for the country to exempt US streamers
from these requirements,
with one source stating that this was intending to,
quote, ensure that there is more content from the US
and less Canadian content available on these platforms,
which generally would probably be unpopular for Canada,
but specifically for Quebec
in terms of the implications there
is just not a feasible discussion.
Quebec today is only really still a part of the country
because of these French language laws,
so even if the prime minister wanted to cut a deal
and agree to these terms,
doing so would prove incredibly tumultuous
for internal affairs.
Finally, given the experience from the trade talks
and, well, everything else,
there were concerns that the US side
wouldn't preserve or honor this trade deal,
which, shocker.
Canadian negotiators allegedly sought insurance
that the US side would not scrap its deal overnight,
while American negotiators maintained
that tariffs would be subject to change at any time.
So there's not much motivation from the Canadian side
to give any sort of concession
until there's more of a guarantee,
with Mark Carney highlighting that
in regards to America's commitment to trade deals.
Sometimes its signature was written in pencil.
Now, these are just some of the standout issues
that cause talks to fall apart between the two countries,
but they aren't the only ones.
The US, for their part,
raised issue with Canada's Buy Canadian program,
which, like a similar US policy,
prioritizes using domestic products
and suppliers for public sector projects.
And there are reports that Canadian negotiators
brought last-minute changes themselves,
asking for auto tariffs to be lowered further
from 7% to zero,
for steel and aluminum tariffs to be brought further down,
and ultimately backing away from its offer
to restart the Keystone XL project.
And since then, things have only continued to escalate.
Naturally, on Saturday, August 22nd,
the day after the trade talks were called off,
we had the US going ahead with its 50% tariff
on certain Canadian goods,
which you can watch this video on that
if you want a deeper dive.
And Canada, meanwhile, announced that it would proceed
with its own retaliatory measures against these 50% tariffs,
with duties of 15% to 50% announced
on over 700 American products,
totaling a similar $27.6 billion Canadian dollars,
or about 20 billion US dollars worth of goods here.
Duties that would be going into effect September 8th.
Now, naturally, it's a long list,
and it's actually been amended since first being published.
Originally, seafood and fish were included.
However, the list has since been updated
to reflect feedback from Canadian industry stakeholders.
Nonetheless, some notable items still on the list
include dairy, construction products, home appliances,
motorcycle and railway parts,
and other agricultural products.
With duties on steel and aluminum specifically
doubling to 50% to now match the US's own tariffs
against Canadian steel and aluminum,
which altogether will impact roughly 6%
of America's exports to Canada
versus the roughly 5% of Canadian exports to the US
that were impacted by America's 50% tariff
introduced last weekend.
Now, Canadian officials have been transparent
that they are targeting different states
with these specific tariffs
to ensure that they have a notable impact.
So while 6% might not sound like a meaningful effect
for the American economy,
there are going to be certain states
that are hit much harder
given their different exposures
to these different industries.
But the goal there being to influence midterm elections
in those states,
that could very well result in reigning in
Donald Trump's power.
Meanwhile, the country also announced
additional support measures to help industries
through this latest round of tariffs,
specifically a 7.5 billion Canadian dollar package
for domestic businesses affected by this 50% levy,
which naturally is pretty prohibitive to trade
for a number of these industries.
Now, in response to Canada's response,
Trump has threatened even more tariffs,
highlighting that he would be increasing auto tariffs
on Canadian imports to 50% at the start of 2027,
with Trump also signing an executive order
to rename the Lake of Ontario, Lake America,
and calling Ontario's premier, Doug Ford, a flunky,
which resulted in Doug Ford calling Trump a loser.
Just really highbrow stuff,
which is a good segue into the next point
that things could naturally continue to escalate from here
given that Doug Ford has in the past
proven a bit trigger happy
and has threatened to cut off electricity exports
to US states or impose a tax on exports.
Meanwhile, Greer himself has suggested
that the US would respond with further measures
if Canada were to retaliate.
And who knows what body of water Trump
might change the name of next.
By the way, Lake Ontario isn't named after the province.
It's actually vice versa.
Ontario is derived from an Iroquois word
meaning sparkling water or Great Lake.
And the lake was named well before the formation of Canada
or even the US for that matter.
And frankly, while I think I've been saying this
every time there's a tariff update
between the two countries,
it's all coming at a pretty rough time.
The war in Iran continues to impact inflation,
which has reached 3% or higher for both countries,
something that of course is not helped by tariffs
which directly increase the cost of goods.
And you can see here from this forecast
from the budget lab at Yale
that while effective US tariffs
are actually down from last year
given the strike down of Trump's IEPA tariffs,
they are projected to continue rising.
The US also faces pressure from its bond market
with yields on the rise in part thanks to inflation,
which only threatens to further exacerbate
affordability issues in the country
and could impact economic growth.
While Canada's own GDP growth has been sluggish
amid the trade war and population headwinds.
So despite government plans to enact supports,
these tariffs are likely to continue
to be a headwind for economic activity.
Now, with all that being said,
it's worth highlighting again
that even with these new tariffs being implemented,
the vast majority of Canadian goods
continue to enter the US market tariff-free and vice versa.
Estimates before this escalation
suggested that 90% of Canadian goods
were still entering the US without duties under KUSMA.
So with another 5% of Canadian exports being impacted here,
that's still the vast majority of trade
that's not being charged any tariff.
And as we've seen in the past,
things are subject to change pretty quickly.
And there is a chance that a deal is still struck here.
Canada has delayed its own implementation
of retaliatory tariffs until September 8th,
seemingly in an attempt to give both sides a chance to cool
and even maybe return to the negotiating table
to do something.
And Greer actually recently softened the US's position
regarding Canadian content laws,
stating in an interview
that while the discoverability issue
had been highlighted by the White House as an irritant,
it was not a deal breaker
and the administration would not let a good deal go by
for something like that.
So hey, maybe the two sides are willing to close the gap
on a number of issues.
But if one thing's for certain,
it's that tariffs are not going away anytime soon,
even if a deal is struck here.
And so while a deal might still be beneficial,
these trade irritants
are gonna be sticking around for some time,
with the prime minister suggesting
that the country will continue to pursue deals
outside the United States.
But that's just the perspective as of today,
and we'll just have to wait and see how things develop.
So thank you for joining me today.
So much for easing back into the workload,
but such is the fate of a tariff channel in 2026.
I don't actually wanna keep covering tariff content,
but I will provide key updates as they arrive.
Let me know your view on the Canada-US trade relations,
how you think both countries should proceed,
and what body of water would you rename if you could?
And what would you change its name to?
Thanks again for joining me,
and as always, be safe out there.
