WSET vs CMS? Are you thinking about taking a wine certification exam? I'm going to be talking about my wine certification journey and what it takes to become a sommelier. I'll be going over my certified sommelier results and things that I wish I had known before I had taken the test. The type of exam questions and the areas I wish I studied more. I'll also talk about the WSET and Master of Wines path.
Cheers! Vivian The Somm Next Door (aka Sommelier, aka wine nerd, aka someone you can have a glass of wine and hang out with)
Vivian, a wine enthusiast and content creator, shares her personal experience with wine certifications. She candidly discusses failing her Level 2 Certified Sommelier exam due to a lack of beverage knowledge beyond wine, compares the CMS and WSET paths, and offers advice on which certification suits different career goals.
This calls for a drink.
I am drinking today a Weisbegunde.
My friend got me this when she was in Germany,
and this is from the Mosel.
And Weisbegunde is Pinot Blanc.
Hey guys, it's Vivian the Som next door,
and today we're gonna be talking about wine certifications.
If you guys like this video,
please hit that thumbs up button,
subscribe to my channel, you know the deal,
and let us get started.
It's been a while since I've like took this out.
These are my results.
And as you can see, it says Vivian Chen.
These are my results.
And you guys, I did not pass.
I did not pass my level two sommelier exam.
And I wanna tell you guys why.
I chose not to retake my exam.
Let me tell you a little bit about my journey.
I think I've mentioned this in other videos,
but I started when I was a college student.
I was a hospitality major.
And within that school,
and it's open to anybody, any student, is a wines course.
We went through regions, we went through wine laws,
and we got to taste, which is great.
I decided to study on my own,
and go for my intro level one CMS exam.
So what you have to do is you have to sign up
and pay to go to this two-day course.
And the two-day course, really,
you're not supposed to go in there
without any studying or any previous knowledge.
You will fail.
You will fail the exam if you do that.
They don't even cover everything
that's on the exam in these two days,
but they kind of give you a taste
of what it's like in the industry as a sommelier,
and what are expectations, serving,
and they're taught by master sommeliers.
I did pass my intro, so I am a level one.
I'm wearing my little pin here.
I never, ever wear that.
So that was end of 20, like 2017.
And then maybe two years later,
I wanted to go on and take my level two,
the certified exam.
And I think some people really think
that that is the true sommelier test
because level one is really just
a 70 multiple choice question test.
So for level two, there's three components.
There is theory, which is kind of similar to level one,
but a lot more in depth.
There is a blind tasting portion
where you have to blind taste three reds and three whites.
And then there is a practical
where you actually have to serve
and demonstrate your beverage management knowledge.
Now, no, no, no, these are my results
for my certified sommelier exam.
So tasting results, pass.
Definitely there was some room for improvement.
My comments were solid tasting
with greater understanding demonstrated
in the white wines,
but could work a little bit better
on my grape variety markers for reds.
Fair, but I passed.
And that was kind of scary.
I was doing blind taste, practicing for it.
Me and my friend,
my friend who was practicing for the W set three, level three
and I was at the same time practicing for my level two.
So it was kind of interesting
and I got a glimpse into W set.
Theory results, pass.
And I got a comment, excellent job.
So I did very well in theory.
So two out of three, I passed.
All right, practical results, no pass.
My mechanics and my salesmanship were satisfactory.
The main reason I failed
and I know because I distinctly remember
this moment in my test,
my beer and my spirits,
but specifically my beer knowledge was not up to snuff.
And I think this is what people don't realize
for a master sommelier is we are a beverage connoisseur.
So we need to know beers.
We need to know spirits.
We need to know cigars.
We needed to know the different parts
into making different cocktails.
I had no cards.
I remember because I went back to my professor
and this was right before my exam
and I was talking to my professor and she was like,
girl, you really need to know your cocktails
and spirits really, really well.
And thank goodness she told me that
because after then I was like trying to study,
but it's not nearly like,
I don't think I realized to the level
of how they were gonna test me
in the sense of like brand names.
For example, name three London dry gin brands.
Name three different types of nut liqueurs.
Name two different Belgian beers.
And like for some people they'll be like,
oh, I know, I know, I know this.
But especially when you're are hyped on adrenaline,
you're serving champagne right now, okay?
And you're trying to remember who do I need to serve next?
Am I going clockwise?
Is my label showing?
Did I pour enough?
Like there's so many things.
You're not just answering these questions.
You are working the table,
trying to be professional at the same time.
It was hard.
It was really hard.
I did not pass my practical.
Therefore I did not pass my certified
sommelier examination.
And I'm gonna be honest.
I am adjacent to the hospitality industry.
I have worked in restaurants.
I have my own pop-up restaurant.
I really love that aspect of restaurant management.
But right now I'm not working in the restaurants.
And I think I could take this again
for another like cool 800 bucks.
But I am very proud with my results
because it kind of just shows
that like I know my wines to a sommelier level.
I just don't know my beers.
And so say what you want
and you can be like, she's a fake som.
But like I'm proud of how I did on this test.
And I know that with wines
it's just a constant learning process.
And I'm always curious.
I'm always learning.
I think having this channel
helps me keep connecting to wine.
And I love sharing my knowledge.
I love exploring different wines with you guys
and letting you guys on my journey.
But in terms of like CMS,
I just don't know if I'm ever gonna take
the level two exam again.
So that's the truth.
That is the truth
that I am not a level two certified sommelier.
I have so much respect for people
who are certified sommeliers, advanced sommeliers,
master sommeliers.
There's only currently 200
and I think 70 something master sommeliers in the world.
And I think people saw it on the Netflix special
but like only at like a smidgen
of what these professionals need to do for this exam.
It's very, very rigorous for sure.
And my point is, is that like
if you're not really in the industry
and working the floor, selling wine,
serving wine and drinks,
then like it might not be the best route for you.
I've had people come to me and be like,
should I go the CMS route?
And I'm just like, if you're not working in a restaurant
I don't know why you'd want to do that.
I think it fit my personality.
I love that interaction.
I love service.
So for me, I wanted to go that route.
But I think after this exam,
even if I did pass,
I don't think I would have kept going
because it just gets harder
if you aren't constantly on the floor serving people.
I think it shows very much
if you're with years of experience
working in restaurants versus not doing it.
So that's my two cents.
Now, WCET, things that I noticed within WCET,
it's much more in the wine making process
and also the vine growing process.
We have some of that in CMS,
but it's not nearly as robust as it is in WCET.
What I also noticed in their tastings,
I think it definitely changes as you go up,
but the end goal of when you taste for WCET
is if the quality is good, ageability,
versus for the CMS tasting,
you're really trying to pinpoint
where this wine is from, how old it is,
the styles within this wine,
and the grape variety you kind of drill down to that level.
Whereas I think for WCET level three,
you didn't really need to do that.
So this is how I would rank them from easiest to hardest.
You guys put in your opinions down below,
but I would say it's WCET level one, WCET level two,
CMS level one, WCET level three,
CMS level two, WCET diploma level four,
and then CMS advanced, which is level three.
And then, I don't know, I think Master of Wines,
so after you've completed your WCET,
then there's three stages for the Master of Wines program.
It's a lot of theory you have to write.
It's like five papers.
You can choose the topics varying from viticulture,
viniculture, wine business, trends.
Stage two, you have blind tastings.
Six to 10,000 were research paper.
There's a little bit over 400 Master of Wines currently.
Master of Wines, of course,
it's a great branding opportunity.
There's a lot of other Master of Wines YouTubers,
which I think is super, super cool.
I think for a lot of people, WCET,
it's a little bit easier to get your foot into.
I mean, you can totally do the intro CMS
without restaurant experience,
but afterwards, it's gonna show in your practicals
if you don't work in a restaurant
or have no restaurant experience.
So I recommend for most people to do WCET,
but I also just believe
that you can also just learn on your own.
I'm really happy that I chose the path
and I learned a lot through it.
I have no regrets with it.
Guys, beer.
So wild.
But anyway, that's the truth.
If someone asks me, I will forthright come clean
and I'm like, I'm level one.
So if you guys like this content
and you guys can still rock with me,
even though I'm not level two,
then please hit that thumbs up button,
subscribe to my channel, and cheers.
I'll catch you guys later.