Hannibal: The Rise of Rome's Greatest Nemesis

Hannibal. One of the most swashbuckling characters in all history. The greatest commander of the ancient world. The man who marched from Spain and took elephants over the Alps. The man who brought the Roman Republic to its knees. This is one of the most epic stories we've ever done on The History. Do not miss it. My reality, he says, is I wake up and go, I haven't done the Hannibal trilogy. He first started talking about this 18 years ago. His desire to make a trilogy about Hannibal Barca, the Carthaginian general, one of the greatest wartime generals in history. The man who, in 218 BC, led a troop of elephants over the Alps to invade Italy. I promised myself I would try to make the Hannibal trilogy. Part of creating mythology in Riddick and creating worlds like Fiest in some bizarre way was preparation for the ultimate task. He will do it, he says. So that's a profile of the actor Vin Diesel, one of your favorite actors, Tom, in Men's Health in 2021. So in that article, Vin Diesel is talking about his great ambition to do a trilogy about the life of Hannibal, the Carthaginian general. And four years on, Diesel has not yet delivered. No, he hasn't. We're still waiting for that Hannibal masterpiece. And why on earth, Tom, when it's such an amazing story, hasn't he done it? Because it's a story that would involve him taking an army, including 37 elephants, over the Alps, winning three of the most celebrated battles of all time, slaughtering enormous numbers of Romans, and bringing Rome almost to her knees. And it is so epic that I imagine the costs would be prohibitive. And actually, the person who put me on to Vin Diesel's enthusiasm for Hannibal, Marina Hyde, as I rest his entertainment, very wittily commented on this, that to make these films would cost only marginally less than an independent nuclear deterrent. Well, that is witty. I think she's not exaggerating. But Vin is obviously still dreaming. That's good, because there's a rival project I read that Denzel Washington, who has dabbled in Swords and Sandals and Gladiator 2, he's ambitious to do a Hannibal epic as well, isn't he? Although there's actually no sign of that coming to the screen either. I think this one may be kind of more in the works. I think it's for Netflix, so it may be coming soon. But I mean, again, no sign of it as yet. And the thing is, I entirely understand the obsession, because it's one I completely share. And if I were a massive Hollywood star, I would be pushing to do a Hannibal film as well. Because basically, I would say, we're going to be doing this series on Hannibal. This is what I've been looking forward to doing since we began the podcast. And if you'd asked me when I was eight, what would I want to be doing when I'm 57? This is basically it. It wouldn't be a podcast about Chatham High Street. No, Hannibal even more than Chatham High Street. Because I think this is one of the greatest stories, not just ancient history, but history full stop. So for people who don't know, this is the story of the Second Punic War, fought at the end of the third century BC. That's right, isn't it? Yeah. 218 to 201. And it's between Carthage, the great sea power of the Mediterranean, North African power, and the emerging superpower of Rome. And the Roman historian, Livy, called it the most memorable war in history. So what do you think it does? Well, you obviously do, given your enthusiasm for it. It's up there with Alexander the Great, or with the war between Athens and Sparta, or the Persian. I mean, arguably, an even greater story, because it has this extraordinary protagonist in Hannibal himself. Hannibal is up there with Alexander as one of the great commanders of ancient history of all time. But I think it has a kind of more tragic quality than the story of Alexander. Because Hannibal's desire to take on Rome is inspired less by a longing for glory and conquest. Carthage is a much less militarist society than Macedon, or even more Rome. And kind of more for a desire to save his city from a threat that he knows is only going to be growing, namely Rome. And also, undoubtedly, he wants revenge, because Carthage has already received a very bloody nose from Rome. And the tragic element is that his very attempt to try and defeat Rome, and thereby save his city, in the long run, dooms it. And this is the second series about Carthage. So we will, in due course, be coming to the story about how Rome triumphs over Carthage and ends up burning it to the ground. But in this series, fans of Carthage, fans of Hannibal, can just sit back and enjoy the ride, because everything in this is Hannibal at his absolute peak. Everything's going brilliantly for him. So we're going to be covering his invasion of Italy, the Alps, the elephants, all of that. We're going to be looking at his first two great victories that he wins at the River Trebia and Lake Trasimene. Then he has a cat and mouse game with a Roman dictator who's appointed to save Rome in the teeth of disaster, Fabius the Delayer. And then we will be culminating in our final episode in Rome's bloodiest and most terrible defeat, the Battle of Cannae. So it is non-stop drama. Very exciting. And if you're a member of the Restless History Club, of course, you can hear all those episodes right now. But before we come to Hannibal himself, this character at the center of the drama, let's have a little bit of a recap for people who didn't listen to our first series about Carthage and Rome, or perhaps have forgotten some of the details. So Carthage is a much more long-established power than Rome, isn't it? It's on the north coast of Africa. It's supposedly founded in 814 BC, so it's been going for about 500 years or so. And it's settled by emigrants from what is now Lebanon, from Tyre. And so they call it the new city, which in the Punic, the language spoken by the Phoenicians and the Carthaginians is Carthadash, so that becomes Carthage. And it has every advantage going for it. So it has magnificent natural harbors. It has very fertile hinterlands, so it can be fed very easily. And essentially today, the ruins of Carthage are part of the suburbs of the city of Tunis. And so that means that it can command the crucial straits in the Mediterranean between what is now Tunisia and Sicily. And for centuries, you mentioned that Carthage is a great naval power. It is by miles the most formidable and the richest naval power in the Western Mediterranean. And in the 3rd century BC, the beginning of the 3rd century BC, it has an empire that includes much of North Africa, a chunk of Sicily. It has Corsica, it has Sardinia, and it's also the mistress of a whole array of Phoenician colonies that docked the kind of southern coast of Iberia, of Spain. Right. But then when we get to the early 3rd century BC, so the 80s, 70s, 260s, there's a growing tension with a new kid on the block, the emerging new land power, military power, which is Rome. And that gives rise to the first Punic war, which we talked about last time, which starts in 264, I think. Is that right? Yeah. And as you said, Rome is the great military power. So it's the elephant against the whale. It's a military power against predominantly a naval power. And partly because the determination not to yield on both sides is completely implacable. The war just goes on and on and on, 23 years in all. So it's the longest continuous war in the whole of antiquity. It bleeds both sides white in terms of manpower and in terms of wealth. But in the end, it is the Carthaginians who were forced to sue for terms. And in 241, a treaty is signed that ends the war. And by its terms, Carthage surrenders all its holdings in Sicily, where it had been a major power for centuries and centuries. It has to clear out. And Sicily then becomes the first overseas province ruled by Rome. So for the first time, Rome is no longer merely an Italian power. Carthage is also obliged to pay a massive indemnity. And the combined effect of these terms imposed on the defeated city essentially is to neutralize her as a naval power. So what had traditionally been her strength. So Carthage hasn't been destroyed, but she's definitely been crippled. And so the obvious question for the Carthaginians is how is she going to come back from this? And this is the challenge that obsesses her leading men. Right. And her leading men, one in particular, will play a part in the story. And this is not yet Hannibal, but it is a man called Hamilcar, Hamilcar Barca. And Barca means the thunderbolt or the lightning bolt or something, doesn't it? Yeah. So expressive of his speed, his ability to incinerate his opponents. Even the Romans acknowledged that Barca, lightning bolt, was an excellent description of him. So to quote Cornelius Nepos, who was writing a couple of centuries afterwards, looking back at this time, he wrote about Hamilcar, wherever he had personal command, he would never yield to the enemy nor give them opportunity to inflict damage on his forces. Quite the opposite indeed, for he would often go on the offensive should the opportunity present itself and invariably emerged victorious. And that kind of Roman emphasis on Hamilcar's ability to go on the offensive. Firstly, that is a Roman recognizing a Roman quality in a Carthaginian. Most Carthaginians are not aggressive militarily in the way that, say, a Roman would be. But also I think he is looking ahead to Hamilcar's ability to muster resources in a way that will enable him to prepare for revenge against the Romans for defeating Carthage in the first Punic war. And Hamilcar himself is a very seasoned Roman fighter. So it's Hamilcar in the dying days of the first Punic war who had led the desperate attempt by the Carthaginians in Sicily to defeat the Romans there. It fails basically because the Carthaginian fleet is defeated and so therefore Hamilcar can no longer be supplied from Carthage. And when Carthage is thereby forced to surrender, it's Hamilcar who is entrusted by the Carthaginians to negotiate the terms. And people who listen to our episode about this may remember that in the wake of Carthage's defeat, they're so skint that they can't afford to pay the mercenaries who provided them with the bulk of their army. The mercenaries rebel. At one point, it looks as though Carthage is going to fall to them. And it's Hamilcar who returns from Sicily, leads the campaign against the mercenaries, and ends up defeating them and executing them all in very horrible and bloody ways. That was a satisfyingly bloody story, wasn't it? The defeat of the mercenaries. So, I mean, he hates Rome. He has massive, massive unfinished business with Rome, doesn't he? But it's more than just political. It's personal for Hamilcar. Is that right? He resents Rome as an opponent in war who has defeated Carthage. So that's understandable. But in due course, his resentment of that, I think is definitely spiced by a personal sense of betrayal because Hamilcar has negotiated these terms with the Romans. And the Romans take advantage of the mercenary war to tighten the screws on Carthage. So essentially exploiting her misfortune. So in 237, that is the year after the defeat of the mercenaries, the Carthaginians want to go and stabilize their position in Sardinia because there have been kind of mercenary uprisings there as well. So they raise an army to go and do that. And the Romans, in a display of coarse and brutal cynicism that is entirely typical of their statecraft, denounce this army as being in breach of the treaty. They say, you're raising this army to come and attack us. And so a Roman embassy arrives in Carthage to demand revisions to the peace treaty because they say that the And the Romans say, you've got to surrender Sardinia and Corsica to us. This was never part of the original treaty. And we are going to increase the indemnity that you need to pay us. So essentially it is massively exploiting Carthage's hour of need and weakness. And so they have no choice but to accept these terms. And Hamilcar is left incredibly embittered. So to quote a historian of the period, resentful of the injustice, but powerless to prevent it. So this is not a kind of man who is going to take it lying down. So how can he go about doing this, Tom? Because you said earlier that Carthage has been hamstrung. So how can they plausibly hope to go toe-to-toe with the Romans once again? Well, so they've lost their land empire in Sicily, in Sardinia and Corsica, but there is another obvious place where Hamilcar can start building a power centre. And this is Spain. So I mentioned that Phoenician colonies have been planted along the southern coast of Spain and actually beyond the Pillars of Hercules, so the Straits of Gibraltar, probably the oldest of the lot is Gardez, which will become Cadiz. And these settlements are very strategically positioned. So as with Carthage, very rich agricultural hinterland, so there's opportunity there to expand. But even more, it is potentially incredibly rich because there are a lot of precious minerals just waiting to be mined. And also, if these minerals can be kind of turned into gold to pay for mercenaries, to conquer more territory, then that conquered territory can supply further troops because Spain is obviously a massive, massive reserve of manpower. Carthage has never actually established a land empire in Spain. To repeat, it is not a city that is interested in establishing kind of direct rule over vast swathes of territory in the way that the Romans have shown themselves to be. But Hamilcar, having looked at the way that Rome has risen to power, recognises, I think, that the only way that Carthage can really survive, let alone defeat the Romans, is to play that game as well. And so his plan essentially is to transform the kind of loose hegemony that Carthage had always exercised over these Phoenician colonies in Spain into a kind of direct rule, and then using these Phoenician ports as bases to expand inland and carve out a Spanish dominion that will be able to replace the empire lost in Sicily, Sardinia and Corsica, and hopefully to provide even greater reserves because of the mineral wealth and the possible reserves of manpower. So on paper this looks like a brilliant plan, right? You can get the silver and the minerals from Spain, you can pick up mercenaries and conscripts from the Iberian peoples, you'll be militarily stronger, you'll be financially stronger, and you can basically begin to rebuild your reputation and you can plausibly hope to have another go at the Romans later on. And it's also good for Hamilcar personally, isn't it? Because if he's able to pull this off, it will entrench his position as the big man in the state. Does I think almost certainly. Politics in Carthage is pretty carnivorous. The penalty for failure is very serious. Generals who lose battles are often crucified. So I think for Hamilcar, who has had personal experience of people trying to stab him in the back while he's been busy fighting the Romans, I think the chance of establishing a great centre of power, not just for Carthage, but for himself and establishing a dynasty there, win-win. Everything is great about it. And it's very clear that Hamilcar is an extremely enthusiastic family man. So we know he has at least three daughters, we don't know their names, but we do know that one of them is married off to Hamilcar's closest political ally in Carthage, who is a guy called Hasdrubal the Handsome. And people who remember our first series may also remember the fact that there are only about three names in Carthage, of which Hasdrubal is probably the most common. So this is Hasdrubal the Handsome because he's such a good looking guy. So good news for Hamilcar's daughter. And in 237, when Hamilcar leaves Carthage for Spain, Hasdrubal is sailing with him. Hamilcar also has three sons. The youngest of these is called Mago. Then inevitably there's a guy called Hasdrubal. So that's Hamilcar's son. And the oldest is a young lad called Hannibal. And this is the Hannibal. So in 237, when Hamilcar is preparing to leave for Spain, Hannibal is only nine years old. And you might think, you know, that's probably too young to be taken to a war zone. But Hamilcar thinks not. And there is a very, very famous anecdote with which we finished our last series on Carthage. But I think it bears repeating because it is very, very revealing about what will motivate Hannibal. And he tells it to various people later in life. So it almost certainly comes from his own lips. And he describes how he joins his father in the great temple of Baal in Carthage, where his father is making sacrifice. And this is supposedly how Hannibal described it. The omens proved favorable. Hamilcar poured a libation to the gods and performed the customary ceremonies, after which he ordered all those who were present at the sacrifice to stand back a little way from the altar. Then he called Hannibal to him and asked him affectionately whether he wished to accompany the expedition. So that's to Spain. Hannibal was overjoyed to accept and like a boy begged to be allowed to go. His father then took him by the hand, led him up to the altar and commanded him to lay his hand upon the victim and swear an oath that he would never become a friend to the Romans. Strong stuff. Strong stuff. And it's a promise that he will keep all his life. And you think this anecdote is probably true? Because Hannibal tells it himself. He probably is, yeah. Okay. So first of all, he has to go to Spain. And actually, this is an unbelievable thing. He goes to Spain at the age of nine and he will not return to Carthage until he's 42. Is that right? Yeah. He is raised in this colonial environment, this process of conquest, then of rule in Spain. And in due course, he will come to take command of it. But first, of course, he has to serve his apprenticeship. And he does this under two formidable men in succession. And the first, of course, is his father, Hamilcar Barca. And even though Hamilcar is probably the most formidable man in Carthage, there's no guarantee of success. He doesn't have that many men. This is Carthage's whole problem, that they don't have a huge citizen body. So generally, they rely on mercenaries, but now they don't have much money. So they can't afford many mercenaries. So the estimation of Dexter Hoyos in his very good book on this Hannibal's dynasty, he reckons probably Hamilcar is sailing to Spain with about 20,000 men. So not that many at all. And it's not surprising, that being so, he needs money. He sails to Gardez, to Cadiz, and what he wants is the silver and copper mines along the Rio Tinto that lie about 60 miles inland from Gardez, and which is rich across the whole of the Mediterranean. So it features in the Bible as Tarshish, a land of fabled wealth. According to tradition, the tribes who live there are so rich that their cattle troughs are made of silver. So obviously, if you're a colonial administrator and desperately need cash, this is exactly the kind of place that you would go straight for. And he does meet with opposition. Yeah. The good news for him though, is that although they're rich, they're not as good at fighting as he is. He will sort of encircle them, won't he? That's his strategy. He encircles them and then he completely massacres them. I mean, he's a pretty ferocious man, Hamilcar Barca. Yes. The strategy of surrounding your enemies and then massacring them. And if young Hannibal is at his side when he's pursuing these tactics, I mean, this is something that clearly Hannibal will bear in mind in due course, because it becomes a favourite tactic of Hannibal himself. And Hamilcar is very brutal in the process of conquering and pacifying Spain. So the leaders of tribes who oppose him are tortured and crucified, and the Carthaginians are very good at torture, as anyone who's listened to our episode on the war with the mercenaries will know. And the men of the tribes that have been defeated will be enrolled into his own forces and they will be given incredibly lavish pay. So this is the other side of the conquest, that Hamilcar is very brutal to those who oppose him. Those who back him, he will lavish all the gold that he's annexed and conquered. And so this enables him to start spreading Carthaginian rule inland from the coast. And after about a decade of operations in Spain, Hamilcar has a garrison there that's probably around 50,000 men. So he's more than doubled it in the space of a decade. And he's incredibly wealthy. His coffers are overflowing with silver. And unsurprisingly, the Romans are not really very thrilled about this. So by 231, they're sufficiently alarmed that they send an embassy to Hamilcar, basically saying, hey, what's going on here? Hamilcar, his reply is, well, I'm raising funds to pay off the war indemnity that you illegally raised. And the Romans have to suck this up, right? Because, I mean, it's a good reply. And also, as Hamilcar can point out, it's none of their business what he's getting up to in Spain. This isn't covered by the treaty. So the Roman ambassadors, they're forced to bite their tongues and go back and accept the existence of this growing Carthaginian empire in Spain. But then a bad blow for Hamilcar. Well, a very bad blow, the worst. Exceedingly bad blow. He dies. In battle against whom? Against a Spanish tribe in the interior. And the stories about how he dies become ever more extravagant as time goes by. So one historian who's relatively close in time to the event and tends to be more sober, he reports in very vague terms that Hamilcar ended his career in a manner which formed a fitting climax to his achievements, for he lost his life after fighting gallantly and with complete disregard for his personal safety in a battle against one of the strongest and most warlike of the tribes. So it's a good death. It's a heroic death. But accounts of exactly how he dies then start to get inflated. So a later report says that he is betrayed by a local chieftain while undertaking a siege. That Hamilcar's forces are taken by surprise and they're forced to withdraw. That his two elder sons, so that's Hannibal and Hamilcar, they are sent off by Hamilcar along one road and he then deliberately draws away the mass of the enemy by taking another road. He's about to be overtaken by his pursuers and ahead of him there's a raging river and he plunges into the river on his horse and drowns. So essentially he sacrifices himself for his two sons. I mean whether true or not we don't know. But he's like a kind of a lion defending his cubs. I think that's dying rather than seeing his cubs exterminated. That's the theme. There's an element with him, isn't there, of the Philip of Macedon, Philip II. For sure, yeah. So he ends up being famous as Hannibal's father but in both cases you can argue the son's achievements are completely predicated on the successes of their father. So in both cases their father leaves them with a lot of silver, a military machine, a load of officers they can rely on, a sense of prestige, you know, all the groundwork has been done basically. Yeah and a kind of military education as well. I mean there is a difference though that Hannibal, unlike Alexander, doesn't succeed his father immediately because he's still only 18. He's not a king, you know, they don't have kings. So the leader of the Carthaginians in Spain is an elected post essentially by the army, by the Carthaginians in the army. And I think that people feel, well an 18 year old, he's too young. So they opt instead for Hasdrubal the Handsome who is the young Hannibal's brother-in-law, Hasdrubal's son-in-law, very good looking, Hannibal Carr's close political ally, has been with him in Spain, knows the ropes and Hannibal Carr the Handsome is very effective. I mean he's a worthy successor to Hannibal Carr and like Hannibal Carr had done he kind of adopts this carrot and stick approach to the Iberians, to the peoples of Spain. So he marries the daughter of an Iberian king. So you asked about the dynastic quality, I mean there's a sense that this Carthaginian dynasty is starting to marry into local royalty. He has himself proclaimed not just by the Carthaginians who have voted for him but by the Iberians as a general with unlimited power. So he's rooting his authority in the colonized as well as the colonizers and even as he's doing that he's continuing this policy of absolutely brutal suppression of any hint of rebellion and his first target obviously is the tribe that had killed Hannibal Carr, they all get wiped out. So he is able to push Carthaginian control ever northwards towards the river Tagus which is the great river that kind of flows through central Spain and this empire needs a new capital Hasdrubal decides and so this is what he does, he founds a new capital and he calls it stunning originality Carthage, which of course means new city but the Romans in due course will call it new Carthage which effectively would be new new city but we'll call it new Carthage because otherwise it's very confusing but the Carthaginians in Spain just called it Carthage. Okay and this is now in Spain? Yeah so it's Cartagena yes yeah which to this day I gather is still one of the kind of the main centers of the Spanish navy so it's clearly as the original Carthage is a natural port a great stronghold and it stands there are kind of four hills dotted around this great natural harbor on the largest of these Hasdrubal builds a great temple to the Carthaginian god of healing and on the second largest he builds his own vast palace which is adorned with all the wealth of Spain and from there he can sit and look down at the harbor and see growing numbers of ships some of the military but lots of the merchant ships swelling his coffers he's got the silver mines inland he's got the shipping routes descending on his great capital he's able to employ the most cutting-edge military architects to build him walls around the city and so it's not surprising that it comes to be hailed by a near contemporary as the chief ornament and the center of the Carthaginian empire in Spain. So by the end of the 220s the Carthaginians are back I mean they have an empire now they have a land colony they have a lot of money they have all the silver they have recruits they have rebuilt a lot of what they'd lost in the first Punic war against the Romans why therefore have very few listeners to this podcast heard of Hasdrubal what happened to him? In 221 BC he gets assassinated by the slave of a disgruntled Iberian ally oh okay and so you know that's the end of him yeah but as you say he has absolutely played his part in reconstituting Carthaginian power possibly on a scale that is even greater than the power that Carthage had enjoyed before the first war with Rome I mean so absolutely Carthage is back she's a great power she can go eyeball to eyeball with Rome again but there is obviously a slight paradox here which is that all the power is now focused in Spain and Carthage herself back in Africa is slightly pallid in comparison right it lacks the reserves it lacks the wealth that is now starting to develop in new Carthage so that means that whoever is elected by the Carthaginian army to succeed Hasdrubal as the leader of Carthaginian power in Spain is probably in a position to prosecute almost an independent foreign policy the fact that it had always been a problem for the Carthaginian ability to project wars that the senate back in Carthage is full of kind of rival power brokers all hate each other now the Barcids the dynasty of Hamilcar Barca they don't have to worry about that they have their wealth they have their army they can essentially do what they like and so obviously the crucial issue now is who will succeed Hasdrubal the handsome who will take command of these incredible military resources who indeed I bet nobody can guess so come back after the break to find out if that person is Hannibal the question of Hasdrubal's successor was quickly decided the military vote was in favor of the young Hannibal who was at once escorted to headquarters where he was unanimously and enthusiastically acclaimed the old soldiers felt that in the person of this young man Hamilcar himself was restored to them in the features and expression of the son's face the troops saw the father once again the same dynamism in his look the same fire in his eyes so that was the Roman historian Livy talking about the election of Hannibal as the new leader of the Carthaginians in Spain the Carthaginian troops so a real bombshell there none of us were expecting that no one saw that coming so he's been chosen by the troops he then gets the seal of approval from the senate and from the citizens assembly back in Carthage so there's nobody questioning his legitimacy we do a lot of succession crises on the rest of the street yeah but this is not one of them no he is in prime position so let's go in to Hannibal the character the man that Vin Diesel wishes to play on film I mean does he look like Vin Diesel what's he look like what's his personality what's his temperament tell all Tom well the only physical description we have of Hannibal is Livy's and Livy's writing in the age of Augustus so almost 200 years after yeah and Livy says that he has a face expressive of dynamism and fire in his eyes yeah but this you know I mean it's kind of pretty generic I guess right he doesn't say whether Hannibal is tall or short whether he's bearded or clean-shaven there are silver coins that are minted and there's a figure of a man on it that some people have suggested might be Hannibal but it's almost certainly a god so we don't really know what Hannibal looked like you asked does it look like Vin Diesel or indeed Denzel Washington absolutely not because both of those are not as young as they were Hannibal is is very young he's only in his mid-20s we know on top of that that Hannibal was proud of his descent from one of the original colonists that had settled Carthage way back in you know the dawn of time right when they had sailed from Tyre so presumably I mean he has a kind of look of the Lebanese a kind maybe a young Nassim Nicholas Taleb perhaps well when I read this I had a look I looked for famous Lebanese celebrities and you know the Hollywood star who was born to play him who was of Lebanese descent himself Vince Vaughn Vince Vaughn he's not as young as he was is he well he perhaps just missed the boat but I think Vince Vaughn Vince Vaughn playing Hannibal would be a really unexpected Vin Diesel would be raging at that he'd be furious yeah Vince Vaughn got in first well my friend George Saab who is Lebanese and I can't see him doing it either okay but no one knows who he is Tom no I know I know right well so we don't really know what he looked like but he kind of probably looked vaguely Lebanese what about his personality did he have Vin Diesel or Vince Vaughn's personality well again Livvy gives a famous description of him and claims that he's a compound of extraordinary qualities and terrible kind of malignant faults very much like us so his qualities Livvy says that he's brave he's very tough indefatigable both physically and mentally he could endure with equal ease extremes of heat or cold so very like Alexander and indeed you Dominic yeah point yourself yeah he dressed ate and drank like a common soldier you know he didn't have a special tent he does roll himself up in his cloak and no matter how cold it was right very very smart so again like you deep penetrating intelligence yeah and then Dominic his vices yeah let's get to the vices so Livvy says he has inhuman cruelty a more than Punic perfidy a total disregard of truth honor and the gods of the sanctity of an oath and of all that other men hold sacred so again it's uncanny eerie very eerie I mean I think several things to say about that portrait obviously Livvy is a Roman and so he's giving a very Roman perspective we just don't have any Carthaginian records isn't it funny how two of the most celebrated characters in all antiquity Cleopatra and Hannibal are basically Roman supervillains all we know of them comes from the Romans and of course to a degree he's a villain but as with Cleopatra they both admire and dread this character right the Romans are always and Livvy being the exemplar always emphasize and acknowledge his qualities which are of course self-evident from his record because Hannibal would prove himself one of the greatest generals of all time but there's also the fact that the more impressive Hannibal is acknowledged to be the more impressive the feat of the Romans in defeating him yeah and Hannibal of course as a commander is in a slightly different elevated position to Cleopatra for the Romans it's humiliating to be fighting a woman whereas Hannibal is a foe who's kind of equal you know he's a worthy adversary what about the Punic perfidy though Punic the word that the Romans use to apply to the Carthaginians this is a stereotype their sense that all Carthaginians are treacherous and tricky is absolutely standard and I think in Hannibal's case it comes from the fact that he is indeed very cunning that he has an incredible mastery of stratagems and traps and essentially what Livvy is complaining about is Hannibal's consistent ability to make a succession of Roman commanders look absolute idiots right so you can kind of see where that's coming from the other accusations that he's an oath breaker that has no respect for the gods we will see whether that's fair or not in due course okay so what's obviously happening with Hannibal is that his father has taken him to Spain when he was nine and has basically trained him yeah ever since then to command a war machine yeah the end goal being that one day you will take on the Romans is that right I mean is it as explicit as that well I already mentioned that you know the idea of Hamilcar as a lion and his three sons Hannibal, Hasdrubal and Mago as his cubs and there's a famous saying that the Romans attribute to Hamilcar that these are the lion cubs I am rearing for the destruction of Rome I think that's an exaggeration as we will see I don't think Hannibal ever aimed to destroy Rome destroying your enemies is something that the Romans do the Carthaginians I don't think were planning to do that but indisputably Hamilcar's ambition in raising his three sons for war is to restore Carthage's status as great power and if this involves going to war with Rome as Hamilcar clearly suspects it will then so be it you know it will be the ultimate trial for his dynasty and for his city and so Hannibal needs to be prepared for that trial and it has to be said that Hamilcar you know prepares his elder son for this great test unbelievably well right and then when Hasdrubal the handsome succeeded Hamilcar he had Hannibal as his cavalry commander didn't he there's no feuding there you might expect there to be tension between the two of them but not at all no and again there's a comparison with Alexander who as a young man commands Philip's cavalry by the time that Hannibal becomes supremo in Spain he has established himself as a very formidable cavalry commander but more than that I think it's given him a sense of the importance and the potential of cavalry in expediting a sense of mobility and this again is something that he will display throughout his career and probably you know it's hard to think of a contemporary cavalry commander who could outclass Hannibal by the time he becomes kind of supremo in 221 and this is again significant for Carthage's prospects in any land war with the Romans because the Roman cavalry is definitely secondary to their infantry right which are heavy heavily armored and therefore potentially ponderous so there is scope there you know there are things that Hannibal can make play with and again just to reiterate this comparison with Alexander the Great he's inherited this war machine he's got this kind of early training as a cavalry commander he's obviously personally very very charismatic when he pointed out that Hasdrubal doesn't in any way seem to have been jealous of him he clearly admires and respects Hannibal even though he's younger and his obvious successor he has all these young officers who've grown up around him one of whom may go his youngest brother seems to have been particularly close to him and he even has a Greek tutor who's a Spartan who will accompany Hannibal on his campaigns and write up a biography again that's very Alexander isn't it having your own historian. But do you think it's plausible that he was consciously modeling himself from Alexander or is that overstated are we projecting that onto him with hindsight? Well Alexander's influence is manifested to the degree that Alexander is an influence on every general in the century that follows his great course of campaigns but I don't think that Hannibal has anything like Alexander's desire to just push eastwards ever eastwards Hannibal's goals are much more succinct much more circumscribed he essentially wants to re-establish Carthage as the greatest power in the western Mediterranean that will obviously require Rome to be humbled to a degree and so Hannibal is prepared to do that but he doesn't I think want to obliterate Rome so if this means war with Rome then Hannibal is prepared to go to war with Rome but I think his preference would probably be I'd rather not have war if we can possibly avoid it he wants his empire in Spain and if he can develop that empire in Spain without war with Rome then all the better But that's where the storm clouds of war begin together isn't it in Spain? They do yeah The Romans by now have woken up to the fact that Spain is very lucrative and Spain is going to be the flashpoint because they are not going to allow the Carthaginians just to occupy the entire peninsula Yeah we say that but actually the first treaty that establishes the relations between Carthage and Rome in Spain it's brought about by a Roman position of weakness so in 225 the Romans are facing an invasion of Gauls so Gaul what's now France and the Gauls had already a century or so before invaded Italy and actually captured Rome so the Romans are very very anxious about Gauls they know that they're a menacing enemy this invasion in 225 causes them great alarm and they're anxious that if the Gauls do invade Italy then this will provide scope for the Carthaginians to start messing around so they sent an embassy to Hasdrubal who's still alive at this point and they sign a formal treaty and by its terms the Carthaginians pledge not to cross the river Ebro which is a great river that joins the Mediterranean south of where Barcelona is today and then it flows from the northwest in a line parallel to the Pyrenees and it's agreed that the Romans will accept everywhere south of the Ebro as being Carthaginian and in the north the Carthaginians will not kind of intrude north of the Ebro but having signed this treaty the Romans then can't help hedging their bets and so shortly after they've signed this treaty with Hasdrubal pledging that they won't poke their noses into Carthaginian affairs south of the river Ebro they annihilate the Gallic invasion which means that that threat is removed and they start being slightly regretting this treaty that they've signed and so it's around the same time and surely not coincidentally that they establish friendly relations with an Iberian town called Saguntum which lies on the coast so very good communications with Rome by the sea and the Saguntines become the kind of the Romans eyes in Spain kind of sending the Romans intelligence updates on what the Carthaginians are up to and they are qualified to do this because they lie just beyond the reach of Carthaginian control however there is no guarantee that this will be permanently the case because Saguntum lies five miles south of the Ebro which means that according to the treaty that the Romans have signed with the Carthaginians they are within the Carthaginian sphere of influence. I was about to say when you look at a map it's now Saguntum which is not far from Valencia in the south of Spain it clearly is a massive infringement of the treaty. It absolutely is and it's absolutely kind of classic this is traditional Roman mischief making there is massive scope for a bust up however the crisis does take time to brew because to begin with Hannibal's focus is not on Saguntum what he wants to do is secure Carthaginian control deep into central Spain along the line of the river Tagus this river that flows through the centre of the peninsula and he's essentially following Hasdrubal the handsome's policy so he too takes a Spanish wife you know he wants to make sure of the loyalty of the Iberians as well as of the Carthaginians again he's very happy to take the fight to those Iberians who oppose him he fights two brilliant campaigns in 222-221 he wins his first major pitched battle it's against enemies who massively outnumber him he wipes them out by drawing them in he tricks them divides them up surrounds them wipes them out with elephants so again there's lots of kind of pointers there to the kind of military courses he'll be adopting he storms towns he takes loot he rewards his troops very very lavishly and it becomes apparent that his men really adore him because he gives them victory he makes them rich and it's evident that he cares for them kind of very very deeply so the more campaigns Hannibal conducts the more he can be confident that his war machine is really primed and ready to go and now that he's got almost the whole of central Spain conquered his eye turns to the last stretch south of the Ebro by which according to a treaty with Rome he's entitled to conquer and that's the coastal stretch which of course includes Saguntum and so in the year 220 at the end of the campaigning season he returns to New Carthage everybody knows that Saguntum is ready for the following year and he finds a Roman embassy waiting for him. Crikey and so do they give him what a settlement an ultimatum what have they got in their locker? They issue him a formal caution and to quote Livy that he should leave the people of Saguntum in peace as allies of the Roman people and Hannibal treats this absolute scorn I mean he he clearly finds the tone of the ambassadors very offensive you know Carthage and Rome have this treaty he can do what he likes to Saguntum by the terms of that treaty and I think more than that it would have reminded him of how the Romans have played this trick before because essentially the war in Sicily that kicked off the first Punic war so the first great conflict between Rome and Carthage the Romans have pulled exactly the same stunt they had invaded Sicily with the defense that they were defending friends that they'd recruited in Sicily yeah and that had obviously ended up with the Romans conquering the whole island and Hannibal knows the Romans have form here he's determined not to allow the Romans to get a foothold in Spain and to try and play the same trick there so he plays the Romans at their own game and he says that he you know he has friends in Saguntum and they're being menaced by hostile faction by the Romans so basically it's his moral duty to attack and right and capture Saguntum I mean he's clearly studied Roman diplomacy as well and he's doing exactly what the Romans do so we're in 220 so you can see very clearly how 219, 218, 217 this might lead to war right there's this flashpoint in the irreconcilable positions yeah because I think it's clear that in 219 Hannibal is absolutely set on attacking Saguntum but he didn't have to right so there were even at the time there were ancient historians ancient authors who thought he could have made a different choice and then history would have unfolded completely differently yes so it was said in the wake of the war Hannibal's war that you know he could have asked the Romans to hand back Sardinia for instance and to remit the indemnity that had been illegally imposed on them were they ever going to do that that seems so un-Roman seems so unlikely that they would ever have done that right that's obviously why Hannibal never even thought to adopt that policy because it was never going to happen right the Romans would never have agreed to pay something to surrender Sardinia because that's not what the Romans do and anyway Hannibal is probably thinking now suppose I do attack and annex Saguntum you know what are the Romans going to do about it Rome is a long way from Spain yeah are they really going to risk war over this one city and even if they do bring it on you know I've got this amazing army I'm ready to go it's clear that Hannibal is not alone in thinking this the senate back in Carthage think this too because the Roman embassy that had been to see Hannibal then go to Carthage to complain about Hannibal's behavior and the senate there even though lots of them don't particularly like Hannibal and they're kind of jealous of him they basically say yeah we're not having this you know so essentially there is a Carthaginian united front and this means that in the early summer of 219 Hannibal embarks on the siege of Saguntum knowing that he has the full backing of everyone in his native city and yet at first I mean you've been talking up Hannibal and his war machine but at first that siege of Saguntum doesn't go terribly well for him no it's a disaster actually he gets wounded in the thigh which isn't very helpful and I think in general Hannibal is better in the field than he is kind of laying siege to cities so all through the summer all through the autumn into the winter Saguntum still hasn't fallen and had the Romans intervened then it could potentially have been a real problem for Hannibal but the Romans don't intervene and the reason for that is essentially it's a bit like Britain in the 30s you know there's a massive disagreement there's a kind of war party and they're saying you know we've got to do this or else you know it's going to lead to disaster and there are others who say oh I'm not sure about that and so these disagreements in Rome enable Hannibal to prosecute the siege until in early 218 the city finally falls the city is stripped of all its treasure the population are either slaughtered or sold into slavery it's an absolute triumph for Hannibal and back in Rome the news of this prompts intense feelings of anger but also I think of shame and from this point on the Romans will never cease to characterize the capture of Saguntum as a terrible war crime of the kind that they themselves would never commit. I mean this it seems like such a standard thing but also the Romans did all the time. Absolutely is so the hypocrisy of the Romans in this I think is quite something and I think that there are still elements within the Roman senate who recognize this so there is a still I wish it's not exactly a peace party but it's a faction that says oh are we really sure we want to go to war over this yeah and this faction is led by a very distinguished senatorial figure called Quintus Fabius Maximus Berucosus so warty a bit like Oliver Cromwell he's got a wart on his nose right and he says look before we declare war let's put out the peace feelers again let's send an embassy to Carthage you know let's see if we can open feelers to Hannibal's enemies in Carthage and just try and avoid open war and I think this is partly because you know they think the war might be quite difficult but also because genuinely the Romans are a very kind of moralistic people and they don't want the guilt of starting the war they're trying to absolutely pin the blame for any conflict on the Carthaginians right so Roman embassy goes to Carthage and they arrive there but despite this kind of you know let's go negotiate with the Carthaginians they're Romans they're not really there to negotiate and their starting demand is so obviously impossible that effectively they're wasting their breath and their starting demand is that Hannibal should be surrendered to the Romans and there's no way that the Carthaginians are going to do this even Hannibal's bitterest enemies can recognize that if they hand over the guy who's in charge of Carthaginian Spain that will be the end of Spain you know the Romans will move in no question yeah of course and so negotiations go nowhere and the leading Roman ambassador who may be Quintus Fabius Maximus or perhaps his cousin the sources are contradictory he stands up a very famous scene and I'll quote a Roman source that describes it he pointed to the bosom of his toga and declared to the Carthaginian senate that in its folds he carried both peace and war and that he would let fall from it whichever they instructed him to leave the Carthaginian chief magistrate answered that he should bring out whichever he thought best and when the envoy replied that it would be war many of the senators so those are the Carthaginians shouted at once we accept it it was on these terms that the senate and the Roman ambassadors parted so the storm clouds of war have not merely gathered Tom the storm is underway yeah as Chris Morris would say it's war it is war and there's so much to come in this story there's elephants there's crossing the Alps there's tremendous battles the battle of Trebia the battle of Lake Trasimene and finally at the end of this mighty series one of the great battles in all ancient history indeed in history full stop the battle of Cannae so Tom what can people do if they want to hear all this story right away well Dominic in a stunning innovation we've set up a private club which enables you to access all four episodes and it's very simple you go to the rest is history.com and very very reasonably prized isn't it Dominic very incredibly giving it away yeah so that's what you can do and you can get all four episodes now and listen these episodes will be some of the most epic the most swashbuckling and the most bloody and the most glamorous that we've ever done in the rest is history do not miss it Tom thank you so much for that and we will see you next time bye