In this relationship psychology video, written and narrated by Alain de Botton, the concept of "emotional etymology" is introduced to explain bitter arguments between couples over seemingly minor issues. The film suggests that most relationship conflicts are not driven by malice or deep incompatibility, but rather by translation errors. While partners use the exact same words and terms, they frequently operate from two completely different personal dictionaries shaped by their respective childhood pasts and family backgrounds. By taking the time to pause fights and unravel these underlying definitions, couples can discover mutual sympathy, de-escalate rage, and avoid unnecessary breakups.
In our worst moments in couples, we tend to assume that our problems are unfixable,
that we simply don't get on, that we're the wrong sort of people to be together.
What we tend not to do is imagine that we have a problem of dictionaries,
that our fundamental problem is that our partner and ourselves are, beneath the surface,
following dictionary definitions that don't align.
We're squabbling because we don't understand what the same things mean for each one of us.
Because we're using the same words and terms without realising that each of us
has an entirely different understanding of their natures.
We imagine, as we try to live with someone else,
that there isn't a gap in the way that we both define concepts like, for example,
delays in answering a message, or leaving the bathroom messy, or spending time with friends.
It simply doesn't occur to us, who've been wielding certain phrases and
one way since early adolescence, that we might have encountered someone
who sees them very differently.
It appears self-evident to us that a messy bathroom means a bathroom whose owner has
shown us no respect, who's vicious, unkind, uncaring, and out to harm us.
It's totally natural, as natural as our understanding of the word chair or glass,
that spending time with friends means a chance to rejuvenate,
to take the pressure off a couple and achieve some necessary distance
before returning to cosiness once more.
What we're forgetting in all this is the noble and arcane discipline of etymology,
that is, the history and genealogy of language.
It's the people we call etymologists who will carefully trace where a given word comes from.
They will tell us, for example, that window comes from the old Norse word
vindauga, meaning wind eye,
or that clue comes from the Greek klothos, meaning ball of thread,
after that thread that Ariadne gave Theseus to escape the labyrinth.
Standard etymology is all very well, but what we need as much, if not more of,
is a form of emotional etymology,
that is, an effort to trace back words and terms to their sources in the lives of lovers.
Couples need to see that they're fighting very often
simply because they are using the same terms in different ways.
A habit of leaving a bathroom in a mess may not, in fact, in one's own dictionary,
stem from any kind of desire to harm.
Maybe it just emerged from a wish to escape a punishing parental figure,
who, while emotionally very cold, placed undue and unwelcome emphasis on etiquette and order.
Just as in a neighbouring dictionary, the very same phrase might stand for
shallowness and selfishness, for imitating the behaviour of a despised step-parent.
It might be an emblem of disdain and cruelty.
All this points to what we should do in our arguments.
Before we imagine what our partner means,
before we settle on an explanation that involves insult and a desire to harm,
we should always take care to remember dictionaries.
We should pause our fights to wonder if our partner isn't simply mad or evil.
They may just have a different dictionary definition in mind.
We need to do one another the favour of some dictionary work.
We should ask one another what a term means,
and then analyse how it came to have this meaning for them.
We may not be beyond comprehension at all.
We may not need to split up.
We just need to understand what is in our respective dictionaries and why.