In this episode of Cinema Therapy, licensed therapist Jonathan Decker and filmmaker Alan Seawright analyze the relationship dynamics in Ang Lee's classic film adaptation of Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility. The duo explores the difference between infatuation and love by ranking the film's main couples from least healthy to healthiest. They dissect the lack of integrity in Marianne and Willoughby's romance, the deep longing and societal pressures surrounding Elinor and Edward, and why Colonel Brandon represents a genuinely good partner for Marianne. Through a therapeutic lens, they highlight key qualities to look for in a healthy relationship, such as trust, consistency, and selflessness.#cinematherapy#senseandsensibility#janeausten#relationshipadvice#moviereview#therapy#alanrickman#emmathompston#romance#filmanalysis
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Jonathan Decker and Alan Seawright analyze the romantic dynamics in *Sense and Sensibility*, ranking the couples based on emotional health. They contrast impulsive infatuation with mature love, arguing that true partnership is defined by consistency, integrity, and selflessness rather than mere passion or performative kindness.
Love is not love.
Marianne and Willoughby?
Willoughby!
Willoughby is not constant, he is not steady,
he is not consistent.
Her boxes are based on an immature concept of what love is.
Eleanor and Edward, she's been through a lot.
She has resigned to, I'm probably going to die alone.
I've come here with no expectations.
Love is trust, love is consistency, love is selflessness.
Marianne and Brandon, he is the polar opposite
of a nice guy, he is a good man.
Colonel Brandon can get it.
He is so attractive in this movie.
I can't even handle it.
I like women, I think.
Hello folks and welcome to Cinema Therapy.
I'm Jonathan Decker, licensed therapist who loves movies.
This is...
Alan Seawright, professional filmmaker who needs therapy.
What's going on my friend?
We are going to do a movie couples therapy
on Ang Lee's, I've heard it both ways.
Sense and Sensibility based on the Jane Austen classic.
This is such a wonderful adaptation.
Okay, hot take.
Is this the best filmed Jane Austen adaptation of all time?
No, that's clueless.
Ugh, as if.
No, actually I think you're right.
I think it is this one.
I think it's this one.
So I'm going to rank the couples.
Okay.
And I'm going to therapize them.
Ooh.
Here we go.
So we're ranking from least healthy to most sumptuous.
Don't argue me.
I won't, it's an Ang Lee film.
All right.
They are sumptuous.
Let's do this.
We are starting with Marianne and-
Willoughby?
Willoughby.
Why are you saying it that way?
What?
You're saying it weird.
Saying what weird?
Willoughby.
Is he the worst one?
Oh, spoiler alert.
Let's go.
My goodness.
Mr. Willoughby, what a pleasure to see you again.
Pleasure is all mine, I can assure you.
I trust Miss Marianne has not caught cold?
You found out my name?
But of course, the neighborhood is crawling
with my spies.
Fun fact, even though he's courting Kate Winslet
in this film, in real life, he is married to Emma Thompson.
That's her husband's husband?
These are not from the hothouse.
Ah, I see mine is not the first offering,
nor the most elegant.
I'm afraid I obtained those from an obliging field.
And I've always preferred wildflowers.
I suspected as much.
Eleanor, would you focus?
He seems a perfect match.
He's handsome, he's tall, he's charming.
He's beyond expression.
But it is I who am grateful.
I've often passed this cottage
and grieved for its lonely state.
Then the first news I had from Lady Allen
when I arrived was that it was taken.
I felt a peculiar interest in the event
which nothing can account for,
but my present delight in meeting you.
Pray sit down, Mr. Willoughby.
Then Kate Winslet is so full of young woman energy.
So good in this.
Marianne is reading them out to us.
Which are your favorites?
Without a doubt, mine is 116.
Let me not to the marriage of true minds
admit impediments.
Love is not love,
which alters when it alteration finds or bends with.
That's right, Kate.
I am falling into his eyes.
Oh no.
It is an ever-fixed mark that looks on storm.
Oh.
Is it Tempest?
I do believe it is Tempest.
So he knows his Shakespeare, Sheila.
It's strange.
You should be reading these,
but I carry them with me always.
Oh, how beautiful.
That's not head over heels.
That's head over heels over head over heels over head.
She's just all the way down the hill.
Yeah, she's full on princess briding it down.
Oh, my sweet Wesley.
What have I done?
So she's ass over tea kettle for this guy.
This is Jane Austen, not a biker movie, okay?
So let's...
I don't think there's a single biker in the world
that's ever said ass over tea kettle.
Well, we move in different circles.
Thanks a lot, dudes.
This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp.
BetterHelp connects you to a licensed therapist
who is trained to listen
and give you helpful, unbiased advice.
To get started, click the link below
or go to betterhelp.com forward slash cinematherapy
and fill out a questionnaire to assess your specific needs.
Then you'll get matched with a therapist,
in most cases, in 48 hours or less.
That's faster than Colonel Brandon
can fetch Mama from the cottage.
BetterHelp has a network of over 30,000 therapists
with a wide range of expertise.
So if your love is engaged to somebody else,
there's probably someone out there to help you with that.
And they're committed to helping you find a therapist
who's a good fit for you.
More committed than Willoughby, that's for darn sure.
Doesn't take a lot.
That's why you can easily switch to a new therapist
at no additional cost
if the first one you're paired with isn't a good fit.
You can also choose a time that's convenient for you,
not me, you.
And you can choose how you want to do your therapy sessions,
a phone call, a video chat, or even via messaging.
No more waiting for the post to be delivered.
Whatever's the most comfortable for you.
Over four million people have used BetterHelp
to start living a happier, healthier life.
So if you think you might benefit from therapy,
click the link below
or go to betterhelp.com forward slash cinematherapy.
You'll get 10% off your first month of BetterHelp
so you can connect with a therapist
and see if it helps you.
I do love that it's a Sonnet 116.
Love is an ever-fixed mark.
Yeah.
Not Willoughby.
Yeah, Willoughby is not constant.
He is not steady.
He is not consistent.
He sure is handsome.
Wow, boy howdy.
I was falling into those eyes.
Seriously, like, damn.
And he's very charming.
And he is a very good fit when it comes to shared interests.
Sure, yeah.
Like, it seems almost a little too perfect.
I carry mine with me always, you know?
Maybe he really does have spies all over the neighborhood.
Can you imagine, like, oh, you like Twilight?
I carry this miniature copy with me at all times.
I'm travel size for your convenience.
That's how far our society's fallen, by the way.
Back then, they carried Shakespeare around.
Anyways, I digress.
Willoughby is a great match for her,
but the problem is he lacks integrity,
which she doesn't see right now.
Colonel Brandon is mature.
He's thoughtful.
And he is a better match,
but she doesn't see it because Willoughby is hot as hell.
He's real, real pretty.
Marianne's pretty immature.
Mm-hmm.
And he seems to be checking all the boxes.
Yes, but her boxes are based
on an immature concept of what love is.
Right, right, right.
And so she's looking at handsome, tall, dashing,
shared interests, and makes my heart go all a fluttery.
Has a well-turned calf.
He does have that.
Let's watch the next clip.
Thank you for your kind inquiry.
Now, this is sometime later,
where he just bounced and didn't explain himself.
She fell totally in love with him,
and he let her on, and then he just left.
He did Regency ghosting.
Didn't respond to her letters for weeks, months.
Good God, Willoughby.
She's just made a scene and drawn attention to him.
Will you not shake hands with me?
Oh dear, can you imagine?
He's cold.
Willoughby, what is the matter?
Why have you not come to see me?
Were you not in London?
Have you not received my letters?
Yes, I had the pleasure of receiving an information
you were so good as to send me.
Just making sure he reframes it for anyone listening.
Heaven's sake, Willoughby.
Tell me what is wrong.
Thank you, I'm most obliged.
If you will excuse me, I must rejoin my party.
This is totally Regency-era ghosting.
Yep.
There's no explanation.
She deserves an explanation.
He's immature and sus.
But he's found somebody else.
Somebody more aligned with...
Well, she's rich.
Exactly.
Oh, oh, that look.
I saw that look in high school a lot.
A lot of girls in my high school dressed like that.
I went to a weird school.
Oof.
So here's the thing.
It doesn't matter how many shared interests they have.
It doesn't matter how attractive they are.
If they don't have integrity
and if they don't have consistency,
there is no foundation for a relationship.
But I thought all you need is love.
All you need is love.
I'm actually gonna backpedal a little bit
because I've kept challenging that
when I said all you need is love and the Beatles were wrong.
The Beatles were right, but love is trust.
Love is consistency.
Love is selflessness.
Love is attentiveness.
And he is not any of those things.
What there was there was infatuation and attraction.
And after they courted for a while,
a little bit of attachment, but then he very selfishly,
not only did he selfishly leave her,
he selfishly didn't explain.
He was too afraid to face his history
and to face what he wanted
instead of having the respect to say,
this is gonna hurt, but here's what's going on with me.
Instead, he just bounced out.
And that's why they're number three.
Number two, a controversial choice.
Eleanor and Edward.
She's the main character of the book.
Yes, and they're charming as hell.
So why did I not put them at number one?
Let's explore.
Colonel Brandon desires me to say,
understanding you wish to join the clergy,
he has great pleasure.
Hugh Grant is so spectacular all the time.
In the hope that it may enable you and Miss Steele to marry.
They courted a little bit.
Colonel Brandon?
Turns out he was already engaged.
Yeah.
Didn't tell her, didn't have the heart to.
It means it is testimony of his concern
for the cruel situation in which you now find yourselves.
The cruel situation is that he doesn't love his fiance,
but he feels honor bound to honor the engagement.
And he doesn't have a living.
And who he truly wants is her.
Colonel Brandon must be a man
of great worth and respectability.
He is the kindest and best of men.
Colonel Brandon is offering him a parish
so that he can marry and have a livelihood.
Because he's a priest.
I ask why the colonel did not tell me himself.
I think he felt it would be better coming from a friend.
Your friendship has been the most important of my life.
How hard for them to be bound by the moors of their society
because they truly love each other and choose each other.
Mr. Ferris, you honor your promises.
That is more important than anything else.
I wish you both very happy.
This little bit right here.
Just the pull of wanting to kiss her or hold her.
And not being able to.
Any kind of physical connection that he can't.
Yeah.
Did anything stand out to you
about that scene filmmaking wise?
It's one shot.
It is one shot.
I love one shots.
It's so great.
And it's so still.
Like it's not a flashy like wonder
that's following people around and doing stuff.
It's Ang Lee going,
oh, I have Emma Thompson and Hugh Grant.
I don't have to do ----.
Yeah.
Just hold and let them do their magic.
I'm gonna put them right there.
The frame is nice.
Great.
Go.
Yeah.
And it's actually some really smart filmmaking.
It's not just laziness.
It accentuates the awkwardness because there's no escape.
Yeah.
There's no like, oh, I can move.
Oh, I can go over here.
I mean, whatever.
It's just, you have to sit in it
and just stew the way they are.
And it is, I love it.
Well, it's the awkwardness and it's the longing.
Yep.
You feel both of those things.
Well, when she says you kept your word,
like nothing could be more important.
That's on the heels of Willoughby not.
Betraying her sister.
Yeah.
The person she cares about the most, right?
And so he's especially attractive now.
Yeah.
Like with the contrast.
How can I be more attracted to you
when you're doing a dumber thing?
That's it.
Well, the hardest thing for her
is she truly wants a man who keeps his word,
but his word binds him to his fiance.
And so he's off now.
And then we come around to one of the best.
I love this scene.
Yes, it's...
I love this scene.
So he's come to visit.
They think he's a married man now,
because...
Is Mrs. Ferrars of the new parish?
No, my mother is in town.
I meant to inquire after Mrs. Edward Ferrars.
Which would be him, his new wife.
Well, then you've not heard.
I think you mean my brother.
You mean Mrs. Robert Ferrars?
Mrs. Robert Ferrars?
Yes.
I received a letter from Miss Steele,
Mrs. Ferrars, I should say.
That it takes her forever to get it out.
The transfer of her affections to my brother, Robert.
It seems they were much thrown together in London.
She's just doing the bath.
She's like, wait.
In view of the change in my circumstances,
I felt it only right that she be released
from our engagement.
At any rate, they were married last week
and are now in Plymouth.
Then you are not married.
Oh no, what did I do?
I love that after all that,
Marianne's the one who knows,
oh, we need to leave now.
She was so resigned to a life of misery.
I met Lucy when I was very young.
Had I had an active profession,
I should never have felt such an idol,
a foolish inclination.
Oh man, I'm cry laughing, it's so funny.
But I convinced myself that you felt any friendship for me
and that it was my heart alone that I was risking.
I've come here with no expectations,
only to profess now that I am at liberty to do so,
that my heart is and always will be.
It's so wonderful.
Gosh dang it, Emma Thompson is a murderer.
She's so good.
This is the most wholesome scene.
And you have to understand,
if you haven't seen the film recently,
she's been through a lot.
She has been through a ton.
And she has given so much for the happiness
of everybody else and always does the right thing.
And she is resigned to, I'm probably going to die alone.
Yeah.
And for him to show up,
and this is what kills me, okay, first of all,
they're only ranked number two,
because one, he needed to be honest up front
from the beginning.
Two, when he came in,
because we cut off the front of the scene,
we cut off a whole lot more awkwardness.
He needed to lead with,
hey, um.
I'm not married.
My brother is, I'm available and I adore you.
Instead, he just like stumbles
and stammers through everything.
Let me sit here and keep you in suspense
for at least three minutes of screen time.
Which is just agonizing.
And it's so much fun to watch.
It is great fun.
And Emma Thompson's choice there
to go full panic crying from joy.
It's beautiful performance.
It's great writing.
And the direction gets out of the way
in all the ways that it needs to
and accentuates very subtly exactly the way it needs to.
Now we're going to get to number one,
Marianne and Brandon.
And what a turn by Rickman.
I'm in love with him.
I, you know.
You've seen him do Slimey and Tragic in Harry Potter.
You've seen him do a trifecta
of some of the greatest villain roles
in Die Hard, Quigley Down Under
and Robin Hood, Prince of Thieves.
What you've never seen him as
unless you go into some of his smaller films
is the perfect romantic lead with amazing hair.
Let's do this.
Mr. Ashwood, tell me once and for all.
Is everything finally resolved
between your sister and Mr. Willoughby?
I mean, this is honestly the hair that I aspire to
and I have not achieved.
Colonel, though neither one has informed me
of their understanding,
I have no doubt of their mutual affection.
So he's in love with her sister.
Thank you, Mr. Ashwood.
And Rickman keeps it so small.
To your sister, I wish all imaginable happiness.
But you see everything.
To Mr. Willoughby.
That he's feeling.
That he may endeavor to deserve her.
What do you mean?
I overspeak because it's Regency era.
I missed that guy.
Yeah.
Everything he did was gold.
Even when the movies weren't gold, he was gold.
He was always, yeah, he was a Tucci.
Yeah, he was.
He elevated everything.
I just wanna draw attention really fast to
when he says what he says about Willoughby,
Emma Thompson, an eyebrow drops.
That's all that happens.
And you see her.
That's everything you need.
And it registers like, wait, what do you mean?
Such a brilliant piece of facial acting.
Colonel Brandon, here after just Brandon for brevity.
Okay.
I love that he is checking to see what's going on.
Do I have a chance?
Because if not, I will back away respectfully.
Yeah.
I mean, this is barely in our society
having the conversations that we've needed to have
for so long of honoring especially a woman's choice.
Yes.
She's not a prize to be won, right?
Like in Ted Lasso when they assume
that she's gonna choose one of them
and it's actually no,
she can do whatever the hell she wants, right?
So I get to choose?
Yeah, pretty much, if it is.
We're just now starting to have these conversations.
Brandon was a character written long ago.
200 years ago.
Who nails that.
And so immediately, are they together?
Is she happy?
Sad for me, but good for her.
Yeah.
He is nothing but respectful.
And this is, we're gonna see in these clips.
He is the polar opposite of a nice guy.
He is a good man.
Yes.
I also love that what he says about Willoughby,
he doesn't say strategically,
like this isn't a Mean Girls moment
where he's dropping a bomb and then saying,
oh, I'm sorry, I don't know what I'd said.
He plays it so well that this is a thing I let slip
and oh crap, I shouldn't have said it.
I should not have said it.
Yeah.
Forgive me and then leave.
I shouldn't have said that.
I should not have said that.
So Marianne, she's deathly ill
and he's deathly worried.
What can I do?
You have done so much already.
Give me an occupation, Ms. Dashwood, or I shall run mad.
She would be easier if her mother were here.
Editing.
Yeah.
All you need is the moment of recognition
and the of course, and then put him on a horse,
get him out of here.
How it plays is he just immediately jumps in.
He's a man of action.
Boom.
Yeah.
And that's something I love about him,
because one, he is a man of action,
but he's a man of honor.
Throughout all of this,
there's an entire thread of he adores Marianne.
He honors if she doesn't choose him
and he simply wants to do right by her
and there is no expectation.
This is why he's the opposite of a nice guy.
If you watch our Megamind video,
nice guys do performative, nice things,
but it's transactional.
So that they can earn points.
So they can earn points, then get you in betters
that you'll fall in love with them.
He certainly hopes she'll fall in love with him,
but even if she doesn't, he just wants to do right by her.
And that's what makes him such a stud.
Colonel Brandon can get it.
It's also a defining characteristic of Brandon
is that he's going to make himself useful in any situation.
Yes, always.
I love that he's not a certain way for Marianne
because he's into her
and then different in other circumstances.
Yeah, we see him numerous times not with Marianne
insert himself like, okay, what can I do?
Yeah, what can I do to help?
And in every circumstance, he's going to do right by people.
He's going to be respectful
and he's going to make himself useful.
He certainly hopes she falls in love with him for that.
But if not, it's just who he is.
She's recovering from her illness.
Come on.
Certainly he's not so dashing as Willoughby.
He has a far more pleasing countenance.
Always was something if you remember
in Willoughby's eyes at times that I did not like.
Sure, mom.
Nor is the earth the less or looseth ought
for whatsoever from one place doth fall
is with the tide unto another brought.
Listen, Willoughby reading sonnets is great.
That may be found.
He's not Rickman.
You can't be Alan Rickman.
Shall we continue tomorrow?
No, for I must away.
Away?
Where?
That I cannot tell you.
It is a secret.
You will not stay away long.
It's just so funny because you watch these other movies
where he plays these slimy characters
or these vicious characters
and you kind of lose sight of because he's so good at it.
Wait a second, is Alan Rickman hot?
And the answer is yes.
The answer is yes.
Yes, he is so attractive in this movie.
I can't even handle it.
I like women.
I think.
There's a word used here by Marianne's mother,
pleasing countenance.
Countenance is not really a word that we use anymore.
In today's vernacular, okay, Willoughby's hotter
but Brandon's got a better vibe.
Yep.
I think it's great that he's reading to her.
On the surface, she saw Willoughby as a better fit.
And yet there's subtle clues throughout
that Brandon is very much like her
even though you don't see it initially.
He loves playing with kids.
He's very playful.
He loves the arts, especially reading, especially music.
And that's when he says, I must away.
It's to get her.
He's off to get her her own piano forte.
Yeah, and her family can't afford a piano.
They're living in the cottage.
And he is at this point, he's like,
well, something's starting here.
I'm gonna show you what happens when I go full Brandon.
You wanna see a Brandon Love Bomb?
I was a colonel in the army.
I know all about bombing.
That's not as sweet as you think it is.
Wow, that was weird.
She thought Willoughby checked a bunch of boxes.
Her boxes, some of them have shifted.
Yeah.
Some of them are still the same,
but he checks them more deeply.
Yes.
Well, she didn't see how much of a match he was for her
until she opened her eyes to it.
Also because of Willoughby, there's a new box, decency.
I need someone honest and constant.
And that is what he is.
And that is why they're my number one.
Come at me.
Am I wrong?
Tell me why I'm wrong.
Also, is Alan Rickman hot as hell?
Let us know.
It's the voice, isn't it?
So until next time.
Miss Dashwood.
Oh.
Oh no.
I've come here without expectation.
And.
Watch movies.
That too.
We wish to thank our patrons,
folks who've supported us along the way.
Folks like.
Benjamin Woodward.
Ian Perez.
Will Fire 03.
The Murray 15.
Deomsee.
Thank you for making me say Deomsee in an RP accent.
It was easy.
Patrons.