The best time to buy great Bordeaux is rarely when everyone is excited. It is when enthusiasm disappears.
After demand softened, interest rates rose and Bordeaux released two consecutive vintages into a much weaker market, prices have corrected dramatically.
Some of my favourite estates are now selling for 40 to 45% less than they were only a few years ago. So, is this the moment to start buying Bordeaux again?
In this video, I compare two wines from my own cellar: Château Malescot-Saint-Exupéry from Margaux Château La Gaffelière from Saint-Émilion
Recent vintages of Malescot-Saint-Exupéry now sell for around US$40, while La Gaffelière can be found for approximately US$50–55.
For estates of this pedigree, I think those prices are remarkable.
After more than 30 years of collecting fine Bordeaux, both wines have become permanent fixtures in my cellar. They represent two very different interpretations of the region.
Malescot-Saint-Exupéry is richer, darker and more opulent, combining Cabernet Sauvignon structure with Margaux perfume and suppleness.
La Gaffelière is fresher, more mineral and precise, with its unusually high proportion of Cabernet Franc bringing lift, structure and remarkable purity.
In this video, I discuss: Whether now is a good time to buy Bordeaux Why recent Bordeaux prices have fallen Margaux vs Saint-Émilion Malescot-Saint-Exupéry vs La Gaffelière Cabernet Sauvignon vs Merlot and Cabernet Franc How differently these wines taste Food pairings for each bottle Which wine I would recommend depending on your preferences
Whether you are building your first cellar or adding to an established collection, I hope this comparison helps you decide where to spend your next US$50.
Chapters 00:00 Is It Time to Buy Bordeaux Again? 02:08 Margaux vs Saint-Émilion 03:22 Château Malescot-Saint-Exupéry 04:18 Château Malescot-Saint-Exupéry's Tasting Notes 05:16 Château La Gaffelière 06:22 Château La Gaffelière's Tasting Notes 07:14 Which Bordeaux Should You Buy? 08:46 Final Verdict
Wines Featured Château Malescot-Saint-Exupéry Château La Gaffelière @chateaulagaffeliere5651
The speaker argues that current market corrections in Bordeaux, driven by softened demand and rising interest rates, have created a prime buying opportunity. By highlighting two specific estates—Chateau Malescot Saint-Exupéry and Chateau La Gaffelière—the video explores the distinct styles of the Left and Right Banks and provides guidance on selection and pairing.
For more than 30 years, I have collected fine Bordeaux through booms, busts and everything
in between. One thing I have learned is this. The best buying opportunities rarely come when
everyone is excited. They come when enthusiasm disappears. That's exactly what's happening today.
After demand softened, interest rates rose and Bordeaux released two consecutive vintages into
a much weaker market. Prices have corrected dramatically. Some of my favorite estates
are now selling for 40 to 45 percent less than they were only a few years ago.
That has me asking one simple question. Is this a moment to start buying Bordeaux again?
Two wines I have been watching closely are Chateau Malisco Saint-Exupéry from Margot
and Chateau Le Gaffelier from Saint-Emilion. Malisco, one of Margot's most respected third
worths, is now selling for around 40 US dollars on the latest vintages. Le Gaffelier,
one of Saint-Emilion's historic benchmark estates and formerly of Premier Grand Cru Classé B,
before leaving the classification in 2022, is around 50 to 55 US dollars.
For wines of this pedigree, those prices are remarkable. I already own multiple vintages of
both. Yet, for the first time in years, I am seriously considering buying more.
In this video, I will compare two Bordeaux from my cellar, explain how differently they taste,
which dishes they pair best with, and ultimately tell you which one I would recommend depending on
the style of Bordeaux you enjoy. And before we begin, while you are still discovering your
preferences, buy three or six bottles rather than a full case of twelve. A cellar should
evolve alongside your taste. First, a quick look at the appellations. Before we get into the wines,
let's spend a minute on why these two regions produce such different styles. Talking about
Malisco Saint-Exupéry and Le Gaffelier is really talking about Bordeaux's two personalities.
On the left bank, the deep variable soils favour Cabernet Sauvignon, producing wines with darker
fruit, firmer tannins, and excellent aging potential. Margaux still relies on Cabernet
Sauvignon, but generally includes considerably more Merlot than neighbouring Pauillac, often
around 40 percent rather than 20 percent, giving the wines greater sopperness and making them
approachable a little earlier. Across the river, on the right bank, clay limestone favour Merlot
and Cabernet Franc. The result is a completely different expression of Bordeaux. Richer textures,
brighter red fruit, finer tannins, greater freshness. Saint-Emilion is celebrated for
wines built around Merlot that combine generosity with remarkable longevity.
Neither style is better. They are simply two very different interpretations of Bordeaux.
Now, let's look at the wines. Chateau Malisco Saint-Exupéry. The estate dates back to the 17th
century and takes its name from two former owners, Simon Malisco, a royal councillor,
and Count Jean-Baptiste de Saint-Exupéry, whose great-grandson, Artois, would later write
The Little Prince. Purchased by Paul Zuger and his son Roger in 1955, the chateau underwent a long
period of restoration before returning to prominence from the 1990s onwards. Today,
Jean-Luc Zuger oversees the 28 hectare family estate, widely regarded as one of Margaux's
strongest performing third rows. The vignette is planted to roughly 50% Cabernet Sauvignon,
35% Merlot, with Cabernet Franc and Petit Verlot competing the blend. A classic Margaux balance
between structure and elegance. On the nose, I find dark berries, cassis, cedar, violets,
baking spice, and a gentle hint of tobacco. The palate is rich, supple, and beautifully textured.
Blackberry, blueberry, raspberry, and licorice are layered over dark chocolate, forest raw,
and subtle earthy notes. Bright acidity and beautifully integrated tannins carry everything
into a long, savoury finish. Under Jean-Luc Zuger's direction, Malisco has become increasingly
generous and opulent, especially in warmer vintages, without sacrificing Margaux's trademark
perfume. The 2024 and 2025 vintages currently sell for around 40 US dollars. By comparison,
the highly regarded 2022 and 2020 vintages are closer to 70 US dollars. Chateau La Gaffelière.
The Mallet-Rocfort family has owned La Gaffelière since 1705, making it one of Saint-Emilion's
oldest family-owned estates. Its unusual name comes from a medieval community of people
affected by leprosy that once stood below the chateau. The estate became Premier Grand Cru Classé B
in 1959 and spent decades building one of the region's strongest reputations. A major turning
point came in 2004, when Stéphane de Renoncourt joined as consultant, helping guide the estate
towards a more precise, elegant style. In 2022, La Gaffelière chose to withdraw from the Saint-Emilion
classification alongside Ozone, Cheval Blanc, and Angelus. Recent vintages are typically built around
60% Mallot and 40% Cabernet Franc, one of the highest Cabernet Franc proportions among
leading Saint-Emilion estates. That helps explain the wine's freshness and remarkable precision.
On the nose, I find red and black fruits, graphite, crushed stone, wood spice, and subtle forest
walnuts. The palate is silky yet beautifully structured. Cassis, blackberry, raspberry,
kirsch, and rye plum sit alongside truffle, sweet spice, and unpronounced mineral backbone.
Everything feels remarkably pure, remarkably focused. Over the past two decades, La Gaffelière
has moved away from heavier extraction towards a style centered on freshness, precision, and terroir
expression. The 2024 and 2025 vintages are currently around 50 to 55 US dollars. The 2020
and 2022 are closer to 90 US dollars. The verdict. If you have watched my channel for a while, you
will know I rarely tell people one wine is better than another. Wine collecting isn't about finding
the best bottle. It's about finding the right bottle for the right occasion. That's exactly how
I think about these two wines. Malescaux Saint-Exupéry and La Gaffelière have become permanent fixtures
in my cellar. They have accompanied countless dinners with family and friends, and have
consistently delivered far more than their prices suggest. If these wines were still selling at 90
or 100 US dollars, I would probably wait. But at today's prices, I am buying. Great buying
opportunities don't come along very often in fine wine. When they do, I would rather act before
everyone else notices. If your taste leans towards richer, darker, and more open Bordeaux, I would
choose Malescaux Saint-Exupéry. Its higher cabernet content and generous texture make it a superb
partner for roast lamb, prime rib, rib eye steak, venison, or grilled portobello mushrooms. If you
prefer greater freshness, brighter fruit, and a more mineral expression, I would choose La Gaffelière.
Its Merlot and Cabernet Franc blend pairs beautifully with roast duck, veal chops, beef tenderloin,
mushroom risotto, truffle pasta, or aged Comté. Personally, I don't choose between them. I buy both
because each represents a completely different side of Bordeaux. And at today's prices, I think
both deserve a place in my cellar. If you had around 50 US dollars to spend today, which style
would you choose? The sumptuous variety richness of Malescaux, or the pure mineral precision of
La Gaffelière? I would love to hear your choice in the comment section below.
You will find more on my cellar insights and tasting notes on Instagram.
Massive thanks for watching today, and I will see you in the next one.