Crime statistics say things are improving in California, yet for some residents that reading does not square with what they notice in their own communities. When the official numbers and what people experience seem to point in different directions, it becomes harder to know what each is telling us.
Part of the difficulty is what never enters the official record. Some victims choose not to report crimes to police, so what the statistics can capture, and what may remain outside them, is an open question.
Patricia Wenskunas, Founder and CEO of Crime Survivors, Inc., and Michael Gates, former Huntington Beach City Attorney and candidate for California Attorney General, bring two different perspectives to that question. Their conversation looks at what happens before an incident becomes part of the official crime data, and what may be missed along the way.
00:00 - Intro 01:46 - The Underreporting of Crime 05:21 - Challenges for Victims and Survivors 12:47 - Supporting Victims and Holding Individuals Accountable 33:53 - Addressing the Future of California
Crime statistics are showing crime is going down in California, which is great news.
A few months ago, we covered this on the show, but a lot of you challenged us and challenged
our guests because you don't believe the statistics and you don't believe the data.
Today, we sit down with Patricia Beneskunas and Michael Gates to explore why there is a big
discrepancy between what they are seeing on the ground and the data, and if there is a flaw in
the system and how to fix it. California is ranked as the second most dangerous state in
the country. Out of 50 states, it's shocking, but it's true. Any type of compensation programs or
rehabilitation programs for victims, I just don't think it'll be able to keep up. We actually treat
the criminals, the offenders, more like victims than we actually do the victims themselves.
I don't see the money going towards anything to do with prevention when it comes to victimization
and trauma. We have more unhoused, more suicides, more mental health, more mental illness. So to me,
if money is going into that pocket, then we're doing something completely wrong.
I'm Siamak. Welcome to California Insider. Patricia, it's great to have you back on.
Welcome back. Thank you so much.
Michael, it's great to have you back on. Welcome back.
Thank you for having me.
Patricia, you are working with crime survivors and you're noticing that people are not reporting
crime as much. And Michael, you've been serving your city as a city attorney. You've been having
an eye on crime in California for a decade. We also had a thought leader from the PPIC,
Magnus Lofstrom. He analyzed the crime data. Together, we talked about it. And his conclusion
that the data is saying crime is going down. When we aired the episode, people didn't believe it.
A lot of the comments, commentators, they were saying this is not true.
What are you seeing out there right now?
You know, as a nonprofit organization, someone that's been working with victims, survivors,
family members in our community for 23 years, I feel like I can't trust or believe data statistics
because I think they can be swayed whichever way we want them to be. Now, I am a huge component
supporter of our law enforcement. I think they're doing the best they can do. They're doing an
incredible job. But I do think that victims and survivors and family members are not reporting
at the levels that they used to for many reasons. A lot of the victims that are coming to us,
they're just like, we don't want to report because we're seeing what's happening throughout
our criminal legal system where individuals are getting slapped on the wrist. They're getting
programs. They're getting services. One victim said to me, you know, Patricia, does it mean
that I wasn't victimized? Because they're basically saying that the offender, if he
does these programs and he sticks with this for a year, it will get removed from his record.
So she's like, if he's not the criminal offender, does that mean I'm not a victim then by the
system? So unfortunately, a lot of our victims are not reporting and yet they're still coming to us
for help and support. Have you seen that? And what would you guys do when you look at the data?
Yeah. So as you know, I was the city attorney of Huntington Beach for 10 years. I was the top
prosecutor there. Crime reporting is a big issue and it's a big deal. Everyday Californians are
actually feeling a lot of crime, a lot of violent crime in their neighborhoods. In addition to that,
the FBI data on violent crime shows that California is ranked sixth highest in crime
in the country out of 50 states, which is shocking. But what's even more shocking
is a recent 2026 consumer affairs report that just came out literally just weeks ago that said,
actually, according to their study, California is ranked as the second most dangerous state
in the country out of 50 states. It's shocking, but it's true. So there's underreporting. I do
think that victims, a lot of victims don't report. We live in a sort of post prop 47 and 57 and AB
109 world where we have basically decriminalized a lot of crimes, a lot of quality of life crimes.
So when people become victim to quality of life crimes, they shrug their shoulders and say, well,
there's no sense in reporting, nothing's ever going to happen. So there's this sort of
complacency that's now been caused by this prop 47, 57 and AB 109. And then you add to it like
prop 36 just passed at the polls in 2024, that was supposed to add teeth back into criminal
prosecution and add some accountability back into our criminal justice system. And yet our
leaders are not enforcing it. We didn't get funding, right? Well, they claim it's funding,
but that's not true because when they put together the new budget for the next year,
they didn't build in any new funding or they built in, I've heard no funding, but insufficient
funding for prop 36. So we need to get back to law and order. The best way to do it, frankly,
is to repeal prop 47 and 57 and AB 109. Therefore we won't need prop 36 and victims and everyday
Californians will get the message that, hey, we're taking crime seriously and crime fighting
seriously throughout the state. So they will be more interested or more invested in reporting.
They will put the legwork in, they will believe that there's consequence and there's going to be
accountability. For me, I mean, I don't want to make things always political either because I
really want to say, I mean, obviously political falls within the arena, right? And no matter who's
in office, like we, we want to say victims matter, like victims voices matter. What happens to them
matters, services, programs, they matter. And we need to step up. And I feel like right now with
all of the budget cuts, we are seeing so many nonprofits that are losing funding. Their funding
is cut. They're losing staff members, like some incredible advocates, service providers. They're
no longer in their position because they've lost funding, they've lost their budgets.
We actually treat the criminals, the offenders more like victims than we actually do the victims
themselves. And this started, like you said, with AB 109, prop 47, prop 57, it was like a slow
garden hose leak that one side strategically started doing within our communities to, I say,
in a sense, kind of brainwashing individuals to think that they were no longer victims or like
they want to, don't you want to go back to your abuser? Like they have more rights even under
Marcy's law that we worked so hard to get passed in 2008. And I know because I worked extremely
hard on that, is now the offenders are basically being early released. So when we see from victims
and survivors that are coming to us saying, especially with the elder parole, where that
individual murdered their loved one, and now that they're 55 or older, they're going to get
early released, or they've changed things so drastically, like someone was supposed to serve
15 years, now they're only serving 10, they're only serving five, which is devastating, right?
But we also have to think about the economy because a lot of the victims that are coming to
us, also why they don't report is they can't afford food, they can't afford gas in their car,
they can't afford transportation, they can't afford a lot of things. So therefore, they're
staying, we witnessed that through COVID, they're staying with their abuser, because their abuser is
paying the bills. Do they come to you guys? And can you give us some examples for those of us that
may not be familiar with these cases? Well, for our organization, we help victims of violent crimes,
so families of murder, survivors of attempted murder, rape, domestic violence, sexual assault,
child abuse, elder abuse and human trafficking. And when we sit, we hear from human trafficked
victims, and they say that they've tried to get help, they've tried to get out of that life,
and they're not getting the help and support to be able to break that the individual is not held
accountable. Or we even have the fentanyl crisis coming in, and victims are trying to figure out
how they can hold those individuals accountable as well, for their kids that have taken something
that they didn't know was laced or drugged with fentanyl. So it's a whirlwind of every different
thing. We have a rape victim that not too long ago, she was raped, and she was convinced,
she thought she was convinced by a certain side, to be able to not report because they told her,
well, if you report and he gets charged, and he has to go to prison, then he's not going to get
the help and support that he really needs to not rape anybody else. Don't you want him out on the
street so we can help him? And when she came to me, she was like, I thought the way they said it,
yeah, because I don't want him to rape anybody else. But then she said, I got in the car and
started sobbing and thinking, no, I want him to go to prison. I want him to go to jail. But I also
know that in the media, she was saying that basically somebody's getting a slap on the wrist,
and then they're getting out in six months to a year. She said, what does that mean for me? Like,
I don't want to live in fear the rest of my life. I don't want that person to come back and harm me
or my family. And in addition to coddling criminals, like Patricia was saying, there
systematically coddling criminals. There really is truly a philosophy in our leadership in California
that says, that dictates that, hey, you have to take criminals into account, their circumstances,
the fact that they may be victimized. But in addition to all of that, we're re-victimizing
victims because just the Victims' Compensation Fund is totally broken. There is a program in
California, a statewide program, where taxpayers pay into a program called the Victims' Compensation
Fund. Tens of millions of dollars of taxpayer money goes into that every year. And this is
designed for, if you can tell us what the program is designed for. Yes, it's designed so that the
money after it's taken in will be distributed to local agencies and then ultimately handed over to
victims who apply for compensation. So if you're a rape victim, if you are a victim of an assault
or attempted murder, things that are oftentimes life-altering. The victims, it's through the
California Victim Compensation Government Claims Board. So a victim has a right, and it's
reimbursed. So they're not getting compensation in the sense of just being paid after being
victimized. It's all reimbursable. So like if someone's unhoused or homeless and doesn't have
funds, they can't really apply because it's on reimbursed amounts, right? So it's through CalVCB,
the California Victim Compensation Government Claims Board, through Sacramento. And basically,
victims apply either directly through CalVCB or through the local victim assistance program.
Now, things like they can apply for is up to $10,000 in counseling and therapy, up to almost
$13,000 if they need to pay for a funeral and burial, up to a certain amount for crime scene
cleanup, up to all these different things, loss of wages. And so there's a certain amount that
they can apply for, right? Now, typically, it depends on what the crime was. They also work
directly with the local victim advocates, with the victim assistance programs, right? And you're
right. They can apply, and if they get turned down, they can appeal. But through the years,
the system has drastically changed to where even now they want to change it to where offenders can
apply because they're saying the offenders were victimized before, and that's the reason why they
went on to. And we've been fighting that for years, right? But it is reimbursable, and it is
through the local victim assistance program, depending on what county it is, right? But it is
never enough. There is never enough to be able to provide to victims and survivors when you also see
the offenders that are incarcerated, that are getting free laptops, iPads, they're getting
Donut gift cards.
So the offenders are getting money from this fund, basically.
And the victims are being denied on a regular basis without real justification. I've met with
dozens and dozens and dozens of victims who say, we have fought these appeals for years,
and we still are getting nowhere. And we've had caseworkers analyze their victims' claims,
and the caseworkers are like, these are legitimate claims that should have been paid on day one,
like instantly, and they're not being paid. So that system is broken. And as we're talking about,
the bias or the bent is in favor of the criminal or the perpetrator and not in favor of the victim.
And to have the system effectively re-victimize victims or not take them seriously or discourage
them, whatever the issue is, it's just a travesty. 65% of people in California believe that California
is headed in the wrong direction. There are a lot of reasons, but this is one of them,
that California is broken.
You mentioned the rape victim. How was she recommended not to do anything about it? Can
you tell us about that? Because that's shocking. Was it through the criminal justice system?
Right. Well, it was through another agency. Actually, there's another agency that has
stolen our name that actually started years ago to be able to get AB 109, Prop 47, and Prop 57 passed.
So they also go by crime survivors, which were the original crime survivors,
and we've been in existence for 23 years, of which I'm very proud of. But they help a lot
of offenders. They help a lot of the criminal side of things, of which we do not.
And when she came to me, she was telling me that the other agency is the one that guided her to
be able to not report. But then when she came to us, she still... Because I am such a great
supporter of law enforcement. I think they're doing an incredible job in this state. I think
they truly do care. They need more funding, though. That's the biggest problem right now,
is that it's so difficult in law enforcement because they just don't have the funding.
They don't have the bodies. They don't have the people to do the work. But we do a lot
of the trainings, a lot of programs, a lot of collaborative partnerships with law enforcement.
That's how the majority of our victims and survivors come to us, is through law enforcement.
And for me, I'm also a true believer. Even if somebody believes in one thing and I believe
in something else, I always believe, agree to disagree with respect. Be at the table.
We don't have to agree on everything to work together, to collaborate, to partner.
But even if someone is helping offenders, I'm always saying,
hey, I'll be at the table. Let's talk about it. How can we come to terms? How do we work together?
You get your programs, we get ours. I remember years ago, I had a good debate with a sheriff
because I said, I don't understand why the state of California is paying a million dollars for
offenders to take yoga classes, a million dollars for offenders to take art classes.
But our victims are not getting art classes. They're not getting offenders classes. I've
been trying since we passed Marcy's Law in 2008 to get CalVCB to cover at least up to $2,000
for attorney fees for a victim. But that takes legislation and that's not being done. I've been
trying to get self-defense and safety classes through CalVCB to be able to cover that. And they
just keep saying it's legislation. But then our legislators don't want to vote in anything for
offenders and not to be political. But at some point, our legislators, our elected leaders do
have to step up and say, we have to balance the scales of justice. We have to make sure
that victims and that our communities know that victims didn't do anything. Like an offender,
a criminal, that's why they say, oh, well, they were victimized when they were a kid.
The system failed them, didn't give them help. That's why they went on to rape or abuse. And
I say hogwash to that. I say that is so offensive to individuals that are innocent victims that did
absolutely nothing wrong. Like myself, I didn't do anything wrong to be victimized. And I'm surviving
and I'm thriving because of the people that have come to help me and support me. And I'm paying it
forward to help other people now. Based on your experience, if you were, if you had that
crime right now, would you be different based on the way society is treating victims now versus
the time you started the organization? Oh, I think, well, it was hard for me at first. I was
known as the squeaky wheel because I was very outspoken. I was very loud and outspoken when I
first started the organization. And then I kind of took a step back for a little bit. And now I feel
like I'm out there again because I'm seeing and witnessing how bad it is right now. I would say
it's actually worse now, 23 years later than what it was when I went through it for victims
and survivors. And that's really unfortunate because some days I feel like such a failure
because I'm like, I got in this movement to make it better. I've sacrificed my child. I've
sacrificed my grandchildren. I've sacrificed my entire life and being to be able to help other
people. And when you see other people that won't come to the table to make it right for victims,
it's devastating. It is devastating to see that, but I'm not going to give up as long as the good
Lord gives me my energy and my breath. I made a promise on April 4th of 2002 that I would live
for God and I would live with a passion, a purpose. As long as he gives me the calling,
I'm going to answer that call. And you have impacted thousands of people's lives.
Yeah. And I'm proud because we serve Southern California and we don't turn anybody away and we
do everything that we can. And not only do we serve victims and survivors, but we collaborate
and partner with our elected leaders. We collaborate and partner very closely with
law enforcement, victim advocates, service providers. Like I said, I say to people all
the time, you don't have to like me. I don't know why you don't like me if you don't like me,
but we can come to the table, check ourselves at the door. And if we're in this for the right
reason, we'll sit at the table with everyone because that way we will have a better system.
We will have a better California if we come together. But if we continue at the rate we're
going right now, I agree with you. So 100% our state is being destroyed and it is continuously
getting worse. Now, Michael, based on what you have seen, so you had a decade in Huntington
Beach, did the laws change and did you see the impact of them? And were you able to navigate
as a city attorney within the California legal system to hold people accountable?
Yeah. So like you said, I was the city attorney of Huntington Beach from 2014 to 2025. Then I went
to Washington DC to work with the Department of Justice. Before all of that, I was in private
practice defending our law enforcement. When the Orange County Sheriff's Department was sued,
when the deputies were sued for doing their job, I was taking their cases to trial and defending
them. So I've got a long history with defending police as well. But when it comes to Huntington
Beach, just so the audience knows too, Huntington Beach is the 23rd largest city in the state of
California out of 482. So it's a very, very large city. It's got 200,000 residents and 15 million
visitors a year. So if there's a potential for high crime in any city, it's a city like that.
And when I took office as city attorney in 2014, that's when Prop 47 and 57 and AB 109 had just
passed and gone into effect. And so we started to see a rise in crime everywhere in the state
of California. Every city, every county was experiencing a rise in crime because of the
passage of those props and AB 109. And in 2017, after seeing the rise in crime in Huntington
Beach, just like we did in everywhere else in the state, I went to my district attorney and I said,
hey, I actually want to start a brand new city level criminal prosecutor program at the city
level in Huntington Beach. Usually cities just make their arrests, the police make their arrests,
and then they refer them to the district attorney for prosecution. And so cities are oftentimes
entirely dependent on what the DA does or the district attorney does with regard to prosecution.
But I wanted more than that for my city in the county of Orange. And so I worked with Tony
Rokakis, the district attorney then, to start the city's Huntington Beach's first city level
criminal prosecutor program. And with that program, we were tough on crime. We were no nonsense,
no excuses. We really held criminals accountable then, starting then in 2017 at the city level.
And in the first year alone, we reduced crime by double digits. And now as we sit here today,
Huntington Beach is one of the safest cities in the entire state of California. So the point is,
when you are tough on crime, it works. We did it in Huntington Beach. And yes,
in response to your question, that was after AB 109 and Prop 47 and 57. Laws matter, enforcement
matters. And when you have law and order and you're tough on crime, you not only have fewer
victims, but you have less suffering throughout the state of California. And frankly, you have
fewer criminals because when the criminals know or prospective criminals or would-be criminals know
that the system is going to be tough and hold you accountable if you commit a crime, that is a
disincentive. I mean, that discourages people from committing crimes in the first place. We have a
crime culture in California and it is a culture and it's our system. And our culture will not
change in California until our system changes. We need to get back to the basics, the old school
way of being tough on crime, tough on the law and tough on criminals, just like we did in Huntington
Beach. Huntington Beach, like I said, as we sit here today, even in 2026 where there's crime
everywhere and California is ranked as one of the most dangerous states in the country to live in,
Huntington Beach is one of the safest cities in the entire state to live in. But the culture that
we live in now really won't change until we change the system. And what I mean by that is
the attitude at the top, the attorney general, our district attorneys, our sheriffs, all the way down
the line, we've got to get back to being tough on crime and then we will reduce victimization.
In California, when somebody's saying, I'm going to be tough on crime,
has it viewed as something negative that you shouldn't do it in the political system?
I think it's changed. I think through the years it's drastically changed. So I think in other
states, in other areas, it is looked at differently than it is in California. And I think years and
years ago, like when I first got into this movement, you could say tough on crime and
everybody wanted tough on crime. But then the system started changing and people would say
tough on crime. No, that's not right. Like we need to take care of these offenders. We need to take
care. We need to rehabilitate. We need to provide them services, directions, programs, all this
stuff so that we're saying, no, we can't be tough on crime. And we all witnessed it with what
happened in Los Angeles County when DA Gascon was in office. It was an absolute nightmare. And we
know it because we've seen the victims, what they had to go through. We saw the cases that what was
happening. It was devastation. But now that there's a new DA, DA Hockman, he has changed everything.
It has made such an incredible difference that his voice and he wants to be tough on crime
and he wants to make sure that he's holding individuals accountable and he supports victims
100 percent, which is an absolute blessing. And then we also have our DA here in Orange County
that has done an incredible job. And you'll see the videos. You'll see different clips
from law enforcement where the criminals will say, what? We're not in L.A. We're going to prison.
We're going to jail. What do you mean? And they're like, we thought this was L.A.
And that's why, like, Todd Spitzer, the DA, he did all these billboards, all these signs saying
like this Orange County is not L.A. So it was a complete change. And I will say Orange County
does things a lot better than a lot of different places. Like, I'm a huge component supporter of
the entire state on how different things are run with law enforcement, victim services,
victim advocates. You know, we collaborate and partner with all of them. Is anything perfect?
No, none of us are perfect. None of us can do a perfect job because we have to stick with rules,
boundaries. There's only so much that we can do or there's so much money that we're able to be
able to spend to be able to do that. But if we all sit together and we figure out a way to work it,
like I said, Orange County does things incredibly different, in my opinion, than other counties do.
And when you're tough on crime, you really, truly prevent crime. And here's just one quick
anecdotal, but one quick example. We saw on the 4th of July what happened in Newport Beach,
California, right? With all of those videos, the riots, the smash and grabs in the strip malls.
And there was a resisting of police then too. A bunch of outsiders came into Newport Beach. They
were partying too hard. They stayed out. They were just creating trouble, right? There was disorder.
Well, that didn't happen in the neighboring city of Huntington Beach. Even though Huntington Beach
is a much, much larger city with much more beach, we had a half a million visitors in Huntington
Beach on the 4th of July. A half a million people were in Huntington Beach on the 4th of July.
That is shocking. That is such a high number. Yet we didn't see those videos coming out of
Huntington Beach. We only saw them coming out of Newport Beach. And when I was city attorney,
and I was working with the police department, we would monitor the chatter on social media.
And oftentimes when events were about to happen, there was chatter on social media that would say,
don't go into Huntington Beach. They will get you. Don't go into Huntington Beach. They're
tough on crime. Don't go into Huntington Beach if you want to do this. So they would literally go to
other cities because Huntington Beach had built such a reputation of being so tough on crime
that we were actually preventing crime. So it's absolutely true that when you are tough and you
build this reputation that criminals take notice and they don't go into your jurisdiction or they
don't commit crimes. So we've got to get tough on crime in California. We absolutely have got to get
tough on crime. So we absolutely need a change. So how do you look at the numbers? So this is what's
confusing. And we have talked to some law enforcement experts that have told us that
when you look at crime data, if you want to get accuracy, you should look at the homicides. But
the homicides are going down significantly. Now the question is, what's really happening? Is the
crime going up and certain type of crime going up and they're not getting reported? Something is
missing here. You can certainly have a shift in a society where the homicides may be going down,
but violent crimes are exploding. And that's really what we're seeing now is the violent crime
data is reflecting very poorly on California. All of these assaults and all of this type of
violent crime that they're measuring, it's not boding well for California. We are not successful
in fighting crime, violent crime in California. The consumer affairs study that I just mentioned,
that also took a look at violent crime. So yeah, you can pick off one crime here or there and say,
is rape up or down? Is homicide up or down? But that's not the way you should measure it.
You should look at all of violent crime, the crimes that affect our everyday lives. And so
violent crime is up in California and the studies are showing it, the data is showing it.
And I know it's political season. There's campaigns that are going to be run. People
are going to be talking about how it looks like homicides might be down this year relative to
last year. Look, when you're a business and you're trying to protect your business from
smash and grabs, and you're just trying to keep your streets safe enough that you have pedestrian
traffic coming into your business, you're not thinking about the homicide rate in the state
of California or the homicide rate in your neighborhood. You're talking about, I literally
just want to keep my jewelry store open for one more day to make one more dollar without a smash
and grab. So it's the violent crime that really impacts everyday Californians on a daily basis.
There's a lot of stores that are just, they throw up their hands, they don't even report it.
They just, they say, look, I'm going to spend six hours with a cop or my store is going to be shut
down for the next three days because they're going to be doing fingerprinting. It's going to lead to
nowhere. Nobody's going to be prosecuted. We looked at the surveillance video. We couldn't
make out who was on it ourselves. So there's no point in reporting it. All of this goes into
the business owner's mind when they're deciding whether they should report it or not. And
oftentimes they're not reporting it. They're saying that right now, statistics, data says
crime is significantly down in the state of California. They're saying homicides, rape,
domestic violence, sexual assault. They're saying they're all down right now. And I,
with much respect to the individuals that are doing that, I disagree with them because I feel
like it is not. It's not accurate data. It's not accurate statistics because they're not including
all of the situations like he's saying. So those numbers are not all included. All the
individuals that are being abused and harassed and stalked and trafficked that are not reporting
for whatever reason that they're not, doesn't really matter at the end of the day, the reason
it's that those statistics are not included into the data.
Nat Malkus We know from anecdotal
information or data too, that a lot of victims, the individual crimes like the rape or the assaults,
if the victim doesn't believe that the system is going to prosecute or hold the criminal
accountable and lock them up and throw away the key, and the system's actually going to just slap
them on the wrist and let them out back on the street, the victim believes that, well, then
they're going to be re-victimized. There's going to be retribution because they reported. So victims
are basically disincentivized from reporting in the first place. They're actually discouraged
from reporting because they literally, rape victims literally think their perpetrators
are going to be back at their front door the next day if they report it, and there's going to be
retribution. They're going to be re-victimized. And so there's a whole bunch of under-reporting
because of that phenomenon. And you look at the, whatever individual crime they think,
nothing's going to happen to that individual. They're just going to come back and take it out
on me that I reported the crime in the first place. So I won't report the crime and maybe
I'll get a pass. Maybe I won't be re-victimized. So it's just this terrible cycle.
The crazy thing is, is our state puts no money into prevention, which to me is just craziness.
Like, why would you not want to put more money into prevention? Because then we're preventing
the crimes from happening rather than now, once it happens, you're having to put so much more money
into victims, survivors, healing process, the court process.
So aren't we investing a lot in prevention? That was the funding that was going to go into
criminal justice reform. The idea was that we will go to the root cause of the crime, which is
having that person that's committing the crime because they grew up in a rough neighborhood
or they were involved with the gangs, to help them not get involved with the gangs.
Is the money not going there?
I don't see it going there. I don't see the money going towards anything to do with
prevention when it comes to victimization and trauma. Nothing. A ton of money has been going
to the unhoused and the homeless and drugs and mental health and things like that. And yet,
in this climate today, we have more unhoused, more homelessness, more rapes and sexual assaults
within the unhoused community, more suicides. The suicide rate is going, rising and rising.
We have more issues. So where is all the money going to? I have no idea where the
money is going to because we have more unhoused, more suicides, more mental health, more mental
illness. So to me, if money is going into that pocket, then we're doing something completely
wrong. In your portfolio of people that you're helping, do you see an uptick of people facing
encounters with criminals? And do you see them not talking about it?
One hundred percent. Absolutely. I have more victims, more survivors than we've ever had.
I talk to service providers every single day. They are getting more phone calls. Shelters are
at max capacity for domestic violence. Rape crisis centers are getting more calls than they have.
And even if a lot of times they'll go to be able to get a rape kit at the rape crisis center,
but they don't want to report, they don't want the police to come, they'll still get the report. So
it's still there. But yes, absolutely. We talk to more and more individuals. Now, uniquely enough,
more victims and family members of homicide will come forward because their loved one has passed.
They're more outspoken. They're more in the forefront than, say, child abuse or domestic
violence or rape or any of those other cases. But for us, and we work with all service providers
throughout Southern California, so I hear it. I facilitate a weekly service provider roundtable
meeting that all service providers are on there, and we range anywhere from 50 to 270
service providers. And they all tell me. And they are continuously, not only are they tapped out,
burned out, but they're also dealing with secondary trauma, compassion fatigue, because they're not
able to take care of themselves. And keeping in mind that the victim advocates are the lowest
paid, people that work at McDonald's are getting paid much more than a victim advocate is that has
caseloads of traumatization of victims constantly on their desk. And to me, I feel like we need to
do better. We need to pay our victim advocates better. We need to pay our service providers
better. We had three victim advocates last year that I, through our organization, started another
program for self-care just for victim advocates. Those three victim advocates were living in their
cars. If they're living in their car and they can't pay their rent, how are they also going
to work every day to take care of the individuals that need help? What do you think is the impact of
this on the future of the state when we have a situation where people don't want to report on
crime because they're afraid of retaliation or the criminal justice system is not going to hold
people accountable? This is a bad trajectory. It's a terrible trend. As we've been talking about,
things have only gotten worse over the past 20 years. And frankly, our legislature in California
is not doing us any favors. They're constantly passing new legislation that basically undermines
the criminal justice system. All of these new laws that keep coming out, we have got to make
a change or there will be far more suffering in the state of California, far more victimization.
And I really am hoping, again, not to overly politicize things, but I'm hoping that with the
election coming up in November, the Californians finally sort of seize the moment and take
control of this situation and elect new leadership so that we can start to turn California around.
Like I said, with new leadership, you can start working on changing the system,
which will then change the culture. We live in a crime-friendly culture. It's a crime-friendly
culture. And so we are only going to have more and more crime, more and more victims. And any
type of compensation programs or rehabilitation programs for victims, I just don't think it'll
be able to keep up with the amount of victims and victimization. And so I think victimization
is going to outpace. Crime is going to continue to proliferate. This is the moment to change
things. I think this, even at this rate, is unsustainable. We need a change in California.
And only with a change can we reduce the suffering, reduce victimhood,
reduce victimization, and get our neighborhoods back and get our business districts back.
You know, the smash and grabs, for instance, they can stop with new leadership. They can stop,
but they're not going to stop as long as we keep making the same mistakes and electing the same
type of leadership that's soft on crime and coddles criminals over victims, coddles criminals
over everyday Californians so that they don't become victims, right? The goal is to actually
allow everyday Californians to enjoy their life, enjoy their American freedoms in society and not
be victimized, right? We want to get there again. We're not there right now. And so I think we're
in a very precarious situation. I think it's not good. Well, you even have the CalVCB victim
comp that I had mentioned earlier. Their applications are like 17 to 26 percent down
right now. And it's not because the victims, there's no victims. It's because victims are
not submitting those applications and they're not being helped to be able to submit those
applications. And because individuals can't afford stuff up front to be reimbursed on.
So there's a whole process that needs to take place. And I think it needs to be a complete
overhaul of the system. And we need to make sure that when we're making changes and we're doing
things that we're always including. Again, I can't say it enough. I feel like I'm a broken record,
to be honest, but I feel like we're not bringing everybody to the table. And it reminds me of the
that was told of like an unhoused man that said, they keep bringing us bags of stuff,
cans of soup that don't have a can opener or a spoon for us to eat. So that's why they're
getting thrown on the street. I'm bald and I don't need a shampoo. But then in the in-housed,
unhoused community, they're trading it for drugs, alcohol, other things, because everybody's going
and blessing them with all this stuff because we feel guilty like they're unhoused or homeless.
I want to bring them socks. I want to bring them clothes. I want to do all this stuff.
But he's like, why don't they put tables out and let us choose what we need? Or why don't they
ask us what we need? And to me, that's one thing that I'm proud of within our organization is I
don't demand from victims. I don't tell them what they need. I ask them. I meet them where they're
at in a trauma informed care setting and ask them what they need. You need diapers. You need food.
You need clothing. You need shelter. What do you need? I think that piece is missing. Like
if individuals were included at the table that have gone through something, we could make a better
system moving forward because we're not going to go out of business. I wish I did. I could go out
of business. You know, most businesses go into business to stay the long haul. Nonprofits,
we wish we could close our doors. But unfortunately, there's always going to be victims.
Do you have any tips for people that are becoming victims?
Yeah, for me, first and foremost, is to make sure that we let victims know that they matter,
that they're not alone, that there is help. There is support for them. Whether they go to
law enforcement or they don't, our agency and many other agencies will be there to help and
support them. Now, we would like them to go and report to the police, but we also don't want to
force them to do anything that they don't want to do, right? They've already been forced into
a situation and circumstance, so we don't want to push that on them. We want to be able to walk
hand in hand, side by side with them for safety, and we want to make sure that they have all the
resources, the support that they need, not only to break the cycles of victimization and trauma,
to be able to have hope, to be able to have healing, to not be defined by the victimization
and trauma, that they can survive and thrive. And it takes a team, and we have a team. We have
many other agencies that will be able to be able to be there to help them, to support them, guide,
and also provide for them whatever they need. So they should reach out to you or organizations
like you across the state? Absolutely, most definitely. And there are thousands and thousands
of organizations that are out there doing an incredible job helping victims and survivors.
If they can't find out who to reach out to, I always say call 211, look up findhelp.org,
call a national hotline, or look at their local victim assistance program and their victim advocate.
So, Michael, now you're running for the Attorney General of California.
Can you tell us more about this role? And this role can have an impact, right?
Right. As you may know, the Attorney General is the top cop in the state of California. The Attorney
General has purview over all 58 counties, all of their law enforcement agencies, the county-level
law enforcement agencies. So the Attorney General has purview over all 58 sheriff's departments
and all 58 district attorney's offices. So when you think of public safety in California,
the buck stops with the Attorney General. The Attorney General is finally ultimately responsible
for all public safety throughout the state of California. So people might think of their local
police officer or their local sheriff or their local district attorney, but ultimately it all
traces back to the Attorney General in the state of California. That's the way our Constitution is
set up. That's the way the government is set up under Article 5, Section 13 of the California
Constitution. It basically says that the Attorney General is the top cop, but also the chief legal
officer for the state of California. That's why we see the Attorney General weighing in on so much
and being responsible for so much of what we're experiencing in the state of California.
So hopefully there will be major changes. So we have to go back and look at all those laws and see
what we need to fix and fix them. It was great to have you on, Patricia and Michael. Thank you.
Thank you so much. What do you think of this discussion? Have you seen crime going up in your
community and have you seen criminal activities in your area? Make sure to tell us in the comments
or email us at siamak at californiasatter.com. We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Karami. This is California Satter. We'll see you next time.