The pistachios on supermarket shelves around the world most likely came from California's Central Valley, where roughly two-thirds of the global supply now grows. The crop has no native history in the state, and most Californians drive past these orchards every day without knowing what they are or how they got there.
The industry's current chapter is stranger than its rise. Even with worldwide demand increasing, the growers who helped build the industry have nearly stopped planting new trees, and the pause traces back to what's happening with California's water. Whether food is grown locally is a question that follows residents on every grocery run, and the people who work this ground are assessing things season by season.
Tom Coleman, chair of the Administrative Committee for Pistachios and owner of Coleman Farming Co., has been growing pistachios since 1982, when the industry barely existed. Alongside Stephen Vasquez, the committee's executive director, he explains how a crop nobody expected to take hold became a world leader, and what now decides whether it keeps growing. Coleman traces the industry's rise back to his own worst harvest, and to something that had nothing to do with farming technology.
00:00 - Introduction 02:36 - Challenges, Growth and Collaboration 10:03 - Water Management and Agricultural Challenges 22:54 - Efficiency Gains in Pistachio Production
California is now number one in producing pistachios globally and pistachios were not
native to California. How were we able to become number one in pistachios? Today we sit down with
some of the pioneers in this industry to tell us what they've done to get us here and where we're
going next. The security of a domestically grown food supply is very important. If we had to rely
upon other countries for all of our food we could be in a very precarious situation. A lot of those
farmers are just small family farmers. They put their heart and soul into that ground and into
that crop and produce the highest quality. That's why we have people coming from all over the world
wanting California pistachios. I'm Siamak, welcome to California Insider. Tom and Steve, it's great
to have you on, welcome. Thank you, thanks for having us. You're in the pistachio industry and this is a
space in California that's actually growing and 65 percent of the pistachio is produced here.
Can you tell us what's happening with your space? Certainly the Dubai chocolate event that happened
really got people interested in pistachios but pistachios have been in California for a long time
still one of the youngest perennial crops they've been in California since about 1850.
There was some initial varieties that were brought they never really got a foothold and then really
in 1929 there was a USDA botanist that found a variety on his trips of collecting and from 1929
1930 there was a lot of evaluations and then really the first harvest that happened in California
was in 1976 on very few acres and then 1979 we had about 31,000 acres which was a very big crop at
that time it was about 17 million pounds which comes out to about I don't know 600 pounds per
acre and then you come to modern day where we're at today with about 600,000 total acres in
California and we're producing a billion pound crops for the past at least five or six years
so a lot has changed over over that time and there's certainly a lot of interest in
in California pistachios. And do you see more growth in this space? There's more growth but
not a lot of new plantings that has slowed down quite a bit water shortage is part of that
called SIGMA sustainable groundwater management act that is limiting how much groundwater can be
used so that has really slowed down development of pistachios so there's not been a lot of new
plantings in the last few years. So you guys plan to increase the yield how are you growing? Well
we're all trying to increase the yields and reduce our costs unfortunately we're not being
very successful at reducing costs with current petroleum prices for fertilizer and diesel and
that sort of thing we are over time getting better at producing larger crops off of the existing
acreage better fertility better farming practices that sort of thing. Has this space been growing
in the last couple of decades? So between 2012 and 2022 we were planting about 30,000 acres of
a year during that period and that got us up to where we're at now at about 600,000 total acres
and the reason why there was a change is that we've had we only had one variety we had the
Kerman variety which was discovered in 1929 that has really been the workhorse of the industry
and then about 2005 the California Pistachio Research Board which is the state marketing order
focuses on production research funding production research and so they were looking for new
varieties because of the climate and the way that pistachios grow pistachios in general
is an alternate bearing crop and so they were looking for a variety that had kind of a more even
yield year to year whereas Kerman has very high yields and then very low yields so in 2005
a new variety was released and that does exactly that it's kind of instead of really high peaks
and then really low valleys in terms of yield it's more like this and everybody wanted that
variety because it was a high producer it was a much you know better pistachio than than the Kerman
in terms of production and yield. Tom you got into this early on can you tell us how you got
into this and what have you seen now? I initially started out with the ornamental wholesale nursery
in the mid-70s then in 1978 interest rates were going through the ceiling and home loans were at
18 percent and nobody was building homes anymore so I converted that nursery into a pistachio nursery
started selling pistachios to mostly developers there were syndications groups of investors that
would hire farm managers to develop pistachios for them and then in 1982 I started farming them
for myself and have continued to increase my acreage a little bit every year since then.
And how does the space look like now is there a lot more players coming into the space?
There are a lot more people at the time that I got started it was very rare to find somebody that
knew how to grow pistachios and it was a very small group of people really and I found that
people were very generous with their time and their knowledge to try and help everyone else
in the industry grow and and do well and prosper. Early on I had what was for me a disaster crop
you know it was just did not produce what I thought it I was expecting and I
talked to someone in the industry about it asking questions. How was it a disaster did it not was it
going according to the plan? When we harvested I was expecting 3,000 pounds per acre and I got more
like 300 pounds per acre. And you took a big risk to get into this right was it risky for you
to jump into this new? Yeah I started out very very small okay I started out with a 20 acre
parcel and a partner and the person that sold it to me did owner financing for the ground
so it was not that big of an investment when it started out and then I kept adding to it but when
I had this disaster crop it was one that on a field that I'd planted and I talked to a friend
and within that week there were three people that drove up from Bakersfield to Fresno well
actually Madera where my orchard was and just showed up and they're going through looking at
leaves the soil everything and giving me advice and the reality was I was not watering enough
so they helped me out told me how to do a better job of measuring my water use and
checking it which I'm very diligent about today but I was just so impressed that they would take
the time to come all that distance and spend their time to help me out so as a result of that
I have been involved with first the California Pistachio Commission now the California Pistachio
Research Board and the Federal Marketing Order for pistachios because I want to give back to
the industry and help other people and I you know just literally on our trip down here I got a
picture from somebody that I know but I don't farm for ask you know asking what do I think is wrong
so that's the sort of thing that I like to continue to do to help others
the nursery business was very secretive people were certainly friendly but everybody was in
competition with everyone else and if you wanted to know how to do a good job of propagating a
certain plant that was a secret nobody was going to share that information with you
you mentioned the challenge you guys are facing the reason this space is not growing is because
of water otherwise it would be there would be a lot more land people would be farming more right
yes what's going on with water right well there's a lot of competition for water right and certainly
agriculture has its challenges but I think with housing there's a need for water and then you
think about the data centers that are coming into the space there's a big need for water to cool the
data centers and so that's in competition with agriculture which is always every year wondering
what their allocation is going to be and then of course if if you don't get an allocation and
you're just using well water how deep is your well or how are you going to have to go deeper
how good is the water quality of that well all those things impact agriculture and even
something like pistachios which has a higher tolerance for salinity it's still a concern
because you you need high quality water to produce a high quality product which is you know pistachios
tom you have 15 000 acres under your your management right yes do you ever worry about
running out of water every day it's something that can be managed the good news is that pistachios
are a high enough value crop that we can afford to pay more for water but there's a great variation
of the cost of water there's districts central california irrigation district that water costs
can be as low as 20 an acre foot currently water in westlands supplemental water is 800 an acre foot
so and i at one time paid almost two thousand dollars an acre foot for water there's no
crop that can sustain itself at two thousand dollars an acre foot for water but pistachios
are more tolerant price wise and drought wise than most other crops now when you pay two thousand per
acre you have to use the water even if you lose money does that work like that a pistachio tree
is not going to die for lack of water it will harm the crop but it will come back back in the
early 80s the pistachio commission did some research and they took trees down in lost hills
and stopped watering them they were mature producing trees they stopped watering them for
three years and at the end of three years they stopped producing nuts they put the water back on
and they came back into production again so they they can sustain drought quite well but the
production might but production is going to go away so when you're if you're going to pay two
thousand dollars an acre foot for water it's usually for the last half an acre foot that you
need to finish your crop you're not going to start out a season paying two thousand dollars an acre
foot and plan on sustaining a profitable orchard at that point so how does it compare with almond
and walnut and other other types of nuts they use pretty close to the same amount of water as tom
said you know the pistachios are much more tolerant because they have a deeper root system and a much
more structural root system than almonds almonds they're a lot more surface rooted uh tree and so
you need to make sure if that's your investment you have to make sure that you're going to you're
going to irrigate that to keep those trees alive whereas pistachios you could go those three years
you won't survive if there's the trees will certainly survive and then of course uh walnuts
can be very sensitive to loss of water they're going to need much more because they're a much
bigger tree so water at the end of the day is is an important part of agriculture and
it doesn't matter what you're growing you need a certain amount to grow that crop
tom what about some californians may have a pushback and say you guys are taking too much
water in the ag space can you tell us what are your thoughts well it takes a lot of water to
grow any kind of food some crops take more some take less but in general most crops take about
three acre feet of water per year we talked about housing in the state housing single family homes
with a yard and typical space takes about three acre feet to sustain homes as well as crops so
once you build a home you can never follow it again you need water there every year regardless
of what the water supply is whereas when you plant a crop you may not get your allocation of
water and you might have to follow it or not water it for that year or or more so once we put in homes
they're there to stay and the water is permanently accounted for do you have any thoughts on the
water like how the state is allocating water growers have paid for uh water that they never
get right and so that's always always painful to be in farming and having to pay for uh water that
you're never going to to see you know they've they've paid to put in uh all the infrastructure
for water and they haven't gotten a lot of that can you tell us how and can you explain that
well the the infrastructure for the california water project where the state the state water
project um growers growers irrigation districts have paid into that over over a period of time i
mean that was put in years ago and they continue to pay into that but they don't always get the
the amount of water the allocation could be 15 for a year but you you're anticipating 100
so what what happens year after year i mean you're always having to fallow ground as a result of not
having that water but i want to go back to what growers have done because if you think about 1979
we had 31,000 acres of pistachios we had 17 million pounds that came uh out of that that
came out to about 600 pounds per acre and if you had that same 31,000 acres today
growers have gotten so efficient that that would result in about 95 million pounds of pistachios
based on the the irrigation practices that they use now the different types of fertilizer that
they use now the newer varieties there's a lot of investment that's gone into what
used to be to where we're at now with pistachios and you can take any crop and really it's the
research that has been done to help growers become more efficient and produce much more food
with the the same or even less amount of water than than they're using today are we a lot more
efficient than the competition across the globe in terms of how much yield we we have how much
we produce per acre definitely iran was the historic home for all pistachios globally and
we outproduced them probably 10 to 1 in terms of yield in terms of yield and it's just water and
farming practices that are just much more enhanced here in terms of water do you have
any recommendations for the state what should they do to improve what's happening with the farmers
right now well i think the state's done a very poor job of managing it and they've decided that
environmental uses are more important than food and so they're have routinely supplied
more water than is necessary to environmental uses and it we've had an issue with endangered
species primarily the delta smelt but they have continued to push more water into the delta and
out to the san francisco bay to try and increase uh the numbers of delta smelt and it has not helped
at all at the same time they have not limited the non-native fish uh the bass that eat delta
smelt is one of their food sources so they're they're sort of working against themselves there
and not managing it in a very good way in my opinion the draft is over in a sense do you guys
see more water allocation coming the state as a whole was out of drought you know this year but
it doesn't mean that we're not going to go potentially back into drought if you look at
our snowpack right now the snowpack is is pretty much non-existent all of our reservoirs are
much higher on average right now than they've been in a long long time but we don't know what
our snowpack is going to be next year so drought is a is always looming over agriculture and they're
always concerned about the allocation of water the availability of of water to produce a crop
when you think about establishing a pistachio orchard or a perennial crop of any kind whether
that's almonds or grapes that's a huge investment in uh in that piece of ground uh whether it's 40
acres or 100 acres the cost to just to establish it you're probably looking at anywhere between
uh 15 and 20 thousand dollars per acre by the time you get a little bit of a crop when we talk
about drought and we talk about snowpack and we talk about water availability and allocations
growers that's all they think about is is water because without water nothing nothing else matters
do you think people are not investing in this space because of the uncertainty with water
absolutely with the sustainable groundwater management act you can no longer pump groundwater
that used to be our go-to when surface water was not available because of drought or because of
restrictions for uh endangered species we would go to our wells and pump groundwater well we
over pumped as a result of not having the surface water available so now
the largest irrigation district in the state is westlands and the pumping allocation this
year is one acre foot that you can pump it's going to drop down in a few years to
just slightly over a half an acre foot that you can pump well if you need three acre feet total
that means you're short roughly two and a half acre feet and you're gonna have to buy surface
water to accommodate that and it's become more and more expensive so you wouldn't grow your
your investment at this stage until you know like there is or would you do it farmers are kind of
gamblers and they often think that they can overcome obstacles in their path and
i'm inclined to think that i can overcome those obstacles and part of it is i believe that with
what's going on in westland's water district in particular where they're uh following huge
tracks of ground for solar that water is not leaving the irrigation district but the need for
it is leaving so as time goes by there'll be less and less demand for that water and hopefully
people with higher value crops can afford to pay the price that you need to pay to get that water
so i am marginally optimistic i have not planted any new pistachios in over three years however
that was my primary go-to business was developing new orchards for other people
and you mentioned farmers can overcome obstacles they're good at that is there a point where you
realize you can do that as a farmer that you overcome something that was you thought it was
impossible to overcome a lot of pistachio farmers in particular have taken very marginal ground
because we have been told that pistachios can take higher levels of salt like higher levels of boron
need less water all these things and so unfortunately for some people they've stretched
that point too far but i feel that i have been successful in getting close to that edge but still
able to produce a good crop for example i farm pistachios in tranquility in san joaquin area
fresno and it's some of the highest clay content of any soil in the world and most people would
not think that you could grow trees in that ground and i actually i'm the first one to
plant pistachios in tranquility and they have done quite well they not as well as other areas with
you know class one soils but certainly profitably how much are you guys bringing into california
it's about 65 percent of all of the world's supply is coming from the farmers here right
i think the industry as a whole is two to two and a half billion dollars that's all the processors
and growers and i mean that's the the value of pistachios we're roughly 70 percent of the world
supply of pistachios so we started from nothing essentially in the 70s and now we're the number
one so the number 70 percent yeah if you were to tell californians that are sitting most of us are
living in the cities you know we were living in southern california northern california coastal
area most of people are getting their food from the supermarket do you have any thoughts for them
on what you guys are seeing from your side a lot of californians who live in this state where
a lot of perennial crops are grown and and our products are shipped all around the world
don't even don't even know that you know stuff is grown here they don't even really take a look at
you know where their food is coming from and it's it's coming from a farmer in the central valley
if it's pistachios it's i mean pistachios are grown from you know baker south of bakersfield
you know all the way up to to redding and a lot of those uh farmers are just small family farmers
yeah maybe they maybe they farm a thousand acres that's still it's a small family farm it's a small
business they put their heart and soul into that ground and into that crop and produce uh the
highest quality uh the most consistency that um has ever been done in terms of pistachios i mean
that's why we have people coming from all over the world wanting california pistachios because it's
the highest uh quality and and very consistent it's always going to be a a wonderful beautiful
looking crop with you know very little issues as people become more health conscious a plant-based
protein is a very strong selling point for pistachios and i think that as you mentioned
a lot of people get their or only contact with food is going to the supermarket
but what they have to realize is that the security of a domestically grown food supply is very
important if we had to rely upon other countries for all of our food we could be in a very
precarious situation from what i'm gathering like we've created this industry in california
from scratch essentially from not much and not only we've grown the acreage significantly
we've also grown the yield significantly you're doing 10 times than iran's pistachios where i'm
from and iran was very proud of this their pistachio production but california is doing
10 times the yield and some people might say that we're using too much pesticides and chemicals
what are your thoughts on that in this space here's what i'll say is that we
have done a much better job we used to put pounds or even hundreds of pounds of pesticides per acre
now oftentimes we're down to ounces per acre because the the space has changed dramatically
both in fertilizers and pesticides and at the end of the day growers don't want to apply anything
because there's a cost associated with that you have to have the person who's going to mix you
have to have the person who's going to drive and then you have all the maintenance that goes
with the tractor and the sprayer if they can avoid any of that they they absolutely will
but the efficiency of applying pesticides and fertilizers has gotten so much so much better
even fertilizers when you think about 1979 the amount of fertilizers that we had we've had maybe
10 different products now we have liquid fertilizers we have dry fertilizers we have
foliar fertilizers a lot of specialty products that help that are applied and help enhance and
improve a crop to to where we're at 3,000 3,200 pounds is about the average for the industry in
terms of pistachios per acre but we have growers that are doing much more than that there are
growers that are getting 5,000 or 6,000 pounds per acre and they really dial in their pesticide
applications and their their fertilizer applications so they can they can get those
types of of yields you know year over year so we've done a pretty good job farmers myself in
particular resist using any chemicals as much as possible because you're a farmer you own the ground
and you want to take care of it because that's what takes care of you so you never want to put
anything on there that might jeopardize that first of all second of all it all comes down to the
bottom line how much did i make and my expenses take away from that whether it's water or fuel or
fertilizer or whatever i want to put as little into it and get as much out of it all these chemicals
are very expensive there's nothing that's inexpensive about it so you want to reduce
the amount that you have to use to the bare minimum if you can get away with not doing it
you absolutely skip it there's things that we are now working on with pheromones to distract
uh breeding of insects our number one pest has been navel orange worm and we've now using
pheromones to confuse them so they can't find each other and create more navel orange worms
those sorts of things i think they're going to be more and more prevalent in the future hopefully
Tom you've been one of the pioneers in this space did you ever think that when you started
doing the pistachios did you ever think we would be here no not at all uh it's turned out
much better than i ever would have imagined and i it's funny i um have told a number of people
that i feel like i'm an evangelist for pistachios um i try and get all my friends involved in it
my my neighbors uh my family as i mentioned i was in the nursery business before it was very
competitive nobody wanted to share anything it's been very good for me and my family and i want it
to be good for everyone else's family so um i have a lot of people that are very happy that i convinced
them to invest in pistachios and did you ever think the yield could be this much higher than
when you started no i really didn't but it seems like over time mainly through the california
pistachio research board we've we keep honing in on you know tweaking what we do you know the
amount of water the amount of fertilizer the timing of all those things um the orchard sanitation um
you know that's been a big thing for controlling navel orange worm is orchard sanitation so just
all these little things along the way is we've learned you know every year and it's funny i
will talk to growers that i've known for a long time in the industry
and they'll say you know as years go by we learn more and more and i feel like there's
more and more that we don't know and that's really the case i mean when i first started out
there was a thing called epicarp lesion and it was from insects stinging the nuts we didn't even
know what it was causing it we just thought it was a natural process that these brown spots
appeared on the outside of the hull of a pistachio so it's been a long time and a long
learning curve but we're still learning more every year and you guys share this information
among each other right absolutely yeah the california pistachio research board is made up of
of growers and so and there's an assessment that is paid by every grower and then the the board
decides they review about 35 to 50 proposals that focus on irrigation and pest and diseases and
genetics and a whole host of other things that are focused on pistachios and they spend
depending on the the merits of the proposals they spend anywhere between 1.5 and 2.5 million
dollars a year funding these projects that are done by a university of california csu
california state university researchers and the usda and so really those projects have helped
kind of propel the pistachio industry to where it's at today well excellent we hope that you
guys grow a lot more and come back and tell us the story it's great to have you on california
insider great thanks for having us what do you think about this discussion on pistachios in
california do you think we should apply these principles to other farming areas make sure to
us in comments or email us at siamakacaliforniainsider.com we read all of your emails and comments
i'm siamak korami this is california insider we'll see you next time