For families struggling to find a home they can afford, an open affordable unit can mean stability after months or even years of waiting. Yet in parts of California’s affordable housing system, some units are sitting empty while the need stays high.
That gap affects more than housing statistics. It reaches the families still waiting and puts focus on a harder issue: what happens after affordable housing is built, but some of those homes remain open?
In this episode, Tia Boatman Patterson, President and CEO of the California Community Reinvestment Corporation, and Jim Righeimer, Chief Executive Officer at Arbor Capital Partners, examine what they are seeing in California’s affordable housing system and what may be happening between an open unit and the person waiting for a home.
00:00 - Intro 04:14 - Challenges in Defining Housing Problems 05:55 - Operational Costs and Wraparound Services 14:18 - Systemic Issues and Policy Changes 16:57 - Coordinated Entry Systems and Lease-Up Issues 24:01 - Impact of Policy Changes on Housing Vacancy
Over the years in California, there's been a ton of investment in affordable housing,
but today we find out that some of this housing might be sitting empty.
Our guests today is Tia Patterson and Jim Rickheimer, who are going to explain what's
happening with affordable housing in California and why some are sitting empty right now as there
is a shortage of housing. I looked deeper in the data, the vacancy rate on my homeless designated
units is really high and those are newer units. There's no reason why a development that is less
than six years old should be sitting empty. The state has now said that housing is a statewide
issue and we're going to take away all the power from the local governments. You get this backlash
from the neighborhood saying you're about to put in a nine-story building or a six-story building
next to single-family houses with half the parking that they should have. People are going to still
have cars. They're going to be in your neighborhood and it just kind of goes crazy.
I'm Siamak. Welcome to California Insider. Jim, Tia, it's great to have you on. Welcome.
Thank you. Great to be here. Great to be back. You guys have both a lot of experience in housing
in California and today we want to talk to you about affordable housing. Tia, you have a big
portfolio of the affordable housing loans in your company that you're managing, you're watching,
and it came to your attention that some of this affordable housing is sitting empty,
which is contradictory to what we are hearing. In California, everywhere we're trying to build
housing, at the beach, in different cities, and there's a lot of drama and there's a lot of battle
around where should we build this housing and why they cost so much. Can you tell us what you're
seeing in your portfolio right now? Right, so I have a 1.5 billion dollar portfolio that I service.
We're very representative of the state of California. Everything that we lend to
is affordable housing. Less than 80% of the area median income, which would be in Los Angeles
County, about $80,000 a year for a family of four. Primarily, I'm probably closer to around
50% AMI when you look at my overall portfolio, which would be about 50,000. Yes, area median
income in Los Angeles. 50% of that would be a family of four that makes about $50,000 a year.
So those are the folks that I am serving or living in the developments that we finance.
So when I look at that overall portfolio, 10% of those loans are what we would call on our watch
list. That means they're having some kind of economic instability. They're having expenses
that are exceeding their revenue, but something's wrong with that 10%. So that 10% or 40 of the 400
developments, I have 42,000 units in my portfolio. So I want to say there's probably about
200 of those that are high vacancy. And when I say high vacancy, I'm saying higher than 5%,
because that would be, I would think, the industry standard. That's what you usually
underwrite to. You have turnover, et cetera. But when you start getting vacancy up 13%,
14%, 16% vacancy, you know there's a problem. And so when I looked at those 200 units,
they were split into largely two groups. A group of 20 properties that are all less
than five years old. So we're talking newer properties who should not be experiencing
problems leasing that. And then there was a group of properties that are older properties
that I'm wondering what's going on with those properties. So I compared those two properties.
Group one primarily serves homeless units. Group two is older family developments.
And so taking a deeper dive and understanding why are these units experiencing higher vacancies?
And so I've come to some conclusions as to why I think and love to hear some discussion about
what that is. But why would newer units that are serving our homeless have a higher vacancy rate?
Shouldn't there be a line? Usually I thought there should be a waiting list for something
like this. People are waiting in line to get... I mean part of the problem here is that how we
define the housing problem that we have. And when we go ahead and say part of our housing problem
is the homeless. And you get a lot of people would disagree that it's not a housing problem.
It's a drug, alcohol, medical, psychological, other issues that is causing people to become
homeless. You'll have a person who loses his job, loses their apartment, things fall apart,
but you get them stabilized again. You get them back in a job and they're okay.
A person who's homeless is homeless for other reasons. I mean when I'm talking about homeless,
I'm talking about you haven't lived indoors for at least months at a time. And you may go into
a program here and there. What you find after a while is people don't want to stay because
they can't get off of drugs or whatever their issue is or their psychological issue,
their family or whatever it is. It's not a rough problem. It has more to do with
who they are and all the issues that they have.
Let me add to what Jim is saying and clarify some of the things. When he says affordable
housing is the most expensive housing that we build. Permanent supportive housing,
which is targeting our homeless population, is the most expensive housing to build.
And our policy makers have prioritized resources to a certain type of housing,
permanent supportive housing, which has higher operational costs and lower rents.
Well, I mean, when you're saying higher, it's massively higher.
Massive.
So what'll happen is they call it wraparound services. So when they say $24 billion got
spent for affordable or for homeless housing or whatever housing over so many years. Yeah,
because we used to think about it as how many units did we get? That's how we solved it.
Now it's solving the whole problem that person has with their life. And it's very expensive.
The issue is all homeless is not alike, but we've tried to solve the homeless problem
with a one size. Like if there's only one issue. In the early 2000, 2006, 2008,
the federal government and the state stopped funding transitional housing. So if that was
a shelter to help you get stabilized, if that was some kind of-
It was a time limited thing. You had to move forward.
So we stopped funding that. But the problem is you can have homeless because you're couch
surfing and you're just vanilla homeless and you just need affordable housing. The model
that Jim talked about where they purchased affordability, that worked. It actually worked
with very shallow subsidy because they weren't having to capitalize operating costs and do all
of these other things. It was someone who had the ability to pay rent was living in that development
and the rent and the expenses, it penciled. So now if you're building only permanent supportive
housing for people who only make $30,000 a year or $0 a year, that rent or that revenue coming in
has to be able to pay for that debt. And so you're now getting to a point to where
that permanent supportive housing that could help someone who maybe has
a few problems, you're trying to serve the highest of high acuity in a development that
really wasn't made for them. That perhaps that person should have been in transitional housing.
This is controversial, but perhaps that person should be institutionalized. That's the issue.
Housing first does not equate to only permanent supportive housing because our systems,
and I'll be honest, I have a son that suffers from mental illness and drug addiction. Every
time he goes to rehab or transitional housing, if he slips up, he gets kicked out and put back
on the street. But that doesn't work. What you need is instead of having low barrier to permanent
supportive housing, why do we not have a system that allows, instead of punishing him, brings him
back and continues to be able to help stabilize him? So what we've said with housing first,
it's how we've implemented housing first. And what kind of housing is it?
And what kind of housing is it? So if you've got a facility,
a big room with a bunch of separate beds and they're kind of closed off with areas,
but they're all together, that's not the same as having your own apartment.
But that's how you earn up to the apartment. Like when you get clean, when you get sober,
when you do it, then you get the care. It's like now you've got a lock on your door. Now you have
your own door and you can do those kinds of things. And those kinds of ideas are the kind
of things you need to kind of help people get through it. I mean, drugs and alcohol, I mean,
it's a horrible situation if kids get caught in that at all.
But you need stabilization. You can't have a system, and this is where I think it's a systemic
problem, not only a housing problem. Correct.
You have to have a system that is able to navigate the right people, the right population
to the right housing type. I cannot be a chronically homeless person with high acuity
that has lived on the street from 10 years and go move straight to permanent supportive housing
with no mandatory service, all voluntary services. If I was outside and I was getting my heat from a
trash can and I was setting fires in the trash can, do you think I'm going to stop setting fires
the minute I move into that permanent supportive housing? There needs to be a system to help that
person. To help you change your behaviors to go back.
And that system is missing. I have on my board a woman who specializes in social services and
case management. Her goal was, I don't think any unit, any development should have more than 25%
of high acuity. Because if I have 100 units of high acuity people, that's too much.
High acuity means I have some kind of mental
disorder. I have some kind of substance abuse disorder, but I am in and out of the system.
And you can't have more than 25% of that in any one development.
So when you have someone who is a high acuity person, that takes a lot of intense case management.
Now you've created policies where you want to serve those high acuity people, but you want to
serve a lot of those high acuity people in one development. And you have to think,
these services are voluntary.
So they're not mandatory.
They're not mandatory services.
You can just do whatever you want.
You don't have to take the service. And so it's like, what do you do? And it's not a lot of people.
So I'm doing my screening, I have 100 development, I'm leasing up. It's one to 3% of the folks that
are potentially causing the problem. You need to limit your number of high acuity folks that
you're going to put in that development. And you need to have a social service plan that is going
to identify that person and understand that person is having problems and they're not probably ready
to be in this unit. And then that person needs to have a place to go, not just back on the street.
And think about when we build an apartment building, it costs X dollars. The costs have
gone crazy. But back when we were doing them, there were $300,000, $400,000. It was a lot of
money then. Now there's $600,000, $800,000. But you would go ahead and put that capital into it.
Now, all of a sudden, you have people that are not inexpensive people to handle these services
and doing the things that they need. And minimum, they're making $80,000, $90,000 a year plus
benefits to go into these different buildings. And they'll have a list of things and they got
to meet with the tenant every so often. They got to check on this or do that. Those are the costs
that continue to go on after the unit's been built. It costs a lot of money to operate that.
And there's no revenue stream for that.
That maybe we should throw out here is the one thing that I think,
and it's starting to get solved with getting the beds and stuff like that. Because what happened,
it was like, how many years ago that all of a sudden this took off? We didn't have this many
homeless and all that problem 15, 20 years ago. We had some, but we didn't have it. I remember when
all of a sudden the flood control channel over by Anaheim Stadium, was that Santa Ana River?
But all of a sudden it was full of people camped the whole length of the bike path that was there.
That just came out of nowhere. And the laws were set up that you couldn't kick people out of parks
or couldn't kick them out of that. Those things have been worked through the system. And now we've
got, as long as you have beds in your community, you can say, hey, you got to get out of the park.
You can't stay here tonight because we've got a place for you to go to. Now you may not want to
go there. Newport Beach, I mean, they're down to like literally a handful of, yeah, like a handful.
They know them all by name because there was something, and I'm not trying to sound cold
on this, but there's something about making people into campers at parks like it was okay.
And you had to start making it uncomfortable to say, no, it's really not okay for you to set up
a tent here and be in our park. And then cities started getting control again because they got
the beds, which the court said they had to do, and they can start bringing it down. So I think
in some ways it's coming down a bit. Yeah. But I think it's curious that you said
we didn't have this problem 15 to 16 years ago. Like it was-
When you go back 15 to 16 years ago and you think about what policy changes did we have,
and is that perhaps unintended consequences of potential policy changes?
Oh, absolutely. I mean, something happened.
Yeah. And I think this is worth studying and having a harder conversation. So 15 to 16 years
ago, you say 16 years ago is 2010. Well, I'm a recovering redevelopment attorney, so...
That's one significant policy change.
She's talking about the fact that they got rid of redevelopment. So basically,
just to get the basics of it, that a city would take an area and say, this is a redevelopment
area, and they'd mark off that area. And then they would say that whatever additional improvements
happen here and make this a nicer community or better, spends more buildings, whatever that
property tax goes up by, that increment, that money gets over to the side and you can now use
that money to borrow money, to build projects, to do stuff. So there was a whole big thing
that redevelopment in many ways really helped things. Now that other people will argue at a
certain point, sometimes it just got to be. Ridiculous.
And then when Governor Brown came back in, there were clearly parts of redevelopment that were
abusive, and he just cut it off and basically shut it down.
What was the dilemma with them? What went wrong?
Let me overlay some other policy changes besides just the elimination of redevelopment,
because I think there were significant policy things that had these indirect consequences.
In 2010, you had the elimination of redevelopment. 2008, you had the housing crisis.
And in 2006, you stopped funding transitional housing. So you take,
I'm not going to fund a certain housing type anymore, transitional housing, homeless shelters,
beds. I'm not going to fund that anymore. That money is no longer available to build
that type of housing. 2006. 2008, you have the housing financial crisis. 2010,
you have the elimination of redevelopment. So you take the impact of all three of those
changes in policy. And I think those changes in policy have a direct line to our increased
unsheltered folks. And I'll give you an example why.
When I was working for Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency,
we went after serving the chronically homeless. And we said, let's have a plan on how we serve
the chronically homeless. Let's have a mix of housing types, because some of these folks need
to move in shelters. Some of these folks need to just have a bed. And some of these folks
need permanent supportive housing. So it wasn't just one type of housing. It was a 10-year plan
because Bush was president and Bush wanted everybody to institute a 10-year plan to
focus on chronically homeless. Out of that plan, the first two years of implementing that plan,
chronically homelessness had been reduced in Sacramento County by 35 percent, following
a strategy of various housing types that serve various populations. Now you get to 2010,
and you know how we funded that plan? Redevelopment dollars.
What about the drug side of it? Was it more restriction on drugs? And some people have told
us this, like before the police was a lot more aggressive towards drugs. Now you have people
doing drugs in front of the police and there's no consequences. It's being normalized that you can
do drugs. Has that had a big impact on the homeless side of things? Clearly, when you have situations,
and we've seen it in California, where district attorneys have lost their jobs because they came
in and said, you know, their level of what's a crime just keeps on going up. There kind of was
lawlessness that was allowed and there's just a breakdown. We didn't build the housing type
to help chronically homeless people who need to destabilize their lives. There's different kinds
of homelessness and we're treating homelessness as if it's all the same. When you can have someone
who is, I'm living in my car because my car broke down and I couldn't get to work.
I mean, there's that kind of homelessness. Or my rent. I missed a payment for my rent and
then I got evicted. That's very different than someone who wants to camp because that's just
their lifestyle. And so having a system that can identify the types of homeless,
the population, and match that person with the type of housing they should be living in,
that system, in my opinion, doesn't really exist.
Well, I mean, there is, not for plug, but I'm on the board for Mercy House. And Mercy House
started by Father Jerome Karcher 20 some years ago was literally a couple people needed some
housing and they did it. And then they got a house and then they got another house. And,
it's up to, I'm on the board, I couldn't even tell you how many of the units are up to now,
but hundreds and hundreds of units, if not thousands of units in about five counties
in a couple of states. So you get the person that's falling on bad times, we can straighten
that up pretty fast. I mean, you can get, you got to stabilize them, get them a few bucks in there.
The system. Does the government have a system?
No. That's what I'm talking about.
Yeah, that's the problem. You can solve for that and get people off the street
and get them if they just lost their job. When they have all the other issues,
that's when it gets to the point of, you're talking 70, 80, $90,000 per homeless person
in services and costs to work this out. Annually.
Annually. And you can't keep on doing that. There's just not enough money on the planet to do
that. So Tia, why do you think the housing you have that portion is empty, sitting empty right
now? Because there should be demand, right? I think there's one primary reason.
And potentially some second and third reasons. But the primary reason, I think it's a lease-up
issue. The homeless housing I have, the way it is financed, the rules require that the tenant
come through what's called a coordinated entry system. The coordinated entry system, each
continuum of care throughout the state of California has a coordinated entry system.
And that sounds expensive, doesn't it? I mean, you know that costs money.
That program has to get funded somehow. And not all coordinated entry systems in
the state of California operate or funded equally. Some coordinated entry systems
work a whole lot better. What is a coordinated entry system?
A coordinated entry system is your system that is supposed to help you track your homeless
population. The homeless population and the funding for that homeless population usually
goes through your, they call them COCs, Continuums of Care. So your Continuums of
Care are getting your federal dollars for homelessness. Your Continuums of Care operate
your coordinated entry system. So HMIS is the technology that you're supposed to use to count
coordinated entry system is the system you're supposed to use to track and place.
Where they are in the system.
Have they gotten housing? Have they gotten a job?
And your Continuums of Care are the people that get the federal funding.
Okay, so that's how it's all supposed to come together. We stopped federal funding or shrunk
the federal funding for your Continuums of Care. The HMIS systems, which are the systems that are
the reporting on how you spent those dollars. They don't all talk to each other in the state
of California because we have 58 counties and 400 and something cities. And so those HMIS,
there's no standardization on that reporting or counting. And then your coordinated entry systems,
which are supposed to do your intake and lease up and referrals to the homeless or to the housing
that's set aside for homeless. Some of it is really bad. Sometimes it'll take six months
to get a person through the coordinated entry system and try to place them in a home.
Just the mechanical system is the problem.
It's a process. Yeah. And then don't start talking about veterans homeless housing that's
supported by BASH vouchers because then now you got to go deal with two different
federal bureaucracies to try to make sure that that... And they want to serve one person at a
time and then they want to go back to their wait list. So what I'm saying is that system
that's in place to help do the lease ups, to pick, refer, and lease up, may be broken.
And in some cases, very broken. But then you have policies that say,
I have to use those systems. And so the developer is like,
I got to follow the rules and this unit is sitting naked.
I'll be default on my loan if I don't.
And we haven't invested in that process. So we've invested in building units.
We have not invested in a process to ensure we're matching populations with the housing type.
I can tell you how many units I have vacant. Can the state of California tell you how many
units they have vacant? Can they tell you which ones of their developments are probably not
meeting their debt service coverage ratio? I can manage mine because I have the data to
tell me where I need to pay attention. If you don't even look at the data,
if you're not even managing that asset, you have no idea.
From what you're saying, Tia, it looks like we may have a lot of units that are empty right now.
So let me give you how many units I have vacant at a point in time. My vacancy rate for those
watch list developments is 13 to 16 percent, which is very high. So if I'm talking about that
group of 40 properties, 21 of which have the high vacancy rate, I would say anywhere from
and of those 21 units I'm talking about of 21 properties, it's about 1400 units.
So of those 1400 units, I would say anywhere from 185 to 225 are vacant. So if I can extrapolate
that I have 10 percent of my family units that are and that are on my watch list and 10 percent
of my homeless units are higher vacancy. Why? I have to ask myself why. And so when I looked
deeper in the data, the vacancy rate on my homeless designated units is really high.
And those are newer units. There's no reason why a development that is less than six years old
should be sitting empty before. When I look at the other side, it's family units that are older,
pre 2008, nine units that are older and they're in lower resource areas. And so I'm like,
what is going on with those units that a family affordable housing unit would
go vacant? And so we took a deeper dive and there's it's systemic. That poor person who
was trying to live in that affordable housing and may have signed up for that affordable housing
three years ago and they're still sitting on the waiting list. Well, their cell phone numbers
changed three times since then. And I'm still trying to call them. The primary reason why
those units are sitting vacant is because we do not have appropriate processes to identify
and put people in. How much is the rent for something like that? By calculation, it has to
be 30 percent of the person's area median income. Let's say you're 60 percent AMI, which is sixty
thousand dollars in Los Angeles for a family of four. Yeah. And you're paying 30 percent of
like nineteen hundred a month. Right. And the average two bedroom, two bedroom, which is a
pretty good. Yeah. Right. But people will be wanting to be twenty five hundred, twenty seven
hundred. And so somebody wants that unit right now. Somebody wants it. Yeah. They can't get in
because because you are held to a certain process on how you select and put folks into that building
and your processes may be go back to your waiting list, which may be six years old
and you're dealing with a population that's probably very mobile. How do and so how do
you ensure that you're able to reach those folks and get them into the housing and whether that's
a homeless person or a very low income family? You have to be able to have a way to communicate
with them. And the public housing authorities have figured this out. The state of California
hasn't figured this out, but public housing authorities have figured it out because they
have managed wait lists for a very long time. I think there are some best practices and lessons.
The section, the section, whether you're section eight or public housing, like owned by the housing
authority, they have to manage wait lists. And if they don't manage those wait lists and keep a 95
occupancy, they get dinged by the federal government and they lose money.
So I think there is a lesson that our private developers who are building affordable housing
using state resources, there are some best practices that they could learn on what is the
best way to manage a wait list and get referrals. I think our coordinated entry systems, there are
some best practices on how to manage and deal with certain populations. This is to me the role of
policy makers. What are the best practices that are going to ensure that our systems operate
efficiently and perform? Let's collect those best practices and let's share that information with
all of our private developers who build affordable housing. And who can fix that right now? It all
comes down to, remember, real estate's local. It gets built somewhere. It's two by fours in
concrete. I mean, it's a mechanical process that has to happen. So it's like, okay, where does it
get approved? And one of the things you have if you're on a city council is if someone brings
an affordable project, the whole neighborhood goes in an uproar because they think you're
bringing a ghetto to their neighborhood. In reality, you're bringing a building that's
going to be well-managed and the people are going to be picked properly to go into that kind of
building and you can do it. So what ends up happening all the time is that the city council,
they'll approve a senior affordable housing, and senior will do, and they'll build the veterans
because veterans, you know, they poll well. It's what it comes down to. In reality,
you need housing for a mom and two kids, but it's hard to translate that and get the votes to do it.
So then what happens...
Or the money.
Because the money has been backfilled now by the state.
And if the state only has money for veterans or homeless, that's what the developers are going to
build.
They're not going to build based on the demand. They're going to build based on the money.
Where's the money to go ahead and build it?
And right now, the money is coming from the state as opposed to local government,
and the money is more restrictive instead of flexible. So you asked, what's the solution?
Well, you put the money closer to local government and have the local government
help navigate that and finance the actual plans and finance the actual systems.
The other problem that you have is then you've got the state who's going to solve everything
for everybody, and they're going to say, here, we're going to make certain areas that if you have
public transportation, which is defined as, you know, a certain level of transportation that they
have a bus come by every so many minutes or whatever it is, it carries a certain amount
of people.
We're going to go ahead and rezone this at a much, much higher density than what the local
officials want it at or the neighbors want it to be at.
And on top of that, because you're next to a bus stop, you don't need a car.
Now, anybody in Southern California knows you need a car, but policymakers have made it clear
that you don't need a car anymore.
So therefore, we don't have to have parking spaces, okay?
And so then you get this backlash from the neighborhood saying, you're about to put in
a nine-story building or a six-story building next to single-family houses with half the
parking that they should have.
People are going to still have cars.
They're going to be in your neighborhood.
And it just kind of goes crazy.
So what's happened is the state has now said that housing is a statewide issue, and we're
going to take away all the power from the local government, especially if you're not a charter
city, if you're a general law city, which a lot of...it's a technical thing, but basically,
you're...
You have less autonomy.
Yeah, your autonomy is the state laws.
You have to follow the state laws.
We're a charter city in Newport, Huntington Beach.
A lot of cities are charter.
They can set up their own set of laws and operate the way they want to operate.
But again, there's just this reaction that's just overkill.
I do believe the state has come in and treated local government sometimes as an adversary
instead of a partner.
I believe there is a disconnect and a misalignment between what the need is and how the state
wants folks to do it.
I believe if some of that money that the state is coming in, and they rewarded jurisdictions
that were doing the right thing by pushing that money down so that it could be distributed
either more regionally or locally, you would have better balance and alignment.
I think you've got that with redevelopment because the money, the planning, and the approvals
were all at the local level.
Once you disconnected that, I think you've got the state coming in trying to implement
policies which by themselves, that makes sense.
But holistically, it may not.
Higher density around transportation by itself makes sense.
But who's taking the transportation?
Who's taking the public transportation?
Is the public transportation getting funded?
Is it up and running?
So there is this misalignment between what is needed and how to balance that with the
funding that is being...because with that funding comes strengths.
And there needs to be more collaboration and local government has to be your partner.
If they had better planning, and when I say planning, it's not just about the housing
and transportation, it's about the amenities and the jobs.
So you know what a house is?
It's where a job goes home to sleep.
And so how do I get back and forth to my job?
Well, during COVID, we found out it's called the internet and you hook up your computer
and you never left.
Right.
But this is the thing, we're very car dependent here in California because we ripped up all
of our good infrastructure.
But is that ever really going to change?
Because when you look at how we're laid out in a grid, mile square grids, that you're
just not close enough to anything and it's already been laid out.
And so the idea that all of a sudden we're going to put a bunch of housing here and somehow
they're going to...well, the project that Anderall, we just talked about earlier,
they wanted to put apartments there, they got it approved for 1,000 apartments.
Who wanted it?
Was it the Regional Planning Agency?
No, the developers wanted it.
1,000 units, they're going to make a fortune on it.
Anderall had to come back in and buy that thing at a much higher value because they
needed it for the jobs, to have the jobs there.
But here's the thing, if your Regional Planning Agency, who's planning all your transportation,
because they're looking at the data, where are the jobs going to be, where are the amenities
going to be, where are the people going to be?
And if they had identified in that regional plan, this is the job center and we're not
putting houses here.
Because there's ways to do this.
It's called specific planning.
Right.
But the state comes back in and says, you will deliver 11,000 units.
The state doesn't tell you, you have to build it.
The state tells you, you have to zone areas such that you can put 11,000 more units in
your town or whatever the number they come back with.
And so the problem is when you're already built out and you're already done, how much
can those planning people make an impact?
Like, well, here's the future.
The future is here.
Look out the window.
It's already built.
The chance of it getting demoed is not there.
Meanwhile, let's go ahead and take single family neighborhoods and add an apartment.
You add an apartment in every third or fourth backyard.
There's no place to park on your street anymore.
The effect on your house and your living is different than when you had a single family
neighborhood.
And there's nothing wrong with having a single family neighborhood.
But yet it's like people are looked down upon.
They're saying, well, no, I really don't want to have my neighbors all have apartments in
their backyard because I don't know.
They're changing their, you know, apartments move out more often every 18 to 24 months
where a homeowner may stay for seven or 10 years.
It's just different.
I have seen several granny flats go into my neighborhood and it hasn't hurt transportation
one bit.
It hasn't yet until it does.
And that's my point.
It's not.
I mean, I can take into neighborhoods now that you go down the block and there's, you
And now between driveway to driveway, where there was no cars parked on the street or
just kind of when you needed them, all of a sudden they're all backed up.
Not completely yet.
And then what does it take?
A couple more units.
And by the way, there's no stopping it now because there's basically no single family
zoning in California anymore.
Nothing is single family zoned.
Well, two thirds of the state of California was zoned single family.
And when you say they've taken away single family units, it's you can't build more than
four units on a single family lot.
And when you think about financing, a fourplex is a single family.
I know.
Yeah.
One to four.
Yeah.
One to four units should be fine on a lot that is standard or bigger.
The issue comes up when the state of California is not providing the resources to do the planning
and the incentives.
OK, let's say we did the planning and we got the incentives.
If you're going into a standard size lot, 50 by 110, 5,500 square foot lot.
And now you go ahead and you've got a two car garage to park, two cars.
And you've got out in the street.
And out of the street is really your guest parking because you can park your two cars
in the garage.
And if you have a little bit of a driveway, you can put another car there.
Yeah.
Cars can't back out, but there's a spot for it.
You had three more apartments there.
If they just have one car in every apartment, which they're going to have more, because
once you have a couple, it's not unlikely they can have two cars.
There's no there's physically no space to put the three cars anymore.
And when I was on the commission, I mean, the mayor of Costa Mesa, I was fine about
building auxiliary dwelling units.
It's actually the word for the granny flat.
I was fine about doing it as long as you parked it, which means that, yeah, you've got to
do a little bit more construction on your existing house.
You've got to move stuff around.
You've got to get a couple of parking spaces.
You do that and you don't impact the neighborhood.
We can get there from here.
But if you just, I mean, to the point now where California has said that the neighbor
who had their garage illegally made into an apartment, now they just have to go into the
city.
They got to get the health and safety stuff done with the fire department and they can
convert that unit to an apartment legally now.
But they don't talk about, they just got rid of two parking spaces.
I know parking is kind of a, it's really in the weeds, but the reality of it is that's
how you destroy neighborhoods that people like to live in after a while.
Number one.
Number two, once you put that unit in the back, you never have a first-time home buyer
buy those units anymore because they can't afford it.
It's now a duplex or a triplex.
And one of my episodes, I talked about measuring and evaluating on the back end.
Of the laws, yeah.
Yeah, so we have passed a significant number of laws.
Right.
I don't think they should pass one more housing law.
I think they need to go back and they need to evaluate, how are we calculating RENA?
How are we treating local government?
Like the regional housing.
All of these laws that we passed that said we were going to do production, how have they
impacted the neighborhood?
And I would like to see them actually do that.
Over 400 pieces of legislation.
The running joke that I have, and I do land development for tracts of homes out of state.
And the running joke that I have is go to a neighborhood that was built in 2000.
That's 26 years ago.
Okay, that's my neighborhood.
And 26 years ago, it's not that old.
I mean, I don't think of it as like some super old neighborhood.
It was built in 2000, okay?
And their building code has changed like six or seven times.
How much better is the neighborhood now than when the building code was done 25 years ago?
I mean, I'm sure there's some better things, but they don't make any massive difference.
But the fact of the matter is when you go to develop, you go get your project approved.
The economy stops.
Your project's on hold.
A couple of years goes by.
They change the building code.
Bring your project back in again.
Let's go ahead and redraw it up again.
The neighborhood park that they promised me, that I've been paying a mellow ruse on for
the last 26 years, because I lived in my house for 26 years, just got built about six months
My kids are all like out of college now.
And it's a beautiful park.
My husband and I went by there now and we're like, oh, this is the park we were supposed
to get 26 years ago.
But Jim is on a good point about the building standards.
They keep changing.
And they don't have to, right?
California has probably the strictest building standards in the nation.
And so I think Jerry Brown used to say a whole lot of good things can equal bad.
This is why we need the evaluation.
This is why when you pass a series of laws and they start coming together, the unintended
consequences of your good may be creating very problematic because a lot of your layering
of your good is now costing us seven, eight hundred thousand dollars a unit to build affordable
housing.
Right.
So you need to evaluate the laws that we have now put in place because are they working?
Are they not working?
There is a reason why our unsheltered population has exploded.
And I told you, we had a series of things that helped create those unintended consequences.
So you are not going to fix this until you do some evaluation and review and understanding
the impact and understanding it's not just a housing issue.
Some of this is social infrastructure and having things in place as a safety net for
certain populations.
And I don't think we've had those conversations.
We've had a kind of a one-size-fits-all mentality.
We've had a top-down mentality for the last 16 years.
It's been a top-down as opposed to a bottom-up.
And you cannot treat strategic partners as your adversary because you know what happens?
You don't get anything done.
Which is the city and cities and states.
And the developers.
If we're going to depend on private developers to build housing, what does the market need?
So the developers in the affordable housing community, because you need subsidy, they
will chase the dollars.
And those dollars may not be what the market needs.
Which causes places to stay empty.
There's a lot to be said for kind of everybody stopping all this changes that we're going
through, the heavy hand the state is doing with all these cities, these fights that they're
getting in with trying to win battles.
It needs to calm down.
It really does.
We need to get back to things that would get housing going.
Like getting projects approved that don't take three or four or five or six years to
get through an environmental impact report.
And having litigation by labor unions that say this project has to be prevailing wage
or you can't build it.
I mean, there's a lot more things that we could talk about.
But we've been buried into the woods once we got to that in there.
The problem can be fixed to a certain point.
But again, I'll say this.
It's impossible to solve everybody's housing problem if they don't have some input
themselves to solve their own problem.
Jim Brick.
Hi, Mayor T.F.
Anderson.
It was great to have you on.
We look forward to bringing you back and having more of these discussions.
Thank you so much.
Thanks for having us.
Tell us what you think about this conversation.
Are you for or against affordable housing in your community?
Make sure to tell us in the comments or email us at cmik.californiansider.com.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm CMI Korami.
This is California Insider.
We'll see you next time.