This episode of Let’s Talk Housing features Steven Thomas of Reports On Housing explaining why affordability remains the single biggest force shaping today’s housing market. The discussion explores how mortgage rates, home prices, and household incomes work together to determine affordability, why the market remains frozen, and what could finally improve conditions for buyers. It also addresses common misconceptions about affordability and why meaningful change takes time.
Got questions? Drop them in the comments or email us at [email protected] for a chance to have them featured in a future episode!
Time Stamps: 00:00 Introduction 01:45 What Happens in the Fall Housing Market 06:17 Why Inflation and Jobs Matter 11:33 What Affordability Really Means 15:04 Affordability vs Mentality 17:40 Can Affordability Improve Over Time? 19:39 The Biggest Affordability Misconception 22:59 Conclusion
Hello, beautiful listeners, and welcome back to another episode of Let's Talk Housing.
I am Brennan Thomas, economist and co-host alongside Steven Thomas, chief economist and
founder of Reports on Housing.
So before we get into today's episode about affordability, because it surrounds the housing
market, Steve, how's everything going?
How is your summer progressing?
Well, it's been really good.
Have had a great summer so far.
Not a whole heck of a lot going on.
It's called summer.
Lots of distractions with lots of kids.
So there's a lot of different times where we go, hey, you know what?
Let's go throw a Frisbee around and go Frisbee golfing.
Did that the other day.
That was a lot of fun.
So did a little bit of bocce ball, too.
When you have the kids around and it's nice out and you're like caught up, you just want
to go out there and do some fun things.
So that's the distractions of summer, period.
And that's why we slow down a little bit for the real estate market.
But that's what's going on for us.
Just more summer.
That's it.
How about you?
What's going on with you?
Pretty same old over here, too.
Just lots of beach days, pool days, just laying out, trying to relax, slow my brain down a
little bit.
I'm enjoying it.
Or at least I'm trying to.
So there's that.
But now I want to switch gears to the housing market.
So as the fall market approaches, it's right around the corner.
What can we expect in the housing arena?
Well, when we get to it's at the very end of August, we're going to we're going to hit
that end of end of summer and kids are going back to school and it's not there's something
to be said about going from August to September where, yeah, it's not really fall until we
get to like the twenty twenty first right around there.
It's the same thing with summer.
It doesn't really begin until June 20th, June 21st.
But really, it begins at the start of that month.
It feels like summer in June at the very beginning of June because kids are out of school.
There's graduations.
There's a lot of more distractions.
The same thing happens on September 1st.
Kids are going back to school.
Even if you don't have kids, it's there's this transition that takes place.
Going into September feels like fall and shoot, you know, we're going to have all the all
the fall stuff as early as early September for Starbucks and everywhere else.
So welcome back.
All those different wonderful flavors that everybody can't wait, wait, wait to get their
first one.
And it's like that comes early.
The holidays come early.
But as soon as we hit September 1st, that's where that transition.
What happens with housing is we get inventory levels coming down and almost all markets.
There are a few exceptions out there, but pretty much we've already peaked in the housing
market as far as inventory is concerned.
Demands peaked a long time ago, but it remains pretty flat from where it peaks during the
spring all the way until you get to about September.
Then you start to see demand drifting down more.
So you have inventory levels, levels drifting down and you have demand levels drifting down
and people go, well, there's a lot of homes that are languishing on the market.
Yeah, but there's not a lot of new homes coming on the market, new properties, properties
hitting the market for the first time.
It's because you're the biggest.
The biggest time for homes coming to market is during the spring and during the summer.
But now you're getting into September and that's typically what everybody has that mentality
that now we're into the fall.
So there are fewer homeowners that come on the market.
It's like the latter half of the year.
There are pretty much only four months left of the year and you're going to go into these
slower seasons.
It's not where people go, this is the best time of the year to come on the market.
That's not what people are thinking.
And the further you get into the fall market, yeah, it just continues that way.
Fewer people come on the market.
Some people that weren't successful during the spring and summer actually pull their
homes off the market come the fall.
Or they can wait longer and they'll pull their homes off the market.
But there starts to be an elevated number of homes coming off the market in September
because gone are the spring and summer and they're going, well, didn't quite do it.
They pull their homes off the market, fewer homes coming on the markets, recipe for inventory
levels coming down.
At the same time, demand activity also comes down.
It's down the fall.
A lot of people go, yeah, I'm not necessarily want to move during the fall or during the
holidays.
Some people do.
And there are a lot of people that do it during the winter break in the month of December.
But that's not what the vast majority of people do.
That's not what the trends show.
Instead, you have supply coming down and you have demand coming down at the same level.
So the speed of the market, surprisingly, doesn't really change.
So it doesn't feel like it's all of a sudden a slower market because we're into September.
It's the exact opposite of that.
It feels the same.
So by the time it gets to the end of the summer, it feels a little bit sluggish.
And then by the time you start the fall, it feels a little bit sluggish.
And that's because if you have more, a whole bunch of people coming off the market or not
as many coming on the same, the numbers are actually going down.
Seller competition is lessening.
So even if you're a buyer and there are fewer buyers in the marketplace, there's not as
many homes on the market as there was when it peaked over the summer.
So you could see that the inventory levels are coming down.
So a lot of people expect that it slows down, thinking that this is not the best time to
purchase a home.
But it's also not the best time to list a home also.
So if you're going to think along that mentality.
So that is the best explanation for it.
Not making this stuff up.
It has to do with actual data and stats and trend analysis, that type of thing.
So so often we talk about economic reports.
I ask you what's going on, the things that have been released, but I feel like it's a
good idea to revisit this topic.
Why do inflation and jobs readings impact housing as much as they do, especially mortgage
rates?
But can you get into the details as to why?
Yeah, so with inflation and jobs, data impact the housing market because it has everything
to do with rates.
And I always talk about rates as being the gas pedal of the housing market, especially
this housing market.
People can't stand listening to me say it.
I was just reading to you some of the comments about the BS that I'm full of, just full of
BS.
And I don't know what the heck I'm talking about because they have all these credentials
in economics and, you know, with their Ph.D. in psychiatry or whatever it is, whatever
it is that they have, communications degree, that does not make them an economist.
So it's unfortunate, but we're at the point where there's not a lot that's going to move
prices.
And if you haven't figured that out so far, prices haven't really moved and they're very,
very flat.
And the reason for that is because there's this equilibrium between the number of sellers
and buyers that are out there.
And I'm talking about sellers that really want to sell.
So there's kind of a balance between the two of them.
It doesn't mean that values are plunging or anything like that or going up.
It's just a balanced market.
And this has to do with where rates are at.
And rates are kind of been where the market's been frozen and it's not it's it's it's kept
a lot of homeowners from placing their homes on the market.
And it's also kept a lot of buyers out of the equation of purchasing.
So the the jobs market, as well as the inflation readings, have that's the dual mandate.
The Federal Reserve is following the Federal Reserve.
They have this thing called the Federal Reserve.
It's the the Fed.
It's their short term federal funds rate.
And that is an overnight banking rate.
So banking, they only they only meet eight times per year and they can either keep it
the same, increase it or decrease it.
And what they've been basically doing this year is pretty much just keeping it the same.
And with them just keeping it the same, you'd think that rates are the same.
They're not.
They they went all the way from a where we were at a floor of six percent prior to the
Iran conflict, all the way up to where they are, you know, above six and a half percent
or right around six percent.
So they went all the way up to six and three quarters percent.
And that was on the backs of them not doing anything.
The only thing that was priced in is that they're going to have to do something down
the road because of inflation.
And that is not make the cuts that they were originally going to and actually maybe even
increase rates down the road.
So mortgage rates on a daily basis go where they think that they need to go.
So they're looking at it now.
The Fed's looking at the job market, which has been fairly stable, but kind of weakening
over time from where it was a couple of years ago.
So that's why there's some there are there's some weakness in the job.
So they're watching jobs very carefully and they're watching inflation.
Now, if inflation goes up too much, what do they do?
They have to increase rates.
If the job market starts to crater, negative things happen.
They have to lower rates.
So they've been a little bit restrictive there.
Their short term federal funds rate where it's at can actually come down a little bit
more. But we have kind of an inflation problem.
And that that was first tariffs bled into that.
And then it was the Iran conflict with fuel that bled into the problem with inflation.
So you're looking at the inflation side of things.
You're also looking at the jobs, which shows some weakness there.
Not too much weakness.
There was a lot of weakness.
You'd actually hear the Federal Reserve change their tune and they might want to start
talking about cutting rates.
But really, there's nothing that's pushing them into either camp.
They're watching inflation very carefully until the jobs market comes down a little
bit more. And then they'll start saying, yeah, maybe we need to cut.
But until then, things are kind of remain the same.
And that's why rates are trading within a channel of between they are at six percent
earlier this year, all the way up to six and three quarters percent.
But that's it. It's been a narrow channel this year.
And and and it's going to remain there pretty much for the remainder of the year.
So we're going to stay in this narrow channel.
But down the road, if we had a recession, they would fight that with the Federal Reserve.
You'd see that in the numbers of both inflation and the jobs in order to fight that
jobs of some sort of recession or is to bring rates down.
So that's the only way we could see rates come down is if we start seeing some
weakening on the jobs side of things.
So we so we talk about affordability a lot, of course.
But when we say affordability controls everything, what exactly do we mean and what
are the factors that actually go into affordability?
So the factors that go into affordability are median household incomes.
So income incomes is a very important aspect.
And so are rates.
Rates are a very important aspect, but it's not those alone.
It's also where prices are, because I keep on hearing, as mentioning to you,
one of the responses to a podcast was that, well, rates have been higher.
These are actually low, but you have to match them against where how high prices
are and where incomes are.
And it shows that that things are really unaffordable.
If we had if we had rates where they're at today and we had incomes where we're at
today, but housing prices weren't as high as they were, but a lot lower, things would
be a lot more affordable.
And yet here we are with the incomes and and rates that are basically the same.
So that's the the other lever that you have to understand of why even at six, six
and a half percent, six and three quarters percent, it's still very, very unaffordable.
And it's because of how high prices are today.
So they're remembering back to 1981 when interest rates got all the way up to 18
percent. Yet the average house, the average median priced house, the median priced
house was way lower and it wasn't as cost prohibitive at 18 percent.
Because if you you can imagine if we had 18 percent interest rates today, nobody could
afford housing. It would be absolutely ridiculous.
Man, man, that just triggers things because I need to do that to illustrate for people
just how ridiculous talking about, well, interest rates back in the day were at 10
percent or 12 percent or 18 percent.
You just can't compare it.
So you have to look at all of those aspects of it.
So those are the levers that control affordability.
And so right now where the levers are at, things are very, very unaffordable.
And and the that's why we've talked about over and over again when rates do fall, that
you will see more and more people inclined to purchase.
And that's because five million households are able to purchase when interest rates fall
a full percentage point.
And where we're at right now to where we could be down the road, we've talked about it
before that we could I think a long term equilibrium for for interest rates is
lower than what a lot of people have said.
And I think it's going to be right at about five and a half percent.
I think that's where it could stay.
And that's with the spread getting normal and everything else being being fine.
And the Federal Reserve coming down to what they call their equilibrium rate for their
federal funds rate.
So if they get down to the right spot and interest rates then would remain right about
five and a half percent.
And that opens up the door to a lot of households that can afford.
And the other piece of that is our incomes.
So and I think we're going to talk about that more, but we'll talk more about incomes
momentarily. Our first time homebuyers having a hard time getting into the housing
market because of affordability problems, or could you also say it's a mentality
problem? I've heard arguments for both sides of the aisle on this topic.
But what is your take, Steve?
And this isn't to discredit people waiting on the sidelines because they can't afford
it. It's just more talking about the argument of people that maybe can but are choosing
to sit on the sidelines.
So what do you have to say about that?
Yeah, it really is an affordability thing.
This is it.
It really boils down to how unaffordable things are.
But you have to know the market is local.
So everybody hears this.
So in some markets, it could be an extremely mental thing because there are areas of the
country where we've seen incomes that have continued to go up.
So we've seen incomes rise and where values are at, it's actually not as cost
prohibitive. And when you look at the number, the median household income and how much
of a home that they're able to afford, you look at those and there are areas across
country where it does make sense.
It might not be necessarily where some people want to live, but there are areas
where they can go to.
And if those people in those areas are listening to it and say, yeah, things are just
unaffordable. Well, that is a mental thing because they're just mentally adopting the
narrative that things are affordable across the board because real estate is local.
But if you're talking about the United States as a whole and where we're at in SoCal,
it's very, very unaffordable.
And we do reports for SoCal, the Bay Area, but there are areas where it's more
affordable than it is where we're located in Orange County, extremely unaffordable
compared to when you start looking at other areas, when you start looking at the
percentage, you're going, huh, things can be a lot more affordable.
But there are tradeoffs to to living in some of these areas.
Some of it has to do with traffic.
Some of it has to do with heat.
There's just different things.
Proximity to the coast, things like that.
But and and those are the tradeoffs that that are made to to go out there.
But yeah, so it's not a mental problem by and by and large, it's just a real
affordability issue where the only thing that corrects this is over time.
And and when I'm saying over time, I'm saying over time.
All right, well, if home prices stay essentially flat and incomes continue to
rise like you could say they happen over the past couple of years, how much can it
truly help affordability?
Like, will it make that large of a difference?
Yeah, so it's time.
And that's the thing.
So from twenty nineteen to through twenty twenty five, how much have incomes gone up?
Twenty five percent.
So and that's that's a significant amount.
But that's over time.
When I tell you, yeah, it'll be a lot better five years from now.
People look at that and go, you're crazy, Stephen Thomas.
Yeah. Or that's six years.
So that's a long time to wait.
Yeah. Things will be much better in six years.
That's economic, slow and boring.
I said it many, many times.
That's what economics is slow and boring.
And it is very, very slow and boring.
Except for you and I, we find it exciting.
And that's because we like to see the trends and all that.
And it will eventually change over time where if values remain relatively flat and
we have incomes that go up, guess what happens?
Properties become more affordable in time.
So this is definitely a time thing.
And like I said, when I say time, I'm talking time.
It's not like the average attention span of of of people across the United States is
about 30 to 45 days on any given topic.
And then we move on to something else.
So when I'm talking years, that's a long time.
It's just like the length of time that we've waited for rates to get down in fives.
Forty eight months.
It's been four years that we've been stuck above six percent.
And for a long period of time that we've been there.
So are we going to go back into the fives?
Yes. In time.
And finally, what is the biggest misunderstanding people have about affordability?
Is there a specific thing that you think people need to know, especially about
unaffordability? I know we talk about it all the time, but just a good hot guest topic.
Yeah, it's they misunderstand it because they don't understand true economics.
They hate listening to this.
It's like when I talk about supply and demand all the time, all over and over and over
again, people just get sick and tired of hearing me talk about supply and demand.
But it has a lot to do with supply and demand.
And we talk about it all the time because that is exactly what what what moves the
markets, supply and demand.
And the same thing with affordability.
When I say it takes time, it takes time.
And people don't like that.
They say, well, my gut tells me and I'm pointing to my gut right now for those people
that are just listening. My gut tells me that that values need to come down and they
need to come down because they are ridiculously priced right now.
And you have no idea what you're talking about, Stephen Thomas.
Those values are got to come down to make things more affordable because people can
afford to afford houses.
It's going to come.
It's going to come to a point where finally, you know, this next generation can afford
anything that nobody's going to be buying.
Yet people have been buying at the tune of four million people per year.
That's not nobody.
That's it's normally five, five million.
It's down to four million.
And it's been stuck there now.
We've talked about that for four years, almost come this November, stuck at a four
million home level.
That's pretty, pretty sad.
But there are still four million people that are purchasing, not zero, four million that
are propping the market up.
And they're pushing down on this demand side of the equation because they're
purchasing four million.
They're ignoring it completely.
And that's just it's it's unfortunate because they still exist.
There's not a lack of total demand.
And yet it's coming.
Really, it's coming.
So why hasn't it arrived so far?
Because people like to transact and move to different places across the United
States. And there are people that move even with rates lower than three percent.
I ask people in rooms, who has a rate at three percent or lower?
A lot of hands go up and I go, who's thinking about moving in this couple of years?
And now we're at the point where people are putting their hands in the air.
Why? They're going to trade in a two point nine percent interest rate for a
six percent interest rate.
Boy, those people are crazy, yet they're doing it.
Why? Because some people are just tired of waiting.
They might have been in their house for like six years, refinanced to a low interest
rate. They've been stuck in their house now for 11 years.
They're ready to move and they're getting to the point where more and more people
are pulling the trigger, even with these lower rates.
So the churn still continues and we'll be talking about
supply and demand until the cows come home.
So that's just how it works.
And it will take time for everything to heal.
But we're not going to crash.
That's the biggest misunderstanding that things are unaffordable.
So things have to crash.
All right. Well, if you listeners can take anything from this episode, I'd say the
words are probably time or patience.
So there's that.
Thank you, everyone, again for tuning in to another episode of Let's Talk Housing.
If you want to learn more about what's going on in the housing industry or in the
economy, anything like that, subscribe to our YouTube channel, please.
We love having you here or you can subscribe to our housing reports in case you want
that wonderful localized information where we get into the details of your local
housing market. So go check that out today.
Please leave us a good review.
We greatly appreciate that.
And if you have any questions at all, throw it my direction and I will make sure we
include it here to get those answers straight back to you for all you lovely
listeners. So we will see you very, very soon and have a fantastic rest of your day.
Thank you. Thank you.