Getting married but not sure you’re on the same page about money? Ask these questions before you say “I do.” 👉 https://ramsey.solutions/id23p7sy
Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ramsey.solutions/vujbgh • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
Connect with our Sponsors: - If you want your car to keep going and going, trust Christian Brothers Automotive. Find a local shop and get an exclusive Ramsey discount of 10% (up to $250) off ⮕ https://www.cbac.com/ramsey - Learn more about Christian Healthcare Ministries. ⮕ https://www.chministries.org/budget - Get started today with Churchill Mortgage. Equal Housing Lender • NMLS ID 1591 • NMLSConsumerAccess.org ⮕ http://ChurchillMortgage.com/RamseyOffer ⮕ Churchill Certified Homebuyer program is available for qualifying borrowers and select loan types only. Ramsey Audience offer of up to a $500 credit applied at closing toward fees incurred for appraisals for a limited time and may be discontinued without notice. - Get 20% off when you join DeleteMe. ⮕ https://www.joindeleteme.com/Ramsey - Visit Zander Insurance or call 1-800-356-4282 for your free instant quote today. ⮕ https://www.zander.com/
Brought to you by CHL,
a budget-friendly faith-based alternative
to health insurance.
chministries.org slash budget.
A couple of months ago, my last parent passed away
and I have received a substantial amount of money.
And my fiance, so I immediately did, you know,
the recommended steps.
Well, my fiance is wanting me to help him pay off his debts.
He has about 18, almost $19,000 worth of credit card debt.
Of course, I'm willing to help him.
I don't expect the money back
because I know in the long run,
it's gonna help us, like our family.
But my stipulation was per the rules, you know,
close your credit card account.
Once I pay these credit card accounts,
you have to close the account.
And he is saying that I'm financially abusing him
because I'm requiring him to do that.
So I just, I don't know.
Oh my gosh.
That's like saying, well, hey, I'll pay for your rehab
if you stop using drugs right now.
And he's like, hey, come on, that's abusive.
Let me enjoy my life.
So why is he anti-closing the cards?
Is he still using them?
He still is using them.
Yeah. Okay.
He pays, he pays about, he gets a payment
from his disability, his VA disability.
He pays $1,900 off each month.
So I know that, you know, he would pay it off soon.
He started at a crazy amount of debt, like $60,000,
and he's got it down to like 18, 19.
But we also, he's looking to get a new vehicle
and he wants to start saving for that.
And so he's like, this fast tracks everything.
So-
When are you guys getting married?
October of next year.
Okay. So a little over a year.
Well, it sounds like you guys are not really aligned
with financial goals or values.
It has been a process.
We've been together for nine years and-
How old are y'all?
I am 31 and he is 34.
How long have you been living together?
Five years.
Okay.
So he sees you guys as a married couple where it's like,
hey, we're already doing life together.
Just go ahead and pay off my debts.
What are you doing?
Right.
Okay.
Well, the fact that you're not married-
And it's harder to tell someone to change
because they haven't had to change.
Yeah.
I mean, it's been a lot of comfort here
of just you guys kind of doing life together
without the actual commitment
and financial legal protection here.
So that's my biggest thing is,
if you're going to ever pay off his credit card debt,
please don't do it until you guys are legally married.
Okay.
That's number one.
Number two-
He's really not gonna like that.
I would not pay his credit card debt
if he's gonna go back into credit card debt.
And it's not that you're financially abusive,
it's we are misaligned financially.
And so I can't, in good faith, from my values,
do this knowing that you're gonna go back into debt
with a car payment the next day.
Yeah.
Okay.
I think he's a little bit beyond a skis here
saying that it's abuse.
I can't put that in that category.
No, no, no, no, no, no.
That's like so offensive to people that actually
suffer with it.
He feels a little bit emasculated that you're stepping in.
When you're in the baby steps,
every expense deserves a second look.
And healthcare is one of the biggest.
That's why I recommend Christian Healthcare Ministries.
CHM is a health cost-sharing ministry
and their programs start at just $115 a month.
A lot of families find CHM
gives them more room in the budget
and it's why members say they're better with CHM.
Right now, new members can get a 50% credit
towards their first month.
Go to chministries.org slash budget
and use promo code Ramsey.
He feels a little bit emasculated that you're stepping in
to sort of save his butt with stipulations
like it's mom with rules.
Well, and the problem is it does sound like,
cause it is, hey, there's a condition
to what I'm going to do.
And I believe, I mean,
I don't think you're wrong in that Amanda,
but I think the biggest red flag,
if you dig a little deeper,
is that this is going to,
if you guys don't get aligned on this,
this will be a tension point in your marriage going forward.
And it's going to be really hard to build wealth.
It will.
And we see it all the time that, you know,
the wife, husband or wife,
you can put either one in the scenario,
but you're wanting to get out of debt.
You're wanting to save for retirement and do all of this.
And he's like, well,
I'm just going to go out and get a truck payment
for 1200 bucks and not tell you
because you would just shame me and make me feel bad.
I'm going to go do, right?
Like there's a, it's this,
it's a level of immaturity on his part,
personally, is what I think.
So I would get, I would be aligned.
And again, you don't have to be the same person.
I'm not saying that.
You don't have to be the same person when it comes to money.
Winston is very different than I am with money,
but our overall household values are aligned.
And so when we have to make big decisions,
you know, for the most part,
we kind of have these guardrails
that we make the decision within,
which is so helpful.
And I'm scared there's no guardrail for you all.
It's just, it is what it is.
And it's been like that for five years in your relationship
because you know, you guys have been acting
like you're married.
And so that's when these habits
and these patterns really start to play in.
And then the moment it changes
and you start to feel like, oh my gosh,
we are going to be a married couple.
And oh my gosh, this windfall of money happened.
Or oh my gosh, he lost his job.
Oh my gosh, I lost, whatever it is, right?
Life starts happening.
It starts to magnify the situation.
And so I would get with a marriage counselor.
And I would go through Financial Peace University as well.
Yeah, and I would do work just on your relationship
as a whole, Amanda, too,
because I do wonder what patterns have creeped in
for you all that you want to look different in marriage.
And one of those is probably going to be money.
Yeah, I definitely feel like
at the beginning of our relationship
versus, you know, now nine years into it,
that there's been a lot of mental change
about the way that he views money.
My parents were very frugal and they taught me what to do
and his parents did not.
And so it's been a big, more of a learning curve for him.
I have faith that, you know,
he's going to get where he needs to be.
But also, like you said, it raises all my red flags
whenever he's like-
Yeah, it should.
I mean, you're nine years into this.
How much did you get with your inheritance?
Just shy of a million dollars.
Have y'all talked about what you want to do with that?
Have you even had the discussion with him?
Yes and no.
I got it.
Everything wasn't liquid.
So I got my parents' IRA
and then they also had a brokerage account
and then they had CDs
and then they also had checking and savings accounts.
So they had a little bit of everything
and I'm keeping the brokerage account as is.
I'm just going to let it keep growing
and I'll put, you know, invest into that.
As far as any of the liquid cash, I don't know.
We do have a house together.
So I was thinking about maybe paying the mortgage off.
Is that in both of your names, the mortgage?
Yes.
And the deed as well?
The house deed?
Yes.
Like this is legally y'all's house.
The ownership.
I'm sure it is.
So I wouldn't touch that asset.
I would not pay that off now.
I would wait till you guys are legally married.
And I don't know why you're waiting
till October of next year now.
Are we waiting till the 10 year mark?
What's the goal with the October 2027 wedding?
We had a specific venue that we wanted to use
and that was when they were first available.
Just not urgent.
Well, Amanda, I would not combine it.
I would not touch his finances
and I would not pay off this house.
I would not do anything until you are married.
And I'm telling you,
if you guys don't get to the root of some of this stuff,
it's gonna be constant conflict.
And you may look up after you get married
and this 900 grand of inheritance
may be spent very quickly.
Christian Healthcare Ministries can save your family
hundreds of dollars on healthcare every month.
Learn more at chministries.org slash budget.