Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ramsey.solutions/vujbgh • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
Connect with our Sponsors: - If you want your car to keep going and going, trust Christian Brothers Automotive. Find a local shop and get an exclusive Ramsey discount of 10% (up to $250) off ⮕ https://www.cbac.com/ramsey - Learn more about Christian Healthcare Ministries. ⮕ https://www.chministries.org/budget - Get started today with Churchill Mortgage. Equal Housing Lender • NMLS ID 1591 • NMLSConsumerAccess.org ⮕ http://ChurchillMortgage.com/RamseyOffer ⮕ Churchill Certified Homebuyer program is available for qualifying borrowers and select loan types only. Ramsey Audience offer of up to a $500 credit applied at closing toward fees incurred for appraisals for a limited time and may be discontinued without notice. - Get 20% off when you join DeleteMe. ⮕ https://www.joindeleteme.com/Ramsey - Visit Zander Insurance or call 1-800-356-4282 for your free instant quote today. ⮕ https://www.zander.com/
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today.
We purchased our home in May of 2025. We are up to date on all payments. We don't do badly at all.
However, we discovered there are about $100,000 in structural damages to our house
foundation-wise, and it's also resulting in our electric bills being around $1,600 a month.
It's not really feasible for us anymore to keep living here with how it is.
However, we did find out that through my hairdresser, she was actually apparently
under contract to buy our house before us, and her inspector found all the structural
damages and reported it to the seller. The seller never disclosed it to us on the seller's disclosure,
which is fraud. We have an attorney set up and everything. We already paid the retainer and sent
demand letters. However, our attorney is wanting about $30,000 to proceed with this case.
Our options right now, as it stands, are to spend the $30,000 to sue the people who sold us the
house. If we win, then we would profit about $250,000 to $300,000. If we lose, though,
then we're $30,000 in debt, and we still have the $100,000 in structural damages that would be
unfixed completely. We can't sell our house because of how much is wrong with it. We would
end up losing about $30,000 on it right now, as it stands, as well. We don't really know what to
do. Is this an okay situation to put ourselves into debt? What's your financial situation? How
much debt do you guys have outside of the mortgage? About $3,000. I know it is debt,
but it's nothing absolutely astronomical. How much do you have in savings? About $1,000, not much.
Have you contacted other lawyers? We have looked around everywhere in our area,
and everybody's running about the same exact price, about the $400, $450 an hour. They all
want a $7,000 retainer, and they're saying that it's going to cost anywhere from $20,000 to $30,000
to get it done, start to finish. I'm trying to think if there's any lawyers that would do it,
knowing that they'll collect on the back end. My uncle's a lawyer in the area. He doesn't
practice this type of law, but he said that's not really a common thing in this area.
It sounds like if you guys pursued this, you would win. I'm confused how it happens.
You can prove the seller's new because you have the previous inspection report.
At that point, I don't know how they go, we're not going to pay this.
Right, exactly. What worries me is that they're saying that they're not going to pay it.
They may not have it either. Right, that's my guess,
is they don't have the money to pay it either. Yeah.
Don't wait for the interest rate to be perfect before buying or refinancing a home. Talk to
Churchill Mortgage. Smart buyers buy the home they can afford now, and then refinance later
if rates improve. Churchill helps you make decisions with confidence instead of guessing,
and Churchill Mortgage has a webpage with special offers just for our audience.
Go to churchillmortgage.com slash Ramsey Offer.
This is a paid advertisement. NMLS ID 1591. NMLSconsumeraccess.org. Equal housing lender.
They aren't poor either. These are people who are flipping houses for a living. I mean,
they live in a massive home. I don't think that they're poor. I just don't think they have
the $100,000 straight up front to pay it. Yeah, probably not. They're probably leveraged.
In all areas. So that would be the thing. They would be forced, I guess, from a lawsuit
perspective, either to come up with the money in an amount of time, or they would sell an asset,
you know, their primary home to pay. I don't know. It does feel like, it still feels like a gamble to
me that you're going to get that much money out of the situation. So I would hate for you to go
$30,000, risk that. So the next option is, if you were to sell it, you said you would lose
probably $30,000 on the home sale. Is that with the structural damages like being up front with
those? Yes. We would have to legally disclose all of the structural issues to the house that we know
about our house. We bought it for $200,000. Our home wouldn't be worth anything more than $120,000.
We'd maybe get $150,000 out of it, is what a couple of realtors spoke to us about.
And have you had any contractors out to look to see if you were to rehab it, what that would be,
what that would cost? $100,000.
How many bids did you get? How many people did you talk to?
We have spoken to probably 10 to 15 different companies.
And they're all around there? Yes. $100,000 was actually the cheapest we could find.
Well, I wouldn't give up on the search because right now your best case is still finding a
lawyer who can do it on contingency. And so I would ask around, call more real estate attorneys
and say, hey, do you take concealment, nondisclosure cases on contingency? The other
thing I would do is check if your title insurance or a home warranty would cover a portion of that
and dig into the fine print. Nothing would cover it. And your inspector, Caitlyn, didn't find all
that. I'm so sorry. No, you're fine. Did you have an inspection?
Yes, we did. And our inspector missed it. And missed it.
But the previous one caught it somehow. Yeah. So it's documented somewhere.
Yeah. Can you get a copy of that inspection report?
Yeah, we have it. My attorney already has it.
Okay. So they've seen this all. They know there's a case here, but they're going, hey,
based on my hourly rate, this is going to cost you this much.
Yes. Man, Caitlyn, I'm so sorry.
It's not your fault. It's just a bad situation.
It is a bad situation all around.
Yeah. My husband makes about $100,000 a year. So I mean, I don't even think that we could
financially budget for $30,000 over the course of a year with three kids as well. I just don't
think that it's feasible for us. So we would 100% have to take out a loan.
Right. And I wouldn't advise you in good faith to do that. So I would either continue
calling attorneys, and maybe some that aren't even local, right? I mean, like maybe you hop
over to another city or something, you know, still in the Indiana state.
Somewhere in the area.
But I mean, I think I would slowly start trying to probably fix it because selling it then puts
you a negative $30,000 with no equity, nothing, starting over versus like what stages over the
three years are we going to fix this house, right? And it's a slow process. And you fix it
little by little. And then you might get in there and do maybe half of what you feel like you need
to do. And it actually ends up fixing a lot of the problem. And you know what I mean? Like you
could get in there, but that's where I tend to lean.
And on the other side, if you want to save up and pay the retainer and go,
hey, we're going to pay you the rest once the case is closed, they might be willing to do sort
a partial contingency there if you cover the retainer. So that might mean we are selling
stuff. Hey, once the kids are down, you're going to get a side job. He's working an extra 20 hours
a week so that you can come up with that money because that's still your best case scenario
as far as the financial damage.
The joys of home ownership. As all the parents go, kids, you're throwing away money on rent,
go buy a house. And then you see situations like this.
That's the other frustrating thing, just immoral people that they know that there's an issue,
the homeowners, and they don't disclose it. I mean, complete fraud, completely illegal.
You cannot do that. And every part of me wants that justice, but also I can't tell,
I mean, I couldn't advise you to go $30,000 in debt. We're still a little bit of a gamble
of if you win or not or what that looks like.
Because then it's just insult to injury. Now you're just in a way worse place.
So there's not a lot of good options here.
I would rather you be putting your money towards something you know is
healing the situation rather than a guess, right?
It's more in your control.
Yeah. Unless they can take the retainer, ask for the 7,000 up front and say,
hey, would you pay this?
Yeah, that feels like enough to where I would go, all right,
I'm willing to at least lose the seven grand.
And maybe a thousand bucks a month, you know, over time to get the rest. I don't know what
kind of deal you could work with an attorney to figure that out.
Just find an attorney with a heart. There's got to be at least one out there.
In Indianapolis. Help Caitlin.
The good people of the Midwest. Where are they?
Create your free every dollar budget today. The simplest way to budget for your life.