Next Steps: • 💸 Start eliminating debt for free with EveryDollar - https://ramsey.solutions/vujbgh • 📞 Have a question for the show? Call 888-825-5225 weekdays from 2–5 p.m. ET or send us an email.
Connect with our Sponsors: - If you want your car to keep going and going, trust Christian Brothers Automotive. Find a local shop and get an exclusive Ramsey discount of 10% (up to $250) off ⮕ https://www.cbac.com/ramsey - Learn more about Christian Healthcare Ministries. ⮕ https://www.chministries.org/budget - Get started today with Churchill Mortgage. Equal Housing Lender • NMLS ID 1591 • NMLSConsumerAccess.org ⮕ http://ChurchillMortgage.com/RamseyOffer ⮕ Churchill Certified Homebuyer program is available for qualifying borrowers and select loan types only. Ramsey Audience offer of up to a $500 credit applied at closing toward fees incurred for appraisals for a limited time and may be discontinued without notice. - Get 20% off when you join DeleteMe. ⮕ https://www.joindeleteme.com/Ramsey - Visit Zander Insurance or call 1-800-356-4282 for your free instant quote today. ⮕ https://www.zander.com/
A man seeks advice regarding a home purchase funded by his father-in-law. Despite paying the majority of the mortgage and maintenance, he has no legal ownership or equity in the property. The advisor warns that this arrangement is financially risky and emotionally damaging, urging the couple to secure legal ownership or move out to protect their marriage and future.
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today.
Prior to my wife and I getting married, he purchased us a house for a million dollars cash
and he pulled ahead $200,000 of our inheritance, leaving an $800,000 balance for us to pay off in
a mortgage that he said he would help us out by just only charging us a 3% interest rate until
the balance is paid off on a 15-year mortgage. So that's a lot of money, but I have no documented
equity or ownership in the house for which I pay a majority of the mortgage, the maintenance,
the repairs, the upgrades, and I find myself just digging myself every month into this deeper hole
that I possibly one day if something bad happens, I will just have no equity in.
Have you talked to him about it, Matt?
I have, to which he said to trust him and everything will work out.
No, thank you.
So how old is he?
He's 70.
Let's pretend that his heart skips a beat as he's driving down the road, which could easily
happen to a 70-year-old, and he loses consciousness and goes across the lane and hits someone head-on
and they die. He's going to get sued for millions and millions of dollars,
and it's going to be a lien on the property that he owns. You're screwed.
And he has put it in a trust in order to...
Doesn't protect it. It does not protect it from that.
Okay.
This is absolutely bogus. This is controlling beyond belief. No. No, I'm not going forward with
this.
Would it be what, an LLC that protects it in that case?
I've nothing that'll protect it. I mean, the LLC is owned by the guy.
You can go after the LLC shares. So the property, if you're going to pay payments on it,
needs to be in your name. There's no excuse for it not being. Trust me is not an answer.
And he's worried that I would take the property potentially from his daughter,
and I haven't nearly paid my half or a fair share of it. So how can we...
How long have you been married?
We've been married over one year.
Okay. So here's what I'm going to do. I mean, you guys do what you want to do,
but this is not tenable for me. Okay. I'm not going to live like this.
So I'm sorry. I shouldn't have done this deal. It's turned out to be a really, really bad idea
and I wished I hadn't done it. And so we're going to undo it.
We're going to let you have your house and we're going to go buy a house
or we're going to refinance this and we're going to put the $800,000 mortgage in our name at 6%
and 5.5% right now. And we're going to pay you off and you're going to put the house in our name.
But we are not going to continue forward with the house only in your name, period.
How will your wife handle that, Matt?
Don't wait for the interest rate to be perfect before buying or refinancing a home. Talk to
Churchill Mortgage. Smart buyers buy the home they can afford now and then refinance later
if rates improve. Churchill helps you make decisions with confidence instead of guessing.
And Churchill Mortgage has a webpage with special offers just for our audience.
Go to churchillmortgage.com slash Ramsey offer.
This is a paid advertisement. NMLS ID 1591. NMLSconsumeraccess.org. Equal housing lenders.
She's not going to be too thrilled because that's going to increase the interest rate
inadvertently for us. That wasn't necessary in her eyes.
It's necessary because you don't own a house and you're so freaking vulnerable that it's ridiculous.
Your father-in-law says, trust me, but he doesn't trust you.
Yeah, it needs to go both ways.
This is not cool.
Yeah, and my fear, Matt, is that a 3% interest rate is going to rattle your one-year marriage.
You know what I mean? If your wife is already taking his side in a level of logic,
right, of just math, just like, oh, I just want to save money and not looking at the
relational equity of what this is doing and then the potential risk of your home,
yeah, it's probably going to cause some waves, but I would say it's probably necessary.
I'm going to cause some waves.
I'm going to start out gentle and I'm going to turn it up.
Start out kind and honoring and say, I appreciate this.
I know you've got good intentions. I love you and I appreciate this,
but I simply am not going to go forward with this. It's not going to happen.
It's not worth the 3% savings. Your risk that you're taking is astronomical.
It's ridiculous. It's a horrible deal for you.
And I asked my wife if she was in the opposite role, if my family had purchased us the house
and she was paying a majority of it, would she be comfortable in this deal?
And she said she wouldn't be comfortable.
Then we have to decide, are we going to leave our father and mother and cleave to our husband
and cleave to our wife? It's an old fashioned saying, you leave the father and cleave. It's
old English from the old English Bible. But yeah, you know, but we have to set up,
okay, who's running your house now, her dad or you guys?
And again, this to me, I'm like, this is a totally, I don't like the idea of people using
family as a bank, right? People do this with student loans. They do it with mortgages. And
it just always, it's always a little icky and weird. It just kind of changes. It changes the
relationship. But the thing on top of it for Matt, for me, it's like, if you guys start having kids
and you're building a family, the place that you call home, that is supposed to be your home.
That's why it doesn't make sense to me of his logic. This is your home and her home,
his daughter's home. And why he doesn't give you all the dignity of putting your name on the title
of following through with the plan that's already agreed to is odd to me. And his fear, I'm like,
I'm a little offended if you're going to do this deal with me and be my banker and be the husband
to your wife. And you can't trust me with a million dollar house. You know what I mean?
Like, it's just like, Oh, it just adds, adds to the relational dynamic.
Yes, it does indeed. And that's why I kind of lose sleep over it. And I see as every month goes
on, it's harder to bring up this conversation. I think the two of you, you and your wife need
to sit down with a good therapist, a good financial counselor, I mean, a good marriage counselor,
and maybe your pastor, if you have one and you guys need to talk it through and then you need
to decide what you're going to do. And then, um, and you guys together as a unified front,
you've got to present it to him and yeah, together or her, you know, either going to,
we're either going to refinance this and get it out of your name and put it into our name,
or we're going to hand you the keys and we're going to move. And so, cause we're not going
forward and listen, don't accept a mortgage from him either. If he says, okay, I'll put it in your
name and I'll just put a mortgage on it. No, I do not want to owe this man money. This has got a
bad vibe on it. The best thing you can do for your wife and your marriage is for this guy,
not to be between you anymore. And I think his intentions are good. I don't think his
intentions are bad. I just think he's emotionally immature. I would never look at Winston Cruz
and say, I can't put this in your name because I don't trust you. After I handed my daughter's
hand to him. That's what I'm saying. It's so, it's so odd. I gave him the most precious thing
I have on the planet. One of my daughters. I don't trust you with a house. But I don't trust
you with a stupid house. Oh, it's backwards. No, thank you. It's backwards. That's just,
that's just emotionally bad. Oh Matt, I'm sorry. And your wife, I'm like. It's going to be,
this is going to be a hard process. It is. But dude. It's going to be good for you guys. If
you guys get through this. Choose the conflict today because the one that's laying out there
10 years from now is much bigger. Create your free, every dollar budget today.
The simplest way to budget for your life.