Carl Sagan said you are made of star stuff. He was half right.
Every heavy element in your body was forged inside a dying star. But the single most abundant element in you, hydrogen, was never made in a star at all. It was made in the first second of the universe, before any star existed.
This is the story of where your atoms actually came from, why the exact ratio of hydrogen to helium in the cosmos is the closest thing physics has to a photograph of the universe one second after the Big Bang, and why the same processes that built you make space the most hostile environment your biology has ever faced.
In this one: - Why "star stuff" is only half the story - The scientists who proved the Big Bang was necessary while trying to disprove it - What happened when my team thought we found the signature of the Big Bang itself, and why we had to retract it - Why radiation, vacuum, and zero gravity make the human body a poorly engineered spacecraft - What panspermia actually predicts, and why the absence of life on Mars is weaker evidence than people think
00:00 The claim that breaks "star stuff" 00:54 Why hydrogen can't be made in a star 04:15 The man who named the Big Bang to mock it 05:12 Building an instrument at the end of the Earth 07:15 The discovery we had to take back 09:59 Space is beautiful. It's also trying to kill you 10:52 Your body is a badly designed spacecraft 12:48 Did life come from outer space 14:05 The math on surviving the trip 15:20 What 0.001% of the universe can do
If this changes how you think about where you came from, my two books go deeper: Losing the Nobel Prize and Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Brian Keating explores the origins of the universe, arguing that humans are \"Big Bang stuff\" rather than just \"star stuff\" due to the prevalence of hydrogen. He reflects on the scientific pursuit of gravitational radiation, the lethal nature of deep space, and the extreme improbability of panspermia, ultimately celebrating the human ability to contemplate its place in a vast, indifferent cosmos.
I'd like to say Carl was right and he was wrong.
Yes, you are star stuff, you know, you have some iron in your body, which is important.
But you know what else you have?
You have an awful lot of hydrogen in your body.
And that's not star stuff at all.
In fact, if it was, we wouldn't be here.
Every atom in your body was forged inside a star that
exploded billions of years before you were born.
That's the beautiful part.
But the same universe that built you is trying to kill you right now.
Radiation, meteorites, things you can't see.
A vacuum that wants your blood to boil.
Zero gravity unraveling the DNA.
It's been four billion years evolving.
I'm Brian Keating.
I built telescopes at the South Pole in Chile and even launched them into space in order to
look at the first light after the Big Bang.
Today, I present where we came from, but not whether or not anything can come from a star,
but whether or not it can survive going back out into one.
They didn't believe in the Big Bang theory.
They had to come up with some way that we could plausibly be here.
And they did discover the correct pathway, but starting from the wrong motivation.
They went to deny that the Big Bang was necessary.
They could make every other element, but they couldn't make hydrogen.
And still to this day, we can't make hydrogen really in a lot of, in large quantities,
except during the Big Bang.
And the exact ratio of hydrogen to helium, to lithium, to beryllium, and the isotopes of those,
including deuterium, discovered by Harold Urey before he came here, but nonetheless,
those tell us exactly, exactly what the universe was like a second after the Big Bang.
Not a thousand or half a million years after the Big Bang like I studied.
One second after the Big Bang.
But they didn't believe in the Big Bang theory.
They had to come up with some way that we could plausibly be here.
And they did discover the correct pathway, but starting from the wrong motivation.
They went to deny that the Big Bang was necessary.
They could make every other element, but they couldn't make hydrogen.
And still to this day, we can't make hydrogen really in a lot of, in large quantities,
except during the Big Bang.
And the exact ratio of hydrogen to helium, to lithium, to beryllium, and the isotopes of those,
including deuterium, discovered by Harold Urey before he came here, but nevertheless,
those tell us exactly, exactly what the universe was like a second after the Big Bang.
Not a thousand or half a million years after the Big Bang like I studied.
One second after the Big Bang.
And so we're really Big Bang stuff, not star stuff.
Maybe the alliteration is better.
So if you trace your body, and you look at the different elements in your body,
and the different isotopes in there, they're basically,
most of them are formed via the same process that produces these meteors.
Tattoo supernovae.
When they explode, they make heavier and heavier elements until they can't
support their gravity anymore from radiation pressure, and then they detonate.
In a thermonuclear fusion device that occurs in deep space.
And sometimes we get other elements in our bodies,
and those come from colliding neutron stars,
but that's really quite minimal.
Things like iodine and other isotopes that are necessary for life.
But we really don't need that many elements,
but of them all, we took away hydrogen, and there's no doubt we wouldn't be here.
So let's zoom out from the cosmic web, the Milky Way, to our solar system.
Let's zoom all the way out.
Let's look at hydrogen, the most abundant, the most mysterious in some ways.
It's a beautiful, beautiful element.
It allows us to understand so much about life, the universe, and everything.
But the main thing that it did is provide the fuel for the stars that came later.
But one of the things we do is we call the first stars that ever formed,
Population 3.
That makes a lot of sense, doesn't it?
Okay, I wasn't there at the beginning, but I didn't name it.
But we call the earliest stars, pure hydrogen, Population 3.
To date, we've never seen one.
We have very good evidence.
Perhaps James Webb will see one.
But they provided the fuel to make the other stars that could make the
supernova that would blow up and produce the materials that we're made up of,
most of the stuff on here.
They all have a trace that can take us back to the Big Bang in some way or another.
And that was figured out primarily by Margaret and Jeff Burbage and their colleagues,
Willie Fowler and Fred Hoyle, who was the man who coined the name the Big Bang
because he hated it so much he wanted to make fun of it.
But allegedly, that's why he called it the Big Bang.
And he made it an object of derision because he never believed in it.
Margaret came up with these ideas.
She didn't win the Nobel Prize, unfortunately, for her work.
But they saw things differently.
And that's what's so important.
In this field, you need a lot of renegades.
How do you get a universe from a non-universe?
Then how do you get matter, honest to goodness, chunks of matter, from pure energy, non-matter?
We go from non-universe to universe, non-matter to matter.
Then you go from non-matter to life, to matter to life, which is non-living to living.
Then you go from life to conscious life, so not unconscious life or non-conscious life,
to conscious life.
But the point is, how do you then get consciousness?
That we can then complete the cosmic Ouroboros and start thinking about,
how does the universe come from nothing?
It's a miracle, in a lot of ways, that we are actually able to think about it.
So every cell in your body is an experiment.
We can understand more about it.
But we can't go back to the very beginning, or at least that's what we thought until about
25 years ago, when I convinced a bunch of my colleagues that we could go to the bottom of
the planet, a very inhospitable place called the South Pole, Antarctica.
And we could build an instrument that could go back further in time than any other instrument
ever has done.
Call that instrument BICEP, and the fans for a kind of corny acronym, Background Imaging
of Cosmic Extragalactic Polarization.
But why would you go there?
Well, it's an extreme place for extremophiles.
And to get into the South Pole, even to work there as a line cook, it's harder to get in
there than it is to get into UCSD or Harvard.
They have hundreds of applications for every job spot that's down there, because people
want to get away from the mafia.
Now, I don't know why they want to go down there, but we built a telescope very similar
to Galileo's first instrument that he discovered, the craters on the moon and the rings of Saturn.
It's a refracting telescope.
It's about my height, a little wider than mine maybe in some places.
And we put it on a tripod, which, by the way, also Galileo invented.
Galileo invented the tripod.
He didn't invent the telescope, but he made it 10 times better than the previous inventor
of that device.
And then we ship it down to Antarctica.
And the reason that we do that is partially for the same reason these people went down
there.
This is the crew of Robert Falcon Scott.
And it says up there, Great God, this is an awful place.
Now, why did it say that?
Well, they actually all froze to death three months after this picture was taken.
It's a very unforgiving place.
And actually, what they're looking at there is the flag of the team that lost to France
today, and that's the Norwegian flag.
The Norwegian explorer, Roald Amundsen, reached the South Pole three weeks before Robert Scott,
and that three-week difference made the difference between life and death for all these people.
And the reason why is very interesting, but I don't have time to get into it.
It's still very dangerous to go there.
If you've ever been to a very cold, forbidding environment, that's one thing.
But the inhabitants there make it even more dangerous.
And so we set out there to take an image of the universe, not using light, not using nuclei,
but using waves of gravity called gravitational radiation.
And this was thought to be the greatest discovery of all time, because we did it.
We made the discovery.
We announced it in the newspaper of record, indeed, the San Diego Union-Tribune.
There I am on the left.
I don't know what that other newspaper is.
I always like this article from The Economist put out.
It just sounds like some guy was just like, wow, the beginning of the universe.
Like some man just saw it, like some random dude.
We're on CNN.
But we always have these nagging doubts, as you have to have as a scientist.
Maybe what you saw is what you thought you wanted to see, but you really saw something else.
That's a very pernicious effect in science called confirmation bias.
You must always guard against it.
And so for us, it was actually undone.
I mean, spoiler alert, my book's called Losing the Nobel Prize.
I wouldn't be anywhere else but here.
I love to be here.
But the point is, it wouldn't be called Losing the Nobel Prize.
It would probably be called Winning the Nobel Prize.
But because of interstellar dust, which is really just a microscopic version of these
meteorites.
So I think maybe somebody mentioned the dangers of space, of radiation.
You go crazy.
You're with your soon-to-be ex-wife.
I don't know.
But everyone's like, oh, I really want to go to Mars.
And I'm like, do you really want to be on a spaceship with Elon Musk?
You couldn't pay me.
If he gave me a trillion dollars, I would not be in.
OK, maybe if he did.
No, I wouldn't.
I mean, you catch up on your reading.
But you can do that at the South Pole, too.
But these little microscopic grains of really the essence of what they are, are these micrometeorites.
These are highly magnetic.
Therefore, they can get aligned in the magnetic field of the Milky Way galaxy.
And they can exactly mimic the inframotor that we were trying to see of this flashpoint
of gravitational radiation at time equals zero.
And that's, in fact, what happened.
We had to retract it.
Here's an illustration of what happens.
They act like little compass needles.
And they mimic the signal we were trying so hard to see.
So the universe doesn't look like this pristine space-time diagram.
It's very smoggy.
It's very dirty.
It's very uninhabitable.
It's a lot like Los Angeles, let's be honest.
So nature always gets the final vote.
And we're nothing if we don't advocate for ourselves and to kind of pick ourselves up,
and dust ourselves off, and go back to the project.
Because it is such a high prize.
Not the Nobel Prize.
I mean, forgive me for being obsessed with it earlier on in my career.
But at this point, it's a discovery.
And how we could possibly glimpse what was the spark that ignited the Big Bang.
And we could put to rest all these other models that say the universe was static,
or it was multiple big crunches and other things, string theory, membranes colliding,
all sorts of other things that could be true.
We would rule them out.
Okay, so to summarize where we've gotten so far.
Space is certainly beautiful.
I think you guys have made that case.
But it's highly deadly.
I don't know what the analogy is.
But it's kind of a question that we have.
Are we able to go into space and live there, assuming that we want to collectively?
There will always be people that want to.
So how do we survive these things?
You guys preempted this.
I don't have to talk about the radiation threat, the effect on your DNA,
what it does to you.
You guys know much better than me.
I like the analogy of the human body kind of being a spacecraft.
But it's a really poorly designed one by the lowest bidder, maybe.
We have all these shields and protections on Earth.
But your body, what does the body have?
The body has almost nothing.
Okay, we have, yes, we have structures, we have skin.
But these are not really going to provide much protection against a journey to stay
for a long time on the moon.
The longest we've ever been on the moon is a week.
I've talked to people.
Again, I've talked to four astronauts.
I talked to one astronaut who probably, hopefully, I hope she's a friend of mine,
be the first woman to walk on the moon, Jessica Meir.
I talked to her while she was on the International Space Station.
It's clear that there'll be people that take these risks.
So how do we do that?
How do we micro-engineer?
Well, you guys know this much better than me.
The body is phenomenal.
Human body and evolution is incredible.
Hashtag Team Tardigrade.
Tardigrades are so resilient.
There's another type of bacteria.
This was pretty amazing to me.
Speaking of AI, I love AI.
I'm on it a lot.
But I asked, like, because there's this type of bacteria, again, you guys know,
is Deinococcus radiodurans, which means, like, very hardened against radiation.
But it's also really hardened against pressure and extreme pressures.
And Japanese scientists have put this under extreme pressure.
So I asked my favorite AI tool.
I said, Grok, I asked Grok, hey, Grok, what kind of pressure can this thing withstand?
And he said, three gigapascals.
And we may be able to do things in space.
And you guys may be the ones that get us there.
And then the question is, should we do it?
Just because you can, as Jeff Goldblum told us in Jurassic Park, doesn't mean you shouldn't.
We're so busy thinking about if you could, Allison, with your brains in space,
you didn't think about now.
I think you do think about that.
We talked about that.
What are the ethics?
What is that?
When I talked to Zach Wienersmith, who's written a book to live and die on Mars or something,
I forget the name of it, a couple of years back.
And he said, yes, it's true.
You could screen every single person here, like they do at the South Pole.
If you want to spend nine months at the South Pole, again, you have to beat out more than
a Harvard admissions class, right?
But they also give you a psychological exam.
And they give you an exam.
They say, at night, do you hear the voices?
Sometimes I do.
Yeah, I guess I do.
And they're like, I don't know.
Is that good or bad?
But so you might pass that test.
But you're condemning generations to come to do the same thing.
Children are going to be born on Mars.
And these extremophiles, the question is, what if life didn't start here on Earth at
all?
This is called panspermia.
What if it arrived on Earth from meteors, FedEx trucks in space with DNA zapping around?
Well, I started asking a different question.
What if life did start here by panspermia, but it was delivered by meteorites?
Then maybe it should be that there's meteorites on other planets.
And maybe the fact that we don't see life, abundant koala bear exhibits on Mars, maybe
that should say something about how easy or hard it is to spread life around the galaxy.
And probably some of you could figure this out.
But a lot of people believe that panspermia is the most plausible way that we got here.
I tend to think it's not.
And others make much greater progress than a cosmologist thinking about this.
But this topic of lithopanspermia, that you have amino acids found on meteorites, and
you will, as I said, because I touch these meteorites, you'll find some life on it if
you look hard enough.
So the question is, how easy or hard is it?
And my question was, well, if life is easy to start via panspermia, then you should see
it on Mars.
Or the fact that you don't see it on Mars, and we have no evidence yet, is a weak, weak,
weak, weak, weak constraint on how easy or hard it is, the Fasunda D question.
And so I have a paper on that.
This is an old, old story.
And the question is, how likely is it that there could have been canals on the moon,
that there could be life existing on the moon that came from the Earth, not the other way
around, like most horror films talk about?
So I go through the calculation.
I'm preparing this paper.
I'm not going to go through everything now.
But it comes out to be really hard, as you might expect.
It's extremely hard to survive the transfer, to survive the ejection of an impact, to then
float around in space, to be hard.
Even if you had the hardiest tardigrades that were all infected with or treated with stem
cells from these radiodurans bacteria, it is extremely hard.
In fact, I calculated how hard it is.
It was kind of like Mbappe kicking a goal and making the goal on Proxima Centauri.
There it is.
There's Mbappe.
Here, I'll do it again.
I had so much fun making this.
Mbappe hitting a goal on Proxima Centauri.
It's not far off, like 10 to the 24th, negative 24th, probably.
But 10 to the 24th planets in the observable universe, it might happen.
OK, I just want to finish up.
Again, we don't know much about the universe.
It pays to be epistemically humble.
We should be humiliated.
We have to have a little bit of chutzpah, a little bit of arrogance to approach these
questions that may not have answers.
But most of it's unknown.
In fact, the cosmic pie chart, which I thought I had on here, but maybe I don't.
The cosmic pie chart basically shows that what we're made of is less than about a thousandth
of a percent of the energy mass density of the universe.
And yet, we're the only type of mass that can think about how it got here.
And that, to me, is just exhilarating and exciting.
And it's the best possible timeline that we could be at the line.
So we're made to exist in the universe.
We're made by the universe.
We're not necessarily made for space.
I think we'd look different.
We'd have evolved differently.
But maybe we will in the deep culture evolve to have different organoids and structures
and allow us to exist in space.
So I think that you guys are doing incredible work as well.
So I'll leave this up and then come up and I'll give you guys a real meteorite to catch
a piece of Mars.
Thank you very much.