http://squarespace.com/Baumgartner to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. - Stepping outside of one's comfort zone allows, no, requires growth. And it's in this space of discomfort that innovation, creativity and yes, growth are born. Sometimes it's challenging, sometimes it's smooth sailing and sometimes it's a bit of both. - Support me on Patreon / baumgartnerrestoration
Follow me on Instagram - / baumgartnerrestoration Facebook - / baumgartnerfineartrestoration Julian Baumgartner takes on a complex restoration of a broken, antique Dutch plate that was previously repaired using non-standard materials. This project requires extensive disassembly, adhesive removal, and meticulous reassembly to stabilize the object for the future. Summary
Transcript Follow along using the transcript.
Show transcript
Baumgartner Restoration 1.96M subscribers Videos About
AI Generated·May contain errors
This video is brought to you by Squarespace. From websites and online stores, to marketing tools
and analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform to build a beautiful online presence
and run your business. Sometimes a project arrives at the studio that's just too good to pass up,
even if it's a little bit out of our wheelhouse. And sometimes a project arrives, and I'm too
foolish to say no. It's a fine line. Such was the case with this decorative Dutch
plate that arrived in many pieces. Clearly broken at least one time, and upon further examination
multiple times with lots of old repairs, old fill-in, old adhesive, this plate was worse for
wear. In addition to some poor repairs, there were some poor attempts at retouching with what looks
like black marker. All of this was problematic. But most concerning was the fact that the old
repairs weren't very good. And I'm not talking about the old retouching or the excess adhesive
and fill-in everywhere. I'm talking about the alignment of the pieces. It just wasn't right,
and so there are ridges and lips all over the piece. And that is problematic. So we're going
to have to figure out some way of addressing all of these problems and putting this piece
back together. While this project may seem like it's about a piece of broken pottery, it's actually
about taking lots of pieces and assembling them to one unified whole. You know, like a website.
No no no, hear me out. You may have a web page, and you may want a gallery, and you may want an
e-commerce solution, and you may want an email list, and you may want search engine optimization,
and you may want scheduling, and there are so many other things that you may want but not know how to
integrate them. And that's why you need Squarespace. But it's also the things you don't know you need
that Squarespace provides, like tutorials, video walkthroughs, articles, and a robust forum to help
you out when you need help. So head over to squarespace.com for a free trial, and when you're
ready to launch, go to squarespace.com slash Baumgartner to save 10% off your first purchase
of a website or domain. As with most projects, this included, everything begins at the disassembly
phase. This is the demolition phase, the stripping down part, the part where we take everything off,
take it all apart, and see what we have remaining, and then figure out how to move forward. And for
this piece, I'm employing heat. Using a hot air gun and some very thick welding gloves, I'm heating up
these joints in hopes that I can separate this adhesive. Multiple solvent tests revealed that
this adhesive was not responsive to any solvents I had in the studio, which makes me 100%
convinced that it was not done by a conservator, but by somebody who was just trying to repair this.
Conservators use reversible adhesives specifically because, well, sometimes pieces need to be taken
apart in the future. And using a heat gun and welding gloves is not really
taking it apart. This is brute force. Luckily though, with enough heat, I can soften up some of
this adhesive. Now when I say enough heat, I have this heat gun at full blast, and it is probably
outputting 500 to 700 degrees Fahrenheit of heat. That's why I'm wearing these welding gloves, and
even with these gloves on, I can feel the heat burning through and affecting my hands, so I don't
have a lot of time to work with each piece. But it's critically important that I do separate all
of these pieces, because one, I need to undo all of that old work, and two, I need to be able to put
it back together, and that just can't happen with all of this old adhesive still remaining.
So I'll make lots of passes, heating up what I can, removing what I can, and eventually I
come to this center area where I just can't separate it anymore. I tried heating it up for
10 minutes straight, almost too hot to touch, and the adhesive just wouldn't budge. Maybe that's
because a different adhesive was used, or maybe it's just too locked in. Either way, some of this
is just not reversible. When it does remove, you can see it's still really really gummy and actually
still has a lot of adhesive properties to it, so I have to use a lot of force to remove these pieces,
and then all of that residue is still remaining. Now I did toy with the idea of just putting this
plate directly into the oven and heating it up to 600 degrees or so, but that was something I
didn't want to risk. There's a label on the back, and at least with the hot air gun, I can control
what part of the plate gets heat, whereas if it was put into an oven and just heated up,
the whole thing would get heat and I wouldn't be able to control that, and I'm not terribly keen
on grabbing a 700 degree plate and trying to work with it. So this was the approach that I figured
was best, and you can see it is hot. Ultimately, I do get a lot of it separated, and you can see this
is the one area that I wasn't able to separate. This is actually pretty okay. You can see as the
raking light goes across, there are very subtle changes in the texture, but not massive ones. So
ultimately, I'm okay with leaving this part. Now once I have all of the pieces that I can separate
removed, I have to start taking off all of that old adhesive. So I start by trying to heat it up
and use my scalpel to scrape it off when it starts to soften and melt. This is really hard, and I
find myself getting very close to burning my hands multiple times. It's also really, really slow. You
can see how sped up this is and how little I'm removing, but unfortunately, this is just kind of
how it goes. So one piece after another, slowly working on one edge at a time, removing all the
old adhesive, and also while I'm at it, removing as much of the old fill-in material as I can.
This stuff comes off much, much more easily, and it doesn't require the use of heat, so at least
I have that going for me. After using the scalpel for a little while, I switched to a steel brush
and some gelled solvents in hopes that that's going to help, and it does a little bit, but
ultimately, scraping is still the best method of doing this. And it's time consuming. This took
several hours just to remove this old adhesive. Now on the front of the painting, where all of
that old fill-in and retouching is, I'm applying a gelled solvent and I'm using my scalpel to
scrape it off. Because this is ceramic, the scalpel isn't going to damage the surface, particularly if
I have a light touch. Once all of that stuff is removed, I can do a dry run of fitting this piece
back together. This is a really important step, even if it sounds kind of ridiculous and wasteful.
Doing a dry run will allow me to see areas that are particularly concerning or might give me
trouble in the future. And so this is why I do a dry run. Also, I just want to see how it all
fits together without any adhesive and any fill-in material, so I can get a better idea of the work
that's ahead. You can see that it almost fits together, but even the slightest little bit of
fill-in material can throw off the alignment. And so here, just that little bit right there,
that little bit of fill-in material has to be removed because otherwise this piece just won't
fit in. Now luckily, using my scalpel, I can chip off this fill-in material. It's a tiny, tiny little
bit. Clean it off a little bit more, and then I can take another stab at fitting it back into its
position. And hopefully, this time it will fit much better. And just like that, we have an almost
perfect fit. It's amazing what a tiny, tiny amount of old adhesive and fill-in material can do.
And that's why I was so intent on removing all of that. I'll continue piecing this together
from the middle outward using just some regular old masking tape to hold it in place. This is
all going to come off almost instantly once I put it together. But again, I just want to
get a lay of the land. Yes, I saw the piece before I took it apart, but I still want to do this step.
It's important. Once I'm done, I can see what the piece will look like when it's all complete.
And like I said, I can take note of any areas that are particularly troublesome or look kind of
worrying or maybe just need extra care. Doing the dry fit allows me to think about how I'm going to
fit it back together when I start using the adhesive. Because believe it or not, there is
one right way to do this. If I started with the outside and tried to work in, I probably wouldn't
be able to put this back together. And so doing a dry run allows me to experience that process and
figure out the right approach. For the adhesive, I'm using one that I mix here in the studio. And
this is a resin in solvent. And this is fully archival and fully reversible. And it's a two-step
process. The first is thinning out this adhesive and then painting it on the porous surface of
the ceramic. If I don't do this step, when I apply the adhesive to the edges, the ceramic will soak
it up and it will be a weakened bond. But here, because the ceramic will absorb a thinned out
adhesive, this adhesive will bond really well to both sides and it won't become dried out. This is
much like putting glue on both sides of wood when you bond them together instead of just on one side.
There are a lot of edges that need to be painted and saturated, so it takes a little time. But
ultimately, I'm finished and I'm ready to start gluing this back together. Now, this adhesive
dries incredibly fast, probably within 15 or 20 seconds, so I don't have a lot of time to work.
And I'm smearing it on pretty heavily. I don't care if it oozes out. I can clean that off later.
What I don't want is to have a starved joint, a glue joint that just doesn't have enough adhesive
and is weakened. So I'll put it into place and then I'll hold it. I'll use my fingers to clean
off some of the excess while I can. And then it's just about done. Bonded in place. I'll use a
little bit of yellow masking tape, which has a higher tack than regular masking tape, just to
everything in place and let me know where I have glued. I can use my fingernail to feel the ridges
and to make sure that this is aligned properly. My goal here is to get things as tight as possible
without squeezing out all of the glue and creating a starved joint. This is slow going and I'm using
some plasticine clay to help me where the bigger pieces are so that they don't sag as I'm putting
them on. The yellow tape is really helpful but ultimately just holding everything in place is
probably easier than trusting the tape. Now there are times where I will glue a piece in place and
it will shift and you can hear the ridge that's been created. This is no good. So this piece needs
to be removed. Now because I've used a reversible adhesive, I can saturate this area with a little
bit of solvent. The same solvent used to thin it out. Let that soften up the adhesive. Apply another
round or two, three. Make sure that that solvent really penetrates in and dissolves the adhesive
or at least weakens it enough that it's malleable. And then I can come back with a pair of pliers
wrapped in tape so that I don't damage the ceramic and wiggle it free. Now you can see this piece is
still really tightly in there and the adhesive is still really strong but I can remove it and I don't
have to heat it up to sun melting temperatures. Now once I have re-glued it in place, you can hear
that it is now flush and so a much better joint has been achieved. And as we come to the last
piece, it feels really good to finally be done with gluing. This took probably almost a whole day
to do, working piece by piece slowly. Every 20 seconds adds up and there were a lot of pieces
that needed to be bonded. But ultimately now with everything put back together, we can see the plate
as one whole piece and not an assembly of broken bits. And once it's all dry and I'll let it sit
for another day or so, I can come back and start removing all of that tape. Removing the tape is
always very rewarding, particularly when the piece doesn't fall apart into a million little pieces.
It's a job well done. And now we can take a look at the joints closer. We can see that they're
still kind of open. There are little gaps in between many of these joints and that's probably
a combination of the old work, the process of removing all of that old adhesive, and well it just
being old and has multiple repairs on it. It's just not going to fit perfectly as if it were broken
and brought to my studio right away. So where there are gaps, I'm going to take some adhesive
and flood those joints. This adhesive is pretty viscous and so it will eventually seep down into
those gaps and help fill and solidify these open joints. I'm going to do the same thing on the back
where the gaps are a little bit wider, just to make sure that I've got as much adhesive in there
as possible and that these joints are as strong as possible. Once that's all dry, I can come back
with my scalpel, very sharp blade, and simply glide over the surface and remove all of that
old adhesive. I could use the solvent but I want to avoid saturating these joints with too much
solvent because, as we saw earlier, it can weaken them, soften up the adhesive, and that's something
I don't want to happen. Again, because this has been fired, this ceramic glaze is incredibly strong
and the surface isn't going to be marred by my blade. I'm not using a lot of pressure, I'm not
scraping very hard, I'm simply gliding over the surface and allowing the blade to chip off the
excess adhesive that's oozed out of those joints. I'll do the same thing on the back and then once
it's all cleaned up, I'll come with that solvent very, very lightly and very quickly just pass over
the surface to remove any of the adhesive that I didn't get off. And this is really simple, really
straightforward, and you can see just how effective it is, but also how little solvent is on my cotton
swab. Not a lot, like when I was removing the piece. With all of the excess adhesive removed, it's time
for fill-in, and I'm using a fill-in material that's very similar to the one that I use on
paintings, except this one has a resin in it, so it's going to be much, much more rigid, much harder.
I don't want this to be soft and flexible, it's not necessary, I want it to be pretty stiff. So I'll
fill in these areas of loss, these gaps, and I'll just kind of smear it all over the surface. I'm
really not all that concerned about keeping it clean at this point, I just want to make sure that
I get it in all of those voids. And I'll probably have to make two passes just because, but again,
unlike a painting, I'm not terribly concerned about making a mess here. I can remove all of
this excess pretty easily, in fact, much easier than on a painting. Because this is a fired surface,
it's incredibly durable, so unlike a painting, I can be a little bit more assertive when I'm
working here. I'm going to come back with a 400 grit sanding sponge, which is incredibly fine,
and I'm just going to go over the surface and start removing some of that material.
This sanding sponge isn't going to abrade or damage the glaze, the glaze is much harder than
400 grit can affect, but it does do wonders in removing and smoothing out all of that fill-in
that I put in. It still does take quite some time, even at 400 grit it's really really really fine,
and this fill-in material is really hard, so I have to work it quite a bit. But it's pretty easy,
and it's pretty straightforward, it just takes time, and sometimes that's the name of the game,
just spending hours upon hours working on a piece, slowly chipping away at the multitude
of projects and steps that are required to complete the work. Once I'm satisfied with the
surface texture, I can take a damp shop towel and I can lift off and remove all of that dust, and
because this is a piece of ceramics, it's really really easy to clean, unlike a painting, so at
least I have that going for me. And then I need to coat this with a resin layer that will make
the retouching process much easier. I have found after doing ceramics for quite some time now that
if I don't do this process, the retouching just doesn't stick as well as it should, and this is
just one of those things I'm not sure exactly why, but this step, as seemingly inconsequential as it
may be, really does help with the retouching process. I don't need to worry about saturating
the colors like I would on a dry oil painting, I just want to make sure that they're going to stick.
One of the other issues with retouching on ceramic is that I'm not ever retouching on the actual
paint layer. You see, a ceramic like this is created with multiple layers. First there's the
blue layer where the artist paints the picture, and then there's the glaze layer which goes on top,
and when it's fired, the glaze layer becomes clear, and we have this beautiful ceramic.
The problem is that that glaze layer is pretty thick, maybe as thick as a half a millimeter,
and while that doesn't seem like a lot, it's enough that the retouching will sit on top of
that glaze, and then there will be sort of a parallax effect, where if you look really really
closely, the retouching won't move at the same rate as the rest of the original. It's kind of
hard to explain, but imagine if you painted something on a piece of paper, and then you put
a thick layer of glass on top of it, and then painted something on that glass. As you move your
head, the bottom layer and the layer on top of the glass will shift differently because they are on
different planes. So that is one of the issues that makes retouching ceramics really hard.
The other is that this is ultramarine blue and water, so there are a lot of very very thin
washes and glazes here, and the retouching paint just doesn't capture that light transparent glaze
effect like the original paint does. So I have to simulate it, but it never really truly matches.
Luckily for us, we're trying to retouch very very small cracks, and so if they're not 100%
perfect, at least when we step back and we look at the plate, they will disappear and blend in.
And that's really what I'm trying to do here. It's almost impossible to retouch this perfectly.
What we're trying to do is the best we can, and try to make the damage disappear when we view
the piece, so that we can view the piece as a whole and not be conscious of the damage.
Now I have talked to other ceramics conservators, and this is something that they have shared with
me is just a fact of life. I have theorized that potentially we could sand down or grind down the
glaze to get to the bottom layer, but that's super risky, and ultimately it's not really worth it
to say nothing of altering the original in a way that can't be undone. So this is how we do it.
Now luckily or unluckily for me, this is just one color, this ultramarine,
which makes it a little bit easier and a little bit more difficult to retouch. A little bit easier
because I know everything is pretty much blue, so I can stay in the blues family. But difficult
because my ultramarine isn't an exact match for this ultramarine, and so depending on whether
it's applied very thick or very thin, I have to add different colors to simulate the effect. So
even though it's just one color, blue ultramarine, it's actually not. I'm using black, I'm using
green, I'm using some purple, and I'm using some yellow in this, all to try to get the color just
right. And so in some respects it's easier because I only have to think about blue, but it's also
much harder because I have to think about all of the possible blues within this one set of
ultramarine blue. So I don't know, maybe I'm overthinking it, but I have a lot of time to
think when I'm retouching. Altogether, this one took, oh, just a couple of hours. Not terribly
long, but not all that swift either. If this were a painting, it probably would have taken
half as much time, but because it's a piece of ceramic, it takes a little bit more. I have to
go back with a lot more thin layers and try to layer this retouching paint on top of itself,
which that in and of itself is really difficult because it's a resin-based paint. Anytime you
try to layer it, the top layer will reactivate the layer underneath and it can get muddy and
mushy and all blend together. But luckily, I have a few tricks up my sleeve and ultimately,
the retouching does go according to plan. With all the retouching complete, I can apply the
final varnish, just like I would on a painting. I'm going to use this application of synthetic
resin to protect the surface and give it a unified sheen. It only takes a very quick pass
with the spray gun to apply enough resin to create a really beautiful surface. So just like that, we
are all done. Except we're not. There's one more thing I want to do. Even though we bonded this
plate back together with a really strong adhesive, it's going to hang on the wall and that means
there's going to be stress on those joints. So I've decided to create an exoskeleton that will
hold it all together. Belt and suspenders, if you will. And that all begins by scanning the plate
with my 3D scanner. And it takes a couple of tries but eventually, I do get a 3D scan that's workable
and I bring it into my CAD software. And you can see just how accurate it is. All of the chips and
nicks and cracks on the back are present. I've simplified this scan because it was overly
complicated and bogging down my computer. And then I've created an armature that will wrap
around the back and the outer lip of the front of the plate. This is a retaining ring, so to speak,
and it will hold everything together. One of the great things about working with 3D software is I
can take the scan of the plate and delete it from the armature that I have created. And then the
armature will fit precisely to the actual shape of the plate. No guesswork here. It's really
amazing. Though I have a pretty large 3D printer, it's not big enough to print the piece in one or
two sections, so I've printed it in quadrants. And then once I've removed all of the supports,
I can test fit this. And just like that, it snaps into place and the whole piece is now secure.
Though this is only plastic, what it will do is make sure that if there is stress on one of those
joints, it's not allowed to come free and separate. And this, like I said, is just belt and suspenders.
I have full faith and confidence in the adhesive, but I have the 3D scanner, I have the 3D printer,
and I have a little bit of know-how modeling in 3D, so I figured why not give it a shot?
This will be a proof of concept if ever I need in the future.
With all the pieces test fit, I can then begin the process of preparing them. And I'm going to
be sanding off some of those layer lines from the 3D printer, at least on the front lip. I don't
really care about the back. I could sand them all off, but that would be an incredible amount of
time. Once I'm satisfied with the surface and it's smooth, I will apply some primer to that edge,
just enough to fill in the scratch marks from the sandpaper. I'm really not all that concerned
about the back or the sides yet. Once that primer is dry, more sanding, just to make sure that that
outer edge is super smooth. Then I can bond the pieces together to make two halves. And I'm using
a plastic adhesive here that will effectively melt the plastic and fuse it together. Instead
of a glue that just sits in between the joints, this really makes sure that this plastic is one
piece instead of two being held together by the glue. So a liberal application. On one side,
I'll rub them together, hold them in place for a couple of seconds, apply some spring clamps,
and then let them dry. And I'll do this with both sides, making sure that everything is aligned and
secure. And then, instead of four pieces, I'll have two. But the work is not done. After a couple
of days of letting it sit and dry, I have to do a little bit of fill-in where the joints were.
There are some seams that I just want to get rid of. So using some filler, I can mix it up. It's
two parts. You mix it up, apply it liberally, let it dry, and then, of course, it's back to sanding.
So more sanding to get rid of the excess filler and just make sure that this is all smooth.
Again, I'm not terribly concerned about the back. It's really the front edge that I don't want to
have a lip. But I'll sand everything just in case. Now, to assemble and hold this in place,
I have created holes on both sides of the two pieces. And I'm using threaded inserts and a
soldering iron to place them into the plastic. Soldering iron heats it up enough that it melts
the plastic. I can inset them and then hold them in place. And then, these are forever bonded.
And this will allow me to use screws to hold this all together. So if this ever needs to be
removed in the future, it can without having to break it loose and run risk of damage to the plate.
And you can see some small metric screws and we're in business. I'm going to thread these
in to the threaded inserts because I'm going to paint this whole thing. And I don't want to get
paint inside those threads because then I would either have to chase them or it would be a big
mess. I'm using some plasticine clay here to fill in the area that's going to come in contact with
the plate. Because it's so tight, I don't want to run the risk that a paint buildup will interfere
with that tight fit. And then, it's on to mixing paint. I'm using a urethane 2k paint here, but
it's base white and that doesn't match the plate. So I'm using some dyes to change the color,
hopefully get it as close as I can. I'll test it on the back, clean it off, adjust it, add some more
dye, lather, rinse, repeat until I have achieved a color that I think is pretty close. I could
continue doing this until I'm 100% satisfied, but again, this is just an outer retaining ring and
it's okay if the color is close but not perfect. After applying another coating of primer to the
whole piece and giving it one final sand, I'm coming along with my spray gun and I'm just
going to spray light coats of this 2k urethane paint onto the pieces that I 3d printed. And by
spraying light coats and making sure that I spray them wet on wet, I can ensure that number one, I
don't get any orange peel and number two, I don't get any runs. So lots and lots of coats and
eventually, I have a built-up layer that I think I'm satisfied with. After allowing the paint to
dry and harden for a few days, I can place the exoskeleton or armature onto the plate. And I'm
using a piece of foam and gloves to protect the painting from fingerprints, chips, nicks, scratches,
and also to protect the armature because everything is really glossy and really pretty right now and
I don't want to mess it up. I'll begin by taking one side and snapping it onto the plate, being
careful not to put too much stress on either the plate or the armature. It is a tight fit after all.
And then I can take some of those screws that have the white painted heads. I decided to keep
them because the white actually kind of looks nice and begin assembling it. Now, I may have
gone a little overboard, including six screws on each side. I don't think that that's all that
necessary. I think maybe three would have been plenty. But of course, this is all a learning
process and I will take away from this process bits and pieces to make the next time a bit better.
And with all 12 of those screws in place and the armature wrapped around the plate,
I can take a step back and see how everything turned out. And I am happy to say that this
plate looks fantastic. Now, it was a fairly low bar given that it came in in multiple pieces,
but now with it assembled and those joints tight and free of all of that excess fill-in material
and that really lousy attempt at retouching, we really don't see these cracks anymore.
And the armature fits around the front perfectly. It is hugging the edge of this plate and making
sure that if there's any stress, if any of those joints become loose, that the pieces don't fall
out and break again. And that was precisely the goal. Now, if we look really, really closely,
we can of course see where the retouching is, because unlike a painting, we're dealing with
a three-dimensional space here. The transparent glaze was always going to be a force to contend
with. But ultimately, what we're looking to do is just eliminate those areas of damage.
Take away the distractions and allow us to see the artist's vision as a whole. We don't want
to have anything that interferes with that. Now, the armature, there is room for improvement.
I learned a ton about 3D scanning, 3D designing, and 3D printing. And while I'm very satisfied with
this process, frankly, it took a good 12 or so times before I got it right, next time will be
even better. And that's one thing that's great about taking on projects that are different,
is they force you to grow. They challenge you to overcome obstacles. And that may be the greatest
reward. So for this piece, I consider myself the lucky one, even if the client gets to take it
home. Before, broken and suffering from multiple poor interventions in the past, this plate was
desperate for a proper conservation. And afterwards, with all of the distractions gone,
the stability secured, and the image restored, I think this was a conservation well served.