A Reddit thread is claiming the Phoenix housing market is being manipulated against buyers — sellers relisting homes to reset days on market and keep prices high. So I pulled the actual data to see what's really going on.
In this week's Phoenix real estate market update, we break down agent days on market vs. cumulative days on market (and the 45-day reset rule most buyers don't know about), why days on market alone doesn't define a buyer's or seller's market, and the one stat that actually caught my attention: the listing success rate, which is currently showing just 59% for August — down from 72% in May.
We also cover: • Current days on market in the Phoenix metro (48 ADOM / 62 median CDOM) and how that compares to 2004–2022 • The Cromford Market Index at 80 — what that means for buyers and sellers • Which Valley cities are in a seller's, buyer's, or balanced market right now (Mesa, Paradise Valley, Queen Creek, Tempe, Peoria, Avondale, Gilbert) • Mortgage rates at 6.79% and the steady climb since February • The contract ratio map — why so many zip codes are running cold
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The speaker examines claims of market manipulation in the Phoenix real estate market, arguing that while some sellers reset \"days on market\" (DOM), actual prices are driven by buyer demand and rising mortgage rates. Data indicates a declining listing success rate and a general market slowdown, with affordability issues causing many participants to remain on the sidelines.
So I'm scrolling on the internet looking for real estate information, as one does, and
I come across this Reddit thread that I have to share with you guys.
It's about market manipulation from the perspective of a buyer in the Phoenix metro area.
This led me to uncover a stat on the Cromford Report that is a little alarming, however
I think maybe we don't have all the data yet, but we're still going to look at that because
I'm not quite sure what's going on with that.
So let's get into it today.
Let's see what's going on, that plus everything else going on in the Phoenix real estate market.
By the way, if you can see a cut on my eye, you can indeed.
You're seeing that correct.
I did get a flying disc point blank straight to the eye last night from my son.
Thank you very much.
My eye is fine, but it's a little swollen and there is a cut there.
So you know, there's the explanation.
Okay.
So this Reddit article here, Phoenix real estate market manipulation against buyers,
bold claim, bold claim, but let's find out what they're talking about here because they
have some valid points.
I sold my house a few years ago in Chandler, thanks divorce, but have been waiting to find
a property.
I've been shocked that what I see in here doesn't reflect what I see when I dive into
listings.
Most of the listings I find or a fair amount have been pulled off the market and then relisted.
So while it shows lower days on market in Zillow and Redfin, I can tell it's been relisted
in the data.
So they're referring to the fact that people are talking about the market is moving quickly
and it's balanced.
However, they are claiming that they're finding that there are more, you know, higher days
on market than what, you know, appears to be the case specifically for Mesa and Scottsdale.
But because days on market stays lower, the market shows that it's fairly balanced and
prices stay higher, which really screws over new buyers, especially younger folks.
Okay, so here's where I need to pause this for a second because while days on market
is an indication of what is actually happening in the market, that's not all that we think
about when we're talking about a balanced market or a seller's market or buyer's market.
That's just kind of a byproduct of the market conditions, right?
So when we are in a buyer's market, that's because the inventory levels overall are staying
elevated and the absorption rate is low, like the amount of buyers that are actually taking
those listings off the market is low.
That's not happening quickly, regardless of how many days there are on the market.
Now, of course, the higher days on market is a byproduct of having lower demand and
a higher number of active listings.
So just because we're seeing, you know, homes that have been on the market for a while,
that doesn't just like on its face say that that means it's a buyer's market.
They're also saying that this is why prices stay higher because of the days on market
and, you know, these listings being manipulated to show that they're lower on market when
they're really not.
And that's not true either, because just because a home shows lower days on market doesn't
mean that like that's going to command a higher price.
If that price is wrong, then it's going to take longer to sell or it never sells or it
comes off market and relisted and still never sells, right?
So that's not really dictating the price.
It's the buyers essentially dictating the price.
What they find to be affordable and reasonable, et cetera.
Okay.
So they go on to say, so I try to think about this and there's a term used, it's called
listing success rate, and it leads to cumulative days on market, which is if you list a property
three times for three months each before it sells, your ADOM will show three months, but
your CDOM will show nine months.
So some clarification here.
First of all, listing success rate.
We've looked at this through Cromford before.
We're going to look at this today.
The cumulative days on market means that the days on market continues even if it's taken
off market temporarily, or if it's taken off market for less than 45 days.
So if it is off MLS for 45 days or more, that number resets.
So you actually do start from zero if you've taken 45 days off the MLS.
The agent days on market is what can reset if you take a pause and get back on market.
For instance, even like pending listings, you've been on market for 10 days, you get
under contract, you fall out because of inspection, you go back on market.
Those days were not accumulating in the agent days on market.
I'm fairly certain that's how it's tracking it.
The whole point of this, however, is the cumulative days on market does actually stop when you
are off market 45 days.
So a home could be listed like 10 times over.
As long as it's spent 45 days off market, it's going to appear as a new listing.
But that is not what affects prices.
That's not really what affects whether or not we're in a buyer's market or seller's
market, but it is an indication that obviously buyers aren't taking the bait, right?
Your price is wrong.
You're conditioned wrong.
Something is wrong with the property where it's not being sold.
And are we seeing more of that?
Yeah, for sure.
Now, they claim this is because institutional sellers and agents are pulling properties
off market to make them look newer and reset days on market.
So I would say some of that is true.
You do have the ability to take it off market and relist and make it look fresh, but you
do have to spend 45 days off market.
So if you have a need to actually sell your home, taking it off market and relisting it
the next day isn't fixing your days on market, you're going to have to spend that time off
market.
And that's not helpful, right?
In my experience, most sellers who are not seeing success but do need to sell their home
are adjusting the price.
They're offering concessions.
They are making updates to their home or they will take it off for 45 days, reset and come
back on.
So it's not something you can very easily manipulate in a short period of time, right?
So what is the actual days on market?
When we look at Cromford, the agent days on market, which is the ADOM, is currently sitting
at 48 days on market.
Now they measure this between listing to the time when it actually goes under contract,
not the actual closing date.
So this is your time on market when you receive a contract.
Now if we look at the CDOM or the cumulative days on market, they have this listed for
Q3 so far.
As of August, it's 87.
Now that's average.
What we were looking at before was the median, so they're measured a little bit differently.
This is also cumulative days on market versus the agent days on market.
The median cumulative days on market comes down to 62.
So all in all, we're looking at something like 50 to 80, 90 days on market, a difference
of about a month or so.
But this also varies based on location and based on price range.
So it is very hard to kind of paint this with a broad brush, especially in Phoenix, because
every hyper local area is a bit different.
Now that said, this reads to me as correct.
And I will tell you, there are many folks that I talk to out there who still have an
expectation to sell their home within the first one week on market or first weekend.
So waiting 50, 60 days feels like a buyer's market to them.
It feels like we are not in a good place from the seller's standpoint, when in reality,
that time on market is pretty normal, especially in a balanced market.
It takes time to sell a home.
They just don't sell in the first weekend unless the price is extremely competitive
and all the other stars align with that property as well.
So taking this median cumulative days on market all the way back to 2004, here's where we're
at today.
And you can definitely see these peaks.
2022, that's when mortgage rates went up.
2013, 2014 was still lower than what we saw in 2022, a little bit lower than where we're
at today, 2011.
And then we've got some higher peaks in 06, 07, 09, for obvious reasons.
And then in 2004 as well.
Seeing 58 days on market in 2004, in 2008 to 2009, we were around 94 days on market.
Today, we're at about 62.
So where we're at doesn't scream to me that we're seeing anything out of place and odd.
Obviously, these were very low days on market in 2020, 21, 22.
We're not surprised by that.
But the listing success rate, they mentioned in this.
And I was like, yeah, let's take a look at the listing success rate.
It's very low at the moment.
And so here's what I'm saying.
I don't think we're at 59%.
This is for August.
I don't know how they run these numbers.
And it is possible that this is because we only have two weeks in August that it's measuring.
So I'm going to come back to this.
And we're going to look at this when the month is fully complete.
But 59% is a low number.
And considering July was 67, June was 70, and May was 72,
this has been trending down since February, which is pretty much this whole year.
And if we really indeed are at 59% right now, that explains a lot, right?
That explains why it feels like it's taking forever to sell a home.
And we see many people delisting their homes,
not trying to manipulate the market, but basically waving the white flag and saying,
I give up.
I'm not getting the price that I want.
I don't want to invest any more money into this home.
I'm just going to hold on to it right now.
And maybe I'll relist it in the fall when the market's better
or in the spring when the market's better.
I say better because we tend to see more activity, but there's no promises for that, right?
So I think that's a lot of what we're seeing is people
not necessarily trying to manipulate the market
because truly you can't.
The longer time you spend off market, the more in mortgage you're paying
and expenses and whatnot, that's not always a win for the seller anyway.
They just want to take a better swing at it when maybe market conditions are better,
or they have time to rehab some things and relist it.
Or they want to see how some comps come into play and what closes
and whether or not they could relist at a different price.
So manipulation, strong word, I think.
However, there is something to be said for how we're tracking days on market,
what that looks like.
But be cautious when you're reading Reddit.
I think we all know that.
I mean, there's some juicy stuff on Reddit.
We love it.
But sometimes it's not the full story, right?
That said, I think they have some really good points that we need to consider.
And that brought us to be looking at the listing success rate and seeing 59%.
So you know we're going to be tracking this and continue to see what is going on.
I can actually break this listing success rate down by city, which is quite interesting.
If you want that information for your city, just check the description below.
I have a link where you can request that information.
So let's look at the CMI.
We're at 80.
The demand is 79.4.
This has gone down.
Supply has also gone down, 98.7.
We've been over 100 with supply most of the year, but this is tapering off.
Demand 79.4.
We've been in the 80s.
This is coming down.
Why?
Well, interest rates have not really been our friend lately,
and I'll show you what's going on there in a second.
And then when we look at the major cities throughout the Phoenix metro area,
a lot of red arrows on this.
So what Cromford is saying, the average CMI is up 1.8% from last month.
This is more favorable for sellers than last week,
but it's all due to the expensive end of the market
where active listings are reduced for the summer, but demand remains healthy.
So I've talked about this before.
The luxury listings or the luxury homes come off the market in the summer.
They are what really increases the supply on that end of things
when they come off the market in the summer and the demand remains stable.
There's fewer homes to choose from.
It gets a little bit more competitive.
The rest of the market is still suffering from weak demand
that's drifting slightly downwards as interest rates rise.
So for any of you who are new here,
the Cromford market index indicates that
anything over 110 is considered a seller's market.
Anything under 90 is considered a buyer's market
and between 90 to 110 is a balanced market.
So we've got a number of cities, according to the CMI,
in this seller's market from Mesa up to Paradise Valley.
And then on the low end, when we're looking at buyer's markets,
anything under 90, so that's surprise to Queen Creek.
And then as far as balance, we have Tempe, Peoria,
Avondale, and Gilbert in balance, according to the CMI.
So mortgage rates are sitting at 6.8, 6.79.
Look at this.
This is February.
And I mean, it's a very clear, steady increase from February.
So if you were someone who came into this year
really hoping rates would go down to make homes more affordable for you,
that's really not what has happened, unfortunately.
And while we've seen some movement in prices,
we haven't seen a really big change in home prices for buyers.
So it's really only gotten more expensive
when you look at the monthly payments for most buyers out there.
So to translate that, you know,
if you're a seller on the market and you're like,
what the heck, this is it.
This is it.
The prices where we're at, the rates where we're at,
there's just a lot of people who are willing to sit on the sidelines.
And there's a lot of people who want to sell their home,
but they're like, man, if I sell this,
my new payment is not going to be what I like.
So I'm just going to stay here for a little while.
Plus it's summer.
So at least we are getting to mid-August.
We'll be in September soon.
Things may pick up as they tend to do September, October, early November.
And then things get a little bit quieter for the holidays.
So if you're planning any moves,
that's generally how the market works here in the Phoenix metro area.
Let's look at the contract ratio,
because it's looking a little chilly,
a little bit more blue than I've seen in a bit.
We have a couple of zip codes that are yellow,
Scottsdale 85255 and then Phoenix 85037.
Everything else is in this like blue green,
which means that it's either balanced or it's cold.
Again, really just kind of reflecting what we're experiencing
in a lot of areas of the Valley.
So I want to know from you guys,
as you are searching for homes on Zillow, Redfin,
all of these other places,
are you checking the days on market?
And are you checking the listing history?
Because I know a lot of clients I work with
are looking at those same details as what was mentioned on Reddit.
And I want to know from you guys,
if that's important to you too, from a buyer standpoint.
If you want that listing success rate,
I can break that down by city,
check the description below to request that information.
And I will be back next week with another market update.