Aug 10, 2026 Head on over to https://squarespace.syuh.net/baumgartner to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain using code BAUMGARTNER. -- Little things matter, but for some pieces, the matter a bit more. Such was the case for this incredibly detailed icon which came in needing a bit of tender loving care. -- Support me on Patreon / baumgartnerrestoration
Follow me on Instagram - / baumgartnerrestoration Facebook - / baumgartnerfineartrestoration Julian Baumgartner restores a highly detailed antique icon painted on a wooden panel. The process involves removing layers of aged varnish, addressing structural losses, and carefully retouching the intricate artwork to preserve its historical character while ensuring long-term stability. Summary
How this was made Auto-dubbed Audio tracks for some languages were automatically generated. Learn more Transcript Follow along using the transcript.
Show transcript
Baumgartner Restoration 1.96M subscribers Videos About
AI Generated·May contain errors
This video is brought to you by Squarespace. From websites and online stores to marketing tools
and analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform to build a beautiful online presence
and run your business. Of all of the types of artwork that we see in the studio, big, small,
simple, complex, landscape, portrait, oil, acrylic, canvas, wood panel, one seems to throw more
frustration at me than the others. And that is an icon. Created on wood panel, often with mixed
medium, tempera, oil, and gold leaf, these little images are incredibly detailed and often incredibly
damaged. This painting is no exception. It is incredibly detailed, but also incredibly damaged.
There are signs of loss and flaking throughout. There are also signs of crude and ill-advised
attempts at repairing this piece. But what we have going for us is that the piece is relatively sound.
The panel has not deteriorated, it's not infested with pests, and it hasn't split in multiple places.
But the damage is not good, and this will have to be reckoned with. But I'm hoping that underneath
all of this grime and old varnish and old overpaint, there's something beautiful and worth
saving. But we've got to roll up our sleeves and get to it to find out. So many of the icons I see
are crudely painted and really not all that detailed, but here, this one, my gosh, the details
are what set it apart. And you know where I'm going with this. Details matter, from icons to websites.
And with Squarespace, the devil is in the details. And yeah, because details matter.
And Squarespace has made it really easy to get that level of precision with their new fluid
engine, which allows you to simply drag and drop elements around the page and position them as you
like. So no more fussing with code and making compromises. And that level of freedom and
flexibility extends to the whole platform. From their e-commerce solutions, which allow you to
create an online store to sell your goods as you want them to be sold, or creating a home on the
internet to showcase your artwork in the way that you want it displayed, Squarespace has you covered.
Even with their support documents, videos, and forums, the detail is granular. Oh, and did I
mention that you can talk to a real live human if you want? How about that little devil hiding
in the details? Head over to squarespace.com slash Baumgartner for a free trial. And when
you're ready to launch, use offer code Baumgartner to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or
domain. With this painting, the first thing that I'm going to do is clean it. There isn't much
stabilization that needs to happen. And so I can jump right into the removal of the surface grime.
And I'm using my neutral organic soap. This is a soap that we mix here in the studio that's
designed to break up dirt, dust, grime, oils that are sitting on the surface. It's pH neutral and
it's composed of organic materials. So it's relatively harmless. In fact, you can use it to
clean your hands if you wanted. I wouldn't necessarily do that, but it is safe. And you can
see just with a little test, some of the grime is coming up. And it's critically important to remove
this grime before we try to remove any other coatings like varnishes. Because if this grime is
still present on the painting, when we try to remove the varnish, the solvents that we use to
remove the varnish, whether they be free or in a gel form, will have difficulty accessing that
varnish layer. This dirt and grime layer will be sitting atop that varnish. And those solvents
don't do a good job of penetrating through this grime layer. And that could lead us to choosing
more harsh or more aggressive solvents, which could lead to damage. And so we remove the grime
separately from the varnish in a two-stage cleaning process. And you can see here that
while it's not terribly, terribly grimy, there is a lot of dirt coming off. And even that thin
layer can pose a problem for the next cleaning process, the removal of the varnish. I use a
old bristle brush here. I paint on the neutral organic soap, and then I agitate it a little bit.
The organic soap does wonders, but the agitation really helps break up this layer of soot and oil
and dust and dirt and grime, all of which can kind of fuse together to create just a general
grime that's hard to remove without the agitation. I'll then come back with a swab and lift off
the remainder of the grime and the organic soap. Now at this stage, when the painting has all the
grime removed, we could call it a day. If the client decided they wanted to keep the old varnish
on the painting for some reason, I don't know why, but for some reason, we could clean off all of the
residues and this painting would effectively be clean. There's a big difference in cleaning a
painting and removing an old varnish. Cleaning a painting refers to removing the accumulated
surface grime, which is what I'm doing now. But removing an old varnish is, well, removing an old
varnish. That's not considered cleaning the painting, that's considered removing the old
varnish. So it's really a two-steps process that involves two different approaches, two different
suites of materials, and two different reasons. What I was hoping I would find was a really bright
painting that was just covered in old grime. Sometimes that happens with these old icons.
They're either in churches or homes where there are candles in front of them and they get incredibly
dirty, really sooty and really gross. And sometimes all it takes is really good cleaning with a neutral
organic soap and the painting looks wonderful and sometimes we can leave the old varnish.
And sometimes we might leave the old varnish because, as I mentioned earlier, these icons are
often created with gold leaf, tempera, and oil and they are not necessarily stable. They're usually
more difficult to clean and so sometimes leaving the old varnish might be desired, either by the
client because of the appearance or because it's just not safe to fully remove. But in this case,
we're not getting the transformation that I had hoped, so I think we are probably going to have
to remove this varnish in the second process. When it comes to removing old varnish, there are
many approaches the conservator can take. Free solvent, gelled solvent, resin soaps, lasers,
mechanical removal, etc. And neither is better or worse than the other. They're just different
and it's up to the conservator to decide which is applicable to the painting.
And like everything from a distance, it's super easy to judge and say that's wrong,
that's not correct, that's not the way it should be done. But without knowing the details of the
project, of the piece, of the solvents used, of the stability, it's really impossible to make those
assertions. But that doesn't mean people won't. In any event, here I've chosen to use free solvent,
which is just a liquid solvent, it's not gelled, and I dip a hand-rolled swab into that solvent
and then I apply it to the surface of the painting and use the swab to agitate and lift it up.
And this is probably the oldest method of removing varnish and the reason we still use it is because
it's tried and true. It gives a lot of control. What I can do here is feel the varnish through the
swab and I can tell when it's getting sticky and when it is starting to lift and then when it's off.
And that's something that can't really be done with a laser or with a gel. And so this is the
approach that I've taken because I want to feel when the varnish is off. Yes, I can see it but I
can also feel it probably before it's starting to come off. And so those little cues are really
important. They allow me to have a lot of control when it comes to removing this varnish.
Now, removing this varnish is slow going. You saw how long it took me to clear that one little
section. And I've chosen to work on the perimeter of this icon first because, well, it's less
detailed and it gives me enough time and exposure to determine how stable the various colors are,
including the really fine text areas, and how this old overpainting comes off or doesn't.
Before I move to the main field, which I'm certain has gold leaf and a lot more colors there, I want
to gather a lot of data and that makes me a better equipped conservator to work on those other areas.
Sometimes diving right into the most important part of the piece is just ill-advised. It may
be the most exciting area to clean off but, you know, you just don't know how those colors are
going to respond. And by working on an area like this, the perimeter or the background first,
it allows me to gather some data. How long it takes to remove the varnish, how stable the reds
are or the greens are. Are these little areas of black text stable enough to use free solvent or
do I have to use a different approach? And then once I've gathered all of that data, I've got
the experience of cleaning this perimeter, then I feel more equipped and more confident in cleaning
the rest of the piece. So I will continue removing all of the varnish from this perimeter area and
it actually looks pretty good. It's not a huge change but, you know, cleaning brown off of brown
just yields kind of a lighter brown. I'm still optimistic that we'll see some better colors in
main field of the painting. With all of the old varnish and residues removed from the perimeter
and it having been stable and going according to plan, I'm now ready to start cleaning the
main field of the painting. Again, using free solvents with the same approach. I'll select a
section, apply the solvent, agitate it a little bit and then lift off the old varnish. And while
you can see a lot of varnish coming off on my swab, the change is not as drastic as I was hoping for
or expecting. But hope is not lost. We will continue to make tests around the rest of the painting
to kind of create some windows and create a baseline, a litmus test so to speak. Let's find
the area that's the lightest and see how much varnish comes off. And here I think I've found
one of those areas. And the change is pretty good. Now with a raking light you can see just how thick
this old varnish is. It's really cracked and deteriorated and when I remove it, well the change
is evident. So on we go and let's see what's lying underneath all of this old discolored varnish.
Well that was quite a change, wasn't it? And I am completely satisfied with how this old varnish
was cleared up. There's a broad range of color and detail that were just completely hidden before.
But there are some areas where I need to take a mechanical approach to removing
stuff. And so I'll take my scalpel and just delicately scrape off what's sitting on the
surface. Whether it be plaster or in this case some wax from a candle that I suspected was
sitting right in front of this gorgeous little icon. This is not terribly complicated but it's a
little tedious. It's necessary to scrape off all of the old overpaint and all of the stuff that just
wouldn't come off with the soap or the solvents. And once I've removed all of that stuff, I can
transfer to the fill-in process. And of all the procedures that we do in the studio, this is
probably my least favorite. It's tedious, it's not high stakes, but it really does matter.
It's just boring. But it's important because even these small divots right here, they will matter.
They'll catch the light, even if retouched properly, and you'll see them. And that would give
away that we've had to repair something. And that's not what we want. We don't want any
interruptions into the viewing process. So I'll go over the entire painting, filling in all of these
little areas, including rebuilding some of the corners and edges that have chipped off. And then
I'll let it dry. And this usually takes a couple of hours, sometimes a day or two. But once it's dry,
I can come back and start removing the excess. The goal here is to only have fill-in material
where it's absolutely necessary. And that would be in voids. So all of this excess fill-in material
that's sitting on the surface of the painting has to go. It's just simply not acceptable for
us to leave it and overpaint over it, like we've seen so many times. I mentioned it's tedious. Yeah,
when it's small and you're using a little swab, it takes time. But this is the way to do it.
So I'll continue over the entire piece, working on the tops, on the sides,
removing all of the excess fill-in that I applied. And maybe this old dog should learn some new
tricks and start applying less fill-in. We'll see. I did mention this is an old dog after all.
And once all of this fill-in is removed, I can prepare it for retouching. And here I'm going
to be applying a layer of synthetic resin onto the surface as sort of a saturation layer. And
also because there's a lot of fill-in, I want to make sure that the fill-in, which is really
absorbent, doesn't absorb all of the retouching medium and then create a matte spot. Sometimes
that can happen. And when we go to varnish it, the sheens don't match. The rest of the painting will
be shiny. And then the areas where the fill-in was applied will be matte. And that's not the end of
the world. We can solve for that. But I'd rather not if I don't have to. In addition, this saturation
layer will simulate what the final varnish would do to the painting. And so now I can retouch
according to what the finished painting will look like. If I retouched on a dry and washed out
painting, my colors would be dry and washed out. And then when I varnished them, the painting would
change, but my retouching colors wouldn't. And that wouldn't look great. Now on to retouching.
This is not terribly complicated, but it is terribly detailed. And so while some areas like
this ochre color are pretty easy with my standard brush, there are going to be other areas where
this brush looks just overwhelmingly too large. And I'll have a couple of tricks up my sleeve
there. But for now, I'm just going to work on color blocking and getting rid of this loss.
This is just a matter of matching a color, applying it, changing it a little bit,
matching another color, applying it, changing a little bit. Even in this area that looks like
one flat color, I'm still applying multiple different shades of this color because it helps
camouflage the loss and allows the eye to complete and fill in the area. It's really,
really hard to match a flat color. In fact, it's almost impossible, particularly because when you
run out of that color, you have to remix it and never ever do you get it perfectly the same.
So mixing a bunch of various shades and then applying them all together is kind of a way of
camouflaging it and making it disappear, or at least allowing your eye to collect that information
and send it to your brain where it will be reassembled as a whole.
Now, once I've come to some of these smaller detailed areas, I'm using a really detailed
pinstriping brush to try to simulate what was probably done with pen and oil paint.
Now, the colors that I use here, the retouching paints, just don't flow like oil paint,
so I can't get that same ultra-fine precision that you get with oil paints.
Some of these areas where there's writing and this really incredible detail,
I'm almost certain that that was done with either a one-hair brush or a kind of quill pen,
and that's fine because oil paint has a really good flow, but the retouching paints don't.
So while a one-hair brush can pick up a lot of oil paint and allow the artist to create these
really fine details, I've tried a one-hair brush and the retouching paint just dries too quickly.
It just doesn't work.
So the best that I have here in the studio is this pinstriping brush, which is incredibly detailed,
but for a painting like this, it's almost comically crude.
But this is what I got, so this is what I'll work with.
And here, it's just a matter of finding the base color, the background color,
applying it on the fill-in to create a unified area,
and then working with the detail colors on top of that.
So in some cases, it's adding little stripes of blue or little stripes of yellow,
these kind of highlights, or in this case, rebuilding these horns or decorations.
It's tedious, and it's really nerve-wracking,
particularly with a camera sitting in front of my face.
It's really hard to see what I'm actually retouching.
I have to kind of look from the side.
But such is the labor of the conservator, to deliver what everybody wants.
So on and on we go, retouching, finding areas where there are losses,
putting down color, and then coming back and refining the detail.
And in an area like this, where there is writing,
I have no idea what the writing is, and I can barely even make it out.
I'm just going to try to simulate something that looks like the writing,
so at least the eye can gloss over it.
Now, if somebody were to come across this and say,
that's not right, there should be actual letters there, which there should,
this retouching can be removed.
Not only is it on top of an isolation layer, but it's a reversible paint.
So if somebody wants to come back and actually add those letters,
they can do so.
And that's why we use modern conservation-specific materials.
Now for an area like this, the little moon,
it's actually kind of fun, even if it's really difficult.
Again, these paints that I have just don't work on this small scale.
Not to mention, they just don't blend like oil paints.
So as I'm applying them, by the time I lift my brush off of the surface,
they're pretty much dry, which means I can't glaze.
I can't blend them like I could with oil paints.
So I have to use lots and lots of changes of color,
lots of gradations of little dots to try to simulate
the smooth gradient that you would have
if you could blend all of these colors together like you could with oil.
It's tedious, it's frustrating,
and it really makes me want to switch to using oil paint,
but that's not something I can do.
I have to use these retouching colors.
But eventually, I get pretty close,
or at least close enough that I'm satisfied that upon quick glance,
or at least viewing this piece,
nobody's going to notice that this area right here isn't as smooth as the other one.
They're just going to gloss over it.
I'm going to say, oh, that's the moon, and the sun is on the other side.
Looks great. What else is there to see?
And, you know, while it may seem like a cop-out,
that really is kind of how retouching works.
Do enough that the eye can pass over the damage,
but not so much that you're kind of repainting the entire thing.
It's a fine, delicate balance,
but one that gets reassessed every time we start retouching for every painting.
We reinvent the wheel every time.
And with all of that retouching complete and being satisfactory,
it's now time for varnish.
And here, I've chosen to spray the varnish on because of the dips in the panel.
I don't want it pooling, and I'm worried that if I brush it on, it will.
In addition, it allows me to get the edges of the piece because this won't be framed,
and those need a varnish, too, so that the overall piece has the same sheen.
Now, it doesn't take a lot of varnish for a painting of this scale,
and when spraying, really, we just need a light coating.
Here, it's mostly just to change the sheen to give it something I like
and to give it a final ultraviolet layer of protection.
And there it is, all complete.
While I mentioned that icons are not necessarily my favorite pieces to work on,
while I don't think that this has fundamentally changed my opinion,
this was actually kind of nice.
It's a beautifully painted piece with incredible detail,
and working on something like that,
well, it feels a little bit better than working on something that's crude
or really, really damaged.
After all, the damage on this piece was relatively minimal,
but addressing it, filling in those losses, doing the retouching,
and of course, cleaning the grime and removing the old varnish
has yielded a pretty radical transformation.
From before to after, the change is self-evident.
And now, this painting can shine in all its resplendent glory.
It is now a painting where the devil,
and maybe even a few angels,
are in the details.