How Habits Are Formed: A Neuroscientist Explains the Science of Addiction explores the fascinating science behind how habits develop and why some behaviors become difficult to change. A neuroscientist explains how the brain responds to repeated behaviors, rewards, and environmental cues, helping us understand the connection between habits and addictive behavior. The video offers useful insights into building healthier routines and making lasting changes.
Dr. Judson Brewer explains that addiction is not a failure of willpower but a result of the brain's reward system. By understanding the \"habit loop\" and the role of dopamine as a motivational trigger, individuals can use mindful awareness and curiosity to \"disenchant\" themselves from bad habits and build the distress tolerance necessary for lasting recovery.
Dopamine's not designed to be pleasant.
Dopamine's there to drive us into action.
World-renowned psychiatrist, neuroscientist,
and best-selling author, Dr. Judson Brewer,
shares his groundbreaking research on what works
to break cycles of addiction and anxiety.
From a neuroscience perspective,
when we look at how habits are formed
and how we break bad habits,
it has nothing to do with willpower.
Welcome to Recoverable.
I'm your host, Terry Maguire.
Joining us today is Dr. Judson Brewer,
and we will be talking about the neuroscience of addiction.
We're going to do something a little different this time
and start with some myth or fact lightning round.
You up for it, Dr. Brewer?
Absolutely.
Excellent. Now, you want to ask me to call you Dr. Jud?
Yes.
So I'll go with that.
All right. Myth or fact?
Addiction is just a lack of willpower.
Myth all the way.
Tell me why, briefly.
Willpower is more myth than muscle.
And if you look at it from a neuroscience perspective,
that's not how we form habits,
and that's not how we break habits.
Dopamine is the chemical that makes you feel high.
Myth or fact?
Depends on how you define high.
So if you talk about that restless, itchy,
urge-y quality of do something,
that's what dopamine is all about.
It's a motivation molecule.
And if we're thinking about a different kind of high?
We're talking about pleasantness.
Dopamine is not designed to be pleasant.
Dopamine is there to drive us into action.
So dopamine, not pleasant, not designed that way.
Okay. Myth or fact?
Relapse means treatment failed.
Myth.
Relapse can mean a lot of things to a lot of different people.
So here, relapse just means somebody relapsed
to using a substance or doing a behavior
that they were trying not to do.
How about myth or fact?
Relapse means you failed.
No, absolutely not.
That's another myth that I think keeps people down.
You know, this isn't about people failing.
This is about people not knowing how their brain works.
Can't wait to learn. Myth or fact?
The teenage brain is more susceptible to addiction.
I would say probably fact.
You know, there's a lot of research showing
that the teenage brain is particularly neuroplastic,
meaning that it's at a very rapid growth stage.
And so there are a lot of places
where things can get locked in in the teenage brain
that make it harder to learn or unlearn as an adult.
We'll be talking about that more.
Myth or fact?
Medication-assisted treatment, or MAT,
is just swapping one drug for another.
Oh, myth. Absolutely.
Certainly in my own personal experience
prescribing medication and seeing people use MAT
absolutely can be very helpful for a lot of people.
Myth or fact?
You have to hit rock bottom before you get help.
Myth.
So a lot of people do hit rock bottom
and then go for help, and that's really unfortunate.
But when people start to see the negative consequences
of whatever it is that they're struggling with,
that's an opportunity for them to start to lean in
to leaning out of that behavior, let's say.
And so they don't have to hit rock bottom
before they can start moving away from it.
So myth or fact?
Prescription pills are safer than street drugs
because a doctor made them.
Well, that's a myth in one sense
because people's brains don't know the difference
between whether their opioid receptor,
for example, is occupied or not.
But the fact is that it's really hard to know
what you're actually getting on the street.
And so in one sense, somebody could say
this is a medication that's made by a pharmaceutical company
or something, and you don't know that that's actually true.
And you can also get addicted
by something you're prescribed, right?
Oh, absolutely.
So the medications can be just as addictive
and are just as addictive as any street drug
depending on what receptor they're hitting
and how they're hitting it.
Myth or fact, the brain can never fully recover
from long-term drug use.
Myth.
Brain can absolutely recover.
At any point?
Well, when at any point is an interesting,
yes, I think I would say it can take some time
for the brain to recover.
And it often can feel like somebody
is not fully recovered for their entire life, so to speak.
But from a brain perspective,
I think you can find a place where the brain,
you know, it's indistinguishable.
One brain from another
where somebody has had an addiction in the past
versus somebody that hasn't.
Myth or fact, addiction is 100% genetic.
Yeah, certainly there are some genetic components
that can contribute to addiction,
but there's a whole lot of learned elements
in that, you know, that's on top of the genetics.
We'll wrap up our lightning round with one last question.
Sugar addiction is exactly the same as cocaine addiction.
There's a lot of stuff on the internet about that.
I would say sugar certainly fires off
the same type of dopamine cascade
that can happen in the brain as cocaine,
which is why, you know, there have been studies in rats
and other non-human animals showing
that you can get the same reward pathway firing
with cocaine and sugar.
So in that sense, they're the same.
But in another sense, you know,
cocaine specifically is blocking a dopamine transporter,
whereas sugar is firing,
hitting the dopamine pathway slightly differently.
So they hit the same pathways,
but they're not exactly the same.
And will have really different impacts.
They certainly can.
So I want to make sure that our viewers
are not intimidated by the fact
we're using words like neuroscience of addiction
because I know that we have chosen you specifically
because you're very good at breaking things down.
And I need to say I have a BA, not a BS,
so I will be asking questions until I understand it
in the hopes that viewers
and listeners will also understand.
Great.
And I'll try not to give you too many BS answers.
Thank you.
I appreciate that.
So I wanted to start,
before we get into the internet questions,
talking about some of your research
because when I was researching you,
I found this habit loop and I was like,
oh, that would be so helpful to know.
So tell me what the habit loop is
and how understanding it could help us.
And habit loop is really something that we all have.
It's evolutionarily conserved,
meaning that we share the same type of learning
all the way back to the sea slug,
which is a big sea slug.
You know, you imagine a slug that's in the ocean
and it only has 20,000 neurons
and those neuron pathways,
those brain cell pathways have been mapped
showing that sea slugs learn in a similar way to humans.
And how that works is through a process
called positive and negative reinforcement.
And so let's take our ancient ancestors as an example.
When they had to forage for food,
you know, they didn't have refrigerators.
So they had to go foraging on the savanna in the woods.
When they found food,
their brains would light up and say,
oh, wait a minute, you know, here's the food.
They would eat the food
and that would actually send this dopamine signal
to their brain that said,
remember what you ate and where you found it.
So a habit loop is made up of three elements,
a trigger, a behavior and a result.
So the trigger would be seeing the food,
the behavior would be eating the food
and then the result would be this dopamine surge
that says, ooh, that was good, remember where that is.
So that's positive reinforcement.
Negative reinforcement's very similar.
Instead of kind of finding something pleasant
and learning to do that again,
we find something that's unpleasant
and learn to avoid it in the future.
So our ancient ancestors,
if they're out foraging for food
and they get chased by a bear or a wolf
or a saber-toothed tiger, right,
the trigger is they see the saber-toothed tiger,
the behavior is they run away
and the results or the reward
from a neuroscience perspective
is that they don't become lunch.
And so that rewarding property feeds back
and says, hey, here's a new habit loop.
Avoid that place in the savanna.
You know, trigger, see the lion behavior run away
and the result is you live
to avoid that part of the savanna in the future.
One of the things I read that you said
is our brains do not distinguish
between good and bad habits.
They simply learn what leads to a reward.
Yes, to our brains, it's all about survival.
So a habit is something
that helps our brains survive in everyday life.
So for example, most of the habits
that we form are actually extremely helpful.
We don't even pay attention to them.
So imagine all of the habits
that we all have every day
that we act out as soon as we wake up.
So we swing our legs over the bed
and stand up and start walking.
Well, that's something that we've learned to do.
We learned to walk at a very young age.
We put on our clothes.
That's something we learn to do.
Maybe we talk to somebody.
We learn to do that.
We make coffee.
We put food in our mouth.
We learn to do that.
Remember, you know, when we're all babies,
the food kind of landed in the direction of our mouth
and then eventually we learn to get it in our mouth.
All of those are extremely helpful habits.
So our brains learn those as survival mechanisms.
Okay, this is good.
Do it again.
So it's not necessarily good and bad
from a survival standpoint,
but some of these habits can seem helpful at the time,
but then either become not so helpful
or get tapped into in terms of this addiction mechanism
where it's a little too good to be true because it is.
And those are the habits that are formed
that aren't actually helpful for us,
but we're compelled to do despite trying not to do them.
So habit would be the big umbrella word
and an addiction would be under it.
It's one of the habits we can have
because we're also talking about you've used anxiety.
We talked a lot about that worrying can be habitual.
Yes.
So I think of these along a spectrum.
So there are extremely helpful habits like walking,
tying our shoes, all those things.
And then along the spectrum are the ones
that we might do that aren't so great,
but they're not terrible.
And then at the far end of the spectrum is addiction.
So the definition of addiction I learned in residency
was continued use despite adverse consequences, right?
And so there's a habit that we might be fully aware of,
but we really feel compelled to do
and don't feel like we can stop.
Contrary to that,
most other habits are things that we do automatically.
That's kind of the definition of a habit
is an automatic behavior.
So is the habitual nature of an addiction
the reason willpower doesn't work to stop it?
I'd like to say simply,
yes, but it's a little more complex than that.
And in the sense that we learn habits
because they're rewarding, right?
That dopamine surge that says do this thing again.
Willpower, I'll just put this bluntly,
willpower is more a myth than muscle.
And what I mean by that is willpower
is probably a story that we tell ourselves
that we either have or we don't have
or we had and we don't have later or something like that.
But from a neuroscience perspective,
when we look at how habits are formed
and how we break bad habits,
it has nothing to do with willpower.
I'll just say my clinic,
my outpatient clinic would look a lot different
if willpower was actually a thing.
Patient would come in, I want to quit smoking.
Okay, stop it.
One visit and they're cured.
That's not how it works.
So let's dive into your three gears of habit change
so we can talk about how habits can be changed
and then we'll again get to the internet questions.
I just found this also interesting.
You said that there are three
and that they have to happen in order.
The first being awareness.
Yes, so the first step
or that we call these gears
in our Mindshift Recovery Program,
the idea is that you've got to become aware of the behavior.
And so from a full perspective,
you can map out what the trigger is,
what the behavior is, and what the result is.
But really to simplify it,
it's zooming in on what the behavior is.
The reason for that is there could be a thousand things
that trigger the behavior.
And more importantly,
the triggers don't actually reinforce the behavior,
meaning that they just set the wheel in motion,
but they don't keep it going
and they don't make it stronger or weaker.
So I've had plenty of patients who have come to me
and said, you know, I've spent decades in therapy
trying to figure out why I'm anxious
or why I have this addiction.
And they're a little startled when I say, you know what?
The why may not matter as much as you think.
And the reason it doesn't matter is that,
well, I shouldn't say it doesn't matter.
So certainly somebody's history
and their lived experience is very important.
But when we talk about changing a habit,
that why isn't what drives it and keeps it going.
It just sets the loop in motion.
So that first step is really recognizing
what the behavior is.
You know, am I picking up my phone?
Am I picking up a cigarette?
Am I picking up a bottle?
You know, am I picking up a joint?
Whatever it is,
that's the behavior that we can zoom in on the first,
as part of the first step.
And that's important because otherwise
we might do it automatically.
I've had a lot of patients who say, you know,
they just kind of wake up
with a half-smoked cigarette in their fingers
and they don't remember lighting it
or smoking the first half of it.
That's autopilot.
The why is the beginning.
The why, there was a reason at some point
in that, as you say, gets the ball rolling.
Yes.
Then at a certain point, it's just automatic.
Yes.
Let's use smoking as an example.
Most of my patients
and the folks in our clinical studies
started smoking around the age of 12 or 13.
So that happens typically not because somebody says,
hey, you know, smoking is good for you
and they'd cigarettes taste great,
you know, and two great things go great together.
No, it's typically we see cool kids at school.
We want to fit in.
We want to rebel whatever it is
and that's actually more rewarding
than all of these negative signals.
We're getting from a cigarette
because nicotine is pretty toxic.
The first time somebody smokes,
they feel nauseated
because that's the nicotine telling them.
Hey, you're putting toxin in your body.
Are you sure you want to do this?
Yeah, and I remember coughing and all of it.
All of it.
Yes, not great,
but it's something that we overcome
because there's something that's more rewarding
and that why whenever it got set up,
however, it got set up in the moment
where it's habitual,
it doesn't matter that much
because we're just repeating the habitual behavior
at this point.
And in your example of smoking in high school
or whatever age you are
and wherever schooling you are at 12 or 13,
you're not trying to be a cool kid anymore,
you know, when you're 50 and still smoking.
No, it's pretty anti-cool.
Yeah, that why is long gone.
So you say that awareness though
is just the first step and not enough
so I can know I shouldn't,
you know, shouldn't drink so much.
I shouldn't, a million things,
a million bad habits,
but that won't stop me from doing it.
No.
It might shame me.
Right, it might
and it might get us into some shaming habits
where we beat ourselves up,
you know, you've probably heard the joke,
we should all over ourselves, right?
You know, we could only,
I should have done this,
I shouldn't have done that.
Well, all of that just pulls energy away
from actually changing a habit.
So once we're aware of whatever the behavior is
and we can become aware of it,
you know, many times a day,
so if we smoke a pack of cigarettes a day,
which could be as many as 20 times a day,
the next step is really dialing in to our brain
and asking a simple question,
which is what am I getting from this?
And this is related,
so some people may be familiar
with motivational interviewing.
When I learned this in residency,
the basic, it boils down to the question,
you know, a patient comes in,
wants to quit smoking.
I say, well, why don't you smoke more?
And they look at me like,
my doc just asked me why I don't smoke.
Well, the idea is to really see
all of the results of the behavior.
So if somebody, you know,
I asked somebody, why don't they smoke more?
They might answer, well,
I get this cough in the morning.
I can't taste food very well.
I have, you know, bad breath.
I know, you know, it's not good for me.
I could get cancer, emphysema.
It makes my skin, all these things that are negative,
but those are all up in their head, right?
But they can start to surface those
in their embodied experience, right?
So it's like, oh, why don't I smoke more?
Well, it's expensive and all these things come up
and they can start to feel
into those direct results of smoking,
which they largely ignore
when they're smoking automatically.
So this taps into a part of the brain,
not that it's important,
but I'll just mention it.
It's called the orbitofrontal cortex.
It's kind of in the front part of our brain.
And that actually determines and stores
how rewarding a behavior is.
And it's important for our everyday survival
because it helps us make decisions very quickly.
So we don't have to try everything every day,
you know, imagine-
Should I touch the stove?
Right, right.
Oh, I learned that that's not such a good idea.
Or do I like this food more than this food, right?
And so we set up these reward hierarchies.
And I think of this with habit formation as set and forget.
So we set the reward value of something
and then we forget about the details.
The reward value for smoking gets set up
at the age of 12 or 13
when somebody starts smoking at that age.
And then they're just smoking habitually.
And in fact, when they become addicted to the nicotine,
they're smoking to avoid the withdrawal symptoms,
you know, where every two hours as that nicotine,
as those nicotine levels get low in the bloodstream,
their body's saying,
hey, I need more nicotine, get it in here.
And that unpleasant feeling
that triggers the behavior to smoke
and that reinforces the loop.
So here we can start with the second step
is really asking, what am I getting from this?
And so it's not thinking about how bad cigarettes are for us
or whatever the substance or the behavior is.
It's really feeling into the direct experience
in the moment.
Like, so with my patients, I have them go ahead and smoke
and they look at me like I'm crazy.
Like my doc told me to smoke.
Well, I say, go ahead and pay attention as you smoke
because you can't stop right now anyway.
So I'm not telling you something
that you're not already going to do,
but you can pay attention when you smoke.
And I still remember somebody said, you know,
as she was really paying attention as she was smoking,
she says, smells like stinky cheese
and tastes like chemicals, yuck.
And so where's the reward in that, right?
And what she was highlighting for herself
in her own direct experience
was what she was actually getting in the moment
from smoking cigarettes.
And the short of that was she wasn't getting much.
In fact, it wasn't pleasant at all.
And for a lot of people,
that becomes the basis for a big shift
where they can start to really feel into this
and see what they're actually feeling
and getting in that moment.
So with smoking in particular,
I have patients pay attention as they puff,
as they take that drag.
What does it feel like going into their mouth?
What's it feel like going into their lungs?
What's it smell like coming out as they breathe out
or breathe out of their mouth or their nose?
There's a lot of negative stuff that comes from that,
just from that one puff
that they can start to dial into
and see how unrewarding it is.
This is where people develop disenchantment.
And I think of this as a Santa Claus moment, right?
So imagine-
Young listeners tune out.
Right, right.
So for all of us that believed in Santa Claus at a young age
and then went to the mall
and pulled on Santa Claus's beard
and realized it was just some old dude
paid for our parents to figure out
what we wanted for Christmas,
for those of us that had the privilege of getting presents,
we start to see, oh, this isn't real.
And so the myth that the smoke-filled haze
of the draw of a cigarette is not there anymore.
And you can't unsee that once you've seen that.
You can't untaste or unfeel or unsmell that
once you've had that experience.
So this is how people develop disenchantment.
And it really goes right back to this
orbitofrontal cortex in the brain
where it's updating that reward value.
And the only thing that's needed for updating is awareness.
And you're saying feel.
You use the verb feel through that hole.
It's not cognitive.
It's like you're trying to get us into our-
research shows that when we're in our bodies
and we smell it and we taste it
and we see how it makes us feel,
that's the distinction?
Yes, I'm glad you bring that up
because that's a critical distinction.
If our cognitive abilities were really strong,
we could just think our way out of all these things.
This is where willpower would work.
And so this highlights how much of a myth it is.
If I could just tell myself to stop smoking
or doing whatever, I would just stop doing it.
So really, reward value is driven
through an embodied experience.
What does it feel like?
What's it taste like?
What's it smell like?
That's our-
I think of it as a bottom-up approach
where our body is telling us everything
that we need to know, which is,
wow, this isn't as great as I thought.
So that awareness and then feeling it
actually leads to a change?
If I suddenly am smoking
and I remember looking at the filter
and being like, oh wow, it's not catching at all
and this is getting in me.
That probably didn't make me stop.
I know it did, but it's-
that will actually lead to a change?
Would you- are you more excited to smoke now
than you were before?
No, absolutely not.
Yeah.
So we'll get to some of the pieces,
whether your experience or others.
But the piece here is,
when people really get the direct experience
of the lack of reward from the behavior,
that's where they develop the disenchantment
and it's much easier to stop doing the thing
because they're not as excited to do it.
It's not as rewarding.
Now, I should add one piece here.
We're talking about cigarettes
where they tend not to intoxicate people, right?
They can be a stimulant,
but they don't cloud people's awareness.
So with intoxicants,
when somebody is literally intoxicated,
so maybe they drank too much alcohol
and they can't see straight, so to speak,
or they're high on some other substance,
it's hard to pay attention
and it's hard to see what the results are.
So in this case,
what I have my patients do is pay attention afterwards,
right, where they see all the results of that behavior
and they can also compare this
and we'll talk about this with step three,
but they compare what it's like to having done the thing
versus simply not having done the thing.
So use the example, please, of drinking
and say you have a substance use disorder with alcohol
and you had a real bad night
and the next day, next days,
I don't know, when you say look back on it and see,
what would that be like?
Well, as soon as they sober up is the best time to do it.
So as close to the behavior as possible
helps us really limit any interference
when it comes to feedback.
So let's say that we drink and we black out or something
and then we wake up the next morning
and we start to piece together all the stuff
that didn't go so well the night before.
Those are the direct results of drinking
and we can see very clearly,
okay, I crashed my car, I ruined this relationship,
oh wow, I can't believe I did that.
There are a lot of things that can happen
when we black out, for example,
but we don't even need to do that.
It could just be that somebody
did something very embarrassing when they were intoxicated.
It could be that they got in a fight
or it could be all these negative things.
Called an ex, that's a big one.
Yes, called an ex and oh, I can't believe,
what did I say, and now they're furious or whatever.
And so all these things can help point to us
what the actual results are of doing the behavior.
And so we can compare those
to what it was actually like to be intoxicated.
Now, the irony is when somebody's intoxicated,
they're only aware for a little while
until they're not very aware anymore.
So somebody can say, yeah, that was great.
Well, what was so great about it
when you can't even remember what that was?
So certainly, I don't wanna cover over the effects
that a lot of people say, well,
have a drink and I feel much more relaxed,
I feel less anxious, I feel these things.
And I've certainly had plenty of patients like that.
This is not to say that's not true
because for a lot of people, it is true, right?
But what they find is,
it's not as true as they hoped it to be.
So for example, I've had a lot of patients report
that like half a drink gets them the pleasant aspect
and anything beyond that's not so good
where they're like, they have that next half
and then they feel compelled to drink the next one
and then the next one and then the next one
and then it's game over from there.
Whereas that half drink that got them calm,
they can start to ask, well, is there some other way
that I can actually feel calm as compared to this
that doesn't have all of these negative consequences
that come with it?
So that's where we can start to add up
and not in an intellectual way, but an embodied way.
Like, well, how good is this really
versus how bad is this really?
And when all the bad stuff adds up
to much more than the good stuff,
that's where people become disenchanted.
So when, and addiction, I do not study it,
but I have interviewed a number of people
and they seem quite aware.
You know, it's, I've lost, I've lost everything.
You know, you hear that, I lost my job,
I crashed my car, I lost my family, lost my kids
and yet they continue to drink.
So why would that be?
Is it not doing that assessment,
not being capable of doing it?
It's a good question.
So here, and I don't want to generalize too much,
but here I think there's a differentiation
between all these negative things
and then knowing how to work with the craving.
Okay.
So we can have all these negative things happen
and then we have this really strong craving
and we don't know how to deal with it.
So we just succumb to it.
That's with full acknowledgement,
like, yes, last time all this bad stuff happened
or the last 20 times or the last 200 times, right?
They're like, and this feels so bad right now,
I need to do something about it.
So our brains are actually really focused
on the present moment experience.
And when our present moment experience is,
this is really bad, make it go away.
And the only thing that they know to make it go away
is to drink or smoke or whatever,
then they're going to go to that thing.
So when we start to see what all the negative results are,
then we can start to find something that's better.
And this is where the third step comes in.
I call it finding the bigger, better offer.
For some people, finding the bigger, better offer
might be simply not doing the thing.
I've had plenty of patients who,
when they've had a bad night of drinking,
they've been, I'm thinking of one who embarrassed herself
in front of her teenage kids yet again,
and she had anxiety.
And so she'd wake up feeling anxious
and feeling even more anxious after the hangover
and then see all the negative results from the night before
and feel even worse, right?
So here, when she could start stringing together
nights of sobriety, she could compare the two,
where it's like, oh, she woke up with a clear head.
Her kids would look her in the eyes
as compared to being embarrassed.
She wasn't as anxious.
She didn't have a hangover,
all these beneficial qualities of that.
And part of what helped her do that
was learning how to be with the cravings themselves.
So cravings feel pretty unpleasant.
And if somebody hasn't learned the tools
to work with the cravings,
it's going to be really hard for them
to just white-knuckle it and try to not do the thing.
This is why so many people relapse.
They're like, swear whatever the thing is off
and then they get to the situation and they're like,
well, this is so bad and I don't know what to do with it
and I can't deal with this unpleasant feeling.
So they just go back to the thing.
Is this where treatment comes in?
Treatment can come in and support them that way.
And I've certainly seen a lot of patients
benefit from treatment there.
So getting some type of treatment can be really helpful.
And as part of this,
really learning distress tolerance skills
I think is critical.
For example, I had a patient,
I was working at the VA hospital
and in my outpatient clinic,
I had a patient whose craving was so strong.
He said he was trying to quit smoking,
comes into my office and he goes,
doc, I feel like my head's going to explode
if I don't smoke.
So that's how strong these cravings can be.
So I taught him a very simple practice
to actually be with those cravings.
And the way we worked with it,
I just kind of did it in real time in the moment.
I wasn't like, oh, let's pull out a book
and learn how to work with this.
So I just went up to my whiteboard
and I started mapping out with him in real time
what his experience was.
So I said, describe what that head exploding feel like.
So he was describing tightness, tension, burning,
heat, restlessness, all these things.
And at the same time,
I was asking him to describe how intense they were.
It's getting more and more and more and more intense.
And then eventually that craving peaked
and started to go down.
And he had this big aha look in his eye.
And I said, what just happened?
He said, I always smoke before,
because the extrapolation is dot, dot, dot,
my head's going to explode.
So he'd always smoke a cigarette
because he didn't want his head to explode.
Who wants an exploded head?
Yeah, I don't think anybody wants that.
So here he realized that just by learning
to be with his experience,
that craving would come and go on its own.
So we trained him to be with those feelings of craving
and those bodily sensations and that they come and go.
And he learned that the only thing he needed to do
was to be with his experience.
And that might seem pretty scary to a lot of people.
I've had patients come in and say,
Doc, I feel like this craving's lasted forever.
And I say, well, so has it been there your whole life?
And they're like, well, not really.
So I'll even have people go home and set a timer
the next time they have a craving,
and get really curious,
like what's this craving feel like in my experience?
Are you ready?
What do you think the longest craving has been
over the last decade of me having patients do this?
Just take a wild guess.
For what?
Are we talking smoking?
It doesn't even matter.
Or is it anything?
Ooh, an hour.
Much shorter.
20 minutes.
Shorter.
10 minutes.
13 minutes.
Wow.
Yeah.
So it's not that long.
Now that 13 minutes might not feel very pleasant
for 13 minutes,
but it's extremely informative.
It helps people see, oh, 13 minutes, you know?
And distract myself.
Yeah.
Or I can learn to lean in.
Even more important.
Eye was off, yeah.
Yes, yeah.
So we can certainly learn to distract ourselves,
but distractions don't always work.
Yeah.
And I've seen that.
I've seen distractions fail many, many more times
than they've succeeded.
Okay.
So when it's something like anxiety and worry,
and that cycle starts,
works the same for a mental health versus a substance?
For a number of mental health issues, yes.
So the most important thing
that I never learned in medical school
was that anxiety could work the same way.
And the way I learned this
was actually through my own struggles.
So, well, several of them.
One is I've had plenty of anxiety through my life,
and I've written about that in my books.
So I had pretty strong anxiety in college
to the point where I got irritable bowel syndrome.
Like that was my body saying,
hey, wake up, you're pretty anxious.
And I was like, oh, me?
Anxious?
And it's like, wake up.
Yes, you.
The other piece was
I started to get panic attacks in residency.
You know, a great formula for panic attacks
is like sleep deprivation, being put in charge,
you know, being responsible for people in the hospital,
all this stuff.
Like, it's pretty stressful.
So I know a little bit personally about anxiety,
but when I started working in my clinic,
in my outpatient clinic when I finished residency,
even prescribing the best medications for anxiety,
only about one in five people
would show a significant reduction in symptoms.
There's a fancy term for this
called the number needed to treat,
which just means how many people
you need to give a medication to
or a treatment to before one person benefits.
And so that number needed to treat
for the best medications is 5.2,
meaning you have to treat more than five people
before one person benefits.
So I basically play the medication lottery
when prescribing a medication for anxiety.
I don't know which one person's
gonna be that lucky individual,
and I don't know what to do with the other four.
So this is where I started looking back
and seeing, you know, starting asking this question,
what can we do about this?
And fortunately, we'd been developing programs
for habits for a couple of years at that point.
So we had done a study
with some of our mindfulness training programs,
and we had found that we could get five times
the quit rates of gold standard treatment
for smoking cessation, right?
People quit five times more using mindfulness training
than cognitive therapy.
And you can see how all of that lines up
with those three steps that I talked about,
because it's really about being aware of the habit,
seeing what you get from it, right?
Seeing how cigarettes smell like stinky cheese
and taste like cigarettes, right?
That type of thing.
But then also learning the skills
to lean into the cravings themselves.
So we'd gotten five times the quit rates
of gold standard treatment for smoking.
We'd done other programs for eating,
helping people overcome whether it was binge eating
or junk food or even overeating.
We'd gotten a 40% reduction in craving-related eating.
And in that program, people were saying,
hey, anxiety is driving me to stress eat.
So if you take the habit loop there,
the feeling of anxiety is not very good.
Somebody can distract themselves by eating some food.
If you eat some engineered type of food,
it can be even more addictive where it says eat,
the potato chip slogan is what?
Bet you can't eat just one.
Yeah, we're designed so you can't.
Yeah, exactly, exactly.
So you can see how people could get locked
into a habit of stress eating,
but it just drives more eating.
So when my patients were saying,
hey, can you develop a program for anxiety?
At first I was thinking, I don't know what to do.
I just prescribe medications.
But as a habit change researcher,
I went, it put a bug in my ear.
And so I went back and looked at the literature
and lo and behold, there was a guy, Thomas Borkovec,
a psychologist who suggested back in the 1980s
that anxiety could be driven through negative reinforcement.
That's that habit loop that we talked about earlier
where something unpleasant's there,
we do something to make it go away.
And then we feel a little bit better.
Now that got buried in the promise of Prozac.
You know, when everybody thought, oh, great,
we're gonna have these SSRIs,
these selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor
classes of medications.
So we're all cured.
Unfortunately, that didn't turn out to be the case.
And in some studies, the SSRIs are no better than placebo.
For the lucky few, they can be very helpful,
but for the majority of people,
unfortunately, they're not the silver bullet.
So here, what I think of is like,
everybody can learn how to work with their brain.
So what Borkovec suggested was that the feeling of anxiety
could drive the mental behavior of worrying.
So often we think of behaviors as things that you can see,
right, you stress eat, you smoke a cigarette,
you drink a drink of alcohol.
But in fact, there's plenty of behavior going on
in our minds all the time.
And one of those for people who are anxious is worrying.
That's actually one of the main behaviors
that occupies a lot of their day.
This is where people with generalized anxiety disorder,
they spend a lot of their energy, a lot of the day worrying.
And we think it's helping.
We do, yeah.
So why might that be the case?
Well, it can distract us from the feeling of anxiety.
So it feels a little bit better.
So it's rewarding in that way.
It can also make us feel like we're in control.
It gives us this illusion of control.
And as my patients put it,
it feels better than doing nothing.
Well, until you pay attention
to what you're actually getting from it.
So what are you actually getting from worrying?
Oh, it's feeding back and making them more anxious.
So that's a critical piece where patients can really,
and people can really lean into this
and ask that second step question,
what am I getting from worrying?
Is it keeping my family member safe?
Is it solving that problem?
Is it, it's not planning.
You can plan something a couple of times,
but when you've planted 17 times, you're just worrying.
This hour?
Yes.
We gotta get to the internet questions,
but this is fascinating to me.
So if I am anxious, which I can be,
if I am thinking of picking up a cigarette
and I don't smoke anymore, but I did,
if I wait 13 minutes or 15 minutes,
if I actually set a timer and say,
I'm just gonna sit here and maybe do some deep breathing,
something that would be present, not distracting myself,
might I wait it out?
Might it be different at the end of that?
Will it be?
I shouldn't say might, it's your research.
Well, what we've found is that your cravings
tend to go away within 13 minutes,
and we can actually make this an active process
so it's not white knuckling,
like looking at the watch, waiting it out.
So here, I love this saying,
you probably are familiar with it.
The only way out is through.
Yeah, I love that.
The only way out is through.
So often, let's take worrying, for example,
or a craving.
The craving comes up, anxiety comes up,
and we have this habitual reaction of oh no, right?
So we try to fight the craving, we get stuck in worrying.
Not so good, it just feeds the process.
So instead, what we can train people to do is get curious
and then flip that oh no to oh.
Oh is directed on the what, not the why.
Not why am I having this craving,
or why am I worrying, or why am I anxious,
but what does this actually feel like in my body?
So going back to the head exploding patient
that I talked about earlier,
we can get really curious
about what those embodied sensations are.
And as we get curious,
we start to see that those sensations aren't as bad
as we thought they might be
because we've been running away from them.
We don't know what they actually feel like.
So we turn and run toward them,
and we get really curious about them.
And here, I love this quote from James Stevens
who was an Irish author and a poet,
where he said,
curiosity will conquer fear even more than bravery will.
Curiosity will conquer fear even more than bravery will.
And so the idea is we can be afraid
of our embodied sensations,
or we can get curious about them.
And when we get curious, it empowers us.
It gives us the power back where we can see,
oh, these are sensations.
Oh, I can be with these sensations.
And what that does
is help us develop distress tolerance, right?
We can be with things that are distressing,
and the being is the active process of doing,
meaning we don't have to do anything
but learn to be with our experience.
And how do we learn to do that?
Through curiosity.
So we train that curiosity muscle
until it becomes the new habit.
Does it matter what you do in those 13 minutes?
I mean, in terms of not running from it,
not distracting yourself?
Well, here, the critical piece is to run toward it.
So we get-
What does that mean?
Oh yeah, so we get into our body.
Like, what does this craving feel like?
Where is the worry in my body?
Is it on the right side or the left side?
Yeah, all of it.
Yeah, is it on the right?
Is it in the front?
Is it in the back?
Is it a tightness?
Is it heat?
And not even looking for something in particular,
but just getting really curious
about what we're actually experiencing.
And that experience is gonna be different moment
to moment, so we can get really nuanced as we get curious.
And that very active process helps us not grit our teeth
or try to brace ourselves.
You know, that saying, what we resist persists.
So instead of resisting our experience,
which we often habitually do,
we actually lean into it.
We open to it and we say, bring it on.
Okay, what does this feel like?
So we're really noticing whatever our body is telling us
in that moment.
As that craving comes up and kind of washes through us.
Thomas, now we'll switch to the internet questions
like we were supposed to.
But when I read that research, I was like,
oh, we can all use that.
Whether we have a substance user addiction
or a mental health condition or not.
The number one question on the internet,
and this is both Google and YouTube related to this topic,
is addiction really a brain disease or is it a choice?
It's a brain disease.
Yeah, absolutely.
So often people who believe that myth of willpower
talk about addiction as a choice
because they're kind of seeing it through that lens of,
oh, there's something broken in you or wrong with you
or something like that.
When in reality, you can think of it as a brain disease
and you can also just think of it as a brain mechanism
that our brain has that's there to help us survive.
And it kind of got off track a little bit.
So I don't even like to think of it as a disease
because then it suggests that there's something,
we're diseased, there's something wrong with us.
When in reality, it's kind of these habit formation systems
in our brain that are extremely helpful
and they kind of got co-opted a little bit.
And so we just kind of can tweak them back into place.
That description makes it sound like it can be overcome,
managed, whatever word would be next,
being broken and having a disease.
Same as using the term mental illness, right?
Can feel so like you're squished under its thumb.
Yes, yes, and we need much less of that.
Yeah, absolutely, because it makes us freeze.
Yeah, makes us feel subhuman even sometimes.
The next question from the internet
is using the word disease again, so I'm gonna go with it.
If addictions are a disease,
does that mean the individual has no responsibility
for their actions?
Well, we can get into philosophical debates
about willpower and free will and all of that,
but I would say the more awareness we have,
the more ability we have to work with our brains.
And so here, when we can learn that awareness
is not only our friend, this curiosity is our superpower,
it puts us back in the driver's seat.
The idea of having some control
when it feels like we have none is very helpful.
Absolutely.
Is it realistic?
I've seen this in my studies, I've seen this in my clinic.
It's not gonna work 100% every time for every person,
but on average, we see a lot of results
that are good in that way.
And so it's just learning to lean into
and build that superpower of curiosity.
I think of this as developing evidence-based faith, right?
So in medicine, we talk about evidence-based medicine.
Is there a randomized controlled trial
showing these fancy terms, right?
Showing like, is this actually helpful?
And those trials can be helpful to separate out
what actually works versus what might just be placebo
or something like that.
And so here, every time we're able to run toward a craving
and lean into it and ride it out,
we've developed a data point showing,
oh, I can actually learn to be with a craving
and my head won't explode.
And then the next time we do it,
we develop another data point
and we get all of this evidence from our own experience
that actually helps give us the faith that we can do this.
Now, it's not to say
that we'll never have a craving ever again.
There are plenty of people
that have had cravings pop up 25 years later
where they're like, where'd that come from, right?
Those things can just lie dormant and it's not a problem.
It's just kind of like, oh, there it is.
Well, I had another craving
because they know how to work with it.
They've got the tools.
They've developed this mental muscle
to be able to lean into the craving every time it comes up.
One marker that I look for
is when people can kind of shift
from being afraid of cravings to kind of saying,
bring it on because they've developed
all that evidence base where they know
no matter how strong the craving is,
they can actually lean into it.
And in fact, every time a craving comes up,
it makes them stronger.
Wow.
Do you use it yourself?
Oh, yes, absolutely.
This is like the most important thing I ever learned.
All sorts of cravings, yes.
I wrote a whole book called The Craving Mind.
A lot of it based on my own experience.
Yeah, there you go.
Yours is a craving mind as well.
That's good to know.
Why do only some people become addicted
to certain substances or behaviors?
That's a great question.
I don't really know the answer to that.
I don't think anybody has a great answer.
Certainly there are genetic components
that can predispose us to these.
Certainly there can be lived experience elements
where somebody's had childhood trauma.
Adverse experiences in childhood
can certainly predict the likelihood
that somebody's going to become addicted
to a substance or a behavior.
But there are a lot of different things that can add up.
And you can look at two people
that have had the exact same situations
where one person becomes addicted and another doesn't.
So the honest truth is we don't have a great handle
and can't predict who's gonna become addicted
and who's not.
But we certainly have things that can predispose people,
that can make them more vulnerable to addiction.
So for example, adverse childhood events
are one of the big ones.
Is there more of an influence from genetics than environment
or is even that unknown?
I would say it's largely unknown.
If I had to guess,
I would probably say it's more environmental than genetic.
Which is good news
because we don't have control over our genes.
Yeah.
Okay, the third most asked question on the internet,
and this is from TikTok and YouTube.
Why can't I stop an addictive behavior
even though I really want to?
Because you don't know how your brain works.
And I don't say that like flippantly,
like I know how your brain works and you don't.
It's just that people have probably been watching
too many TikToks or YouTube videos
from influencers who are trying to garner a bunch of hits,
but are not exactly trained in neuroscience
and are not trained medical professionals.
I would even say
there are a lot of trained medical professionals
that don't have the neuroscience background
that helps them really get addiction at its core.
I didn't learn this stuff in medical school.
That's why I had to do the research in my lab
to figure out what are the best ways to do this.
And so what I'd like to see
is that as the medical education develops
and grows and matures, especially with addiction,
that people are bringing in
some of these evidence-based findings,
whether it's from the clinical side
or even from the neuroscience side,
and actually training people to do that.
And then hopefully the TikTok influencers
can learn to read a neuroscience paper
and really dissect the pieces
where they can get at the core of like,
oh, this is what reinforcement learning does.
Oh, here's how Rescorla and Wagner,
these two researchers that came up with the formula
really understood it.
And then they can go out and influence people
based on accurate information
as compared to something that sounds good.
It's literally why we're doing this podcast,
the way we're doing it,
because it's so hard when you're in a bad place,
whether, again, that's an addiction
or a mental health condition,
and you go online to get information,
you don't know who you're getting it from
and where they got it,
including maybe made it up
because it would be great clickbait, right?
So-
I am a trained psychiatrist and a neuroscientist
for the record.
I appreciate that.
And I've actually done the research
and I've actually treated the patients.
Yeah, great.
That's why we wanted you here.
Does this explain why people in addiction
often lie or steal,
or is that just survival brain taking over?
I would say that's more survival brain taking over.
It's amazing what the brain will do in survival mode.
That is not only embarrassing,
but it's heart-wrenching
when people look back on experience
and they just feel so guilty for what they've done.
And I would say,
that's your survival brain taking over.
Good luck fighting with that thing
because it thinks it's trying to help you survive.
It just doesn't know how to do it.
One more under that same heading.
Are there any practical tips that you can suggest
that you know work to help the logical brain
take over in a moment of crisis?
Here, I would say don't rely on the logical brain, right?
So the logical brain is the youngest
and weakest part of the brain
from an evolutionary perspective.
It's the first that goes offline.
I would say rely on the embodied mind.
And what I mean by that is really leaning back
into all the experience that people have had.
So they don't have to go and drink again
or use a substance again or gamble again
or go on a porn site again.
They can reflect back on all the things
that they got from the previous times that they've done it.
And I call this retrospectives
where they can do a retrospective
and look back on their previous behavior.
In fact, a future behavior,
the best way to predict future behavior
is based on past behavior.
So if we can reflect on past behavior
and really keep that in our working memory, right?
Really keep that in mind as we have that craving come up,
like, oh, I have this craving to do this thing.
What did I get from this last time?
Well, I got all this negative stuff.
Am I as excited to do it now?
No, it helps dampen that enthusiasm,
so to speak, for our brain.
And then we can bring in these tools
to help us write out the craving.
And that one-two is a really useful one-two punch
to help work with those cravings.
And where would someone learn them?
Because if we're not, we go to our doctor and they say,
you just have to quit or here's a pill or whatever it is.
Where would the average person who is listening
or watching say, I want to learn that.
I want to stop or start whatever it is, you know, so badly.
Yeah.
Well, I wish this was in standard medical education,
but it's not.
So we formed a nonprofit called MindShift Recovery,
and there's actually a free app called MindShift Recovery
that people can download onto their phone
and it will teach them everything that they need to know.
They'll learn these three steps.
We call these three gears in the program.
And there are many courses for each of the addictions
that people might have, ranging from substances
to behaviors like gambling or porn
to even problematic phone use, you know,
like technology addiction.
And so we've put that resource out
because it's not widely available.
TikTok and YouTube.
What is a dopamine hit actually doing to my brain?
Well, dopamine is an interesting molecule.
It serves two main functions in our brain,
and both of those have to do with learning.
So the first hit means that we get a dopamine spritz
at a time when something important happens.
And the importance often is
when something surprising happens.
So go back to the image that we talked about earlier
with survival, right?
So if we're foraging for food on the Savannah,
our brain doesn't actually have the brain space
to remember every single plant that we walk by.
It's not actually that important.
What our brain needs to learn is where the food source is.
And so we find the food, remember that's the trigger.
We eat the food, there's that behavior,
and then that dopamine hits.
So dopamine literally fires in our nucleus accumbens
for what it's worth, but part of this reward system.
And it says, hey, remember this.
So there's a surprise.
Oh, wow, there's food here, right?
So there's a surprise that happens.
Also, when something dangerous happens that surprises us,
we almost get hit by a car.
Oh, maybe I should put my phone away
and look both ways before I cross the street
or whatever it was that we did
where we were in a dangerous situation.
So that dopamine hit first happens
when something surprising happens.
But when we go back and do the thing again,
that dopamine firing shifts to not,
because it's not surprising anymore,
we know the food's there.
So it shifts to anticipatory firing,
meaning that it says, hey, you're hungry.
Don't just sit here, go get that food.
You know where it is.
So dopamine is often described as this motivation molecule.
And so we're gonna get a dopamine hit
when we're motivated to do something.
So that could happen when we're hungry.
That could happen if we're addicted to cigarettes,
when our nicotine levels in our bloodstream are getting low,
where that dopamine starts firing and says,
do something, do something, do something,
go get that thing.
So that's what a dopamine hit is about
when we've already learned a behavior.
It's an anticipatory hit that says, go do the thing.
Remember, not about pleasure.
Dopamine shouldn't be about pleasure.
Because if we were pleasurable, we'd be like,
oh, I don't need to do it, I feel fine.
Dopamine's there to motivate us to get off the couch
or get out the door and do whatever and go do the thing.
So is dopamine fasting a real scientific solution
or an internet trend?
Internet trend for sure.
Because?
Well, there's no neuroscience behind it.
Is there any danger to it?
Let's ask what it is.
What is dopamine fasting that we hear about on the internet?
So my understanding of it,
and I haven't thoroughly scoured the internet,
but my understanding is that people on the internet say,
oh, dopamine, that's the problem, right?
That's the thing that gives you jonesing
to go do the thing.
So just fast from dopamine.
Just don't do it.
So I'm not exactly sure how that works.
So people say, oh, well,
I'm just not gonna go on the internet for a while
if that's where I get all my dopamine.
Okay, don't go on the internet for a while
and then they go back on the internet.
In fact, I think the internet's often pretty useful
to find information, right?
Not always useful if we're scrolling all the time,
but I check my email on the internet.
I get directions when I'm in a different city
on the internet.
There are a lot of places
where the internet can be helpful.
So it's kind of hard to avoid the things that cause dopamine.
The other thing is dopamine's not the problem.
It's just learning how to work with the dopamine
and not feed these loops.
So somebody does a dopamine fast
and they haven't actually dismantled
that habit loop at all.
They've just kind of put it on hold for a while,
which actually it's kind of like water behind a dam.
You build up that water pressure
and suddenly that dam bursts.
So there's a scientific term for this
called the abstinence violation effect.
So you dopamine fast,
you abstain from whatever it was
your dopamine hit was for a while.
And then your brain's like,
oh, I really want to, I really want to.
And then we do the thing.
My patients, they have a more formal term for this.
They call it the effits.
Okay.
So they're like, eff it, I can't handle this anymore.
And they just do it and they go nuts, right?
And so it's like somebody's fasted from chocolate
because that's their dopamine hit.
And suddenly they're indulging in chocolate.
You know, that's what's that movie Chocolates
where the mayor abstains from chocolate for all of Lent.
And then he tastes this little bit of chocolate
and then he goes nuts and goes on this chocolate rampage.
So I think that's probably a great picture
of how well dopamine fasting works,
which is it works until it doesn't.
We will stop this conversation here.
We will be back next week and we will go through six
because we only got to four of them now
of the top questions asked on the internet.
I greatly appreciate your perspective.
And I love that it is based in your lived experience,
your research, your clinical experience,
all the things that we need to learn from and believe in.
Thank you.
And we'll be back next week
and continue this discussion with Dr. Judson Brewer.