Fresh peaches or canned peaches—which ones make the best peach cobbler?
In this Peach Cobbler Two Ways comparison, I’m making one cobbler with fresh peaches and another with canned peaches. We’ll compare the flavor, filling, texture, crust, convenience, and final results so you can decide which version belongs on your table.
The fresh-peach cobbler delivers homemade seasonal flavor, while the canned-peach version gives you an easy option that can be made throughout the year. Watch until the end to see how they compare.
"Subscribe and hit the bell for new recipe alerts!"
Online YouTube Store - https: //shorturl.at/hmpX6
SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE ►►
PERKS for YOUTUBE MEMBERS: For just $5, become a Smokin’ and Grillin’ wit AB YouTube Member and unlock exclusive perks, including bi-weekly recipes, private live streams, member-only content, and a special credit in our videos.
Join Smokin’ and Grillin’ wit AB today and be part of the family. Thank you in advance for your support!
DISCLAIMER: This video and description contains affiliate links, which means that if you click on one of the product links, I’ll receive a small commission.
Okay, folks, look, we finna go ahead
and start talking about that.
This is like the great debate
when it comes to peach cobbler, right?
Are you gonna do fresh peaches?
Or check this out, you're gonna do canned peaches.
You know what?
I'm gonna tell you, I know the answer to this right now.
Some of you guys not gonna like it.
You know what I mean?
But we finna do what we do.
And if you ever want yours to turn out like this right here,
and as you can see, both of these are really the same, right?
The only difference is, do we use canned or that?
But I promise you, I put this out here.
I wanna know, can you guys tell me.
With that being said, let's get it.
All right, so look,
we gonna look at some of these ingredients.
I'm just finna show you, it's like really none.
And truly, the real difference is
whether we using fresh peaches
or we gonna use canned peaches, right?
Now, I know you guys are wanting to know,
like, dang, that's a lot of brown sugar.
That's because I cook with it and I bake it
and I make so many peach cobblers.
You know what I mean?
I could make this if I hadn't slept in a week.
You know what I mean?
With no sleep, do it in the dark.
So we got brown sugar right here.
I brought this one because this one,
the other one is actually full
and then, you know, counter space, right?
But I keep both, right?
We got white sugar, all-purpose flour.
And check it out, we got a little baking powder.
Oh, and I didn't say nothing, but as you guys saw,
I'm gonna make a real peach cobbler.
Not the peach pie that I make
that my family calls peach cobbler.
We gonna make the real thing, right?
We got our fresh peaches.
We got our canned peaches.
We got our, you know what this is for right here.
This is gonna be for our slurry
if we gonna do any thickening.
Whole milk, butter, vanilla extract.
I'm just getting ready to get rid of this.
You know what?
Because I have made my own.
If you guys wanna check it out,
it's on my website, smokingandgrillingwithab.com.
And that's W-I-T-A-B.com.
Listen, making your own vanilla extract
is the way to go, folks.
All right, then we got cinnamon, nutmeg.
You know what I mean?
And ah, I'm gonna talk to you guys about this right here.
This right here is what we gonna use.
Since we doing fresh peaches,
you're gonna have to have cold water, right?
So after I blanch, that's how we gonna do the blanching.
I'm gonna explain all that to you again
in just one second,
but I don't wanna over-talk any more than I am.
Oh, and by the way, this is what I want you to do.
Preheat your oven right now to 375 degrees.
All right, so look, this is what we gonna do.
If you're doing fresh peaches, right?
You wanna score this right here.
It's gonna help it peel.
So what we do is I got a sharp knife right here.
I just lay it on here.
You know what I mean?
I don't really put no pressure.
You gotta watch out.
Any pressure, it'll slip right in, right?
It doesn't hurt it no type of way,
but we really just supposed to score it.
You know what I mean?
So however you gotta do it.
You know, my knife is just extremely sharp, you know?
So there we go.
All right, so that's it.
Little X pattern, right?
Now, if you pay attention, look at my pot right here.
I got boiling water.
I'm gonna get these peaches in here
and I'm only using about eight.
That's about all you need.
You know what I mean?
It depends on how much filling you wanna get, right?
And we gonna be using a 13 by nine.
So I'm gonna go ahead and drop these in here.
Right, we gonna leave these in here for about 60 seconds.
Right, hot water.
Go.
Now, while that's going, I'm gonna set me a little timer
because I like to be pretty much accurate
on this part right here.
I keep my fire under here.
You'll see it starting to roll.
Now, come back over here to my cutting board.
Look, I got ice in here.
What I'm gonna do is put water in here
because when these are done, after 60 seconds,
we gonna take them out of the hot water.
We gonna put them right in here,
shock them, get them nice and cold.
We gotta be able to, you know, hold them.
And then you know what?
The peel is gonna come right off.
All right, so 60 seconds, we good.
Let them drain, drop them right in.
Now, I'll let them sit in this bath right here
for about, I don't know, about three minutes.
That way, the inside will be able to cool.
Right, and to get that where we can just peel them.
Okay, so as you can see, look,
you can see them hot peaches.
Look at that right there.
You see how it started melting all that ice?
Right, so now what I did was I emptied my water
and while that's still cooling,
because I told you, it takes about three or four minutes.
Right, meanwhile, we can go ahead and make this filling.
You know, start with the filling for the canned peaches.
Right, so I'm gonna start with a stick of butter.
Now, you know, I can't say this right here.
Let me turn that off.
I don't want it to be that hot.
Ah, my thing is like, you can use unsalted butter.
You know what I mean?
Especially for those of us that are watching our,
watching our sodium intake.
You know, we use unsalted butter, right?
Now, with that being said,
what you just saw me put in there, that's salted butter.
I just love the taste of the salted butter.
And that's just a butter of choice for myself,
even though I should be watching my sodium.
You know what I mean?
You wanna control it, right?
But when I use salted butter,
I don't have to put no spice or salt in there
or nothing like that.
That just works out good.
And one thing you guys didn't see, I take some lemon, right?
And I put it, you know, squeeze a little,
about a half of a lemon inside of my filling also.
Right, so once this melts, then we'll move on.
As a matter of fact, we can just move on now.
Now, I'm getting ready to add my peaches.
If you notice, I don't do no draining.
I put it in here just like you see.
Right?
Because that's where the slurry comes in at.
You know, in this process, when I get to the slurry,
that's what we're gonna use to thicken.
Now, I'm back at a medium flame,
like a medium-high flame,
just to get everything to start to work.
All right, so for the nutmeg and the cinnamon, right,
I put a tablespoon in here.
Right?
And we'll come in here like this.
If you guys ever get some of these spoons like that,
you ever wanna know why one end of it is like that?
It's supposed to be so that you can put this in here.
But you see how it don't just fit in that one?
And obviously, this is not gonna fit either.
But just letting you guys know
that some of your spice jars, you get one,
that's why I like them like this.
They even have them even narrower, and they just long.
Right, but we'll just add this to it now.
I do it over the top
because it doesn't make a difference,
anything fall in there.
All that is, that's just a lot of goodness.
That's that down-home, you know, flavor.
Now, I'm gonna give you guys a little bit of a heads up.
Give you some knowledge.
Like when I was coming up, my grandmother made this
the way I'm making it for you guys right now,
but she put one cup of brown and white sugar in there.
I don't, I reduced that a little bit.
I haven't heard anybody ever complain.
So it's really about three quarters, right?
So just breaking some of this up.
That's fine.
What you guys are gonna see is I got one cup of brown sugar,
but I just reduce a little bit.
Instead of using all the different ones,
like a half cup and then a quarter cup,
this is good enough for me.
So what you see right there, that's good.
You drop that right over the top
and I'm gonna do the exact same thing,
you know, with my white granulated sugar.
So remember, this is one cup, right?
That would be one cup.
I just pour a little bit of that out,
call that three quarters.
I can eyeball that.
And the way I'm cooking right now
is probably the way most of you guys are gonna cook.
This is not one of those type of recipes
where you need to do the exact measurements,
you know what I mean?
But we get it pretty close,
but your sugar gonna make a difference.
So for those of us that's trying to get healthy,
you wanna do something
like what you see me doing right here,
a reduction with the sugar.
And some of you guys might reduce it even more than that.
All right, and now we're gonna add the vanilla extract,
right?
Again, I made this.
You guys gotta check out my website.
It's on there.
All you gotta do is type in a search,
you know, vanilla extract and this recipe will come up.
Once you read that, you guys gonna be so surprised
how easy it is.
You guys probably make it for the rest of your life.
You know what I mean?
And then check this out.
The longer you hold it, the more premium it is, right?
So this is pure.
So let's go ahead and put a little bit of that in there.
Oh, that's enough.
Right?
So now that we have that in there,
got my spot.
Let's go ahead and get this, you know, incorporated.
Let this heat do its thing.
You can see it turns colors.
Now remember, I didn't do no draining, all right?
So you can look at it and then to you guys,
the word I'm gonna be using is like, it's soupy.
We'll fix all of that in just one second.
But right now I wanna cook it.
Now, how long do I cook it?
I'm gonna tell you this.
It depends on how high you have it.
And I look at my peaches.
This is gonna be key.
You see the peach?
You can tell when this peach is cooked
because you can look at this one,
pick a one that's a little bit smaller
and see how it looks.
Look around the edge and it becomes softer.
You know what I mean?
So this process usually takes about,
you know, about 15 minutes on a medium high.
You know what I mean?
I let it roll and do its thing.
You know what I mean?
But once these get soft
and I can take them up against the side
and I can just, oh, like that one there,
it's ready.
So we just continue with the heat, right?
We got everything in there.
Now we're finna go ahead and peel
some of these fresh peaches.
Okay, so I did these,
and I'm gonna be honest with you,
these wasn't peeling the way I wanted them to peel.
So if you look at them,
I went ahead and just used my regular peeler,
like this right here,
and just peeled them that way.
I probably should've left them in the hot water
a little bit longer.
Maybe I should've left them in there a couple of minutes.
So I would suggest you guys make that adjustment
and put them in the hot water
and then leave them in there for about 30.
I mean, excuse me.
30, nowhere near that.
About three minutes in the heat.
Then go ahead and hit them with the ice cold water
so you can get them to settle down
and then they'll slide much easier, right?
But I wanna do this part for you guys right now.
It's not that I don't wanna do anymore.
I just wanna show you something.
You see this skin?
If you leave the skin on,
cause you can make it that way,
this darkens up your filling
and it gives it a tint of that red.
It gives it a nice color.
After I did this,
cause I've done that a couple of times
and I actually wanted to say that,
but I really wanted you guys to see
to just peel them, right?
So now I'm just gonna come here
and we just hit it.
Now that we have it cut,
we just go ahead and get our slices out of here.
And then you just set them right over there.
Let's go ahead and pit this, get this out.
And I'm not finna bore you.
You guys know how to do this part from here on.
You cut your slices,
you know, per the size that you want them to be.
Okay, so look,
what I did was I put corn starch in here.
Now remember, everything is in equal parts.
If you didn't know, now you know, right?
So you got corn starch.
So meaning if it's one tablespoon of corn starch,
it's one tablespoon of equally cool water, right?
And when I say cool, I mean cold.
Now I put two tablespoons in here
cause I'm gonna thicken it up just a little bit,
but I don't have to do what I,
you know, I don't have to measure my water out.
Only reason is because I've been making this for a minute
and I know how the, you know, the consistency should be.
So what you wanna do,
as soon as you put that water in there,
you know what I mean?
You wanna make sure you give it a good mix,
meaning you don't want this to like thicken up
and have those clots or nothing like that.
You know, them clumps, right?
So this right here is good.
It's a little bit more on a watery side,
but that's good for me.
I don't wanna make it too thick.
Now, now we got it.
I'm gonna come over here.
This is already ready to go.
I'm gonna turn this off
cause I don't need it no more, no more heat.
Now that we have this here, we just add it.
Now we get right in here and immediately,
you know, start stirring it.
And then if you look at it,
it'll thicken up right in front of your eyes.
Look at that right there.
Okay, so look, our filling is done.
I'll start getting all my ingredients ready,
you know, to start making my, you know, my batter, right?
So what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna take a cup and a half.
We'll just put it there.
I'm gonna show you guys an easy way.
I had put it in a Pyrex
cause I could have just put this in the microwave
and just microwaved it,
but I'm gonna go ahead and put it like this.
I'm gonna stick this inside of the oven until this melts.
Meanwhile, we'll go ahead and start, you know, preparing.
This is gonna make it real simple for everybody, right?
What I'm gonna do is I'm gonna put all of my dry ingredients
into the bowl, real simple.
This right here, I have, this is one cup.
All right, now we're gonna add a cup of sugar here, right?
That's a half, do it like that.
Now we add our baking powder.
All right, now we give it just a pinch of salt,
probably like about a half a teaspoon, right?
Now we're gonna go ahead and grab, you know, our whisk,
and we're gonna go ahead and incorporate.
All right, so once we have our dry, you know,
and that's fully mixed, now we add our milk.
I'm just gonna pour this in here like that.
And before I do any type of mixing,
what I'm gonna do, set that off to the side,
and I'm gonna go ahead and add about a tablespoon
of this vanilla extract.
All right, now I know I got my whisk here,
but usually when I get to this part right here,
I try not to overwork it,
but I'm just trying to get rid of most of the white.
Once it thickens up like that,
now we're gonna do a little bit of folding, right?
So this is like a little bit of a shortcut.
For those of you guys that are new,
I suggest you just go ahead and take your spatula,
and then, you know, you just work it from there.
All right, so now I use a spatula to, you know,
get up underneath the bottle, right?
And just make sure it's all incorporated.
It's not really thick enough for me to be using the term,
you know, to overwork it, you know?
But still, this is the way I like to do it,
instead of just keep hitting it with the,
you know, the whisk, right?
So there we go.
And I can see down here at the bottom,
I got all of the white up, so we do that.
Okay, now let me check on the casserole dish
and that butter.
Everything's melted.
Pull this out, right?
All right, so come on in here,
because look, I'm getting ready to pour this in here,
but I want you guys to see.
Butter completely melted, right?
13 by nine.
And then as you let this sit up,
it kind of like picks up on its own anyway.
You guys are gonna want to have a spatula,
you know, a rubber spatula,
because you want to get it all in there, right?
This is what we do.
There's no really, no rhyme or reason to it.
I can just tell you, once you put it in here,
you just don't want to,
the thing is, you don't want to like stir it in here, right?
I know it's going to be butter on the side.
This is like the easiest way.
So now we use the rubber part, right?
It seals, scrapes, does all of that.
So if we took the time to make it,
let's get it all in there.
Now, I hope you guys are seeing the simplicity
of how to make a, you know, this real cobbler here.
So now I'm going to come in here.
I got my ladle.
You know what?
I'm going to need to put something underneath my hand,
because we don't want to have no dripping, right?
So you guys got to remember,
like if you're cleaning up your kitchen,
you know, we want to just stay prepared.
You know, if you're working by yourself,
meaning I can have it like this, like that.
And then what I'm doing is,
I just ladle this in here, just like this.
And so some of you guys know right now,
and then, oh, you know what?
Look at that thickness.
Remember we talked about that earlier, right?
If you want it to be a little bit more soupier,
or I guess that's it.
You know what I mean?
You don't have to put as much cornstarch.
Maybe one tablespoon works for you.
Get some of these peaches in there.
Now this right here, it's all going in there together.
But this one is a,
this is the one that we made with the can,
the canned peach.
Okay, so once we got this one set, you know, right?
I'm going to take this one.
Now it's still a little hot.
I'm going to put this on the counter over here,
because I want them both to go in
at the same exact time, right?
So now you guys know what it looks like.
This will go over here.
You'll see butter all over the place.
That's a good thing, right?
Now, what I'm getting ready to do is,
I'm melting my butter there.
I'm going to let that continue.
Now I'm going to add my peaches, right?
Now here go the fresh peaches.
Now I'm getting ready to bring my sugar into play.
Both white and brown.
Now you guys got it.
I gave you guys a measurement.
You already know it's on my website,
smokingandgrillingwithab.com,
and that's W-I-T-A-B.com.
And this is really about at the end result,
which is better, fresh or canned?
Or can you even taste the difference?
Okay, I got all my ingredients in here.
Now you see this right here?
Look at all that liquid.
All of that come from, you know,
the brown sugar, the white sugar.
You know what I mean?
That we did add, you know, the butter in there, right?
And then we got our vanilla extract,
but mainly the peach juice comes from the real peaches.
So look at that.
And if you can tell,
I can see the little red tint.
I hope the camera's picking that up.
You know what I mean?
That's from having that skin on there.
Trust me, folks, it's worth doing.
You know, it gives it a nice little look to it.
So we're going to let these simmer
for about five to seven minutes, right?
And then when that's done,
I'm going to go ahead and mix this.
I just put the casserole dish in the inside right now
so I can melt my butter.
All this is going to come together,
and then we're going to move on, folks.
All right, so we got both of them in here,
side by side.
This is fresh, that's canned.
Now I'm going to set a timer for 55 minutes.
You know what?
Actually, I'm going to set it for 50 minutes
and we go from there.
You know what I mean?
It usually takes about an hour for it to come up
since we're baking the whole, you know,
the whole real peach collar.
So I'll see you guys when I take it out.
Okay, so let's take a look at it.
Now this is what it looked like in 50 minutes.
My timer just went out, went off.
Look at that right there.
Now remember, this is the one over here
that had the fresh peaches.
I could tell by the color,
and that's the one with the canned peaches.
Now I'm going to go ahead and turn this off
because this right here is nice.
It's ready to go.
Yeah, let's go ahead and stop this.
And what I'm going to do is I'm going to let them cool.
Now I'm going to let these rest, you know, for about,
I'm going to say these are probably going to take
about 15 minutes.
So let's take these out.
And just so you guys can catch it and look at it.
Look at that right there.
Now that's a peach cobbler.
Okay, folks, look.
Completely done, cooled, and ready to be tasted, right?
If you guys come on in there and take a look,
this right here, the red one,
this represents, you know, the fresh peaches, right?
We left some of the skin on there.
And to be honest with you, looking at this right here,
I wish I would've left it all on there, you know,
because I did a half and half.
But look at the color.
They give it that caramelized type of look.
And you can see everything is set.
That's what happens when you let it, you know,
cool properly.
Over here, this right here is our canned peaches.
This would be the filling that more you got,
you know, that you guys are most used to seeing me do.
You know what I mean?
And I actually make a peach pie,
but my family have always called that the peach cobbler
because cobblers don't have any bottom crust, folks.
And this right here is what everybody want, right?
So I got a bowl right here.
Now I'm finna go in here and just get me some.
You know, I'm that guy.
I just really want to hit it like in the middle,
but I ain't gonna do it like that.
I'm just gonna go in here and get some right here.
Ooh, this screams.
Look at that.
That screams ice cream, right?
So now I'm gonna come in here
and we're gonna do the same thing,
you know, for the canned peaches.
You see this?
Look.
Now I do got to take some pictures,
but I'm gonna go ahead and taste this.
Nice and hot.
And I'm gonna go ahead and taste it, you know,
without the ice cream, just so I get the flavor.
Because the real question is,
which one is better, fresh or canned, right?
So that's a trip.
You know, your brain tell you you about to eat something
and you know it's good.
It's how your mouth just starts to water, right?
So I'm gonna go in here and go,
I'm gonna start with the, ooh, man, the crust.
Ooh.
I'm sorry, y'all.
I keep saying ooh, but I don't know what else to do.
Either I can do that dance.
You know what I'm saying?
But this right here, this is the fresh peach.
And I've been making this forever.
To me, it tastes like it's supposed to.
One more time.
Now you saw me hit it from the edge.
You know it got that crust on the edge.
Sweet.
Good.
Now for the canned peaches.
Get my palate empty.
Cheers again, y'all.
Damn, that crust is good.
I'm gonna stop all the antics
and I'm gonna keep it real with you guys.
I'm gonna just say it this way.
Outside of the look, there's obviously a different look
because I left the skin on.
You don't even have no skin inside of there.
It kind of like just dissolves on its own,
but it leaves the color.
I like the color more so
because it looks great when you put it out.
And this really looks fire
if I'd have done this in like a cast iron skillet, right?
Now, with that being said, let's talk about like the taste.
If you asked me if I was blindfolded,
I'd tell you, well, I really don't know.
Like, they both the same.
You know, and that's my opinion.
I know that's gonna spark up a whole bunch of stuff
because everybody got in their brain
that when something is fresh, like a fresh peach,
it ain't hit no serve or nothing like that
coming from no factory inside of a can,
that the fresh will be better.
I'm giving you my honest opinion, folks.
It ain't just, they the same.
So either one, it's up to you.
Now let's just talk about what I've done in the past.
Millions of views on them, you know what I mean?
I did a peach cobbler,
showed everybody how easy it is to make.
If you really want to know what the easiest one to make is,
that's this one right here.
You can have this ready in 15 minutes.
You know, nah, I'm gonna say you probably have it
in the oven in 20 minutes.
Hey, with that being said,
let me know down in the comment section below,
you know, what would you guys do?
There's a few things we can add to this to make it our own.
Maybe you want to try some different fruits,
but I'd love to hear from it.
Hear from you guys so that we can talk about it
down in that comment section, right?
Now, if you're new to my channel,
let me take this time to say,
thank you for watching this video.
Don't forget to like, smash that subscribe button,
and tell everybody out there,
there's a channel out here that's simplifying these recipes
and taking the mystery out of cooking.
And you know what I'm about to do, folks?
I'm about to hit you with the piece,
but we about to get another bowl.
We about to get a little ice cream
and we about to eat, folks.
I'm out, peace.