Spider-Man: Brand New Day REVIEW

Movie review
9 followers
Spider-Man: Brand New Day REVIEW with spoilers.
Edited by @QTRBlackGarrett
#hollywood #spiderman #movie #review
Spoilers 08:30
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis review of *Spider-Man: Brand New Day* praises Tom Holland's mature performance and the film's high-quality action and costume design. While the reviewer criticizes the narrative clutter and the handling of the antagonist, Jean Grey, they conclude that the film successfully captures the essence of heroism and serves as a powerful antidote to general superhero fatigue.
You ready?
How do they deliver the script to you?
It's definitely very well protected.
Who are you most excited to see?
Just keep your mouth shut. It's not that bad. It's not that hard.
That's good advice.
Yep.
Good advice.
I've heard that many times.
She's the villain but like there's a reason to her madness.
Okay, is that a spoiler?
Pack your things.
You're fired!
Greetings, you over 1 million Hellions and the 40% who haven't subscribed yet.
The return of everyone's favorite web head to the silver screen is upon us.
But before we get to that, let's take a little trip down memory lane
to the very forgettable year of 2021,
when the world was still recovering from a totally not man-made uber cold.
On the advice of counsel, I respectfully decline to answer
based upon my rights under the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution.
And Hollywood was just getting back after spending a year shut down.
And that included Disney Marvel's box office juggernaut, the MCU particularly,
coming off their last two films,
Endgame, which grossed over $2 billion,
and the end of Phase 3, Spider-Man Far From Home, which grossed $1.1 billion.
Unfortunately, this year would be the first signs of real trouble for the MCU
and the start of the infamous MCU.
Phase 4 started with Black Widow, a prequel about a dead character,
a film so abysmal I would argue it would have flopped anyway.
But since it was released day and day,
it led to the film's star, Scarlett Johansson, suing Disney Marvel.
But its worst crime of all, it introduced Yelena,
something that will be important for this review.
This was followed up with Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Bracelets,
featuring Simu Liu getting kicked in the balls.
Then poor Simu Liu got kicked in the balls again
when it was announced that the absolute triumph that was Shang-Chi
would get a sequel that never happened.
A film directed by Destin Daniel Cretton,
which will also be important for this review.
But hey Simu, look on the bright side.
You got to star in Doomsday along with 47 other people,
and I'm sure that promised sequel is right around the corner.
And the third film released in 2021 was The Eternals,
a film that literally saved lives.
Can you imagine how many lives this is going to be saving?
And it did that by fewer people risking the journey to the theater
in a car or on a train to go see it.
And you might recall all three of these films' performance,
ranging from outright flop to eking out a profit,
was blamed on the totally not manufactured cold.
On the advice of counsel, I respectfully decline to answer
based upon my rights under the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution.
Coincidentally, as I record this intro,
Anthony Fauci is currently in a Senate hearing
answering questions about that totally not manufactured cold.
And that narrative might have worked for Disney, Marvel,
and the rest of Hollywood
if it wasn't for a little film called Spider-Man No Way Home.
That made almost $2 billion,
had a $600 million opening weekend,
and all's it took was three Spider-Men.
At the time, it was Tom Holland's best performance
as Peter Parker's Spider-Man.
And a lot of the box office is being attributed
to the return of Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield.
And I wouldn't deny that,
but don't sell short the brilliant Willem Dafoe,
who became one of the MCU's greatest villains
returning as Green Goblin.
But as The Flash showed us,
simply having a beloved actor returning to a beloved part
is not enough.
You have to have a story, and it has to have heart.
And that's everything Spider-Man No Way Home had,
despite its flaws.
It was a crowd pleaser, and I still love it.
So it was a foregone conclusion to get a sequel
that surprisingly took over four years to get here.
And as you know, after Spider-Man No Way Home,
things didn't get any better for Disney, Sony, or Disney Marvel,
despite a couple of successes.
As a matter of fact, they've gotten a lot worse.
After Madam Web, Venom Last Dance, and Kraven,
Sony decided to stop making Spider-Man films
without Spider-Man, with the exception of Miles Morales.
And the MCU has scrapped everything involving Kang
so they could bring back Robert Downey Jr.
to play Dr. Doom, Chris Hemsworth as Thor,
and Chris Evans as Captain Shirtpants.
This brings us to The Year of Our Lord 2026,
the second year in a row that the MCU
was gonna turn things around
because 2025 didn't work out so well.
And they are gonna start it with a Sony film.
Spider-Man Brand New Day.
Now, keeping in mind that my take
on the box office juggernaut that is The Odyssey
went against the vast majority of corporate critics
and the vast majority of humanity, here's my review.
On the advice of counsel, I respectfully decline to answer
based upon my rights under the Fifth Amendment
of the Constitution.
I wouldn't do that to you guys.
Now, on to the review.
Spider-Man Brand New Day, a title that I absolutely loathe,
but that has everything to do with the comics
and nothing to do with the actual film,
is being reported as a mixed bag,
and that is not entirely untrue,
but it's a mixed bag that I enjoy.
Do I have my fan man goggles on a little bit for this one?
Absolutely.
Does it have too many characters?
Yes and no.
Does it have two completely different movies in one?
Kind of.
Does it have a character or two
that could be removed from this film
and nothing would change?
Yes.
Does it feature that overused brand of Marvel humor?
Surprisingly, very little.
Does it have the misunderstood
and victimized female antagonist?
That would be a big yes.
Is Spider-Man a side character in his own story?
That would be a big no.
Is it ultimately a story about being a hero and heroism?
Thankfully, yes.
And the most important question,
outside of is this movie actually worth going to or not,
is does Tom Holland finally graduate
from Spider-Boy to Spider-Man?
And that would be a yes.
And I would also argue, despite this movie's flaws,
that it's his best performance as the character.
I can't undersell how good he was in this movie
and whatever else is wrong with it, it ain't him.
Set four years after the events of No Way Home
when Doctor Strange cast a spell to make everybody forget
that Peter Parker was Spider-Man,
including Ned Leeds and his beloved Zendaya.
In those four years, he's been fighting crime in solitude
in New York City and completely ignoring
the Wilson Fisk administration
where the Kingpin murdered a bunch of people in City Hall.
While Peter is struggling with his isolation
and doing a bit of light stalking of MJ,
he's also dealing with a potentially dangerous evolution
of his powers.
And what makes things worse
is Spider-Man is investigating a psychotic telepath
who wants to infiltrate damage control
and she isn't really concerned with what or who gets in her way.
And yes, our misunderstood female antagonist
in Spider-Man Brand New Day is a villain through and through.
And on the surface, you'd be going,
great, yes, we want Spider-Man fighting a villain,
but there's one teensy little problem
with who the villain actually is.
And we'll get to that.
But I don't know about you,
but I go to Spider-Man movies to see Spider-Man
do whatever a spider can.
And this is without a doubt
the best Spider-Man action put to screen to date.
And it is the best Spider-Man costume put on screen to date
based on the John Romita design,
which is the most iconic.
And it's the most accurate superhero costume
since Donner's Superman.
And the best part is Spider-Man keeps his mask on
for most of the film.
So they got the costume right
and they're finally keeping his mask on
and it only took him a couple of decades.
What's unfortunate is there is a lot going on
in Spider-Man Brand New Day
and the descriptions of it being a great movie
wrapped inside just a good one or pretty accurate.
You'll hear the word mature being attributed
to it a lot because a lot of the themes are loss,
acceptance, and what it means to be a hero.
And your mileage may vary on this
because it takes up a large portion of the film.
When it focuses on Tom Holland's Peter Parker Spider-Man,
it's done extremely well.
Now I would have preferred they moved on
from Ned Leeds and Zendaya's MJ,
although I did like them in No Way Home,
but I also liked that tragic end.
That being said, and I can't believe I'm saying this,
I actually thought they were pretty good in this,
particularly Ned.
The other things that worked for me surprisingly,
Jon Bernthal's hammed up PG-13 Punisher,
who was in the movie a lot more
than I thought it would be.
The savage Hulk who wasn't in the movie
as much as I thought it would be.
And we're gonna have to put an asterisk on this one,
but I thought Sadie Sink did a good job acting in her role.
I just didn't like what the writers did with the character.
And yes, as a comic book fan,
I fully appreciate trying to get
as many comic book covers as you possibly can
in this movie, at times forcing it.
But to be fair, other Spider-Man movies
have done this in the past.
Ultimately, Spider-Man Brand New Day
is a 10 out of 10 performance from Tom Holland.
It's a film with a lot of heart
that tries a little too hard at times.
And I think it's gonna make a lot of money.
I've been to two screenings that were sold out
with enthusiastic crowds.
But now it's time to get to the spoilers
and why I hate the title Brand New Day
and any comic fan would,
because it's the follow-up to the worst storyline
in the history of Spider-Man,
one that arguably broke the character forever.
And that will be one more day
written by Babylon 5's J. Michael Straczynski.
But the real responsibility for this storyline
lays at the feet of one Joe Quesada,
who hated the fact that Peter Parker
was married to Mary Jane,
and he felt that it aged the character
and made him less relatable to younger readers.
In this ridiculous storyline,
to save Aunt May,
Peter sells his marriage
and his memories of the relationship
to Mary Jane Watson to Mephisto
instead of his soul.
Quite frankly, it would have been better
just to kill Mary Jane.
And this storyline eventually led to Peter Parker
becoming a complete cuck.
And no, I'm not kidding.
And I guess that's relatable to younger readers.
Anyway, it led to a lot of lost sales.
It cost me thousands in my comic store.
And if you even mention one more day
or say the phrase around a Spider-Man fan,
they might twitch a little.
While I have not been the biggest fan
of John Watt's adaptation of Spider-Man
in his trilogy,
I started coming around with No Way Home
and I would argue he did a much better version
of One More Day.
It is a rare example of the movies
capturing Peter Parker's selfless heroism
much better than they did in the comic books.
But my biggest concern in Brand New Day
was what they were going to do
with Zendaya's MJ and Ned Leeds.
My unrealistic preference was to have them
in the movie very little or not at all
and have Peter still dealing with his isolation
but making new friends like,
I don't know, Felicia Hardy, Gwen Stacy,
or the real Mary Jane.
But the reality is MJ and Ned Leeds
are in this movie a lot
and for the most part,
I felt like their scenes actually had meaning.
As most of you know by now,
although there were some audible gasps
in the theater when her name was revealed,
Jean Grey is the villain of this story.
That's right, they decided to introduce
the MCU's first X-Men,
Jean Grey the Omega level mutant
in a Sony film.
But she really isn't at her full abilities yet
and all she can really do is jump in
and possess people if they're within 33 feet.
Obviously the screenwriter is a mason,
but the one person she can't fully possess
is Spider-Man due to his spider sense,
but she was in his mind long enough
to find his apartment,
find out he's Peter Parker,
and eventually find the letter
that he wrote to Mary Jane
at the end of No Way Home,
which puts her in immediate danger
so Spider-Man essentially has to abduct her
from her apartment willingly
and once they're on a rooftop,
there is a moment where you think
that MJ actually remembers
that Peter Parker is Spider-Man,
but it turns out to be Jean Grey.
A nice little cold twist
and it also shows that they might actually
be sticking with the bit.
Spider-Man takes MJ to the Punisher
to keep an eye on her
and eventually she finds the letter
that he wrote at the end of No Way Home
and confronts him on it.
So Doctor Strange's spell really worked
and I was worried that they would have
this Omega level telepath around
who can just snap her fingers
and get rid of the spell,
which didn't happen or did it.
And that's one of the three major storylines.
The other one is Peter's mutating abilities
and it's interesting that I use the word mutate
because they don't use the word mutant
in this film.
Now this is the part
where they're loosely adapting
J. Michael Straczynski's The Other
from the comics.
Peter's powers start evolving
due to the isolation,
the stress of fighting crime full-time
and watching MJ make out with her boyfriend.
This mutation leads to heightened senses,
he's stronger and organic web shooters.
And yes, there is a Tobey Spider-Man reference.
He also gets a lot more aggressive
when he's fighting the Scorpion
possessed by Jean Grey.
He almost kills a cop,
but to be fair to our friendly neighborhood Spider-Man,
it was a fat female cop
who probably would have been fine
if she would have laid off the donuts.
This of course mortifies our hero Spider-Man
who seeks out Bruce Banner
to see how his inhibitor works
that keeps Savage Hulk at bay.
Now this eventually leads to Peter
developing an inhibitor for himself
to keep his monster at bay
and a universal inhibitor
that can nullify the powers of all superheroes,
including mutants
that you can't contractually call mutants
in a Sony film.
Now I don't have a problem
with Peter Parker sciencing stuff up
or even having a pretty good computer,
but he has an awful lot of nice tech,
including an AI called Evie
in a sh**y apartment with no job.
Because I seem to recall him having one
in the comic books
working for a place called the Daily Bugle
with J. Jonah Jameson,
something that this film is missing.
It would be hilarious
to have Peter Parker being a videographer
for the MCU's version of Info Wars.
And again, this is a busy film.
It's got a lot of characters
and it's introduced a lot of things
from the comics
and I was concerned
that J. Michael Straczynski's
The Other storyline
was just going to be shoehorned in and not fit,
but to the film's credit, it actually works.
Look at it as acting as an opposite
of what Raimi did in Spider-Man 2.
Instead of losing his powers, he evolves
and now they've amped up Peter's powers
for a future film
and I wonder what that could be.
And while this pays off,
the other setups for future films don't.
Speaking of busy,
there's an awful lot of side characters
in Brand New Day
and a lot of them are Blink and You'll Miss It,
but we'll start with Detective Jean DeWolf,
another character that's been race swapped
from a redhead
so you can add that to the list.
She essentially acts
as Spider-Man's confidant slash cheerleader
and disappointingly,
under the category of Blink and You'll Miss It,
there's Tombstone, Tarantula, Boomerang and Ramrod
and there's the Scorpion played by Michael Mando
who does a good job
but is really underused
and there's The Hand,
the formerly deadly ninja assassin organization
turned into a K-pop group
that admittedly,
when it fights,
it's pretty cool.
Trammell Tillman,
who feels like he's in everything these days
from Severance,
playing Bill Metzger
from, I want to say,
Damage Incorporated,
hail Metallica,
Damage Control
and he is the real bad guy
and all of them are fine,
save for one,
Florence Pugh's Yelena.
Now, I don't have a problem
with Florence Pugh as an actress,
but I do have a problem
with her portrayal as Yelena
and I have a problem
with Kevin Feige's insistence
to force this character down our throat.
In one of her, thankfully,
two very short scenes
that didn't need to be in this film
and if you took them out,
it wouldn't have changed anything,
particularly the first scene
where you learn absolutely nothing,
she forces Spider-Man to disrobe
to join her in a pool
and this is one of those cases
if you reverse the scenario,
corporate critics especially
would call it misogynist
and it just reeks as remnants of,
I'm gonna say it,
the MCU that Marvel is clearly moving away from
and having her the leader
of even the New Avengers
and saying things like,
what Spider-Man does is small potatoes
is just laughable.
But this brings us
to Spider-Man brand new day's villain,
the misunderstood victimized female antagonist,
Jean Grey played by Stranger Things' Sadie Sink.
So the rumors were true
and why would you introduce
your first MCU X-Men in a Sony film?
No idea.
Why would you make the introduction
of your very first X-Men
in a Spider-Man movie from Sony a villain?
No idea.
And I can hear you now, dear viewer,
well, maybe at some point in the film
we find out what her motivation was
and she gets redeemed
and I can tell you that does not happen.
I had a much higher score for this film
until we creeped into the morality
of WandaVision, Black Widow and Wonder Woman 84.
WandaVision had Wanda enslaving a town of men,
women and children against their will.
Gal Gadot's Wonder Woman
raped a dude in Wonder Woman 84
and the woman who enslaved all the women
in Black Widow was let go
because she's a woman.
Throughout the film,
Sadie Sink's Jean Grey
is trying to infiltrate damage control
to find her sister, Sarah,
who they abducted.
And to do this,
she has no problem possessing
hundreds of people against their will,
shooting people.
Now, they make a point in the film
to show that these are not
life-threatening injuries.
She just shoots them in the knee
and they'll never walk again
and rely on disability
for the rest of their lives.
But there is one confirmed kill
when Jean Grey forces a guy
to walk in front of a speeding car.
But it's not just one kill.
Considering what she did
throughout Brand New Day,
it's a pretty high body count.
Now, if this was Killgrave
or Mr. Negative
or Mrs. Negative in this case,
or even Emma Frost,
it would have played off a little better.
But this was Jean Grey.
When damage control
eventually captures her
with the help of Spider-Man
and his inhibitor,
she unlocks her power
and blasts a mind wave for a kilometer,
which had to kill hundreds of people.
You know, they were really leaning
into the international audience here
when the Punisher says kilometer
because what the f*** is a kilometer?
But like I said,
Sadie Sink does a good job in the role,
particularly at the end
when she's captured by damage control.
But up until that inexplicable end,
I was fine with what they were doing.
I liked the fact that
she was hopping through bodies.
I liked it when she possessed the Punisher.
It was pretty funny.
And I liked it when she possessed Professor Hulk,
where ultimately it was Savage Hulk
who kicked her out of his head.
And let me not be the first one to say,
thank God Savage Hulk is back.
And hey,
can we maybe just not have him
turn back into Bruce Banner?
And I'm conflicted with the ending
because I really like the Spider-Man stuff
and really do not like the Jean Grey stuff.
After fighting the hands,
Spider-Man takes off his inhibitor
and embraces his evolution
with the help of Sadie Sink's Jean Grey.
And then Peter talks her down
and keeps her from killing Bill Metzger
by allowing her into his head
so she can interact with the memory of Aunt May.
But it's a good heartfelt speech about acceptance,
bordering on superficial.
But you also have to put yourself
in the shoes of a foster kid
who's probably never heard anything like that
in their entire life.
But the Punisher said,
if Spider-Man is taken down,
he's going to take Sadie Sink's Jean Grey out.
Luckily, he was just outside
of that one kilometer mind wave
and he takes a shot
and Peter takes the bullet.
And by the way,
the Punisher was completely justified in doing this.
So yes, I'm torn
because it's a great scene
of Peter showing his selfless heroism
and forgiveness.
But then after Peter recovers
with the help of Jean Grey,
they let her go.
Jean Grey's villainous intent
and villainous accomplishment
in Spider-Man Brand New Day
is motivated by Damage Control
abducting her sister, Sarah,
while not abducting Jean Grey
when they had the chance.
So they could experiment on her,
which was essentially torture,
and it ended up killing her.
Now, Damage Control
killing Jean Grey's sister, Sarah,
certainly justifies her
taking out some upper-ranking members
of Damage Control,
but it does not justify her
mind-raping tens of thousands of people
and killing some of them.
Not the best way to introduce
the hated and feared X-Men
into the MCU
when they've made a pretty good case
they should at the very least be feared.
I think a better ending
would have been like Faith in Buffy,
where Jean Grey willingly turns herself in
and starts to rehabilitate
and, I don't know,
accepting some accountability,
and then you could have actually
had a real post-credit scene
where she's being visited
by somebody in a wheelchair.
It might have also been better
if you just didn't have
Jean Grey murdering people.
If it wasn't for that,
this film would have been
a 9 out of 10 for me,
but instead it's a 7.5 out of 10,
and it has everything to do
with how I feel about this
being a Spider-Man movie.
This is the movie for me
where Tom Holland embodied the character,
and I couldn't see
anybody else playing him now.
And it's the closest MCU Sony film
to capture the essence,
or the vibe, as the kids say,
of the comic books I read
up until Disney bought Marvel Comics
and completely ruined them.
And I might like this film
a little bit more than No Way Home
because I'm liking it
for Tom Holland's Spider-Man.
Don't get me wrong,
Tobey is still the GOAT.
And maybe pump the brakes on calling it
the greatest Spider-Man movie ever made
because we all know that's Spider-Man 2
and the discussion is over.
Because with that film's villain,
Doctor Octopus,
while they did make him much nicer
than he was in the comics,
his redemption came
when he realized he did wrong,
although it was an AI
taking over his brain,
took accountability,
and then did the heroic act
of sacrificing his life
to save millions of people,
unlike Jean Grey.
But I have to stress
that I like Sadie Sink in the role,
essentially playing Max again
from Stranger Things.
The thing that really works
the most for me in this film
is it hits all the emotional beats.
They're not cheesy,
they're not saccharine,
they're meaningful.
And for a superhero film,
I think it does a pretty good job
capturing what it's really like
to be isolated and lonely,
something we've all felt
at one point in our lives.
Sure, Spider-Man is surrounded
by millions of people,
where in the last movie
they hated him
and now they love him,
but they have no idea who he is.
Yes, he does talk to people
like Gene DeWolf or his AI, Evie,
but there's no real personal connection.
And he obviously wasn't
going to make any new friends
because he would be potentially
putting them in danger too.
But don't get me wrong,
this isn't a mopey,
amazing Spider-Man.
They actually balance it
with a lot of fun.
The one thing I appreciate
about Spider-Man Brand New Day,
whether you loved it,
just liked it,
or absolutely loathed it,
we can have a normal
nerd discussion about it.
Sure, as I said,
there's a little girl boss scene
with Yelena and again,
there is the misunderstood,
victimized female antagonist,
but they don't spend the entire film
on the main character,
like for example,
Doctor Strange Mom
or like Superman.
And thankfully,
and I look forward to
never having to bring this up again,
but we know that's not
exactly going to happen.
We don't have to waste any time
talking about the message.
Hey, it looks like
you can make a black guy
the villain again.
Maybe in the next film,
we can have some female accountability.
Despite any of my issues,
I like the film quite a bit.
I've seen it twice.
It got better for me
on the second viewing.
Going to see it a third time
and I'm definitely going to buy
the 4K steel box special edition.
Word of mouth on this film is insane
and it's killing it at the box office.
But the added bonus
with Spider-Man Brand New Day
is by Friday,
technically it's third day,
it's already outgrossed
Supergirl's worldwide box office total.
And by the end of the weekend,
it might have outgrossed
the entirety of James Gunn's DCU.
And let's keep it going.
By its second weekend,
it could possibly outgross
Captain African American,
Thunderbolts,
and Fantastic Four First Steps combined.
And that's a good thing.
So it looks like once again,
we have the answer
of fighting superhero fatigue.
Since Endgame,
the only films
that have crossed a billion dollars
are an aging Hugh Jackman
with respect in a Deadpool movie
and Spider-Man movies.
Three of them to be exact.
And without a doubt,
Spider-Man is the most popular superhero
in the world,
which makes it a shame
that the only place
he's really not turning
any numbers right now
is in the comics.
But as far as those rumors
of Sony selling Spider-Man
back to Disney are concerned,
not saying it would never happen,
but I would also argue
that Disney would have to pay
more for just the Spider-Man film rights
than they did for all of Marvel.
No, Spider-Man Brand New Day
is not the best Spider-Man movie ever made.
Let's not be prisoners of the moment,
but it is one of the better ones
and it's worth the trip to the theater.
While it does have issues
and lacks complexity
while being busy,
it makes up for that
with having a lot of heart and heroism.
And the heart and soul of this film
is one Tom Holland,
whose performance
is both spectacular and amazing.
If you like what you heard,
please like, share, and subscribe.
If you didn't like what you heard,
I thank you for listening this long.
I will see you in the next video.
