We Ran Mobil 1 Advanced Clean vs. Valvoline R&P in the Same F-150 for 1 Year — A Clear Winner

Engine in Focus
4 followers
In this video, we provide a side-by-side comparison of
Valvoline Restore & Protect and Mobil 1 Advanced Clean motor oils.
We examine the general features and characteristics of each product.
#machine #Equipment #Engine
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA year-long head-to-head test using a 2018 Ford F-150 compared Valvoline Restore and Protect against Mobil 1 Advanced Clean. While both premium oils successfully mobilized engine deposits, Valvoline demonstrated a superior trend in reducing wear metals over consecutive intervals, making it the more effective choice for engine cleaning and protection.
We ran two of the most hyped cleaning oils on the market
through the same F-150 for a full year
and sent drain samples to an independent lab
at every single change.
One of them produced results
that are genuinely hard to justify at any price.
The other one earned every dollar it costs.
Both of these oils retail at $11 to $14 a quart,
roughly 50% more than a standard full synthetic,
and both of them make the same core promise.
They will clean your engine while they protect it.
That sounds like a straightforward upgrade,
but cleaning and protecting are two different things.
And after a full year of back-to-back lab data
on the same truck,
they do not always point in the same direction.
The two oils are Valvoline Restore and Protect
and Mobil 1 Advanced Clean.
Valvoline launched theirs in 2022.
Mobil 1 answered with Advanced Clean in 2023.
Both positioned themselves at the same price point
and both made deposit cleaning their primary selling claim.
Valvoline says 50% better engine cleaning
versus industry standard.
Mobil 1 says 40% better cleaning
versus their own extended performance.
The comment sections on every oil video we have made
have been asking us to test these two head-to-head
for over a year.
This is that test.
We use the same 2018 F-150 with the 5.0 Coyote 5.8
that we have tracked for three years
with a documented service history
and a clean pretest inspection.
Same driver rotation, same routes, same fuel stations,
same 5,000 mile drain intervals on both oils,
same filter, same lab, same testing methodology.
We ran Valvoline Restore and Protect first
for two full intervals
and Mobil 1 Advanced Clean second for two full intervals.
Four drain samples, four lab reports, one truck.
Before we get into the numbers,
here is something most people do not know
about how cleaning oils actually work.
The detergent and dispersant additives in these products
suspend existing carbon deposits and sludge
and carry them out at the drain.
This is why your used oil looks noticeably darker
when you first run a cleaning oil,
not because the oil is breaking down faster,
but because it is doing exactly what the marketing says
and mobilizing material
that was already sitting in your engine.
The question that the marketing does not answer
is whether that cleaning action
produces measurably better wear protection.
The first drain on Valvoline Restore and Protect
came back darker than anything we had seen
from this engine in three years
of standard full synthetic use.
Iron at seven parts per million,
copper at three parts per million,
aluminum at two parts per million.
The oil had clearly been doing something inside the engine
because the used sample color
was noticeably different from the baseline.
Those wear numbers are solid,
well within the healthy range for this mileage and interval.
The second Valvoline drain at 10,000 miles
of total cleaning oil use told a cleaner story.
Iron dropped to six parts per million.
Copper stayed at three parts per million.
Aluminum was at two parts per million.
The trend was moving in the right direction
and the darker used oil from the first interval
had cleared somewhat,
which is consistent with what happens
once the bulk of the accumulated deposits
have been suspended and removed.
The engine was cleaner.
The data showed it.
That part of the Valvoline claim held up.
If you are finding this useful,
hit the subscribe button
because here is where the two oils
stop behaving like competitors
and start telling completely different stories.
Mobile One Advanced Clean
went in at the same interval structure.
First drain at 5,000 miles
came back with iron at eight parts per million,
copper at four, aluminum at two.
The used oil was slightly darker than baseline,
consistent with some deposit mobilization,
but not as dramatically dark as the first Valvoline drain.
That could mean the engine was already cleaner
after two intervals of Valvoline.
It could also mean the Mobile One's cleaning action
operates differently.
The wear numbers were still solid,
but trending slightly higher than where Valvoline left off.
The second Mobile One Advanced Clean drain
is where this test produced its most uncomfortable result.
Iron came back at nine parts per million,
copper at four, aluminum at three.
Those numbers are still within normal range.
We are not talking about a failing engine,
but the trend had reversed.
After two intervals of Valvoline
showing wear metals declining,
two intervals of Mobile One Advanced Clean
showed them climbing slightly back toward baseline.
That is not what a premium cleaning
and protection oil is supposed to do
in the second interval
when the engine should be at its cleanest.
Here's the part that reframes everything.
Mobile One Advanced Clean uses a group four PAO base stock.
Valvoline Restore and Protect uses a group three base
with an enhanced additive package.
The PAO base in the Mobile One
is generally considered a higher quality base oil
for high temperature viscosity retention.
But in this engine at this interval,
it was the additive package in the Valvoline product
that appeared to be doing more measurable work
at the interface where wear actually happens.
Base oil quality and additive performance are both real,
and they do not always move together.
The cleaning claim, taken on its own, both oils deliver.
Both produce darker used oil samples
than standard full synthetic.
Both showed some degree of deposit mobilization.
But the question was never
which oil cleans better on a paper towel.
The question was whether cleaning better
translates into protecting better
over a full year of real driving conditions.
And the answer, at least in this engine
over these four intervals,
is that Valvoline Restore and Protect came out ahead
on the metric that matters most,
wear metal trend over consecutive intervals.
This does not mean Mobile One Advanced Clean is a bad oil.
It is not.
Nine parts per million of iron in a healthy engine
at 5,000 miles is completely acceptable.
But at $11 to $14 a quart,
you are paying for performance above the standard.
And in this test, the Valvoline product
delivered that premium more consistently
across four consecutive drain intervals.
The owner who benefits most from either of these oils
is running a higher mileage EcoBoost
with accumulated deposits from years of direct injection
and PCV oil vapor cycling.
A walnut blasting service to clean intake valves
on an EcoBoost typically costs between 200 and $350
at an independent shop.
If running a cleaning oil on a consistent interval
genuinely slows that deposit accumulation,
and the drain data suggests it does,
the premium cost over standard full synthetic
pays for itself well before the valves need blasting.
After a full year and four lab reports,
here is exactly what we would put in our own F-150.
If you are running a higher mileage EcoBoost
or a Coyote with documented deposit history,
Valvoline Restore and Protect at 5,000 mile intervals
showed the most consistent wear metal improvement
across consecutive drains.
If your engine is relatively clean
and you want a premium oil with a strong base stock
for high temperature protection,
standard mobile one extended performance
at the same interval gives you most
of what advanced clean offers at a lower price per quart.
The cleaning oil category is real.
The deposit mobilization is real.
But not every cleaning oil protects equally well.
And the label that spins the most on marketing
is not always the one that shows the best numbers
when the oil comes out dirty at the drain.
If you want to see how these same two oils perform
on the 3.5 EcoBoost under towing conditions,
that test is already in progress.
Subscribe so you do not miss it when the data comes in.
Drop a comment telling me which of these two oils
you are running and whether you have sent a sample to a lab
and I read every one of them.
I will see you in the next one.
