Is The 36v Metabo HPT (Hikoki) MultiVolt Triple Hammer Worth the Upgrade over the 18v? WH36DB

Power Machine Tools
2 followers
Hey guys, Indy here with Ultimate 2 Reviews. Now, I know I've mentioned a couple previous videos
about the Metabo HPT, the triple hammer impact. Now, I had the 18 volt impact for, you know,
quite a while earlier in the year. I really wasn't overall impressed with it. I thought the power
was just kind of okay for, you know, what it was. And I thought it was just an okay impact driver.
Now, there's been a ton of videos. I know Torque Test Channel did one.
There's been a few other reviews as well too about the triple hammer impact.
I definitely recommend you check out Torque Test Channel's video where he actually cuts
open the anvil here and he shows you an interesting issue with that triple hammer impact
where when it's under an extreme load or really basically full load, the triple hammer actually
starts skipping on that anvil and it doesn't actually impact every single time. It'll actually
end up skipping over the hammer and not impact every single time. It's kind of a weird thing.
I definitely kind of noticed, you know, that earlier in the year too when I was trying out
the impact. But what I wanted to do when I mentioned was that I said, you know what,
let me try the 36 volt. Now, if you look at the specs between the 36 volt and the 18 volt
triple hammers, they are very, very similar. There's like about a 50 inch pound difference
in power between the 18 volt and the 36 volt. Now, that's pretty minimum. Pretty much you're
not going to notice that much power difference. But I will say I like the 36 volt a lot more than
the 18 volt. And there's one big reason for that. And that's probably that I didn't have
a multivolt battery for the 18 volt impact. Now, I know you're thinking, oh, it's not a
multivolt tool. It's not going to necessarily take advantage of that. But as we've learned
from, you know, a lot of people doing the tests on larger batteries, they do give a better
performance for the tool. So yes, that's definitely very true. So when you add in the multivolt
triple hammer impact, you add in a nice, you know, much bigger battery, you're definitely
going to see a lot more performance with that one tool. So guys, I want to do a few comparisons here
between, you know, this Makita. I wasn't really sure what Makita impact driver I wanted to put
against the Metabo. There's a lot of, you know, options I've got here. I didn't want to pick one
that was going to be, you know, way over what the price point of the Metabo would be. This Metabo is
not even the current triple hammer impact. There is a new version out, although I don't want to
pick it up just yet. It is really pricey at $300 for a charger and a battery, which is the same
battery right here. I think it's a bit overpriced for right now for what it is. I'm waiting to find
a deal on that. Once I get a deal on that, I'll definitely get in and get it reviewed.
So for the Makita that I picked to go up against the, you know, this triple hammer impact,
I chose the Makita XDT14. And you can find both of these impact drivers for around the same price.
I would say the Metabo you're going to be able to find maybe a bit cheaper, a little bit easier.
Now I got this Metabo for $50 on eBay. It came just like this. The cool thing was that it
came actually pretty dirty. And what's cool about it is it's IP56 rated. So I got it in from eBay,
came in one day out of the box. I threw it in my kitchen sink, covered it in soap and just
washed it off. Of course I didn't have a battery on that, but wash it off, no big deal. And here
it is. I really love that feature of Metabo being able to just have basically, I wouldn't say,
you know, it's fully waterproof, but it's pretty much there being IP56 rated and it's a really
cool tool. Now I did a whole fence install with the 18-volt Metabo and, you know, it was okay.
I definitely noticed that it was not as powerful as, you know, some of my base model Makitas.
You know, when you're putting in, you know, a couple of screws every couple of minutes,
it gets annoying to have a tool that's not keeping with other tools. That's what I found
with the 18-volt Metabo very quickly. When I was with my helper putting in more screws,
he was using the Makita, he'd be done and I'm still putting in screws for another couple seconds.
It got really annoying really fast. But I will say, trying out the 36-volt Metabo, it definitely
makes a difference. And don't let the, you know, the slight power increase kind of fool you there.
It's definitely adding a larger battery because 18-volt Metabo has just an 18-volt battery,
or sorry, a 3 amp hour battery, whereas the smallest multi-volt battery is going to be a 2.5,
but it's multi-volt, so it's going to be a 5 amp hour at 18-volt. So it definitely
can give you an advantage there. Now, what I'm going to do actually for this test here is I'm
actually not going to use this battery. I'm going to grab one of the larger batteries,
one of the 4 amp hour multi-volt batteries. I want to give this thing the absolute best case
scenario here to do the best possible job. So let's do that. Let's start doing some screws, guys.
All right. So I got it fully charged. This is one of the big 8 amp hours at 18-volt batteries
from Metabo. I got a bunch of these from that free rebate. Really happy with Metabo and that
free rebate deal. That was actually absolutely fantastic. So let's put some screws in, guys,
and see how this thing does. All right. I've got just some regular drywall screws here, guys. I'm
not going to actually time these. I'm just going to use these as more of a demonstration here.
Pretty much any impact driver should be able to put these in relatively quickly.
One thing you're definitely going to notice about these triple-hammer impacts,
what you just heard there, was just the extra bit of impacts that you're going to hear
from a regular two-hammer impact. So let me show that with a Makita here.
And here we go with the Makita.
I'm already stripping that screw out.
Let's grab another screw. All right. Let's go for it with that Makita.
So I don't know if you heard that on that video, but you can definitely hear the less impacts
happening with the Makita versus that Metabo. It's quite noticeable very easily, but that's
just how the triple-hammer impacts work, is that it's going to be impacting more,
but with less power. I like to think about it as like a gearing ratio,
whereas this is going to be in a lower gear, so it's going to be moving slower,
but getting you higher torque with impacts, whereas the Metabo is going to be, say,
in a higher gear, giving you faster impacts, but at a lower torque ratio.
So there's, of course, going to be pros and cons to how that works out,
but it's something that is going to be quite interesting, and depending on what you're doing
with it, it's going to be quite advantageous at certain times. So let's try some larger screws now.
All right. Got a larger drywall screw here. Let's give this thing a shot.
And I'm actually kind of curious to see how this compares to the Makita, so I'm going to time this
one. One, two, three. The Makita. And with the Makita, one, two, three. You know, guys, it's
cool when you think about the Metabo. It's not just an advantage going to the 36-volt version,
but also having that larger battery. I've been proved by a lot of channels that, you know,
that larger amp-hour battery allows a greater amount of power to be drawn from the battery
into the tool, giving you better performance. So really cool to see that. So let's grab something
a little bit bigger. Let's grab a lag bolt. I'm really curious to see how that goes.
I wish the Metabo's had the quick insert collets, but unfortunately they don't.
Not a big deal though, but let's see here with a larger lag bolt. I'm gonna use the exact same
setup on the Makita as well, too. What I'm gonna do is I'm gonna just get this thing started,
and then I'm gonna start the clock. All right. There we go. Just getting started now.
Now let's see how far we can get in with this lag bolt. Three, two, one.
Not bad. Let's see how the Makita does on that test as well. All right. Let's get it in just
enough. There we go. Now let's see how it does compared to that Metabo. About the same distance
the Metabo got it in. Right around the same speed there. But, you know, I will say I don't know the
times right now. Get this out quick. All right, guys. So I don't know the times just yet to edit
the video, but they seem super similar between these two impact drivers. Now, of course, Metabo
is not, you know, winning any, you know, crowns for the fastest impact driver out there. But I
will say if you're gonna buy a Metabo triple hammer, definitely go with the 36 volt. That's
what I learned from this whole, you know, thing between the 18 volt, the 36 volt. We've been
watching some of like the tools and stuff videos where he compares them both. He says it's kind of
the same thing I'm saying where, you know, they're super similar. But, you know, 36 volt definitely
is going to have that advantage. And with this eight ampere battery, I know it is quite bulky,
but they're pretty much just giving away most of the time when they have those free battery
rebates. And this thing will last you, I mean, it could last you days, weeks even with the amount
of battery life you're gonna get from this thing. So really cool to see that. I am definitely
much more impressed. You know, I'm definitely going to use this much more often now, the 36
volt versus the 18 volt. It's just one of those things where, you know, the 18 volt could not
keep up with some of my more basic Makita impacts, whereas the 36 volt definitely is an improvement.
There's a few little things that I still am not a huge fan of when it comes to Metabo. I'm not a
of this, you know, side, you know, selection here of some of the modes. S&P, I mean, I gotta look
that up in the manual to know what that means. You know, I know P is something with like power,
S is something, I'm not sure what they are. Whereas, you know, a lot of the Makita, Milwaukee,
DeWalt stuff, it's super clear to understand. It's, you know, slow, high, you know, it's easy
to understand exactly what that stuff means. But, you know, Metabo is still doing some really,
really cool stuff. It's definitely one of the brands I want to keep a lookout for as we go
into the holiday season, go into the next year. They're slowly releasing power tools. One thing
that I did want to mention that'd be really cool, that they're giving away so many of these, you
know, 8 amp hour batteries. I wish they would release that chainsaw here in the U.S. I mean,
I'm at now at least six of these multi-volt batteries that I've gotten for really, really
cheap. That'd be awesome to have a chainsaw, be able to use these with and really put these to
their full potential. You know, Metabo is kind of one of those brands to watch.
I know this kind of sounds bad, but don't buy the tools at, you know, retail price.
They're always having some deal happening here and there, and it's not always going to be at lows.
Definitely check out, you know, Acme Tools, Tool Nut, Tool Barn. Those guys, you know,
on their Instagrams, they kind of show off, you know, a random tool deal once in a while here,
guys, and some of them are just fantastic. Whereas, you're going to find some of the
clearances on Metabo at lows, and you're going to find just incredible deals. I know I did a recent,
you know, clearance deal on the half-inch impact and the six and a half inch circular saw. Both
those deals I got on clearance, as well as some of the other tools I've got from, like, Amazon,
as well, that were just really cheap. But I will say, to kind of summarize just everything here,
when it comes to Metabo, it's definitely going to be something very similar to, like,
Milwaukee, where a lot of guys are like, you know, if you're going to buy Milwaukee,
buy fuel or buy nothing. When it comes to Metabo, I'm kind of going to say, you know,
buy the multivolt stuff or buy nothing. It's kind of, you know, very similar to that Milwaukee
mentality, where that multivolt stuff is just in a league of its own. This is definitely a
far better tool. Even though you can find it at a relatively similar price, the 18-volt
triple hammer impact, it's definitely going to feel a lot more powerful. I wouldn't say,
you know, a lot more powerful, but definitely going to hold its own against some of the
competitors like Makita, DeWalt, Milwaukee. And this is when you pair it with a multivolt battery,
such as, you know, these basically, you know, the free rebate ones that I've got for
the four amp hour at 36 volts. Just impressive batteries now that are going to give this thing
a lot of power. So, guys, hope you enjoyed the video. Hope this kind of showed you some cool
stuff about Metabo HPT, or as we know it in the rest of the world, as Hikoki. I don't want to get
started on that. I'm not a big fan of the Hikoki name, not so much the Metabo HPT. But, guys,
don't forget to like and subscribe, guys. Take care, guys. Have a good rest of your week,
and thanks for watching.
