Medium Format Portraits after 2 years- Addressing your comments

Photo Camera Landscape Expert
201 followers
#PhotoCamera, #LandscapePhotography, #PhotographyExpert, #NatureShots, #ScenicViews, #OutdoorPhotography, #CameraGear, #LandscapeExpert, #TravelPhotography, #WideAngleShots, #PhotographySkills, #NaturalBeauty, #CameraTips, #PhotographyMastery, #LandscapeLovers
AI Generated·May contain errors
In response to my first video where I discussed my experience with medium format cameras over
a span of two years, I'm making this video because I got absolutely cooked in the comments
and I have to address some of them, okay? In part one, I did a photo shoot with the Hasselblad X2D
up against the Sony A1 and the Canon R5 Mark II, which are two of the best full-frame cameras
available. I then proceeded to compare them and that's where I got absolutely roasted because
I didn't match the white balance in all the photos and look, that's totally fair,
pure laziness on my part, but I do shoot with auto white balance for a reason and I'll explain
why later on. And as a bonus, I'm going to print large. I'm going to take a photo from the medium
format in full frame. I'm going to print it on my new Canon Pro 1100 printer. I'm going to take it
to my boy's house. I'm going to take it to my mom's, all right? We're going to get some different
eyeballs on these photos and I want to see if they can tell the difference between the two.
So let's get started. So this video is not sponsored, but if you want to support me and
my channel and get better at flash at the same time, well, you can check out my off-camera flash
mini course, where I show you how I approach my camera settings and flash power, how I tackle
that harsh afternoon sun, how I find the perfect light placement, how I approach my compositions
and so much more. Link will be down in description. Okay. So the first photo that we're going to
revisit is the one of Samantha with the slit lighting across her face. These are the ones
from the Hasselblad and these are already color corrected. Let me show you how I color correct my
images. So this one is not corrected. This is on the Sony. What I do is just hit the eye dropper
tool. I find the neutral point in the photo where it could be like white. It could be a shirt or
anything here in the background. It's pretty, you know, it's all the same and you'll see the red,
green and blue. You just want that to pretty much be the same or really close to the same number.
So here we've got 9.8, 9.1. I mean, that's pretty close. That's a pretty good match. Yeah. The whites
look. Yeah. That's a pretty good match right there. So that's how I go about finding white
balance. I've been doing this for a while. You guys are probably dissected and tell me
that I'm doing it all wrong, but that's just, it's always worked for me. So on the left,
I have the A7R5 and on the right, I have the Hasselblad X2D. And now because we're doing more
of an apples to apples comparison here, right on the Hasselblad, it always imports as camera
standard in terms of the profile. And that's how I left it in the last video because why change it?
Everything I was just going for more of like, Hey, straight out of camera. This is what you get,
but we're going to just switch it to Adobe color because the Sony is also in Adobe color.
I might ask just the white balance one more time. Cause switching the profile
seemed like it, the image looks a little bit more yellow now. There we go. All right. Both
images are in Adobe color now. Now the big thing that I talked about with medium format, or at
least the thing that I noticed the most was the tonal transitions. I wanted to like, there was
something about that filmic look. Now that the white balance matched up, you know, I can, I can
see it on this screen. I can see there's a, a nice tonal. Just look at across the face into the
hair, into the background. Look at how much more smoother the highlight to shadow roll-off
transition is here on the highlight to the cheek, to the hair, to the backdrop. Look at here.
Yeah. I think a lot of the magic that I'm trying to describe here is all in those mid-tones. You
know, the images feels more real, more lifelike on the medium format. I'm going to switch both
images to camera standard profile. Cause that's how the Hasselblad comes right out of the box.
It always comes camera standard or Adobe standard. So I'm going to switch to Sony and the Hasselblad
and Adobe standard is just a more, it's a more flatter profile with just less contrast. You're
going to notice it here. The colors are less saturated and I'm not going to lie. I think the
Sony looks better in Adobe standard. The thing is that I still see the smoother transitions from
highlight to shadow on the Hasselblad. It still has that filmic quality to it that I love. Now we
have the photo of Julia that I shot in the studio to correct the white balance here. I just, I
zoomed into the white part of her eye and found the neutral spot there. It did a pretty good job
of matching both of them. Now zooming in Sony A1 85 1.4 and on the right you got the Hasselblad.
Both are in Adobe color. Zooming in. I want you to look next to the light streak on her face and
how smooth the transition is going from the shadows on the medium format. You know, it's also
slightly more detailed and all that, but not going to lie here. The full frame is definitely holding
its own with this lighting setup. Comparing to the Sony file that I showed in part one. I mean,
yeah, it's, it's kind of the same thing. The medium format file. Yeah. It's more detailed has,
it has a more of a rich quality to it, but it's only really noticeable when you start to zoom in,
which only goes to show how freaking good these full frame sensors have gotten.
What's impressive this camera, Sony A1, it's a fully stacked sensor created for speed,
and it still could put out top notch image quality, which is something I've been saying
for a long time. But let's just be honest, the straight out of camera colors are kind of ass.
Now for this next one, I'm going to switch it up and I'm going to go to the GFX 100 too. Cause I
used it for this comparison as well against the Sony A7R5. Let's zoom in. I already color corrected
them to match. Let's zoom in to a hundred percent on both. You know what? I think that more than
anything, this is a good example of what micro contrast is, what 3d pop actually looks like.
Sure on medium format, it helps that we have a really good prime lens in front of a hundred
megapixel medium format sensor. But on the Sony side, I'm using arguably their sharpest mid range
zoom lens. I know it's not the same, but on their highest resolution sensor and just look at how
much more flatter the images on the left when compared to the right, look at the subtle details
in the skin on the Fuji. I mean, just right here, look at the bridge of the nose leading to the
under eye, look at all the detail and the colors in contrast here leading to the cheeks and the hair,
the richness, the depth, the Fuji looks absolutely unbelievable here. And I think
partially has to do with medium format, but also a big part of that is the lens as well. So you put
a really good lens in front of your full frame sensor, and you're going to be able to get an
image that looks like this as well. Okay. So I know I said, I was going to print these images
and go to my mom's, go to my friends, see if they could tell the difference, but the reality is
no one is going to be able to tell the difference. So I did my first test prints on the Canon Pro
1100 and oh my God, these files are beautiful. But as you see 17 by 22 is not that large, but
see what I was going to do is crop in on the face really tight. And so that you could really see the
details of the image, but the reality is nobody, nobody's going to be able to tell the difference
between these files. These cameras are just too high resolution. You're going to need to blow
these. You're going to have to blow them up for anyone to see any difference. So I am going to
abandon this plan. Now I want to quickly address some of the comments in my previous video,
talking about, you know, or like why I shoot auto white balance. And there is no good reason.
There is no good reason for that. I think that it's just the type of person that I am. I just
like to keep things as simple as possible. Like when I'm shooting at the studio, I'm tunnel vision
locked in when I have another human being in front of me and I'm using lights and I'm filming myself.
I'm all over the place. I'm not worried about the gray card that's sitting on my shelf over there
because it takes three seconds to adjust my white balance in post and I'm already mentally
scrambled. I'm everywhere. But that's still not a good enough excuse. You know, it's just a bad
habit of mine. It was funny is that I'm a perfectionist with almost everything else.
But with this, I kind of overlook it because it doesn't make sense ever shooting auto white
balance in a studio. We have all the most advanced cameras and they all suck in the studio. They do
pretty good job outdoors. The studio will always trick a camera in its auto white balance. So now
that still doesn't explain why I didn't just color correct the photos for the video. And I could have
done that. But, again, I tried to take the approach of approaching this from a non-technical
perspective, like I said in the beginning. But who am I kidding? You can't approach this from
a non-technical way, especially if I'm talking about tonal transitions, which inevitably will
lead me into color science and all that. And so, yeah, I should have definitely compared them.
You know, I've done this before, actually. I've done a whole color science video that never saw
the light of day because I shot with every system and even though I was matching the white balances,
I was still getting off. There were some that appeared more green than these and it still
required me to like match them in post. And I was just like, well, what's the point of putting so
much work into trying to get apples to apples comparison when I'm still going to have to do
some correcting? And I was just trying to avoid that. That's a bad look. But you know what? At
the end of the day, I hope that part one and this video helps you understand a little bit more of
the nuances of medium format and when people talk about the medium format look,
what that consists of. It gets really nuanced and there's so many videos out there on that. And
personally, I don't really like getting into all this technical stuff because I'm
the first person to tell you that all this stuff don't matter. All this technical,
this stuff doesn't really matter at the end of the day. Like I'll get into it and I like to,
I want you guys to see what I see, but none of this ---- matters. Lighting, posing, composition
is what actually matters. I could have shot the same photo with the crop sensor camera and I still
would have picked it simply because of her pose. Her head was tilted a little bit differently. Her
head was down, her chin down a little bit and the light was falling on her face nicely on the Sony.
I'm choosing a Sony over the Hasselblad any day of the week. This is what actually matters. Doesn't
matter the camera, the lens, it matters. All the other things matter more. The lighting,
composition, posing, this is what actually matters. So, you know, I got to get back to
doing what I do best. I feel like I thrive better when speaking about technique and lighting.
That is where I thrive on the technical aspect, on the technical side. I mean, I feel like I'm
pretty proficient, but my audience, y'all, you guys are on a different level. You guys are
really, you guys got it down. You know, maybe this is part of the, this is what happens when
you don't go to school for photography. You just kind of do everything and learn everything on
your own. I'm just not, I feel like I'm a pretty technical photographer, but I'm not
as technical as some of you guys out there. But I'm just grateful that the technique aspect,
again, just the actual technique is something that I feel I'm pretty strong at. And at the
end of the day, again, that's what actually matters. All this, I don't want to argue about
pixel peeping and this and that, you know, for medium format, you have to be able to appreciate
the details, the nuances of these files. If that is something that you're not interested in and
you don't see value in that, there's no reason. There's no reason to spend more money and get
into something like this. I could care less what you shoot. I don't care. There's nothing,
there's nothing in it for me to, you know, if I can give you my best advice, if you're still
shooting full frame, you're shooting a really good full frame camera and you want to get this look,
you want to get this 3D look that I get on medium format with these lenses in combination,
get yourself a lens that has the characteristics that I was talking about, right? Like micro
contrast that has that ability to capture an image in a non-sterile way. Because a lot of
full frame lenses nowadays are just made to be so perfect that it just renders a more of a flat
image. And not everybody will notice these things. But when you're zooming into images like I am and
really paying attention to the details, getting a lens that has these characteristics on a full
frame camera, you're going to be, I mean, it's going to be really hard to, you know, really
tell the difference between that in a medium format file at the end of the day, especially
after exporting. So that is all I have to say about that. I need to get my butt back
in doing actual photography because FOMO hits me really hard. I see all this new gear coming out.
I feel like I need to be in front. I feel like I need to do something with it.
But it's not something that brings me joy at the end of the day. You know, I'll put out a video and
I'm just like, I never want to look at this thing ever again. Because I know what actually matters
to me. And it's this stuff, portraits, lighting. This is what like fuels me. I got to get back
into it, man. I got to do more consistently. Yeah. All right, man. I'll talk to you later.
