Why You Can’t See Your Own Value

Educational Channel
424 followers
Chapters
00:00 Recap, and Why Self-Esteem Enters the Picture
03:29 Where Self-Esteem Came From: William James
07:49 The Self-Esteem Movement and the California Experiment
12:58 The Praise Trap: Rewarding Who You Are vs. What You Do
19:09 Why the Self-Esteem Movement Backfired
28:29 How You Actually Build Generalized Confidence
30:54 Meta Self-Efficacy: Trusting You Can Cope
32:16 Building From Scratch: The Spanx Story
41:11 Uncertainty, Control, and Tying It Together
#Confidence #SelfEsteem #markmanson #psychology
AI Generated·May contain errors
So a quick recap up to this point. In chapter one we talked about how most self-help advice
gets confidence completely backwards. This is the Peel Fallacy. This idea that you need to
feel confident or believe that you're confident before you can actually perform well. Turns out
that's not true. In chapter two we learned it's actually the reverse. You have to perform well
and that's what builds confidence. Confidence is the output, not the input, of high performance.
But there are a couple caveats to that building of confidence. For one, confidence is domain
specific. Two, you have to build that evidence but that evidence has to be rooted in reality.
And then in chapter three we learned about all of the ways that we
misinterpret reality, let's say. We are miscalibrated towards reality. We overestimate
ourselves in some situations because of our ignorance. We underestimate ourselves in other
situations because we just assume that we got lucky or that we're in the right place at the
right time. And then of course there's all sorts of social comparison aspects, different narcissistic
tendencies that can warp our perception of how good we are at something. And that can give the
illusion of confidence. Now that last point is really important because in this chapter we're
going to take a little bit of a detour to talk about self-esteem because self-esteem is very
relevant to this discussion of confidence. And up until this point we've really been shitting on
the self-help industry and traditional self-help advice and the peel fallacy and how it's gotten
it backwards. But it turns out that conventional psychology also got this backwards for a good
60 or 70 years as well. And their version of getting this backwards was the self-esteem movement.
So I want to take a few minutes and just kind of briefly catch our listeners up on what self-esteem
is, where the idea came from, how prevalent it became for a number of decades, how it infiltrated
public policy quite a bit, and what the repercussions of those mistakes ended up being.
Because it's going to relate back to a lot of this discussion of confidence that we've had.
The concept of self-esteem goes all the way back to the early days of psychology. I think from the
beginning everybody kind of had this intuitive sense that people seem to have a relationship
with themselves. And if you have a good relationship with yourself, where if you tend to have positive
feelings and thoughts about yourself, you probably are doing better in life. Versus if you have bad
thoughts and feelings about yourself. William James was one of the first people that really
tried to pin down this concept and put a framework around it. And he simply defined
self-esteem as your successes divided by your pretensions. Essentially what you achieved
divided by what you expect of yourself. And so if you have insanely irrationally high expectations
of yourself, you're probably going to feel bad about yourself quite often. Whereas if you have
very low expectations for yourself, and you actually achieve quite a bit, you're going to
feel very good about yourself. Now this little equation, it's fun, but I think it's more
descriptive than prescriptive. It doesn't really tell us what to do, right? Does it mean we should
have low expectations for ourselves? I don't know if that's necessarily the case. Does it tell us
that we should go out and achieve as much as possible? I don't know if that's necessarily
great advice either. The thing that William James intuitively got correct was that he saw self-esteem
as an output of your actions and behaviors, not an input of your actions and behaviors.
As we're going to see, this is going to change pretty soon. Because the next generation of
psychologists came along, starting with Carl Rogers in the 40s and 50s. And Carl Rogers,
you know, Rogerian therapy, we've talked about on some previous episodes, you know,
his big thing was this concept of unconditional positive regard. So what he noticed in his
clinical practices is that generally people who came in with a lot of problems, there was an
intense amount of self-judgment and an intense amount of shame. And they seemed extremely
critical about themselves and often in very irrational and unfair ways towards themselves.
And so Carl Rogers was just very focused on getting people to accept themselves, right? Like
just tolerate their own flaws and faults. And sure enough, he discovered that if you were able to do
this, it then seemed to free people up to actually improve their lives in some meaningful way.
Now, around the same time, Abraham Maslow was doing his early work around humanistic psychology
and he was playing around with different hierarchies of psychological needs. You know,
most people at this point are pretty familiar with Maslow's pyramid. It turns out the pyramid is not
very empirical. It was just kind of a throwaway framework that he jotted down in a notebook,
but that's a podcast for another day. But Maslow was the first person who really put
self-esteem as a need. And not only that, but he put it like pretty high in the hierarchy.
And so he saw it as a prerequisite to high human functioning. And I think this is,
him and Rogers are kind of the first point where you see this argument of like, no,
self-esteem is not the result of living a good life. It is necessary to live a good life. And
so this is where the Peale fallacy creeps in. And I have not seen any direct evidence that Norman
Vincent Peale pulled from Maslow and Rogers, but Maslow and Rogers were prominent and doing a lot
of their work in the 1940s when Peale was going through all of his insecurities and anxieties.
So it would not surprise me if Peale kind of pulled his framework off of Maslow and Rogers
and then popularized it to the mainstream. Yeah. Either way, it was kind of in a zeitgeist,
right? Yeah. That was just kind of the thought that was coming up in the culture for sure.
So once we get into the 1950s, you start getting into some of the work by Nathaniel Brandon,
and he wrote a very popular book called The Six Pillars of Self-Esteem. And this is where you
really see the concept just take hold. And Brandon and a number of researchers and psychologists
around him really strongly believed that if you could just make people feel good about themselves,
then you would see all sorts of good positive outcomes happen as a downstream effect of that.
It was really just the Rogerian idea of unconditional positive self-regard on
steroids to the point where there was a strong moral inclination of like,
we should be implementing this into schools. We should be implementing this into prisons.
This should be part of our public policies, like giving people high self-esteem, making sure that
everybody in society feels good about themselves. So then that will enable them to go out and
achieve great things. And so by the time you get to the 1970s and 80s, this is just the water that
everybody's swimming in. Self-esteem and the peel fallacy, not only is it dominating the personal
growth and self-help spaces, it is now just kind of accepted orthodoxy of psychologists and is being
aggressively pushed into public policy. So one simple example of this is that in the 1980s,
there was a California assemblyman by the name of John Vasconcellos, and he was the chairman of the
Ways and Means Committee and controlled the entire California educational state budget.
Now Vasconcellos became a bit of a self-help junkie. He attended Esalen Institute. He got
really into the human potential movement. I believe he went to like a Wayne Dyer seminar
or something, and he just got completely converted. He was like, this changed my life.
Everybody needs to do this. And he actually had quite a bit of power in the state of California
to implement a lot of these changes. So in 1986, he managed to create the California Task Force
to Promote Self-Esteem and Personal and Social Responsibility. God, you got to love bureaucrat.
These names, so good. So this task force commissioned UC professors to research the
link between self-esteem and six social problems, crime, drug abuse, teen pregnancy,
child abuse, welfare dependency, and academic failure. And so the California state system
started implementing this research. They started really digging into everything and really trying
to see where these interventions helped and what sort of difference they were making.
So the researchers studied for over three years, and they found nothing. There was no link. There
was no connection. There was no causation. They couldn't find anything. The problem was,
was that the guy who controlled their budget wanted there to be a link. He had basically
staked his career on there being a connection between self-esteem and all these pro-social
outcomes. So in 1989, the task force published its public report and the press release declared
a strong relationship between self-esteem and social problems had been, quote unquote,
definitely confirmed. The statement itself was false. It did not reflect the data accurately.
The researchers who allowed it to go through knew it was false, but they also knew Vasconcellos
controlled the University of California state budget. This was crazy. I didn't know that. I
knew that the self-esteem movement started in California. I've heard that story. I did not know
there was like a systematic kind of papering over of the actual results at the time. They knew it
was false and they kept pushing it. That's wild. This is one of the few times that political
corruption has intersected with psychology and actually had a very real impact and effect
on the world. This task force report from California, it went on to become the best
selling state document in history. It sold over 60,000 copies. Vasconcellos became a
national celebrity. He went on countless talk shows. More than 40 California counties formed
their own self-esteem task forces. The ripple effects lasted for decades. What it did is it
validated the hypothesis, which had been around since the 60s. If you could just make people feel
good about themselves, then they would perform highly as a result. It's the peel fallacy all
over again. It's one thing to be like peel and write a book about it. It's another to be a
government official and like, this is our policy, institute it and scale it to that degree and
institutionalize it. That's what I just found wild. They did it knowing that it wasn't actually
true, that it didn't actually work. I don't know about you. We talked a little bit earlier in the
episode. You said that you didn't feel like this stuff was pushed on you. I didn't feel like it
shoved down my throat in that way. I do remember the grade inflation stuff. That I do remember
being a thing. When I was in middle school, everybody's getting A's and B's. This is weird.
So I do remember that. We had great inflation. We had participation trophies. I remember I was
horrible at sports and I got a trophy for everything I did, which I remember at the time
just thinking it was ridiculous. I'm like, why are they giving me a trophy? I don't even want
to be here. This also could have just been the water I swam in though too. There was a lot of
positive regard around it. Because I do remember there were definitely adults around me saying,
oh, you kids are so coddled these days. I do remember that. But I just don't remember it
being shoved down my throat. Everybody's special and everything like that. Grade inflation was
definitely there. There was a lot of that. So I very specifically, because I was an
underachiever in school, and I very specifically remember my teachers telling me that I could do
anything I wanted, that I was brilliant, anything I dreamed I could accomplish. I just had to
believe in myself. I remember going to school counselors and they were telling me.
You have assembly speakers come and stuff? I do remember that. Okay, maybe I'm misremembering
this a little bit because I remember this now. There was motivational speakers who would come
to our school. Yeah, we had motivational speakers come. I remember there was tons of stuff.
Yeah, okay. I might be misremembering this a little bit. I think it was a little bit since
I was a kid. I didn't know what came before that. And to tie this back into some of the
we talked about earlier, right, about the link between performance and confidence,
remember adults, if you make them feel better about themselves, they will perform a little bit
better. Kids, they will not. And in fact, what you find with children, and this is actually a
very important point for the parents out there, when you are trying to motivate and validate your
kids, it's very important that you validate them for things that they've done, not for things that
are. Because if you tell a kid, you're so smart, you're so great, you can do anything,
and they haven't done anything, what you're actually subtly doing is you're creating an
incentive for them to not do anything. Because they're already being rewarded for just existing.
And so if they actually try and fail, then they risk losing what they already have.
Whereas if you only validate them for the things that they try,
then you create an incentive for them to keep trying new things. And this is really important.
You see it come up a lot with gifted children. I did a YouTube video on this last year,
but there's some really interesting research around kids who are particularly talented or
gifted. It's very common that they get validated way too much when they're young.
And so what happens is that they actually become demotivated. Because obviously,
when you're young, anything you try to learn, you're going to fail at. You're going to be bad
at first. And so if you're one of these kids that is just always being told how great you are
without doing anything, then you actually develop some neuroses around trying and failing. You just
kind of become a sloth. Right. Yeah. Or perfectionism takes over to the point where
you don't act and don't take those risks. And yeah. Yeah. You see that a lot.
Stay right there. More solved coming up after this. This episode is brought to you by Shopify.
We treat confidence like it's a prerequisite to starting something, but usually it's the other
way around. You start and then the confidence later catches up. Take starting a business,
for example. Most people, they never even start because the list of reasons not to
outlast their nerve. Now Shopify clears that list and makes it easy to make things happen.
Everything you need to start selling is ready from day one. And it especially helps with the
moment that somebody goes to pay you for the first time. This is where a lot of sales quietly die,
but Shopify checkout gets more of them across the line and more returning customers' details
are already saved. It's just one tap and it's done. And because Shopify runs everything from
setup to checkout, you can focus on what actually matters, growing the damn thing,
making a better product. And you have all the tools to do it. With Shopify,
nothing stands between your idea and a real business. So go make it one. Start your free
trial at shopify.com slash solved. That's shopify.com slash solved. Start your free trial
at shopify.com slash solved. All right, we're back. Let's jump back into it.
So yeah, we kind of forget now, but it is hard to overstate how big the self-esteem movement
got. Not only did it comprise the entire self-help industry and personal growth industry,
by the mid nineties, it's a multi-billion dollar industry. But we're talking about
education systems across the Western world. We're talking about public policy. We're talking about
government bureaucracies are being created. NGOs are being created. You're talking about
prison systems, correctional systems, corporate programs, seminars, billions and billions of
dollars, tens of thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands of jobs are hinging on this idea that
if you can make people feel good, they will perform better. The problem was, is that the academics
quietly knew the math was not mapping. The data was not lining up. There was not much strong
evidence going on. So around the year 2000, the Association for Psychological Science
decided that somebody needed to get to the bottom of this. Somebody needed to really figure this
out. And so they tapped a researcher by the name of Roy Balmeister at the University of Florida
State. And Balmeister is a superstar. You and I are both fanboys of him. Anybody who's like,
if you're a psychologist listening to this, you probably know who Balmeister is.
And if you're not, you probably don't. But Balmeister is a bit of a badass. And he was
tapped by the Association of Psychological Science and basically told like, look, you have all the
resources you need. We'll give you all the researchers you need to help you get to the
bottom of this, figure this out, like get the data right and come back to us with what the reality
is, what the effect sizes are. And it's worth noting that Balmeister himself fully subscribed
to self-esteem. He was completely bought into the movement, totally bought into the idea that you
need to make people feel better about themselves. And so he took the project on with a lot of pride
and gusto. And over the next few years, what he found was basically a nuclear bomb to the
self-esteem movement. He published a paper in 2003 and the results pretty much just murdered
the self-esteem movement, like shot it in the ******* face. And it has been dead ever since.
Yeah. Yeah. I shot it dead in its tracks more or less. And then it basically said what we
already knew about it. That self-esteem really is largely an outcome of success, not the input,
not the cause of it. Artificially inflating it, like you said, especially in children,
doesn't produce better outcomes, doesn't produce achievement. It actually a lot of times does the
opposite, like we've talked about. There were two tiny effects that did survive kind of the scrutiny
of it though. One of them was just kind of people with higher self-esteem were a little bit happier
and they were a bit more likely to just take action on things like behavioral activation type
things. But the quote from Baumeister was, it fell short of what many psychologists had hoped
for, including himself, like you said. So he took a very honest look at this and up to that point,
he kind of thought that for the past 30, 40, 50, 60 years, this has been the holy grail of
psychology is finding a way to get people to feel better about himself. And he just flat out admitted
like, no, that's actually wrong. He also found though too, interestingly, which we've kind of
already talked about, a connection to narcissism. High self-esteem they found was actually
positively associated with a lot of narcissistic traits. And not only that, but when ego is
threatened under these circumstances, aggression became actually a lot more common. So somebody who
was very high self-esteem staked a lot of their identity on something and you threatened them,
they were much more likely to become aggressive out of this. I believe they even did some of these
studies in prison populations. You think about this a little bit, just think about it. If you go
into a prison, you're probably actually going to find a lot of people who are very high in
self-esteem. They think a lot about themselves. And they're also very, very aggressive if you
threaten their self-esteem in any way, threaten their identity in any way. Baumeister was one of
the first ones to really find that connection there. The conclusion that they really came to
though out of this was that it wasn't the level of self-regard that you have, the level of
self-esteem that you had that predicted the problems, but like whether or not it was anchored
to anything real, which is exactly what we've been talking about this whole time, that evidence
building, that mastery experience that you have. If you can link your self-regard and your self-worth
to something that's actually real in the real world that you've done, that's a more durable
form of self-esteem and that you don't get all the aggression and everything with it. If you
just pump up self-esteem and don't anchor it to anything real, it becomes very fragile at that
point and turns into narcissism. So this is kind of what they found in the early 2000s when they
started doing all that. There was another set of researchers too, another couple of them, Crocker
and Knight. They basically found that same thing and they said self-esteem, it wasn't about the
level that you had, it wasn't how much you had, but what you staked it on, what you staked your
self-esteem on. So if you tie your self-esteem, if you tie your self-worth to a specific domain,
then any threat to that domain is also a threat on you. This is where you get a lot of people
coming back at you and it can turn into aggression at some point, actual physical aggression at some
point. What they found is just even ordinary feedback, if you've placed all your self-esteem
in this one area and you get ordinary feedback from it, you'll get very defensive with it too.
I don't know about you, but there's definitely been times in the past where I staked a lot of
my self-esteem on being the smart kid or whatever. I was good in school and went to grad school and
had this whole identity around being smart and any perceived slight of my intelligence,
I would get incredibly defensive about it and even lash out at people sometimes too or just be like,
oh, **** you, you're dumb, whatever, you don't know what you're talking about. I had to really
sit and wrestle with that for a long time. It's interesting because by my definition,
that's not self-esteem. If you're having to defend yourself all the time-
You don't have a whole lot of self-esteem around you.
You clearly don't feel great about yourself. Maybe at some point we'll do an episode on
self-esteem, but I've always felt like one of the core issues of self-esteem has just been a
definition problem and a measurement problem. It is interesting because if you do go back to some
of those original researchers and writers in the 50s and 60s, they did define it in a much more
holistic way or they tried to at least. If you go back and read Nathaniel Brandon, he talked about
self-esteem is it really is a comfort with yourself even when things are not going well.
It is a willingness to be different or be rejected or to have your ideas not accepted because you
feel comfortable enough with yourself. This is often the difficulty with psychology is that
when it comes time to measure things, it's very difficult to measure psychological processes and
psychological experiences. To get some form of measurement, you have to boil things down into a
simple survey. Once you water it down into a survey question, you dilute the concept and you
make it a little bit of a caricature or a cartoon version of what the original philosophical claim
was. With Carl Rogers or Maslow or Young, they were not advocating for an unrealistic form of
self-esteem. They were trying to get at there needs to be something here that you can rely on,
that you can lean on. Can I go on a tangent really quick? I'll allow it.
I mean, we're already on a tangent. This comes up a lot. There's a lot of discourse these days
around therapy culture. One of the more intelligent things I've seen written about it
came from a writer named Freddie DeBoer. He basically made the argument, he said that
therapy concepts, there's a certain class of ideas and concepts that are very good and healthy on an
individual level, but they become unhealthy on a social level. I could see self-esteem being one
of those things. When you think about Carl Rogers, I have a lot of sympathy and understanding for
where he was coming from. He was a clinical psychologist. He's working with individual
people. People are coming to him with massive life issues, huge crises going on in their lives.
They're probably coming in being unbelievably harsh on themselves. Of course, he rightly observed,
which I think all of us have observed the same thing. All of us know somebody in our lives that
is irrationally hard on themselves and makes themselves miserable quite frequently because
of the amount of self-judgment that they have. I think Carl Rogers was just making a very obvious
observation of like, hey, dude, you shouldn't do that so much. You should give yourself a break.
Have some love. When your partner fucks up, you don't scream at them for every little
error that they make. You have some compassion. You forgive them. You tell them it's going to be
all right. You look at the better sides of their personality. Why don't you do that for yourself?
That was it. I think with the self-esteem movement is they tried to take that concept that was true
in the micro and then make a macro version of it. It's like, well, let's just make everybody feel
great about themselves because then clearly it will map well onto society. I just think it's one
of those concepts that it just doesn't work that way. You can't scale it.
It was the same kind of thing with Peel, where he's like, this worked for me,
so it should work for everybody, right? Same thing.
Same fallacy.
Yeah. Whatever it is, a technique, a therapeutic modality, whatever it is,
working on the individual level, once you scale it, then it just gets perverted.
That's a definitional problem, I think, too, because everybody has a different definition
of it, like you said. That's an interesting little tangent we went on. I'm glad I allowed it.
You should feel good about yourself for allowing that.
Where this gets into problems, though, too, so the Crocker and Knight, the whole thing around
staking your self-esteem on a single domain somewhere. You've also talked about this before,
too, about diversifying your identity. If you do stake your identity on too many things,
this is something I definitely realized where a long time I was just like,
I got to be a smart person or whatever it is. That's a very fragile way to live. Maybe there's
relationships you need to stake your identity on as well. Maybe there's other areas. Maybe
there's hobbies. Maybe there's whatever. The problems you run into, though, Crocker and
Knight, they identified several areas. The two big ones, though, really were learning and
relationships. When you're learning something, you're staking a lot of your identity on that.
Any setbacks on that are considered huge catastrophic failures at that point. Then
you're stupid, or you can't learn, or you can't do this. You're incompetent. Again,
it's just like a catastrophic failure on your part. The other one is relationships, though,
too, because at that point, what you're doing is you're staking your self-esteem on all of
that external validation, which we've already talked about, too. You're looking for an external
source of a little drip of validation. When you don't get that, boom, that's also a catastrophic
failure of your identity around that. There's kind of a metabolic tax to it, too, that they've
come across. If your self-image needs this constant defending, there's a low-grade vigilance that's
going on. You're always on guard, and you're always looking for some external way to get
that validation. It's exhausting. Self-esteem is definitely not what it's cracked up to be,
but that's what we found. Again, it's the side effect of getting things right. It's not the
cause. We were raised to believe that self-esteem was something that we could be given. We could be
it through trophies, compliments, encouragement, great inflation. What nobody actually told us is
that self-esteem that isn't earned doesn't stick. People can tell us all the best things in the
world about ourselves, but if we didn't do anything to be told that, it's not actually
going to help us. It's not actually going to make us feel better about ourselves.
It turns out, in many ways, this can backfire. That backfiring explains, I think, a lot of the
problems that the last few generations have grown up with. We've taken the self-esteem detour,
and I think that's useful as context for what we're going to explain in the rest of this chapter,
which is how you actually do build that generalized confidence. If you can't delude
yourself into feeling confident, as we saw with the Peel Fallacy and the self-esteem movement,
how the **** is it that some people just seem to be so self-assured in so many situations?
There are generally confident people in the world. We've all met them. We've all been around them.
Maybe there have been times in our lives that we've felt that way ourselves.
Where does that come from? How do we get it? If self-esteem is not the way we get it,
if the Peel Fallacy is not the way we get it, how do we actually get it?
Bandura came back to save the day. In the late 2000s, I think around 2007, 2008,
Bandura returned to the concept of self-efficacy, but he added to it. He found a broader, more
widely applicable version of self-efficacy. Now, we talked earlier, Drew, about me not patting
myself on the back too much, but can I just take a victory lap on this one?
I wrote something probably about 12, 13 years ago. I think it started as a viral article. Since then,
I post it on social media all the time. One of the drums that I bang on frequently is I say,
confidence is not an expectation of success. Confidence is a comfort with failure.
That is exactly what Bandura found. That generalized confidence,
it is not feeling like you're going to succeed in every domain you go into.
Generalized confidence is a comfort with failure and setback, no matter what you do.
One way to think about this is Bandura's original finding was that self-efficacy
or confidence can be built only within a domain, but that domain can be a lot of different things.
That domain, it could be woodworking, it could be music, it could be relationship skills,
it could be your career path, it could also be managing failure. You could treat managing failure
as a skill that you can develop confidence in. Almost magically, if you choose that skill to
build confidence around, a tolerance of failure, that makes you confident across the board.
That is what allows you to walk into any room and feel self-assured and not worry what's going to
happen to you because you know you can handle the worst case situation. Bandura called this
coping self-efficacy. I like to think of it as meta self-efficacy because it's almost like
if you and I have been drilling towards the core of what confidence is, I think we have now just
entered the core. This is the base level that if you want to feel confidence across a wide span
of areas and experiences in your life, the way to do that is to become comfortable and
develop self-efficacy around the tolerance of failure, around the tolerance of challenge and
setback. This is not new. Once you get into accepting and embracing failure, now you're
calling back to the ancient Greeks and Romans. This is stuff that's been around for thousands
of years. Obviously, any process of learning requires a certain degree of failure. Any
process of growth requires a certain degree of failure. Acceptance and tolerance of failure is
what drives humility. It's what drives compassion. It's what drives forgiveness. So many of the
classic virtues of the Western world are rooted in a tolerance for failure and an ability to manage
and overcome failure. When we were doing research, the best example I came across
of a process to build this meta self-efficacy is there's a great story about Sarah Blakely,
who's the founder of Spanx, a billion-dollar company. Blakely had zero entrepreneurial
experience before she started the business. She had sold fax machines door-to-door for seven years.
She had faced constant rejection. She had no experience in fashion. She had no experience in
clothing or textile. She had no business degree, no connections, no venture capital. She had never
started a business before. All she did is one day, she cut off the feet of her pantyhose,
wore them under white pants to a party, and realized that she had found a gap in the market,
that a bunch of women were really interested and excited about this super simple thing.
She called dozens of hosiery mills. She was turned down by every single one.
Then finally, she convinced one to make a prototype. From there, the rest is history.
The interesting thing about Blakely, there's this anecdote that she tells from her childhood
that's super fascinating, which is that every day that she came home from school, most parents,
I don't know if your parents did this, but mine certainly did not. Most parents, though,
when kids come home from school, the question they ask is, what did you do at school today?
Her father asked a different question. He said, what did you fail at today? Every single day.
She had to come home and tell him something that she tried and failed at. What this did was it
conditioned into her brain that failure is completely normal and okay, and actually that
that is what you get rewarded for in life. First of all, I'm trying to imagine my parents
asking me this question, and I can't even visualize it. Second of all, I'm trying to
imagine what the hell I would say to them. My parents would say, tell me one good thing
that happened today. It's all the positive thinking. I do like to say when I go skiing
with my friends, I joke a little bit and I say, if you don't eat ---- at least once,
you're not going hard enough. Terrible advice. Don't take that. You're going to hurt yourself.
The spirit behind that idea is definitely there. It's a weird upbringing she had for that.
It's not a normal thing. Very weird. I imagine this mindset's pretty common in athletics.
I could see coaches trying to really foster this in athletes, but other than athletics,
I really think business is the only area that you see this widely encouraged. I remember very early
on in my career where I was very much struggling to get by, was not making much money trying to
launch products, sell products. Nobody was buying anything. I remember going to a seminar,
and this guy got up on stage and he said that if 5% of your customers are not asking for a refund,
you're not selling hard enough. That blew my ******* mind. Blew my ******* mind. I was like,
----. Yeah, I'm not doing anything. I don't know. I have personally found,
and I do think in many ways, business is often a very great proxy for personal growth and
development because it has the financial stakes, obviously. It's like you ******* care. At the end
of the day, you **** your ego. If you're losing money, you just have to leave your ego at the
door. It is ruthless in making you reevaluate a lot of your own emotional assumptions and
dispositions. Learning how to accept that what you thought was true is just not true at all.
I agree definitely with that. I think it's more accepted in that community and it hasn't gotten
really as distributed throughout other parts of society and culture. We talked about the loop
back in chapter two, the competence loop, getting that started. There's that chicken and the egg
thing. The obstacle to getting that started is rarely the belief in the skill. A lot of times,
you're like, yeah, I could probably do that, but really what it is is like, but what if I fail?
I can probably figure that out over time, but a lot of people, including myself with a lot of
things, it's like, I'm not sure I could handle the failure around this. You're right. There's
a high tolerance for that in the business community, in the entrepreneurial community,
for whatever reason, and athletics too. For whatever reason, it just hasn't spread to the
other parts. For instance, if you grow up in a really difficult background, there's no margin
for error. That's true. That's a good point. That's a very good point. I think about how my
wife grew up. She had zero margin for error. She couldn't afford to fail a test or miss a week of
school. It could be catastrophic. Yeah. Not only that, but actually too, if we think about it,
the default kind of is to just not go there, right? Inaction is kind of the default for a good
reason. It's less risky. Not taking the risk is actually the better option just from a survival
standpoint. Inaction really, it's not a character flaw. It's kind of what we do. We have to learn
to be okay with failure. It's not the other way around. Remember all the research on learned
helplessness? Yeah. Back in the, what was this? The 50s and 60s. It was the 60s. Yeah. They did
the research on that. That was Martin Seligman actually too, another famous psychologist.
What they found, I don't know how far you want to get into this. It was the dog study though,
where they- Yeah, where they shocked dogs randomly and they found that if it was
unpredictable when the dogs would be punished, that they just gave up.
Yeah. That's what the conclusion they made was like, oh, if the dogs didn't know,
they're just uncertain, unpredictable. They couldn't figure out what was going to, they
couldn't predict what was going to happen. They would just give up. In the mid 2010s,
they actually came back and they said, actually, we got that backwards. The default is to just not
do anything. We actually have to learn that- To do something.
To do something in the face of failure and uncertainty. Yeah.
So they had that backwards for like 50 years. If I can bring Maslow back for a second,
this just occurred to me, listening to you talk. Let's just accept at face value Maslow's hierarchy,
which I don't think either of us totally buys into Maslow's hierarchy. I don't think even
Maslow bought into Maslow's hierarchy. Just the pyramid actually wasn't his
invention. That was a marketing thing in the 60s and 70s that came out.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Anyway. It was also, it was a concept that was revived after he died
that he never published himself and he probably never published it because he didn't put a whole
lot of weight on it. It was an idea.
It was just an idea. It's like a throwaway idea that he had. To bring back Maslow's pyramid,
because I do think there's enough truth in it that it can be useful to think about.
If you think about the lower levels of his pyramid, like physiological needs, safety needs,
and then community or connection needs, those you can't really risk losing.
Those are very high stakes things. Those also kind of become the safety net for you to take
risks in other areas of your life. If you do have a stable environment with a loving family
and a strong network of friends who can support you and take care of you, that liberates you
to take more risks and become more tolerant of failure, which then builds confidence and
self-advocacy and self-esteem, all the great things. If you don't have those things in the
first place, it's actually irrational to risk your financial stability to become comfortable
with failure. We talked about this in the purpose debate we did, too, a little bit.
Yeah, yeah. My friend Scott Barry Kaufman has revised Maslow's hierarchy. He revised it into
a sailboat, but he basically made this differentiation. He said there is a fundamental
difference between the lower levels of the pyramid and the upper levels of the pyramid,
which is that the lower levels of the pyramid are protective. You have to have them. If you
don't have them, you will suffer and be miserable, whereas the upper levels of the pyramid are
optional, but they are optimal. They help you flourish. You don't need them, but by pursuing
them, they help you flourish. That would be your esteem and your self-actualization and your sense
of purpose and all that stuff. Anyway, that's just something that occurred to me. I don't want
to say self-esteem is a privilege because that feels like it's probably going too far, but it's
if you have the opportunity and the safety net in your life that you can tolerate a lot of failures,
to a certain extent, that is a privilege position.
Yeah. There's probably some people who can do it without that, but most people are not like that.
That makes sense to me. Okay, so we kind of just established that meta-self-efficacy
is actually a domain-specific competence around failure, right? I actually think it's broader
than that though. I think it actually has to do more with uncertainty. You're good at sitting
with uncertainty, which in failure has a lot of uncertainty around it, right?
That's very Buddhist of you, Drew Birney.
Well, hear me out. There's a really rich literature around what they call the intolerance
of uncertainty with this too, okay? Now, intolerance of uncertainty, there's cognitive,
there's emotional, there's behavioral aspects to it. You think uncertainty is a bad thing.
It's a stressful, bad thing, right? It's unfair, it's dangerous, whatever.
So right there, you've already kind of pigeonholed yourself into
a certain way of dealing with this, right? You have an emotional response to that too,
an aversive emotional response. You're anxious about uncertain things.
What might happen.
What might happen, and oh my God, there's a million horrible things that could go wrong
in this situation, right? But then you also have all these behavioral responses to that. So
what that does, you have those cognitive distortions, you have those emotional reactions
to it, and that motivates you to engage in a bunch of coping mechanisms around uncertainty
that actually just end up making it worse, right? So for instance, there's excessive
information seeking. Somebody who goes out and researches for whatever, months before they can
buy a carpet or a rug or something like that, right? Then you have reassurance seeking. That's
a big one. If you're not confident in a relationship, you go to the person, you keep
seeking reassurance from them. You avoid the decision altogether, maybe. You keep checking
on things. You premature commitment to the safest option. You just see, okay, that's
the highest certainty option. I'm going to go with that, even if that's not the best situation
or the best decision in that situation, right? Each one of those, okay? Each one of those
behaviors that you do, they give you short-term relief from that anxiety of the uncertainty,
right? But it actually prevents you from discovering that you would have just been
fine without having that certainty. Wait. So, okay. That's actually really interesting.
So back in chapter two, we talked about the mechanism of building self-efficacy. There
were a few factors that were involved in one of which was you needed to be at the edge of
your capability. And then the other was that you needed to have accurate feedback that was
based in reality of like how you performed. And if we're constantly looking for reassurance and
for other people to tell us that, you're okay, you're doing fine. No, it's going to be fine.
Everything's okay. Like here, look, everything's arranged perfectly. What you're doing very
subtly is you're robbing yourself of the ability of developing that self-efficacy around uncertainty
because you are removing, A, you're no longer at the edge of your capability. And then B,
the feedback that's coming back to you is that you need somebody else to reassure you to handle
uncertainty. If you look at uncertainty as a skill, you're never developing the skill. It's
like you're never taking the training wheels off. And so you continue to flounder in a fear
of uncertainty. Right, right. You're learning, but you're learning in the wrong direction here.
Because what you're learning is not how to deal with uncertainty. You're learning how to avoid the
discomfort of uncertainty. That's really what you're doing here. And so every time you do that,
you're just reinforcing like, oh no, I need to avoid this uncertainty by engaging in all these
reassurance-seeking behaviors. And so every time that comes back up again, you're just going to
engage in that loop over and over again. You're not actually going to get good at sitting with
uncertainty. You're just avoiding the discomfort of the uncertainty. That's what you're teaching
yourself. Interesting. That makes sense to me. People who are high in the intolerance for
uncertainty, they actually see this. They become less confident over repeated decisions. It's
the exact opposite of what they're trying to do, right? Each decision, rather than generating that
mastery evidence that we talked about, is actually draining your confidence further. Because again,
you're just avoiding the discomfort rather than engaging with the uncertainty there.
Yeah. It is interesting. I mean, I'm just doing a common sense check. And when I think about
the most confident people I know, or the most confident people I've been around,
there is kind of just this like, they don't even think about the result.
No. Yeah.
Right? They just-
Devil may care, right?
They just do things.
Yeah. And it's-
And they take what comes.
And they understand, they're like, hey, it might not go well, but whatever. We'll deal
with it when it happens. And to me, it's like a piece of this too is really coming back to that,
understanding what you control and understanding what you don't control, right? Because the things
you don't control, you're never going to be certain about them. There's nothing you can
do to be certain about them. And what you just pointed out, the mechanism you just described
shows that the more you try to be certain about them, the more
you just foster greater sense of uncertainty.
Exactly. And so, yeah, I do think it does kind of come back to the stoic thing of just
focus on what you can control and then just let go of everything else.
If you think about it too, taken to this extreme, this is like OCD, right?
Yes.
So people who have an obsessive compulsive disorder around something like cleanliness or
whatever, the more they check, the more anxious they get about it.
Because again, they're just reinforcing that like, I can't sit with this discomfort,
so I have to engage in these repetitive behaviors around it. So taken to extreme, that's what it is.
Yeah, that makes sense. One of the biggest takeaways here is that uncertainty is not the
enemy. It's actually the price of admission to kind of anything worth having or having a broad,
generalized sense of confidence. And the people who try to eliminate uncertainty,
they just unintentionally promote greater intolerance of uncertainty, greater anxiety,
greater fear of the unknown. So ultimately, if we're trying to build a skill, the skill of
confidence, it is the ability to act without needing to know what the outcome is. That seems
to be like the seed at the core of all of this. So it's interesting. I mean, this episode is
taking us on quite a journey. You know, we started with a very conventional understanding
of confidence from Norman Midson Peale. At this point, we've dug into all the research,
we've debunked it in a bunch of different ways. We went through the self-esteem movement.
And really what we're drilling down and we're finding is that at the end of the day,
the trick isn't to feel more certain of your success, it's to become more tolerant of your
failures, which means that pursuing confidence isn't really about pursuing anything per se.
It's almost about allowing things to happen. It's developing this kind of paradoxical ability to
do things without expecting a certain result, which is a bit of a mindfuck in like we're now
leaving psychology land and entering into philosophy land. And I think that's where
we're going to end up in chapter five, because the conclusion that I've come to, that we've come
to in our research is that confidence isn't even really the right question that people should be
asking. We've been hammering on this point throughout the episode that confidence is a
byproduct of doing the right things, not the cause of doing the right things. It is the output,
not the input. So the question remains, what is that input? What allows you to act without
expectation? What allows you to tolerate failure and uncertainty, but still do things that seem
worth doing? And what we'll find is actually an ancient virtue that has been around for as long
as human civilization has been around. And it turns out, modern psychology backs up, that this is what
we should have been focusing on all along. Hey, everybody. Thank you for watching. This chapter
is part of a much larger episode. You can get that entire episode right now on Spotify. Check it out
there. And if you want to consume it chapter by chapter here on YouTube, we release them every
few days. And if you want to get a full PDF guide with all of our citations, resources, and full
summary of the entire episode, you can go to solvepodcast.com slash confidence and get it there.
Check it out. I'll see you again soon.
