Why Does God Let Bad Things Happen?

What God did?
17 followers
37 Video Views·Jul 21, 2026
How can God be good, but allow bad things to happen? Fr. Mike Schmitz tackles one of the toughest questions religious believers must answer.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedFr. Mike Schmitz addresses the common but misleading claim that tragedies are \"part of God's plan.\" He explains the theological distinction between God's perfect will and His permissive will, arguing that while God is intimately involved in our lives, He voluntarily limits His control to preserve human freedom and the laws of nature.
Hi, my name is Fr. Mike Schmitz and this is Ascension Presents.
A number of years ago, a friend of mine had another friend who...
Just this tragic case where he was taking care of his newborn baby
and changing the baby on a high table.
And he turned away just to grab a diaper.
And when he turned away, the baby rolled over and rolled off the table and died.
Awful.
Now, I want to pause and just say I know that some of you have experienced things just like that,
or maybe even worse.
And what a lot of people said to this guy,
and what a lot of people probably have said to you,
is, well, trying to comfort, trying to offer some kind of consolation,
has been, well, this is part of God's plan.
For some reason, we don't understand it, but this is all part of God's plan.
And the thing is, we have to realize this.
As Catholic Christians, that's not true.
That's just not true.
That is not part of God's plan.
And we have to stop saying that.
Here's the reason why.
Because sometimes we like to think, well, God's in control.
God's in control.
God's in control of everything.
And yes and no.
I would say this.
I would say God's intimately involved with everything,
but God is not in control of everything.
And he did this on purpose.
Now, God is all-powerful? Absolutely.
God is omnipotent is the word, right?
So God is all-powerful.
And so he could be in control of every little detail.
But here's the crazy thing.
As Catholic Christians, in our Judeo-Christian view of Revelation,
reveals to us that God is independent of all creation.
He's the source of all being.
The moment that God created anything outside of himself,
he gave up, voluntarily gave up, a degree of power.
What I mean by that is,
the moment that God created something like physics and thermodynamics
and things like circles and squares,
he gave up his power over there being the possibility
of there being a circle square, square circle,
or that possibility that physics doesn't work.
The moment God created anything outside of himself,
he gave up a certain degree of his power.
The moment God created free human beings or free angelic beings,
he gave up a certain degree of his power
that he's not in control of you.
He's not in control of the angels,
unless we submit our wills to his.
But we all know this, right?
We know what sin is.
When I say to God,
And we look at that and we're like,
man, especially in the midst of war,
in the midst of violence,
in the midst of heartbreak,
we're like, don't.
Actually, God, it would be really awesome
if you could just take away some human freedom
and give me back my child.
Give me back my mom and dad.
Actually, God, take control
and let your will be done.
But God wills that you and I retain our freedom
and that this world still acts according to certain laws.
Now, we know that God did not make death.
In fact, the book of wisdom in the Old Testament says,
God did not make death,
nor does he rejoice in the destruction of the living.
So when someone dies, that's not God's will.
That's not part of God's plan.
That doesn't mean that God is distant.
That doesn't mean that he doesn't care.
That doesn't mean he's disengaged.
God is intimately, intimately involved
with every moment of our lives.
In fact, what did Jesus say?
He said that there's not one sparrow
that can fall from the sky,
that God does not know about it
and apparently care about it.
So God is deeply, intimately involved
in every element of our lives,
but that doesn't mean that everything that happens
is therefore part of his plan.
Because we could say it's all God's will.
Yep, we say it's all God's will,
but we need to make a very important distinction.
There's such a thing as God's perfect will.
Those are the things that he directly wills,
that he directly wants to happen.
Now, we have to understand that God's character,
his very essence is goodness,
is life, is love, is reason, is wisdom.
All these good things.
And so whenever there's life and love
and joy and wisdom and truth,
all of the things, beauty,
they're all some part of his directly willing those things.
When evil things happen,
that is not part of God's perfect will.
That's part of what we refer to as God's permissive will.
That he allows it to happen.
So when someone says about the child
who fell off the table and they died,
part of God's plan.
No, false.
That is not plan A.
God allowed that to happen.
It's his permissive will,
but he did not want that to happen.
He allowed it to happen,
but he did not want it to happen.
But because he created a world
where he's not a tyrant,
where he's not in control of every little thing,
because he created a world like that,
those things happen.
Now, but you think again, let's go back to this.
God, why don't you just take it away?
Why don't you take away some freedom?
Turn off the laws of physics.
Turn off the laws of thermodynamics.
Turn off the stuff in the air
that can poison us and kill us.
Like, do something about that.
There's two reasons
why God doesn't violate our free human will.
One, at least two.
One reason is because
apparently God deems
the retention of our freedom
as a greater good
than even the momentary suspension
of human freedom
for human security and safety.
And I don't get it,
but if God's good,
then I'm going to trust that.
The second reason is because God knows
that even in the midst of the worst evil,
he can bring about a greater good.
We know that this is true.
God did not will that Jesus died.
That's not part of his perfect will.
That's part of his permissive will.
He allowed that to happen.
And Jesus allowed that to happen to him.
He offered himself up in that.
But that's not part of God's perfect will.
He allowed it to happen
knowing that he could bring about a greater good.
Think of the worst thing
that ever happened in human history.
God became human,
became vulnerable,
and we killed him.
That led to the greatest thing
that ever happened in human history.
Is that because even though we killed God,
God saved us.
So God allows these things to happen
not because he wants them to happen,
but because he knows, A,
that freedom is a greater good,
B, that he can bring about
a greater redemption
through even the worst stuff that happens.
Because one of the things,
this is just a word of hope,
because this sounds like,
well, gosh, God's just going to let anything happen.
No, no, not exactly.
God does not will evil.
And even when evil happens,
it does not thwart God's plan.
When someone dies,
that wasn't necessarily part of God's plan,
but it doesn't thwart God's plan.
When someone is attacked and brutalized,
violated,
that was not part of God's plan,
but that still does not thwart God's plan.
God knows that I can take this broken thing
and I make it whole again.
He can take your destroyed heart,
your destroyed life,
and he can bring it back to life.
God can take even stuff that is dead
and bring it to life.
Hang in there.
He can bring about a greater good.
Don't give up.
God not only can,
he wants to.
His perfect will
is that he brings about a greater good
even through stuff that we just don't get,
even through death,
even through accidents,
even through disease.
And that should give us hope.
From all of us here at Ascension Presents,
my name is Father Mike.
God bless.
