Why do innocent people suffer? Where was God during the Holocaust? And can faith survive in a world full of evil? In this episode of Theological, host Shabbos Kestenbaum sits down with Michael Jones from @InspiringPhilosophy one of the most influential Christian apologists on YouTube — for a deep, honest, and at times challenging conversation on theodicy: the problem of evil and suffering. From the Book of Job to the Holocaust, from Jeremiah to C.S. Lewis, Shabbos and Mike explore: Why God would create a world with suffering at all The Jewish and Christian responses to the Holocaust — "Where was God?" vs. "Where was man?" The resurrection of the dead: who gets included? Whether faith in God can logically survive personal tragedy The "Law of Triumph" — how suffering can be transformed into instrumental good Why Mike's entire Christian faith hinges on one historical event When Jesus returns — and what Christians are supposed to do until then This is one of the most ancient questions in human history, and two thoughtful believers from different traditions take it on together — with intellectual rigor, personal honesty, and genuine respect.
Why are innocent people suffering?
As a Christian, when we look at all that suffering, we start to ask why?
Why not create a perfect world?
God says, you don't understand how I'm going to take all of this
and turn it into something far greater.
It's not a world where there is no suffering.
It's a world where there is suffering and evil, but it's triumphed over.
There must be a God that is active all the time.
Otherwise, your argument doesn't have any merit to it.
This is one of the most profound questions we have to wrestle with.
If he's going to allow human beings to create Auschwitz,
then why do you need God at all?
Well, we're here with Michael Jones.
Mike, we first got to know each other on a Jubilee episode, of all places.
One Christian versus one Jew versus one Muslim, one atheist.
It was really exciting.
And I got to say, before we get into our conversation on theodicy,
you have a fascinating background.
How did you get to be one of the most prominent Christian apologists,
not just in the political circles, but also on YouTube?
I appreciate you having me.
I don't know.
I started a YouTube channel back in 2011, in December,
because I felt like there was just nobody really doing that on YouTube.
No one was taking advantage.
So I was working as a security guard.
I was sitting in a trailer for eight hours.
I had all this time on my hands.
I'm like, I guess I can make videos.
And then just one thing led to another.
And then people don't realize, for the first five years, I hid my face and name.
I didn't want anyone to know who I was.
But then that got exposed.
That got leaked.
And so then it just built on its own, I feel like.
I have not had a plan.
This is just something that's been happening.
I feel like, all right, go to that area, do that area, do that area.
Honestly, if I'm going to get religious,
I feel like God's just been leading me here against my will half the time.
So as I said, the conversation today is on a very happy, optimistic topic,
theodicy, evil, and suffering.
And I want to frame the conversation in the most elementary way I can.
And to me, that's Jeremiah.
Jeremiah 9-12, to me, helps me understand the most rudimentary way
why there is evil and why there is suffering.
So Jeremiah, through God, he says that,
Vayomer HaShem al azva matorasi, asher nasasi lifnei hem.
God is saying, the reason the land is destroyed
is because you forsook the Torah that I gave you,
v'lo shamu bikoli, v'lo hal chubo.
You did not listen to my voice and you did not walk in its ways.
So the most, again, root, elementary way
that we can understand suffering from the Hebrew Bible is,
why is there suffering?
Because you sinned.
Is that a Christian interpretation that you think is legitimate
in our contemporary society today?
Why is there pain?
Why are there trials and tribulations?
Well, you just must have done something wrong.
So, short answer, yes.
Long answer is, that's a surface level.
That's true, yes.
You reject God's law, you don't follow God, you will suffer.
This is just a natural consequence in a lot of ways.
But there's also a lot of deeper reasons
as to why suffering exists, as to why it is.
Because we know in, for example, the Torah,
God says they're not going to be able to keep this law.
You're going to fail at this.
And so the Christian perspective plays back into that
because then we look to Christ
as the one who came and fulfilled it for us.
And then again, it points back to God coming in flesh
to save us, kind of a thing.
So yes, sin results in punishment.
It results in shame.
We also have to take in the fact
that there are just natural consequences of sin
built into the universe.
If you chase after lust,
you're not going to find real, meaningful love.
If you chase after greed, you're never going to be satisfied.
If you chase after pride,
you're never going to find true happiness.
Because true happiness, as we were designed,
is giving yourself to others.
But pride makes you focus on yourself.
It makes you turn inward.
So we believe that is the case.
We believe that's naturally built into the universe for sure.
Not necessarily.
I do think there is divine retribution.
God has every right to execute punishment
for us being sinful.
The question is, why doesn't he do it now?
I got a friend named David Wood.
He's a diagnosed psychopath.
And he's a Christian.
But when he was an atheist,
he said one of the reasons he didn't believe in God
is because if a just God did exist,
he would destroy us.
Look at how evil we are.
We deserve that.
So that's a profound thing to think about.
I mean, you think of all the sin.
I like going to the story of Elijah.
That's one of my favorite biblical stories.
I think Elijah is one of the most fascinating prophets.
You notice what he does on Mount Carmel
with the prophets of Baal.
He defeats them.
What does it say after?
He ran to the capital of Israel.
He was so thrilled to go there
because he thought the revolution was going to start.
He just defeated the prophets of Baal.
Israel was going to turn back to the God of Israel.
He knew it.
And he shows up.
It doesn't happen.
Jezebel says, I'm going to kill you.
So what does he do?
He runs out into the desert, super depressed.
And it's profound.
He did everything right.
He did the miracle.
God showed up.
He won.
But Israel didn't turn back to God.
So where does he go?
He goes to Mount Sinai.
And he's super depressed about all this.
He's like, God, I've been very zealous for you.
I did everything right.
But Israel has turned away.
I'm the only one left.
And what does God basically tell him?
I mean, I feel like the theological implications are.
It's like, look, Elijah, if I came down in all that power,
I'd win the war, but I'd lose you because you're all sinful.
You're only here because of my mercy.
I could come down in these earthquakes with these fires.
I could do that.
But none of you would be saved.
And so I think that's just one of the most profound things
about God is his mercy in the light of all of our sin.
This somewhat reminds me as well as the story of Eov, of Job,
and the rejection of divine retribution,
as in the story itself challenges the idea that suffering
is always a consequence or a punishment for sin.
So Job, ostensibly, if you just read the verses,
I mean, the Talmud starts to interpret in a different way.
But the verses themselves, it doesn't really offer
a comprehensive reason as to why Job would suffer
these trials and tribulations.
And it's chapter 38, verse 4, where I think we get
one of the funniest responses that God ever gives
to a human being where Job says, you know,
why did you do this to me?
And God basically says,
Where were you when I formed the world?
You don't know anything.
You know, you do not understand the complexities
of not only the natural physical world,
but also I'm dealing with millions of people
and millions of different priorities
and value systems and circumstances.
You as mere mortal man,
you can't even conceive of the behind the scenes
of why I do what I do.
And in fact, when Jews pray, we pray three times a day.
And the standard prayer is the Shemona Esrei,
these 18 blessings.
And the first blessing we actually say
is not one whereby we ask God,
bring about the Messiah, end world hunger.
It's that you, God, give man wisdom.
And please give us wisdom, clarity, and understanding,
because this world is so complex,
we just don't understand it.
And in order to create a divine relationship with you,
we have to have some knowledge.
And this is the knowledge that God was telling Job,
you just simply don't have.
So how do you as a Christian understand seemingly this,
I don't wanna say randomness,
but this idea that sometimes when there is punishment,
we just don't know.
Oh yeah, and that's what,
it's amazing that Bronze Age goat herders
could write such a complex philosophical work
like the book of Job.
I mean, it really just-
Happy coincidence.
Happy coincidence, yeah.
I mean, it's a profound book
because we still wrestle with it today,
that it doesn't answer,
that's the amazing thing about the book of Job,
it doesn't give you the answer
to the problem of evil and suffering.
It just leaves you with an open-ended question like,
okay, well, yeah, I don't understand the complexity,
but now what?
And I think that's one of the profound things
about that book.
I mean, as a Christian,
when we look at that complexity
and we look at all that suffering,
we start to ask why.
One of the things I try to give to people is like,
people ask me,
why did God create the world that he did?
Why did he create the world like this?
Why not create a perfect world?
And I go, well, that's not the world you pick.
And they push back.
I would pick a world without suffering if I could.
I'm like, no, you wouldn't.
Let me give you an example.
Let's say, instead of watching this interview,
we were gonna watch the entire season of Teletubbies,
season one,
or we could watch
The Lord of the Rings Extended Edition.
I guarantee 99.9% of the audience
watching this would pick Lord of the Rings.
Well, wait a minute.
You just picked a world of suffering.
You didn't pick the world with no suffering.
But you didn't just pick a world of suffering.
You picked a world with triumph.
And that's what I think is the best possible world.
It's not a world where there is no suffering.
It's a world where there is suffering and evil,
but it's defeated.
It's triumphed over.
And if that's the best kind of possible world,
it creates the best kind of virtues.
You can't experience courage if you're never afraid.
You can't experience compassion.
If no one is ever suffering.
And so that creates the best kind of virtues in us.
It creates the best kind of souls,
the best kind of stories.
And if we recognize that in the stories
we come up with or tell,
surely our Heavenly Father does as well.
So he's gonna create a world where,
yeah, there is suffering,
but it's gonna be defeated.
It's gonna be triumphed over.
And what is not that story,
if not the Bible,
where evil is gonna be defeated and triumphed over?
You know, just to wrap up on that,
go back to the Book of Job.
Notice at the end,
he gets double everything except children,
because the resurrection is coming.
He does get double children.
The children that died in the beginning,
they're still there.
Their souls still exist.
He will have them again in the resurrection.
That's why, like St. Augustine said,
God doesn't give him double children
because he still has double children.
The seven are just waiting for him on the other side.
You know, this somewhat reminds me of this midrash
or rabbinic exposition
whereby the angels ushered into heaven
and they stormed God's palace and said,
don't create man.
Because you know that by creating these mortal beings,
they're going to sin.
They are going to stray away from your commandments.
Better don't go through those trials and tribulations.
And God says exactly what you just said.
Better for man,
through the process of human agency of free will,
to yes, make bad choices,
but ultimately have the ability to make good choices.
And God tells the angels,
I don't want more yes-men.
That's what angels do.
In fact, the Talmudic understanding of an angel
is they just have one purpose in life, one mission.
And once they complete that purpose,
their existence ceases to be.
So the three administering angels who tell Abraham,
we're going to destroy Sodom and Gomorrah,
and you're going to have your own son.
That's it.
That's their purpose and they have fulfilled it.
Whereas human beings, yeah, it's true.
You can't have triumph without first going through,
you know, the trials at first.
I do want to go back to the question of the Odyssey.
So this brings me to Jeremiah 12.1
where Jeremiah is asking,
why has the way of the wicked prospered?
It's the topic of the entire book of Job, of Eov.
And in fact, according to the rabbis in the Talmud,
Tractate Brechot, page 7, folio A,
at Mount Sinai, Moshe Rabbeinu,
Moses himself asks God,
why some of the righteous prosper,
but others suffer,
and why some of the wicked suffer,
but others prosper?
And there's no obvious answer.
In fact, the rabbis explain this problem
as tzaddik viralo and rasha v'tovlo.
You have righteous people that have badness,
and you have evil people that have goodness.
And so the Gomorrah tries to explain,
well, this type of suffering
might be considered yesurin shel ava,
literally sufferings of love.
And these sufferings of love
were sent by God to purify a person
and increase their reward,
not here in the physical world,
olam hazeh,
but in the afterlife,
what's called olam haba.
And the rabbis try to explain,
not all agree,
but they try to explain
that it is better to come into the next world,
cleansed and free of sin rather than not,
and therefore punishment for sin here
can actually be a very good thing.
So I guess,
can you understand suffering and evil
without the afterlife?
It sort of seems like the only way
we can understand why there is chaos,
why the good have bad and the bad have good
is because, well, there's this next world.
There is this world of emes, of truth.
Is that how we can understand suffering
through the afterlife?
Yeah, I think that's definitely part of it for sure.
But it's not just the afterlife
because Jews and Christians,
we believe in the resurrection.
We believe in life after life after death.
We believe that we will come back in physical bodies
to reign in this universe forever.
And I think that leads to a lot of things.
Okay, well, are we just going to be
sitting on earth forever?
No, I think there's a big empty universe out there
because God's going to continue the work
he started in Eden that we failed with.
He said in Genesis 1,
I want you to go out and subdue creation,
subdue and rule over the earth.
That was step one.
One, if we've got this big giant universe
and we're going to be resurrected in bodies for eternity,
I think we have to take that to the whole universe.
God is preparing us to do that.
And so I think that's a profound thing in and of itself.
And so, but we need to be purged
of all these selfish desires.
We need to, and that's going to require
suffering for a lot of people.
But everyone is different.
So some people that, you know,
for example, the Christian,
we'll see people come to Christ
and they get a really good life after that.
Some people have a really bad life.
It's kind of weird, but God knows the heart.
That's what 1 Samuel says.
You know, don't look when Samuel goes
to pick King David.
He goes to all the older brothers
and God says, don't look on appearance.
Look at the heart for God knows the heart.
And that's why he picks David
because he knows the right person to lead Israel.
And so God looks at all of our hearts and goes,
I know what you need.
I know what they need.
It's not going to be the same path for everyone.
Well, let me just quickly, not push back,
but just clarify here because it's true.
Maimonides, 12th century, rabbinic sage,
he has 13 principles of faith.
And one of them is,
Ani ma'amim b'muna shlema,
I believe in whole and complete faith.
Sh'tia t'chias ha-mesim,
there will be this resurrection of the dead.
So I want to ask you a question
that the rabbis themselves have debated
and argued for centuries.
Who gets resurrected?
I mean, as a Christian,
we say who gets resurrected
is those who have given themselves to Christ.
Those are people who we know.
As a Christian, people ask me,
well, what about people like before Jesus came?
What about people who never heard of the gospel?
And I think that's answered in the New Testament.
So you have John 9, 41, John 15, 22,
where Jesus is speaking of the Pharisees.
And he says, now that I have come,
they have no excuse.
If I had not come, they would.
So he says right there, he's like,
okay, so people are judged
based on the information they get.
You also have Paul in Romans 5, 13,
that sin is not counted where there was no law,
or Acts 17, where he says,
in the past, God overlooked times of ignorance.
So we say Christ is an assured way to be saved,
but it's not the only way
because Abraham, obviously we believe he's saved.
But I mean, he didn't,
he wasn't baptized, for example.
So we pray as Christians
that God just brings all people into the kingdom
and saves all.
That's what we're going to say.
We cannot, but we, as I said,
we don't look at the heart.
Only God knows the heart.
So he will save everyone who he knows he can save.
So I feel like we're friends,
so I can ask you this.
And it's going to be a boring question
because I'm sure you get it a lot.
But I live post-Christ, spoiler,
but also spoiler,
I don't accept the divinity of Christ
unless you can make a really good argument
that I'm happy to be swayed.
But as someone who,
I like to think I live a relatively moral life.
I mean, I go to synagogue
far more than Christians go to church.
I go to synagogue three times a day.
I don't believe I've ever killed or stolen
or done any of the cardinal sins.
But as I said, I reject the divinity of Christ.
So would I be included in that resurrection?
And I'm happy to get a straightforward answer.
I won't take offense.
The straightforward church answer is
we don't know.
We are not the judge.
We pray that you do accept Christ.
We pray that God saves you regardless.
That is always going to be our prayer.
But we always will say
the only way to heaven is through Christ.
So that's what Christ taught us.
That's what we follow.
So that's what we have to proclaim.
And that's what we stand on.
And we say, listen, the church,
like for example, the Catholic church
won't even say Judas is in hell.
Like they won't say that
because they're not the judges.
God is the one who looks at the heart.
He will save everyone he can save.
And so we just pray for the Jews.
Plus what Paul tells us to do in Romans 11.
He says, you know,
when the fullness of Gentiles comes in,
then all of Israel will be saved.
So we say, yes, that's what we want.
We want all of Israel to be saved and be in heaven.
And we just pray that Christ accomplishes that.
Well, thank you.
We appreciate it.
Let me go back though.
There's this 8th century
rabbinic figure of Sadiqaon.
And he has a, again, I don't want to say bizarre,
but an interesting perspective
on suffering and theodicy
where he essentially says that
perhaps God brings suffering upon the righteous,
even though they are not deserving
of that particular punishment
in order so that we as non-righteous individuals
can look at that righteous person and say,
wow, what great heights of spirituality
that this individual went through
such trials and challenges,
but nevertheless has such faith,
resolved faith in God that is immovable.
It's almost a lesson to us.
Now you and I can perhaps appreciate it
because we're not righteous
or I'm not righteous.
What about that righteous individual?
Because it sort of seems like
he is this unwilling sacrifice
of I need to be on the receiving end
of these challenges
so that other people may come on to God.
And as I'm speaking out loud,
this sounds a heck of a lot like Jesus Christ.
Yeah, we got to be careful though with some of that.
I remember reading Soren Kierkegaard
and listening to Tim Keller,
and they both said that really sin is,
it's breaking God's law,
but it's also deeper.
There's a reason we break God's law
because sin is really building your identity
on anything but God.
If you take a good thing,
you turn it into an ultimate thing.
That is really the root of sin
and causes us to break God's law.
And the reason why Soren Kierkegaard
was talking about this
because he was looking at the Pharisees
and the gospels and he's like,
they're fastidiously following the law,
yet they're lost.
Why? Because when the Pharisees
take their own moral worth,
their own moral righteousness,
and they place that as an idol,
they have replaced it with God.
They're doing the moral works
as a means to an end,
to earn salvation,
to earn righteousness.
And that's a scary thing for Christians,
Jews, anyone really,
to make sure we don't do that,
that we don't replace our own moral worth,
our own moral works,
and put them center and say,
that is how I know I'm saved.
Because what Augustine talked about,
that just actually creates more sin
because you get pride out of that.
You get self-centeredness out of that.
When you're like,
I'm a good person
because I did all these good works
and now I know I'm saved.
But that creates sin in you.
So we've got to be very careful
that we don't fall into that.
Perhaps I'm misunderstanding your point then,
because this sounds like a catch-22.
As in, if you don't keep the laws,
you're sinning.
But even if you do keep the laws,
you could still fall into this pit of sin
because you have a degree of what?
Arrogance in,
I am better than the others
who aren't keeping this law?
Yes.
So what exactly is the average,
in Hebrew it's called,
benonany,
the middleman,
the average guy
who's not particularly sinful
but he's certainly not righteous.
How exactly are we meant to keep the law then?
Let me tell you about Jesus.
That's what,
I mean that's what it is.
He kept the law perfectly for us
because he could.
He was God in the flesh.
He came and he did it
without falling into pride and arrogance
and then he took it to the cross,
nailed it,
and then rose from the dead
and he now is our priest.
And this is what Paul says in Ephesians 2,
by grace we are saved,
not through works that no man may boast.
We are saved by grace through faith.
So yeah,
I totally admit,
there's no way I can climb that mountain of morality.
I have to have Christ come down and do it for me.
And this,
I think that's just the Christian message
that encapsulates it.
Yeah,
there's no way we can do it.
This is why the church fathers
wrestled with this idea.
God,
I can't keep the law.
I fall into pride.
I fall into sin.
And the Christian message has always been the same.
Exactly.
That's why I had to come down and do it for you.
Do you ever think though,
I'm thinking of Moses.
When he is asked to lead the Jewish people,
his reaction is no.
I'm a heart of speech.
I can't do it.
And he almost needs convincing by God
that you are the one.
Now,
that's not true of all prophets.
So Abraham is probably the best example
why that's not true.
God goes to Abraham.
He says,
Avraham,
Avraham.
And Abraham says,
Hineni,
here I am.
Whatever you need me to do,
I'll do it.
And God says,
go sacrifice your son.
And Abraham says,
okay.
But I'm just thinking out loud again.
When God goes on to Jesus and says,
you're going to be the one.
You will be sacrificed.
You will be crucified for others.
Did Jesus have a choice in that?
Maybe there was a part of him,
like Moses,
who says,
send another.
Why do I have to be the one?
He did.
That's exactly what he said.
So he had a human nature.
So when he goes to the garden of Gethsemane,
he falls and he prays,
Father,
if there be another way,
let this cup pass from me.
So he felt the weight of that coming
and he prayed for a way out.
But he ultimately said,
not my will,
but your will be done.
So Jesus did not actually want to have
the faith that he had,
but his love of God was so powerful
that it overcame his physical desires
and wants.
Exactly.
He lived the life we should have lived
and he died the death we deserved.
Wow.
So let me go back to Maimonides
for a moment.
In his Guide for the Perplexed,
Moren Nebuchadnezzar,
in the third chapter,
he creates...
By the way,
second grade is Moses.
Second grade?
That's funny.
Very, very intelligent philosopher.
Well, actually,
they say on his grave,
mimosha ad mosha,
locom comosha.
From Moses to Moses,
there was no one like Moses.
And in fact,
there was a 20th century rabbinic figure
of Moshe Feinstein,
who was just an absolute giant in Jewish law.
And on his tombstone,
it says the same thing.
So there are a lot of good Moseses.
I am not named Moses,
so I can't compete.
But yes,
in this Moses,
Maimonides,
in his Guide for the Perplexed,
in the third chapter,
he classifies suffering into three types.
There's number one,
those that stem naturally,
you know,
like mortality,
death.
Then there are those that are inflicted by others.
Someone comes up to you and stabs you.
And then there are those
that we bring upon ourselves.
And he actually argues
that it is that third type
that is the most common and damaging.
And the implication,
though,
is that there exists a physical world.
And when bad things happen,
it's almost always as a result
of being in a physical world.
But that's kind of problematic
because I study Holocaust theology.
That's what I did in undergrad,
what I did in grad school.
And there's a common approach.
I wouldn't say the majority,
but certainly the plurality of rabbis today.
They will say that when you ask the question,
oh, where was God during the Holocaust?
That's the wrong question.
The real question is where was man?
Because it was man that built Auschwitz.
It was man that,
you know,
built gas chambers.
It was man that killed 60 million people
in World War II.
But the problem with that approach
and the problem,
I believe,
with the approach of Maimonides
is if that's true,
that this world is merely a consequence
of the physical actions of other people,
then what's the point of God?
Like, what does God do?
And I don't mean it on an emotional level,
on a spiritual level.
Oh, he gives me meaning.
He gives me purpose.
That's all true.
And that can be fine.
But on a,
God is going to save me from punishment
or God is going to help me
because I'm deserving,
clearly those answers
will not support that idea.
It's like, what's the point of God?
Yeah, that's one of the profound questions
we need to all wrestle with
as just human beings.
Why is God allowing this kind of stuff
and not coming in and ending it all?
I mean, on the road to Damascus,
Jesus appears to Paul and he says,
Saul, Saul,
why are you persecuting me?
Notice he doesn't say,
why are you persecuting my people?
He says, why are you persecuting me?
I'm right there in the suffering with them
and you're persecuting me.
Stop it.
I think this is
one of the most profound questions
we have to wrestle with
is like, what is God doing
when he's allowing this kind of stuff?
And the question I go back to,
I mean, as a Christian,
I have to go back to the cross
because that's where
suffering met the divine.
That's where it all was poured out
on him directly.
There's an old track that says,
old evangelist track.
Someone is saying,
it's you they ought to crucify.
Sorry, he says,
it's God they ought to crucify,
not you and me.
I said to the carpenter on the tree.
In that message,
we need to wrestle with this idea of like,
why is God allowing the suffering?
And the Christian answer is,
God is right there in the suffering
and he came and demonstrated that.
So if the suffering was so bad,
it cannot be triumphed over,
God would not allow it
because he's united himself
to creation,
as he says in these scriptures,
in a way that's profound to us,
that he is there experiencing
all the suffering with us.
So what do we do with that?
If God is on mission,
he knows the future.
He knows what's going to happen.
He knows that suffering
will all be defeated.
I talk about this thing,
I call it the law of triumph.
So it's this idea that God
is imbued in creation,
this idea that suffering,
if a creature so chooses,
can be turned into an instrumental good.
So all that fear will become courage.
All that hate will become compassion.
And we see that in people
throughout the Bible,
like with Elijah or Abraham,
or Moses.
Horrible things they did
are then turned into goods
that help shape them.
You talked about Moses
not wanting to go speak.
But by the end of his career,
he's giving the sermon of Deuteronomy.
I mean, like he became
the exact thing he thought
he never could.
And his suffering led him
to become something he never could.
So you see also with like David,
you know, sinful man
does all sorts of horrible things,
but God used him to become
this great king of Israel.
I think that's what it's about.
God is seeing the suffering
and he says,
yes, it is bad,
but wait till you see how I do it.
You know, as Joseph said in Genesis,
what you meant for evil,
God meant for good.
And you just don't understand my power.
You don't understand
how I'm going to take all of this
and turn it into something far greater.
And just to wrap up,
C.S. Lewis said in his book,
The Great Divorce,
if you take all the evil
and you drop it into
the goodness of heaven,
it would be like an atom
falling into the ocean.
Look, as a religious person,
not only do I sympathize
with that argument,
at least intellectually,
I agree with that argument,
even if I can't,
A. Articulate it nearly
as well as you did,
or B. Be able to emotionally
relate with it.
I guess to be a little unfair
and push back,
there was a note
etched into the walls
of the Mauthausen
concentration camp.
If there is a God,
he will have to beg
for my forgiveness.
So I can say,
sure, but God was suffering with you.
But to that prisoner,
who the hell cares?
I don't care.
Because I was still suffering.
Just because I have
another person
who's in it with me
does not make the pain
any lesser.
So to ask you
an unfair question,
what would you say
to that prisoner?
Nothing.
And the reason why
is because if someone
is going through
immense suffering,
you can't give them a lecture.
You need to just
give them a hug.
You need to just
be there for them.
And that's just something
we need to wrestle
with as humans.
We're not reason
instrument machines.
We are humans
that have reason
capabilities,
but we are far
more complex than that.
And sometimes the best thing
to do for a person
going through suffering
is to not just
give them the lecture
or explain to them
the complexities of
why God allowed this
or why did that.
Just be there
in the suffering with them.
So, you know,
we were talking earlier
before we started filming
about this
post-Charlie Kirk bump
and whether young people
are going back to religion.
And the studies
basically bear out
that they probably are.
But if I can ask
in the most elementary
way I can,
and again,
it's not a novel question
because we've been
grappling with it
for 3,000 years.
If you have a Gen Z American
who's interested
in reading the Bible
and he's going to church
every now and then,
but he has the most
fundamental problem,
which is
why are innocent people
suffering?
And in fact,
even going back to
The Guide to the Perplexed
and Maimonides'
three different classifications,
none of that explains
natural punishment
like getting cancer,
tornado.
You know,
that can explain
punishments that we get
as a result of human behavior,
but there are things
that are just outside
of our control.
You know,
why is it that
I was run over?
That wasn't on me.
I looked both ways.
That was on this
drunken driver.
How was I supposed
to prevent that?
So again,
it's an unfair way
of me asking the question.
I acknowledge it,
but how do you
tell these young people,
yes,
God loves you so much,
but also
your four-year-old
sister has cancer?
Yeah.
Again,
you don't give
someone in that instance
that pep talk.
We can explain
suffering on the
intellectual level,
but someone going
through that,
they got to wrestle
through that
and they need to go
through the experience.
The way I talk about it
when I give a presentation
on suffering is
you have to remember
that this is part
of a grand story
and we are right
in the middle of it.
We are not at the end.
We cannot piece
all the puzzle pieces together,
but it's often the time
when we go through
intense suffering.
We look back and go,
oh,
yeah,
actually,
now I see how that is.
I once was talking
to a girl
who she interviewed
me on her TikTok.
She said,
yeah,
I have a disabled child,
but I wouldn't change anything.
I wouldn't change my past.
I've talked to people
that have gone through
immense suffering
and they're like,
yeah,
I wouldn't change anything
because it made me
into who I was.
And I want that
to be a part of my story.
What they want
to be a part of
is they want to be a part
of that soul building process
and they want to say,
not only did I experience
that suffering,
but I defeated it.
And having defeated that,
I became more human
than I realized I could
because that's what
it is to be human.
God created us
in the beginning
to subdue creation.
We are to go out
and find the problems
and we are to defeat them
and make them
into something better.
So when people see
that stuff in their lives,
they want that.
Surprisingly,
it shocks us all.
It shocks even ourselves
when we say that,
that we see these sufferings
in our lives
and we don't say,
yeah, if I had a time machine,
I'd go back
and I wouldn't go
through that suffering.
Because we were created by God
to be the answer
to the chaos of creation.
We were sent to go in
and subdue that
and make it into something better.
And so when we see suffering
and we experience it,
it sucks when we're in it.
But when we get to the other side,
we thank God for it
and we thank him most of all
that we triumphed over it
and we became
who we were meant to be,
the true sons of God.
So the greatest story ever told
is still ongoing, essentially.
I have to ask, though, again,
I'm just curious.
It doesn't sound like
you're very bothered
by the issues of suffering
and evil in this world.
Is that an accurate
characterization of your beliefs?
No, I'm definitely bothered by it.
I just like to talk about it.
I mean, it's...
Sorry, when I say bothered,
I don't mean personally.
Of course, we're upset with tragedies,
but I'm saying on a theological lens,
your belief in God
isn't really determined
by these tragedies we're seeing.
Yeah, I mean, because I think
it makes sense.
I think suffering is expected
on a Judeo-Christian worldview.
I think if we're the image of God,
we're going to make worlds
like the way God makes it.
We make stories
and what do we have?
It's suffering that's defeated.
Every great book,
every great movie
has suffering in it that's defeated.
And if we are sons of God,
I mean, OK, yeah,
that's what we have too.
He's going to make a world
where there is suffering,
but it's going to be defeated.
And so that's what...
That's the story that's unfolding.
So I have faith in God.
I have faith that he is going
to see us to the end.
And we will be there
in the resurrection and go...
We will be there in the resurrection
and we'll go,
now I see why.
Now I see what God has to hear.
And now we have a job to do.
We have to get back
to subduing creation.
That answer very much hinges
on divine intervention,
which I want to get to in a second.
Just before I do,
because otherwise I'll forget.
There was...
There is a Jewish educator,
Racheli Frenkel.
In June of 2014,
her son Naftali,
along with two other boys,
were kidnapped
and eventually killed
by Palestinian terrorists.
And she was giving a talk.
She's an inspirational figure,
obviously,
and a child at one
of her lectures asked,
why is it that God
didn't answer your prayers?
And Racheli Frenkel
was kind of stunned
and said, what do you mean?
Well, and this kid said,
well, you wanted your son back
and God did not give you
your son back.
And Racheli Frenkel said,
well, God did answer my prayers.
And the answer was no.
And that just requires
an immense level
of belief in God
that I certainly don't have
and I aspire to have one day,
but ultimately is
superhuman in a way.
That even though you have
killed my own child,
nevertheless,
not only do I still believe
in you,
but I acknowledge that
whatever you did
in the Talmud that says
kol da'avid rachmana latav da'avid,
all that God does,
for whatever reason,
for reasons I cannot comprehend,
just like Eof,
just like Job,
nevertheless,
you know, I respect
and I understand
your answer of no.
I mean, I don't even know
what the question is.
Like, what do you make
of that level of belief
that one must have in God?
So when they see destruction
and when they see pain
and when they see suffering,
nevertheless,
I believe in you today,
just like I believed in you
before the pain.
Yeah, profound.
You give me that faith.
I mean, that's what I say.
That's the faith
we all got to have.
But I mean, also,
we need to remember
that we shouldn't be judging
whether God exists
or what religion is true
based on our own
personal experiences
and our own emotions.
I mean, that would be,
I think it'd be
the most unhuman thing to do.
We recognize that we
are to love God
with all our heart, soul, and mind.
If we only love them
with our heart,
that means that
something bad happens,
we just whimsically
move on to something else.
We love them with our minds.
We understand
there's a grander planet play
and there's plenty of evidence
for God's existence
and why we believe
what we believe.
So, we understand also
that his promises are made,
that he's in charge,
he will set everything right
at the end,
and people will see
their dead children again.
They're not dead.
This is what the Book of Job
is about, ultimately.
His children are still there,
just waiting for him
on the other side.
That's actually what Jews say
at night before we go to bed.
We say the Shema prayer,
that you should love your God
with all your heart,
with your soul,
with your actions as well.
We're very much in alignment
with that.
Let's go back to
divine intervention.
The early Kabbalists have...
I'm really going to hell
because I keep saying bizarre.
I've got to think of
a better adjective.
But they have an idea
that there's something
called Tzimtzum.
Tzimtzum literally
means constrainment.
The idea was that
God exists in all spaces.
He occupies all avenues
of life and the universe.
The problem is, though,
as we have already discussed,
we have free will.
We can make our own choices.
So, the Kabbalists were
sort of faced with this dilemma
of if God exists in all spaces
and all the universes,
then how can human beings
sort of do their own thing
and possess moral agency?
And so the Kabbalists say,
well, in Jewish mysticism,
we believe that there
was a constrainment
where God says,
I'm deliberately not going
to put my place
in the space of human agency
in order to allow mankind
to exercise their free will.
And they can use that free will
to do really great stuff,
or they could use that free will
to do some really not great stuff
like building in Auschwitz.
And your arguments thus far,
which I mostly agree with,
all hinge on the idea
of good defeats evil ultimately,
even if it's not now.
Why?
Because there's this ultimate
intelligent design.
That was our latest episode
with a professor.
So I guess, though,
you must believe that
God is intimately involved
and intervening on our daily lives.
Otherwise, I mean,
your argument doesn't
have any merit to it.
There must be a God
that is active every single day
all the time.
Yep.
Yeah, there is.
And that basis comes from what?
Or where?
It comes from what I think
I was taught in scripture.
I mean, just go through
the Old Testament.
God is always acting
and talking to the prophets.
I'm going to do this.
Now I'm going to do that.
I mean, he's very much involved.
But also, I mean,
there's plenty of evidence
for modern miracles as well.
I mean, the Catholic Church
has documented several.
You can check out
Craig Keener's book,
Miracles, two volumes of
just documented cases
of different things.
So I do think God is very active.
He very much wants to be
a part of this story
that's unfolding.
He doesn't want to
determine everything,
but he's still part of
the story that's unfolding.
And he wants to
be the main character.
He is the main character
of the story unfolding.
And so we need to recognize
that and realize that
we are just participating
in his story.
And again, going back
to what you're saying earlier,
there's an idea from
Rabbi Menachem
Mendel Morgenstern.
He's a 19th century
Hasidic figure.
He talks about, you know,
when a human being is in pain,
God is in pain as well.
When a human being cries out,
God cries out as well.
Which, yes, will that be able
to alleviate the physical pain
of the individual in Mauthausen?
Probably not.
But on an emotional,
religious level,
know that he is with you
in that difficulty.
So this actually brings me
to Sefer Eicha, Lamentations,
chapter 30, verse 40,
where essentially,
after talking about
four chapters and verses
about the destruction
of Jerusalem,
essentially the author says
the nashuvah ad Hashem,
that we should now
return to God.
The question, therefore,
is not why.
The question is not
why did this happen?
Why is Jerusalem desolate?
The question is,
what do we do about it
now that it did happen?
You know, Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik,
a preeminent American
20th century rabbinic figure,
makes this point as well
in response to the Holocaust.
One can absolve themselves
of their religious obligations
of making blessings on food,
of putting on phylacteries,
of going to synagogue
by simply saying,
my experiences
through the Holocaust
were so overwhelming
and so earth-shakingly difficult,
I just can't do that anymore.
And one can make that argument
or one can say,
it happened.
Why did it happen?
We can discuss it,
but ultimately,
that's not going to change
the reality on the ground
that there is an all-powerful,
all-loving,
all-merciful God
who commands me to do things,
who commands me to give charity
and commands me to pray
and commands me to eat kosher food.
And I'm wondering
if you see a parallel to this
in Christian thought,
that actually the question
we should be asking
isn't really why,
but the question
we should really be asking
is what.
What can we do
out of the misery
that we may not be able
to understand,
but I don't want to say
it's irrelevant,
but it's almost not the point.
No, you're absolutely correct.
That is the question
we are always put forward.
I mean, you could have asked the Jews
they were being taken to Babylon
or in exile,
like, why is this happening?
But if you would have told them
the present,
what's happening in the present right now,
they wouldn't believe you.
I mean, in the ancient mindset,
they would have looked at that
like the Babylonians would have said,
like, our God Marduk
just defeated your God
and your kingdom is over.
Tell those same people,
in about 2500 years,
people are going to be praising
the God of Israel
all over the world.
You're going to invent machines
you've never even heard of
and they're going to change reality.
They would have looked at you
like you're crazy,
but that was part of the plan.
The Jews were taken to Babylon
as part of the plan of redemption
as part of the story
that brought humanity
to where it is.
We get the story of Esther.
We get the story of Daniel.
This was all part of that process
and it was about
God was using Israel
to bring about that process.
And what happened is
prophets like Ezekiel, like Daniel,
Esther, Mordecai,
they said,
it's not about why,
now it's what we have to do
and we have to turn back
to the God of Israel.
And if we do,
he promises he will redeem us
and save us.
And I don't think they even
could have seen the type of world
that God has now created
through people who follow him.
I mean, despite what people want to say,
Christianity, Judeo-Christian values
are crucial for developing science.
We wouldn't have this world today
if the God of Israel
did not do what he did
through the Old and New Testament.
And so now we have to,
now we're living in this amazing world
because people turn to him
and they followed his plan
and they trusted in him.
And that's what we have to do.
And we will see things in the future
that we can't even imagine
in this day and age.
Just because you mentioned
the book of Esther,
I mean, Queen Esther,
the name itself
comes from the Hebrew sater,
meaning hidden.
So not only was her Jewish identity
hidden in order to,
eventually, she knows at the time,
save the Jewish people,
but God himself is hidden.
His name does not appear
anywhere in the Megillah,
anywhere in the scroll.
In fact, the Qumran community
of the Dead Sea Scrolls,
they don't actually include
the book of Esther at all.
Now, there are a couple of reasons why,
but one of the reasons offered
is because they actually don't view it
as a divinely inspired document
because, well, where's God in it?
But that's exactly the point.
Again, in modern Jewish thought,
and I'm sure there's convenience
with Christianity,
it is the hiddenness
that often is the miracle.
So young people today,
myself included,
when I was less observant
as I am today,
I would say, well,
unless there's a great splitting
of the sea today
in the 21st century,
how exactly am I meant
to believe in God?
Unless it starts raining down frogs,
unless the Talmud gives this example
of unless the walls
start talking to me,
why would I believe in God?
Because I need to see open miracles.
And I think within the biblical canon,
it's teaching us that sometimes
the most obvious miracles
are the ones that actually
are a little hidden.
You have to go deeper.
Well, I think it's going
even further than that.
Think about what you just said.
If it was raining frogs,
you would believe in God.
But why?
Not because you wanted to fall in love,
but because you had to.
If Zeus appeared before us right now,
we'd believe in Zeus.
I don't think we'd love Zeus
or worship Zeus.
We'd be like, all right.
Or if we did, it would be out of fear.
And I think that's one of the beauties
of what we see in the Bible
is that God is not just trying
to get people to believe in him.
He's trying to get people
to love him and follow him.
And sometimes he has
to be hidden to do that.
You know, if he came
in all his power and glory,
people would worship him,
but out of fear,
not for who he truly is.
So maybe God knows
exactly what he's doing.
Right. And to that point,
I mean, in my Instagram bio,
I have the verse Deuteronomy 30, 19,
which is where God is telling
the Jewish people,
you're about to enter
the land of Israel.
Moses can't come with you,
but just know you will be faced
with good things and bad things,
and you'll be able to choose life
and you'll also be able
to choose death.
And I, as God, I can't force
you to make that choice.
Only you can make the choice
of good over bad.
Only you can make the choice
of life over death.
And that, I believe,
is the most foundational verse
in the entire Hebraic canon,
because it's God telling people
you have agency,
you have morality,
and you have free will.
And even I, as God,
can't force you to do things
that you otherwise
would not want to do.
So yeah, if God were to appear
to us in an open vision tomorrow,
sure, we might believe in him,
but that's not out of free will.
That's not because of our
human intellect and reasoning.
It's because, well,
we don't have any choice.
And that's just so antithetical
to Jewish and to Christian thought.
So I guess my last question,
then, is your faith.
What is that?
I don't say what does that hinge on,
but where does your faith
and belief in God come from?
As in, we've had people
on this show who talk
about the science of God,
that the more they discover
the cosmos,
the more they are convinced
that there must be
an intelligent design.
We've had people on the show
talk about open miracles
that have happened to them,
and there's no other
plausible explanation.
Nature can't explain it.
Science can't explain it.
It must be this third other thing,
this divine thing.
Where do you get
your sense of convictions from?
The reason I'm a Christian
is because of the resurrection
of Jesus at the end of the day.
The evidence for it in
when I've studied it
is overwhelming,
that he actually did
rise from the dead
and he rose from the dead
that gives me a very,
very good reason
to trust what he said.
And so when I studied that
in my youth,
and I was kind of
taken aback going,
wow, there's actually a lot
of really good evidence here.
I guess I'm a Christian now.
I mean, it was like,
it was kind of like that.
Darn it.
Yeah.
But if that's the case,
then he really did die.
He really did die
to atone for my sins.
And now I can lean on him.
He is now my foundation
and my faith.
And ultimately,
that's everything right there.
You debunk the resurrection,
I got nothing.
I go back to being a deist,
I guess.
But I mean, I feel like
at that point,
that is where my faith comes from.
It comes back to Christ,
what he did,
how he accomplished it.
And I can't get away
from that fact.
Okay, really last question,
just because you've intrigued me.
Within Jewish thought,
we don't really know
when the Messiah will come.
There are ways that we could
sort of hasten his arrival,
doing good deeds,
coming together, unity.
Do Christians have any idea
when Jesus is coming back?
I feel like when I'm on YouTube,
I always have these suggested videos.
I don't know why,
but I have suggested videos
in my feed saying,
pastor discovers hidden code
in the book of Romans,
Jesus is coming back
on this specific day.
So, A, do you know
when he's coming back?
And or B, can you do anything
to hasten his arrival?
I'm a post-millennialist,
so I have a different eschatology
than a lot of Christians.
And I'll just be,
when Israel says,
blessed is he who comes
in the name of the Lord,
he will return.
Jesus said it quite clearly
in Matthew 23.
He's talking to the Jews.
He says, you will not see me again
until you say,
blessed is he who comes
in the name of the Lord.
He said it.
He said, when Israel accepts me,
I will come back.
So, we know what Paul says,
that's been delayed
until the fullness
of Gentiles come in.
Then all Israel will be saved.
He also says in 1 Corinthians 15,
he will reign until all enemies
are under his feet,
and the last enemy
to be destroyed is death.
So, as a post-millennialist,
my job is to bring more people
into the church,
because that's our job,
is to save the whole world,
and then Jesus returns.
That's what I believe
the Bible teaches, actually.
Israel has now become
a light to the nations,
but it's through
Jesus Christ, actually.
Now, I mean,
everyone around the world
knows of the God of Israel,
and it's the world's largest religion,
and people are now
calling upon a God
from this tiny little country
in the Middle East.
It's profound.
So, yeah, I think
that has accomplished the mission.
So, yeah, when Jesus returns,
it's when everyone says,
all right, you are the Messiah,
you are God.
Just so I understand,
are you suggesting
that Jesus was a Jew?
Yeah, I believe in facts.
Yeah, he was a Jew.
I didn't say it.
You heard it from him.
Look, as we wrap up
this conversation,
I think there are
sort of three verses
that come to mind.
The first is Rabbi Tarfon
in The Ethics of Our Fathers,
Pirkei Avot.
It's this 2nd century
rabbinic text,
and in the 2nd chapter
of the 16th Mishnah,
Rabbi Tarfon essentially says,
you are not obligated.
Lo alacha ham l'chali g'mor.
You are not obligated
to complete the work.
Ve'lo ata ben chorin,
but neither are you absolved
from doing nothing about it.
And so, too, we have
He says,
don't be daunted
by the enormity
of the world's grief.
Instead, he says,
do justly now,
love mercy now,
walk humbly now.
And so, too,
the ending of Sefer Koheles,
the Book of Ecclesiastes,
it ends
sof davar ha'kol neshama,
after everything has been
said and done
at the end of the day,
elokim yirei ah,
you should be in awe of God,
ve'et mitzvosav shemor,
and keep his commandments,
kize kol hadam,
because that is the core,
that is the root of man.
And I think
we can continue
this conversation
on the whys,
but if there was
a practical take-home message,
it would be the
what is more important
is the what.
What are we going to do
now that the whys
have already happened?
And so Michael Jones,
otherwise known
as Inspiring Philosophy
on YouTube,
definitely check out his page.
This has really been
an illuminating conversation.
I thank you
for making the time
and really for all
your incredible videos
and your work
to ensure that young people
can really return to faith.
So thanks again.
Thanks for having me.