'Labour thinks it has responsibility to prevent the rise of Reform UK', historian says

FMM - F24 Video Clips
26 followers
1 Video View·Jul 20, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Well it is by now a now well rehearsed handover. Andy Burnham has taken office as the UK's new
Prime Minister. It's seventh since 2016. He's pledging to tackle the cost of living crisis,
revive British industry and return more powers to local government. Burnham has also acknowledged
the scale of the challenges that lie ahead, saying his new cabinet will pursue a long-term
vision for the country but questions remain over how he intends to fund his ambitious agenda.
And we will take power out of here and carry it into every postcode in the land
so that they can do more and in doing more build a new economy where we put life's essentials back
under stronger public control to make them affordable to you again.
Re-industrialising Britain using public procurement to back British industry.
Later this year I will bring forward a new plan for Britain.
On one historic day in UK politics let's bring in Martin Farr, a senior lecturer
in contemporary British history at Newcastle University. Thanks for being with us on the
programme this evening Martin. So Andy Burnham saying he's deeply conscious of the political
revolving door he's walking through today. Just what kind of leader do you think he's going to be?
Well it contrasts very strongly with his predecessor. We saw that this afternoon just
by the way he addressed the media by eschewing a lectern. He demonstrated he was much more
confident in his skin and has a much clearer message to convey. Keir Starmer had many qualities
but they weren't very apparent as prime minister and I think he betrayed the fact that he wasn't
a practised politician. He had a big job before politics and that was part of the appeal when he
became leader in 2019. But that wasn't really sufficient to be able to convince the public to
craft a narrative, to create a story. It may not be sufficient but it is necessary for a politician,
for a prime minister certainly to have the ability to carry an audience, that is to say the electorate
with him. And the feeling in the Labour Party is so strongly that Burnham has those qualities that
there was not even a contest for the leadership of the party or as it's proven this afternoon.
As you say his predecessor only lasting two years in at the top job. How do you think Burnham's
going to do? Is he going to fare much better than that do you think? And how is his
premiership at a very early stage albeit being viewed by the British public? I'm afraid since
Brexit the prime minister has been biennial. We change them every two years. It reflects the
fluidity, the inconsistency, the increasingly short patience and the fact that this election
in particular, the one in three years time as we're expecting, could be for the first time in 100
years the first new party government. And that's Reform UK which is Britain's version of a populist
right party. And I think the Labour Party members and its MPs certainly think that there's a
responsibility almost to prevent that from happening. And that's why they changed horses
in midstream as it were with their leaders. There was no great crisis that started over,
there was no economic calamity, but it was thought to be such a serious matter that Labour
has not been in a position where the extremist right, as Labour members would see it, are in a
position to be successful. And that's revealed partly through Andy Burnham's route to Parliament.
He was elected in the Makerfield constituency which is an area between Manchester and Liverpool.
He was thought likely to win but not by the extent that he did in the end win.
It was so emphatic a victory where Reform had done so well three months earlier in local elections
that the party felt and hopes today that he has the ability to re-engage with Labour voters who
were lost to the party and who looked elsewhere. And that only he can bring the party together. So
there's enormous expectation on his part, weight of expectation. And indeed the word he used
himself this afternoon, hope. And of course it's not just the Prime Minister that's changing,
changing faces too in Cabinet. Rachel Reeves is out, we're also hearing that former Labour
party leader Ed Miliband is set to be the UK's next foreign minister. So what do you make of
these choices that we're seeing when it comes to who exactly Burnham is putting into which positions?
The key appointment, as it is for every Prime Minister, is Chancellor. And Ed Miliband has
for some time almost been expecting the role and certainly the left of the party wanted that
because he would be a different type of Chancellor, a left of centre Chancellor in the Labour party.
But there were concerns about his ability to frighten the bond markets,
about his ability to undermine confidence in the government's economic policy. It's probity as it
were. So this is a view from the right rather than the left. And also I think the feeling
that he may become too powerful as Chancellor. And so it turns out that John Healey, not to sound
wise after the event, but I was predicting a month ago that John Healey would be a very good
pick for Chancellor in the sense that he's not political, he's not of left or right factions.
And he overnight resolves Labour's dilemma over defence spending because he resigned from
Starmer's cabinet over a shortfall in defence spending. Now he's the person who can make it
happen as Chancellor. It also means that Shabana Mahmood, who had been tipped to be Chancellor,
will remain in the Home Office, which is quite controversial in the Labour party because of
their stubborn stance on migration, but is popular with the country at large and with voters. So
that's really significant. Miliband had to have a big role, and that's why it's been given the
Foreign Secretaryship, the only role that could really be promoted to. And there could be tensions
with the Americans, who are known not to be fans of his, largely over his time as Energy Secretary
and refusal to mine or to allow further drilling in the North Sea. So coming out as we see the
changes in real time, it was clear that there had to be a chained top. So Lammy as Deputy Prime
Minister, Reeves as Chancellor had to go for there to be a new administration. What happens at the
other posts will be very interesting to see, because it's been an unusually tight ship for
Burnham. There've been no leaks, and this reveals another one of his big pitches, which is a Prime
Minister and the government not concerned about briefings and undermining ministers,
but being straightforward with the public. It's been a good start so far.
Martin, very early days, as we say. The new Prime Minister has already spoken,
with Donald Trump continuing British support for Ukraine. What do you think he's going to do,
the new Prime Minister, in terms of foreign policy? Do you think there's going to be any
major departures from his predecessor, Keir Starmer? I suspect not. He's a politician in
public life for 30 years with almost no footprints in foreign policy or foreign issues. Starmer came
into politics afresh, but Burnham's been around for a long time. He's never been concerned with
these things particularly. Indeed, his remit, his mandate, the purpose of him being leader today
is to be concerned, preoccupied, focus on domestic issues, on cost of living issues.
He needs a strong foreign secretary, which Miliband will provide. The first foreign
meeting or the first foreign phone call is always with the American president.
The biggest issue, I think, will arise over whether to allow a base for US flights in their
attacks on Iran. Otherwise, this was a big issue for Starmer too, otherwise I think there'll be
continuity. Ukraine unites the parties. He will be concerned with closer EU cooperation, but be
very aware of the way that could play with critics in the country, with the opposition, and not least,
of course, with Reform UK and Nigel Farage. So, tentative steps there. This is very much a
domestically focused Prime Minister. Whether he can stay that way, of course, is largely up to
affairs around the world. And Martin, he was, of course, very popular former mayor of Manchester.
Do you think that popularity is going to transfer over to the role of Prime Minister? I heard one
voter earlier calling him, describing him as Keir Starmer, but from the north. Yes, I don't quite
see the merit in that observation, if I may say so. They're very different people. The fact he's
the north is true, but also, he's culturally of the north. A big part of Burnham's political
philosophy is a politics of place. And so, he believes very strongly in being rooted in one's
area. And so, he's proposed what's called the Makerfield test, that as Prime Minister, he will
not be doing anything that wouldn't work for his constituents in Makerfield, most of whom, it should
be said, voted to form in the May elections, and were to form in the next general election. So,
he has that background of not being from London. And indeed, Keir Starmer wasn't merely from London,
but from North London, a particular sect within the capital, which is distinct from the rest of
the country and the rest of the Labour Party, the Labour movement. Burnham is imbued with the Labour
Party and the movement. And this will come across very well with his MPs, with his members of his
party, as we'll see in Liverpool in September at the party conference, whether it relates to the
public more broadly, and the public indeed in the south, where Labour did very well and have to do
very well to win general elections, remains to be seen. Martin, we'll have to leave it there for now.
Thanks so much for joining us, though, with that analysis. That's Martin Farr,
Senior Lecturer in Contemporary British History at Newcastle University.
